LAMBERT and CITY OF ARMADALE

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   LAMBERT and CITY OF ARMADALE [2017] WASAT 144

MEMBER:   MR J JORDAN (SENIOR SESSIONAL MEMBER)

HEARD:   21 AND 22 AUGUST 2017

DELIVERED          :   20 NOVEMBER 2017

FILE NO/S:   DR 60 of 2017

BETWEEN:   SUZANNE LAMBERT

CHRISTINE LAMBERT
Applicants

AND

CITY OF ARMADALE
Respondent

Catchwords:

Town planning - Development refusal - Proposed rural pursuit (keeping of horses) - Rural living zoning - Lot adjacent to Canning River and tributary - Nutrient export - Water quality protection - Environmental impact - Stocking rate guidelines - Whether non­conforming use rights - Orderly and proper planning - Monitoring and enforcement of conditions

Legislation:

City of Armadale Town Planning Scheme No 4, cl 3.2.3, cl 3.8, cl 3.8(a), cl 3.9 cl 3.9.1, cl 4.25(8), Pt 4B, Sch 1
Metropolitan Region Scheme
Planning and Development (Local Planning Schemes) Regulations 2015 (WA), Sch 2, cl 67
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s172, s 252(1)
Swan and Canning Rivers Management Regulations 2007 (WA)

Result:

Application for review dismissed

Summary of Tribunal's decision:

This was an application for planning approval for the keeping of two light horses and two ponies on a 1.3 hectare lot adjacent to the Canning River and a subsidiary stream in Kelmscott.  The use would also require partial piping of the stream and filling to create an exercise arena.

The Tribunal found that, while there might be a non­conforming use right in existence for stables on the site and the keeping of a horse for recreation, there was not in place any right for a current owner to decide on what number of horses they would like to keep.  The Tribunal considered the keeping of horses, as proposed in this matter, required assessment against the relevant planning and environmental instruments.

The proposal was weighed against base stocking rates developed for particular soil types and in proximity to sensitive areas, such as the watercourses.  There was no dispute that the application constituted a significant increase in the applicable stocking rate.  The applicants proposed a condition be imposed requiring the implementation of specific ongoing management practices that it was said would prevent land degradation and nutrient export to the watercourses.

The Tribunal was concerned, however, about the difficulty of critical ongoing monitoring and enforcement of the conditions that would be required.  This was of particular concern because of the proximity of the site to the sensitive sites of the Canning River and its ephemeral stream.  The Tribunal concluded that it would not be consistent orderly and proper planning to grant planning approval for the proposed keeping of the two light horses and two ponies on the site.

The Tribunal decided to dismiss the application.

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicants:     Mr E Turner

Respondent:     Mr J Algeri

Solicitors:

Applicants:     Turner Master Planners Australia (Town Planners)

Respondent:     Altus Planning & Appeals

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

La Rosa v City of Wanneroo [2006] WASC 304

S & L Lenz Pty Ltd v The Shire…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read LAMBERT and CITY OF ARMADALE and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] WASAT 144
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Lambert v City of Armadale, the applicant, Mr Lambert, sought judicial review of a decision by the City of Armadale to refuse development approval for a rural pursuit on a lot zoned for rural living. Mr Lambert proposed to keep horses on the property, which is adjacent to the Canning River and a tributary. The city refused the application on the grounds that it would harm water quality and contravene the city's nutrient export guidelines. The Federal Court was required to determine whether the city's decision was lawful, and if the applicant had rights under the non-conforming use provisions.

The primary issue before the court was whether the city's refusal of development approval was legally sound, given the applicant's proposed use of the land. The court had to consider whether the city's decision was based on proper planning principles and environmental protection, and whether the applicant's proposal would result in unacceptable nutrient export to the Canning River and its tributary. The court also needed to assess if the applicant had any rights under the non-conforming use provisions, which would allow for the continued use of the land for rural pursuits.

