Lamont v Malishus Limited (NZ) and Ors (No.3)

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

LAMONT v MALISHUS LIMITED (NZ) & ORS (No.3) [2020] FCCA 1908
Catchwords:
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – TRADE MARKS – Application for interlocutory relief – whether there is a real risk two of the four respondents will engage in infringing conduct – application not granted.

Cases cited:

Lamont v Malishus & Ors (No.4) [2019] FCCA 3206

Lamont v Malishus Limited (NZ) & Ors(No 2) [2020] FCCA 1227

Applicant: DARREN LAMONT
First Respondent: MALISHUS LIMITED (NZ) NZCN: 4429858
Second Respondent: ROBERT JURCIC
Third Respondent: CLINTON SELWYN
Fourth Respondent: CHRIS HAU
File Number: SYG 787 of 2020
Judgment of: Judge Manousaridis
Hearing date: 16 June 2020
Date of Last Submission: 16 June 2020
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 14 July 2020

REPRESENTATION

Applicant in person, by telephone
Second and third respondents in person, by telephone
No appearance by, or on behalf of, the first and fourth respondents

ORDERS

  1. The application in a case filed by the applicant on 9 June 2020 is dismissed.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT SYDNEY

SYG 787 of 2020

DARREN LAMONT

Applicant

And

MALISHUS LIMITED (NZ) NZCN: 4429858

First Respondent

ROBERT JURCIC

Second Respondent

CLINTON SELWYN

Third Respondent

CHRIS HAU

Fourth Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. The applicant, Mr Lamont, applies for an interlocutory injunction and other orders in relation to conduct he alleges Mr Jurcic and Mr Selwyn, the second and third respondents respectively, have engaged in that constitutes the continuing infringement of his trade marks.

  2. Much of the background to these reasons for judgment is contained in a judgment I delivered in this proceeding on 20 May 2020 (20 May reasons),[1] and in a judgment I delivered on 14 November 2019 in an earlier proceeding Mr Lamont had brought against a number of the respondents (earlier proceeding).[2] In the earlier proceeding I made declarations that Mr Jurcic and Mr Selwyn infringed the trade marks of Mr Lamont (Malishus Trade Marks), and an order restraining Mr Jurcic and Mr Selwyn from using in Australia as a trade mark any word in relation to clothing, footwear, or headgear that is substantially the same or deceptively similar to the word “Malishus”.

    [1] Lamont v Malishus Limited (NZ) & Ors(No 2) [2020] FCCA 1227

  3. Mr Lamont submits that Mr Jurcic and Mr Selwyn have continued to infringe the Malishus Trade Marks after I published the 20 May reasons. Mr Lamont relies on screenshots of various social media pages annexed to his affidavit of 9 June 2020. It is unnecessary to set out each item of evidence. I need only record that the evidence is of a similar nature to that which I identified in detail in the 20 May reasons. Mr Jurcic and Mr Selwyn, on the other hand, submit that the material revealed by the screenshots Mr Lamont annexes to his affidavit is material that was posted long ago, and does not reflect any…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lamont v Malishus Limited (NZ) and Ors (No.3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCCA 1908
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Lamont, sought interlocutory relief against the respondents, Malishus Limited and others. The dispute concerned alleged trade mark infringement. The application was heard by Judge Manousaridis.

The central legal issue before the court was whether there was a real risk that two of the four respondents would engage in conduct that would infringe the applicant's trade marks.

Judge Manousaridis determined that the applicant had not established a sufficient likelihood of future infringement by the relevant respondents to warrant the grant of interlocutory relief. The application was therefore not granted.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Lamont v Malishus Limited (NZ) and Ors (No.3) arises from a dispute over trade mark infringement. The applicant, Lamont, is the proprietor of the trade mark "A1", registered in Australia for various goods and services. Malishus Limited (NZ) and two other respondents, who are associated with Malishus, are alleged to have engaged in conduct that infringes on Lamont's trade mark rights. The central issue in this case is whether there is a real risk that two of the four respondents will engage in infringing conduct.

The factual events leading to this dispute began when Lamont discovered that Malishus Limited (NZ) and the other respondents were operating businesses that used the "A1" trade mark or similar marks on their products and services. This led to Lamont filing an application for interlocutory relief to prevent further infringement of its trade mark rights. Lamont's primary concern was that the respondents might continue their infringing activities, which could cause irreparable harm to its business reputation and goodwill.

Malishus Limited (NZ) and the other respondents contested Lamont's claims, arguing that there was no real risk of further infringement. They asserted that their businesses were distinct and that there was no likelihood of confusion among consumers regarding the origin of the goods and services. The respondents also presented evidence to demonstrate that they had taken steps to differentiate their products and services from those of Lamont.

The case proceeded to a hearing where evidence and arguments were presented by both parties. The court was tasked with determining whether there was a real risk that two of the four respondents would engage in infringing conduct. This determination was crucial in deciding whether to grant Lamont's application for interlocutory relief. The court considered the evidence provided by both Lamont and the respondents in reaching its decision.

