Lamers and Veterans' Review Board and Repatriation Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2001] AATA 542

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No  V2000/992

VETERANS APPEALS DIVISION           )          
           Re      PETER LAMERS   

Applicant

And  And     VETERANS' REVIEW BOARD Respondent REPATRIATION COMMISSION PARTY JOINED     

DECISION

Tribunal       Mr J. Handley, Senior Member     

Date8 June 2001

PlaceMelbourne

Decision      The decision under review is affirmed.   
  ..........Sgd. Mr J. Handley...........
  Senior Member
CATCHWORDS
Veteran's Entitlements – Dismissal by VRB of application – Mandatory notice – failure to provide written statement – decision affirmed.
Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986 ss 126(1) 155AA 166(1A)

REASONS FOR DECISION

8 June 2001           Mr J. Handley, Senior Member     

  1. This is an application to review a decision made by the Veterans' Review Board ("VRB"), made on 18 July 2000, to dismiss an application pursuant to s.155AA(5) of the Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986 ("the Act").

  2. Subsequent to the commencement of the proceedings in this Tribunal, an application was made by the Repatriation Commission to be joined as a party pursuant to s.30(1)(d) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975.  There being no opposition to the joinder by the applicant's representative, an Order was made on 21 February 2001 that the Repatriation Commission be joined as a party.

  3. The hearing of this application was convened in Melbourne on 9 May 2001.  Mr De Marchi appeared on behalf of the applicant.  Mr Topperwien appeared on behalf of the Principal Member of the VRB.  Mr Hanks of Counsel appeared on behalf of the Repatriation Commission.  A number of documents were received into evidence and will be referred to in these reasons.  Mr Hoelzinger, the Registrar of the VRB gave evidence.
    The Legislation

  4. The relevant sections of the Act are s.126(1) & (4), 155AA and 166(1A). Those sections are reproduced as follows-

    "126  Death of claimant

    (1)On the death of a claimant, the claim does not lapse in respect of any period before the death of the claimant, but the legal personal representative of the claimant, or a person approved by the Commission, may take such action in respect of the claim as the claimant could have taken if the claimant had not died and, for that purpose, the legal personal representative or person so approved shall be treated as the claimant.

    (4)In this section, claim means a claim in accordance with section 14, 35B, 36D, 37D, 38D, 39D or 45I, an application in accordance with section 15, and an application for review under Division 16 of Part IIIB, section 135 or 175, and claimant has a corresponding meaning.

    155AA  Power to dismiss application - initial consideration

    (1)       In this section:

    standard review period, in relation to an application for review, means the period of 2 years after the day on which the application was received at an office of the Department in Australia.

    (2)       This section applies to an application for review unless:

    (a)the hearing of the review has finished within the standard review period; or

    (b)as at the end of the standard review period, a date, time and place is fixed for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lamers and Veterans' Review Board and Repatriation Commissio... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] AATA 542
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved Lamers, the Veterans' Review Board (VRB), and the Repatriation Commission. The dispute centered on the dismissal of Lamers' application by the VRB, specifically focusing on whether mandatory notice requirements under the Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986 were complied with. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with reviewing the VRB's decision.

The court was required to determine whether the VRB's dismissal of Lamers' application complied with statutory obligations under sections 155AA and 166(1A) of the Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986. The key issues were whether the VRB Registrar, Mr Hoelzinger, provided the mandatory written notice to Lamers as required by section 155AA and whether the VRB's decision to dismiss the application was lawful given Lamers' failure to respond to the notice.

The court found that Mr Hoelzinger was properly delegated to act on behalf of the Principal Member under section 166(1A) of the Act. The court held that the written notice sent to Lamers on 5 June was valid and contained the necessary information as per section 155AA(4)(c) and (d). The court noted that there was no written response from Lamers to the notice, thereby fulfilling the legal requirement for the VRB to dismiss the application under section 155AA(5). The court dismissed allegations that Mr Hoelzinger was influenced by external parties, describing them as unfounded and unsupported by evidence. The court emphasized that the application had been pending for over five years, with delays partially attributed to the death of Mr Flentjar, but largely unexplained. Correspondence was sent to Lamers and his solicitor, and the court considered the additional communication to be a matter of courtesy rather than a statutory obligation.

In conclusion, the court upheld the VRB's decision to dismiss Lamers' application, finding that the statutory notice requirements were met and that there was no lawful basis to overturn the dismissal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

With respect to the file note concerning the telephone conversation initiated by Mr Flentjar of 22 June 2000, Mr Hoelzinger denied that Mr Flentjar had indicated that Mr Lamers did wish to proceed with the application and that he (Mr Flentjar) had wanted the application to be fixed.Conclusion & Reasons For Decision The provisions of section 155AA appear to me to be a form of case management imposed on the VRB Registrar by the legislation. Contemporary evidence within Courts and Tribunals in Australia indicates that Registrars have a responsibility for the administration and management of applications to ensure that there is no inordinate delay. Whilst the budgetary allocation to Courts and Tribunals does not necessarily increase commensurate with increased numbers of applications, the management of available resources dictates that unnecessary or unexplained delay can and will interfere with efficiency and sound administration. (Refer discussion in Re Adams and Veterans' Review Board (1992) 16 AAR 307 at 317). The provisions of section 155AA are mandatory to the extent that the Principal Member must give a written notice to an applicant requesting a written statement as to readiness to proceed. The Principal Member then must dismiss the application if the written statement is not provided. However if the application has not been concluded within two years of its lodgement, the appellant has the opportunity to provide a written statement concerning a readiness to proceed or to provide a written statement explaining why the application is not ready to proceed. In the present application I am satisfied that the District Registrar, Mr Hoelzinger, is properly delegated by the Principal Member pursuant to section 166(1)(A) of the Act. I am also satisfied that the document forwarded by Mr Hoelzinger to Mr Lamers on 5 June is a "written notice" within the meaning of section 155AA. I am also satisfied that it contains the information dictated by sub-section (4) (c) and (d). I am also satisfied and find as a fact, that the notice of 5 June was forwarded to the legal personal representative and was properly addressed. I am also satisfied that there was no written response to that notice. It follows that Mr Hoelzinger was obliged as a matter of law, to dismiss the application pursuant to section 155AA(5) of the Act. During the hearing the applicant's representative sought to impugn and to tarnish the reputation of Mr Hoelzinger. It was suggested that Mr Hoelzinger was "influenced" to make the decision that he did and or that "Canberra" was responsible for the decision made. Mr Hanks described these allegations as "fantasy". I would describe the allegations as absurd and ridiculous. The allegations made by Mr DeMarchi were unsupported by any evidence. Mr Topperwein sat beside Mr DeMarchi at the bar table yet no application was made to call him to give evidence. What is beyond doubt in these proceedings is that the application was more than five years old when it was dismissed. While some delay can be explained by the unfortunate death of Mr Flentjar, there is little to explain why there was continued delay. I note that Mr Hoelzinger wrote to the applicant on 17 May, drawing to his attention that the file was more than two years old and that it was intended to issue a notice under section 155AA. That notice was eventually issued and when there was a failure to respond, the notice under section 155AA was issued. I note that all of the correspondence was forwarded to both the applicant, to the applicant's solicitor and to Mr Richards. There was no obligation for Mr Hoelzinger to write to any person other than Mr Lamers as the legal personal representative. I would consider in the circumstances that the correspondence was forwarded to all of the persons referred to above as a matter of courtesy.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established