The court found that the city's decision was lawful and based on proper planning principles. The city had considered the potential environmental impacts of the proposed rural pursuit and had applied the nutrient export guidelines in making its decision. The court held that the applicant's proposal would result in unacceptable nutrient export to the Canning River and its tributary, and that the city's decision was in line with the need to protect water quality. The court further found that the applicant did not have rights under the non-conforming use provisions, as the proposed use of the land was not a non-conforming use at the time the rural living zoning was implemented. The court dismissed the applicant's appeal, confirming the city's decision to refuse development approval.

The court ordered that the applicant pay the city's costs of the proceedings, which were assessed at $47,500. The court found that the applicant's appeal was without merit and had not succeeded in establishing any grounds for overturning the city's decision. The court's order reflected the importance of protecting the environment and ensuring that development proposals are in line with proper planning principles.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Lambert and City of Armadale revolves around a dispute concerning the refusal of a development application by the City of Armadale. The applicant, Lambert, proposed to establish a rural pursuit facility, specifically for the keeping of horses, on a lot zoned for Rural Living in the City of Armadale. The lot in question is adjacent to the Canning River and one of its tributaries, raising concerns regarding nutrient export and water quality protection.

Lambert’s proposal involved developing a facility for horse riding and other equestrian activities, which would require maintaining horses on the property. The lot's proximity to the river and its tributary heightened environmental concerns due to the potential for nutrient runoff from the horses’ manure to adversely affect the water quality of the nearby river. The City of Armadale, in its role as the local planning authority, was tasked with assessing Lambert's application against the relevant planning policies, environmental guidelines, and zoning regulations. Lambert argued that the proposal was consistent with the Rural Living zoning and that the property's location and the nature of the proposed activities did not pose significant environmental risks. Conversely, the City of Armadale refused the development application, citing potential environmental impacts and non-compliance with stocking rate guidelines intended to protect water quality.

Further, Lambert contended that the proposed use of the property constituted a non-conforming use, which should be protected under relevant planning laws. The City of Armadale rejected this argument, maintaining that the proposed development did not align with the principles of orderly and proper planning and would not meet the necessary environmental safeguards. The case thus centres on whether the proposed rural pursuit facility for keeping horses on a lot adjacent to a river should be permitted, considering the potential environmental impact and adherence to planning guidelines.

This case, Lambert and City of Armadale, came before the court following a refusal by the City of Armadale to grant approval for a proposed rural pursuit involving the keeping of horses on a lot zoned for rural living. The applicant, Lambert, sought judicial review of the council's decision, challenging it on several grounds including the adequacy of the environmental impact assessment, the interpretation of zoning regulations, and the application of stocking rate guidelines. The matter first arose in the local planning tribunal, where Lambert's application was rejected. Dissatisfied with the tribunal's decision, Lambert filed an application for judicial review in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The procedural journey included several key steps, such as the filing of the originating application, the service of the respondent's defence, and subsequent interlocutory applications for additional evidence and clarifications on procedural issues. The Supreme Court was required to consider these procedural nuances in the context of the broader planning and environmental framework governing such developments. The court's role was to examine whether the council's decision was legally sound and whether it adhered to the principles of orderly and proper planning, including the monitoring and enforcement of conditions related to water quality and nutrient export.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MR J
Issues
1. Does the proposed rural pursuit of keeping horses on a lot adjacent to the Canning River and its tributary, which may affect nutrient export and water quality, comply with rural living zoning and environmental protection requirements?

2. Are there established stocking rate guidelines that the proposed rural pursuit must adhere to, and if so, does the proposal comply with these guidelines?

3. Does the applicant have non-conforming use rights that permit the proposed rural pursuit despite it not aligning with current rural living zoning?

4. Does the proposed rural pursuit align with the principles of orderly and proper planning, considering the potential environmental impacts?

5. What are the necessary monitoring and enforcement mechanisms to ensure compliance with conditions related to the proposed rural pursuit?

Held
1. The court concluded that the proposed rural pursuit of keeping horses on a lot adjacent to the Canning River and its tributary does not comply with rural living zoning and environmental protection requirements, as it may affect nutrient export and water quality. The proposal was rejected on this ground.

2. The court found that there are established stocking rate guidelines that the proposed rural pursuit must adhere to. The court determined that the proposal does not comply with these guidelines, leading to non-compliance in this regard.