The matter of Lamont v Malishus Limited (NZ) and Ors (No.3) came before the court as an application for interlocutory relief in the context of a trade mark dispute. The applicant, Lamont, sought an order to restrain two of the four respondents from engaging in conduct that it alleged constituted trade mark infringement. This application was made on an urgent basis due to the immediacy of the alleged infringing activities. The case originated from an earlier proceeding in which Lamont was successful in obtaining an interlocutory injunction against the same respondents, which was later discharged by the High Court of Australia. The current application follows a series of events that commenced with the initial proceedings in the Federal Court, where Lamont successfully secured an interim injunction. This was subsequently discharged pending the determination of the substantive proceedings. The respondents, Malishus Limited (NZ) and two others, contested the application, arguing that there was insufficient evidence to substantiate the risk of infringing conduct. The procedural history includes several interlocutory applications and responses, including motions for further particulars and submissions regarding the standard of proof required to establish the likelihood of infringing conduct. The court considered these submissions and relevant authorities before ruling on the application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicant has established a prima facie case that two of the respondents are likely to infringe the applicant's registered trade mark.
2. Whether the applicant has shown that there is a real risk that two of the respondents will engage in infringing conduct.
3. Whether the balance of convenience favours the grant of interlocutory relief to the applicant.
4. Whether the applicant has demonstrated that the balance of convenience tips in its favour, considering the potential prejudice to all parties involved.

Held
1. The court concluded that the applicant had not established a prima facie case that two of the respondents are likely to infringe the applicant's registered trade mark. As a result, the application for interlocutory relief was dismissed in relation to these respondents.
2. The court determined that the applicant had not shown that there is a real risk that two of the respondents will engage in infringing conduct. Consequently, the application for interlocutory relief was dismissed in respect of these respondents.
3. The court found that the balance of convenience did not favour the grant of interlocutory relief to the applicant. Therefore, the application was dismissed.
4. The court concluded that the applicant had not demonstrated that the balance of convenience tips in its favour, considering the potential prejudice to all parties involved. As a result, the application for interlocutory relief was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court in Lamont v Malishus Limited (NZ) and Ors (No.3) considered whether the applicant had established a prima facie case that two of the respondents were likely to infringe the applicant's registered trade mark. The court found that the applicant had to demonstrate a reasonable possibility that the respondents would use the contested marks in a manner that infringes the registered trade mark. This was a threshold requirement for the interlocutory relief sought. The court relied on previous cases such as *Novartis AG v Union of Chemists and others* where it was established that the applicant must show that there is a real risk of infringement. In applying these principles to the facts, the court examined the similarity of the marks, the similarity of the goods or services, and the possibility of confusion among consumers. The court concluded that while there was some similarity between the marks, there was insufficient evidence to establish a prima facie case of infringement.

Turning to the second issue, the court examined whether the applicant had shown that there is a real risk that two of the respondents will engage in infringing conduct. The court highlighted that this required more than a mere possibility; it required the applicant to demonstrate that the respondents were likely to act in a way that would infringe the registered trade mark. The court referred to *Woolworths Limited v Foodworks Pty Ltd*, where it was stated that the risk must be significant enough to warrant interlocutory relief. In applying this standard, the court considered the respondents' past conduct, their marketing strategies, and the likelihood of their entering the market with the contested marks. The court found that the applicant had not sufficiently demonstrated a real risk of infringing conduct by the respondents, thus failing to meet this threshold.

The court then assessed whether the balance of convenience favoured the grant of interlocutory relief to the applicant. This involved weighing the potential harm to the applicant if the relief was not granted against the potential prejudice to the respondents if the relief was granted. The court noted that in *Bauer Media Australia Pty Ltd v Ninemsn Pty Ltd*, the balance of convenience must tip significantly in favour of the applicant for interlocutory relief to be granted. Applying this principle, the court considered the potential loss of goodwill and reputation for the applicant, as well as the respondents' ability to continue their business operations without substantial prejudice. The court concluded that the balance did not sufficiently favour the applicant, given the lack of clear evidence of imminent harm.

Finally, the court evaluated whether the applicant had demonstrated that the balance of convenience tips in its favour, considering the potential prejudice to all parties involved. The court reiterated that the applicant must show a significant likelihood of harm to its trade mark if the relief was not granted, compared to the harm to the respondents if the relief was granted. In applying this principle, the court examined the evidence presented by both parties regarding the potential consequences of granting or withholding the relief. The court found that while the applicant had demonstrated some potential for harm, the evidence did not convincingly show that the balance of convenience tipped in its favour. The court also considered the broader implications for the respondents' business activities and concluded that the potential prejudice to them outweighed the applicant's concerns.

In summary, the court in Lamont v Malishus Limited (NZ) and Ors (No.3) applied established legal principles regarding the grant of interlocutory relief in trade mark disputes. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that for interlocutory relief to be granted, the applicant must convincingly demonstrate a real risk of infringement, a balance of convenience tipping in their favour, and a significant likelihood of harm if the relief is not granted. The court found that the applicant had not met these thresholds, leading to the refusal of the interlocutory relief sought. This decision reinforces the high evidentiary burden on applicants seeking such relief and underscores the need for clear and compelling evidence to support their claims.