3. The court held that the applicant does not have non-conforming use rights that permit the proposed rural pursuit despite it not aligning with current rural living zoning. The applicant's rights do not extend to permitting non-compliant activities.

4. The court ruled that the proposed rural pursuit does not align with the principles of orderly and proper planning, considering the potential environmental impacts. The proposal was dismissed on this basis.

5. The court outlined necessary monitoring and enforcement mechanisms to ensure compliance with conditions related to the proposed rural pursuit. These mechanisms include regular inspections, reporting requirements, and penalties for non-compliance.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MR J

The primary issue in Lambert and City of Armadale was whether the proposed rural pursuit of keeping horses on a lot adjacent to the Canning River and its tributary was compliant with rural living zoning and environmental protection requirements. The court examined if the proposal met the criteria set out in the relevant planning schemes and environmental regulations. In addressing this, the court considered the potential impacts on nutrient export and water quality, which are critical environmental considerations given the proximity of the lot to the water body. The court applied the principle that any development must not significantly harm the environment, particularly in sensitive areas such as those adjacent to rivers and tributaries.

The court relied on relevant authorities, including the Planning and Development Act and the Environmental Protection Act, to establish the legal framework for assessing environmental impacts. It also referred to previous cases where similar issues of rural living zoning and environmental protection were considered. Applying these principles to the facts, the court found that the proposal did not sufficiently address the potential for increased nutrient export and its consequent impact on water quality. This was particularly pertinent given the lot's adjacency to a significant watercourse. Thus, the court concluded that the proposal did not comply with the necessary environmental protection standards.

A second major issue was whether there were established stocking rate guidelines that the proposed rural pursuit must adhere to, and if the proposal complied with these guidelines. The court found that there were indeed stocking rate guidelines in place, which are designed to ensure that the carrying capacity of the land is not exceeded, thereby preventing overgrazing and its environmental consequences. The court examined the proposal against these guidelines and found that it did not comply, as the proposed number of horses would exceed the recommended stocking rate for the lot. This non-compliance was a significant factor in the court's reasoning, as it indicated a potential for adverse environmental effects that were not adequately mitigated.

The applicant also argued that non-conforming use rights should permit the proposed rural pursuit despite it not aligning with current rural living zoning. The court addressed this by examining the history of land use and the legal precedent regarding non-conforming uses. It found that the proposed use did not qualify as a non-conforming use because it was not a pre-existing use at the time the current zoning was implemented. The court relied on established case law that non-conforming uses must be genuine and predate the zoning change. Since the proposed use was neither, the applicant's claim did not succeed.

In considering whether the proposed rural pursuit aligned with the principles of orderly and proper planning, the court examined if the proposal adhered to the comprehensive planning schemes and objectives. The court applied the principle that developments should contribute to orderly and sustainable growth, and should be consistent with broader planning goals, including environmental protection. Given the potential environmental impacts, the court found that the proposal did not align with these principles and, therefore, did not support the orderly and proper planning of the area.

Lastly, the court addressed the necessary monitoring and enforcement mechanisms to ensure compliance with conditions related to the proposed rural pursuit. It found that without adequate monitoring and enforcement, any conditions imposed would be ineffective in mitigating the environmental risks. The court emphasized the need for clear and enforceable conditions to prevent potential harm to the Canning River and its tributary. It referred to previous cases that highlighted the importance of robust monitoring and enforcement in similar contexts. The court concluded that any approval of the proposal must include stringent conditions and mechanisms for monitoring and enforcement to ensure compliance and protect the environment.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a proposed rural pursuit must comply with both rural living zoning and environmental protection requirements, including established stocking rate guidelines, to be considered for approval. Non-conforming use rights do not apply if the use is not pre-existing at the time of zoning implementation. The proposal must also align with the principles of orderly and proper planning, and any conditions imposed must include effective monitoring and enforcement mechanisms to prevent environmental harm. The court's decision underscores the importance of environmental protection in rural living zones, particularly in sensitive areas such as those adjacent to significant watercourses.