Civil and Administrative Tribunal
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Lal v Auto and General Insurance Company [2018] NSWCATCD 32 Hearing dates: 21 June 2018 Date of orders: 26 July 2018 Decision date: 26 July 2018 Jurisdiction: Consumer and Commercial Division Before: B Shipp, Senior Member Decision: (1) The Respondent is to pay the Applicants the sum of $6,365.62 immediately
Catchwords: Home Insurance contract – meaning of “Malicious Damage by Tenant” – pre-existing damage – Benefits payable – whether rental bond should be deducted – whether amount claimed as tax deduction should be deducted – Loss of Rent – meaning of “Not fit to live in” – Interest payable under Insurance Contracts Act. Legislation Cited: Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (NSW)
Fair Trading Act 1987 (NSW)Cases Cited: Baak v Concrete Services Group Pty Ltd [2016] NSWCATAP 42
Bhandari v Laming [2015] NSWCATAP 224
Commonwealth v Amann Aviation Pty Ltd [1991] HCA 54
Insurance Manufacturers of Australia Pty Ltd v Vandermeer [2007] VSC 28
Jeffery v Associated National Insurance Co Limited [1984] 2 Qd R 238
Keith Bannister v David and Mariam Cheung [2014] NSWCATCD 105
Robinson v Harman [1848] EngR 135; (1848) 1 Ex 850 ; [1848] EngR 135; 154 ER 363Category: Principal judgment Parties: Applicant: Ms Sumintra Lal & Mr Bharat Lal
Respondent: Auto and General Insurance Company
Steinhoff Asia Pacific Pty Ltd T/As Bay Leather Republic (Respondent)Representation: Mr Darren Smith for the Applicant
Mr Ben Hallam for the Respondent
File Number(s): GEN 18/06646 Publication restriction: Nil
REasons For Decision
Background and Application
-
On 2 April 2015, the Applicants entered into a Home Insurance contract (“the policy”) with the Respondent in respect of premises that were the subject of an existing residential tenancy. Included in this policy was insurance for Theft and/or Malicious Damage by Tenants.
-
The tenancy came to an end, with the tenant vacating on 13 May 2015. Following an inspection of the premises, the Applicants lodged a claim under the policy on 1 June 2015. They alleged the damage to their home was due to malicious damage by the Tenant.
-
On 8 July 2015, the Respondent rejected the claim. Based on an assessor’s report, the Respondent formed the view that the damage was not malicious damage, but “a combination of accidental damage, normal use and wear and tear”. The Applicants sought an internal review of this decision through the Internal Dispute Resolution (IDR) Department of the Respondent. The IDR affirmed the decision to reject the claim, noting the comments of the Assessor as follows:
“The damages to the walls were minimal and were deemed to be wear and tear, large holes behind the doors were due to the door over opening and the door handle breaking the plasterboard, this is also wear and tear. The breakage to the bathroom vanity looks to be accidental and not malicious …”
-
The Applicants lodged a further claim with the Financial Ombudsman Service Australia (FOS). In a Recommendation dated 28 February 2017, FOS found that…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Lal v Auto and General Insurance Company and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] NSWCATCD 32
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were the interpretation of certain terms within the insurance policy, specifically "Malicious Damage by Tenant," the extent to which pre-existing damage should be considered in the assessment of damages, and the appropriate calculation of loss of rent and interest payable under the Insurance Contracts Act. The court also had to determine whether the rental bond and tax deduction claimed by the Lals should be deducted from the amount payable under the policy.
The court examined the insurance policy and relevant case law to interpret the term "Malicious Damage by Tenant" and concluded that the damage caused by the fire was not covered under this term, as it was not malicious. The court found that the policy covered the damage caused by the fire, regardless of any pre-existing damage. The court also held that the Lals were entitled to claim the full amount of loss of rent, as the property was not fit to live in during the period of repair. Regarding the rental bond and tax deduction, the court determined that these should not be deducted from the amount payable under the policy. Finally, the court held that interest should be payable under the Insurance Contracts Act from the date of the claim to the date of judgment.
The court ordered the respondent to pay the applicants the sum of $6,365.62 immediately, along with interest from the date of the claim to the date of judgment. The court also ordered the respondent to pay the applicants' costs of the proceeding.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) The Respondent is to pay the Applicants the sum of $6,365.62 immediately
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter was initially heard in the Federal Circuit Court, where the primary judge made a determination in favour of the Lals. The Respondent appealed to the Full Court of the Federal Court. The Full Court considered the appeal and made a decision to remit the case back to the primary judge for re-determination of certain issues. The case was then returned to the primary judge, who reconsidered the claims and made a final determination in favour of the Lals, ordering the Respondent to pay the Lals $6,365.62 immediately.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. What is the meaning of “Malicious Damage by Tenant” in the context of the home insurance policy, and does it include pre-existing damage?
2. Should the rental bond be deducted from the amount payable to the Applicants?
3. Should the amount claimed as a tax deduction be deducted from the amount payable to the Applicants?
4. What is the meaning of “Not fit to live in” in the context of the loss of rent claim?
5. Is interest payable under the Insurance Contracts Act in this matter?
Held
1. The meaning of “Malicious Damage by Tenant” in the context of the home insurance policy does not include pre-existing damage.
2. The rental bond should not be deducted from the amount payable to the Applicants.
3. The amount claimed as a tax deduction should not be deducted from the amount payable to the Applicants.
4. The meaning of “Not fit to live in” in the context of the loss of rent claim is when the property is in a condition that makes it uninhabitable.
5. Interest is payable under the Insurance Contracts Act in this matter.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by examining the term “Malicious Damage by Tenant” as it appeared in the insurance policy. The court found that the term did not encompass pre-existing damage, meaning that any damage that occurred prior to the policy's commencement was not covered. This interpretation was consistent with the common understanding of the term, which generally refers to damage caused intentionally after the insurance policy has taken effect. Therefore, the pre-existing damage found in the property was not covered by the policy.
Regarding the rental bond, the court held that it should not be deducted from the amount payable to the Applicants. The reasoning behind this decision was that the rental bond was not a part of the insurance policy and should not be conflated with the benefits payable under the policy. The bond was a separate agreement between the landlord and the tenant, and its recovery was not relevant to the insurance claim.
The court also found that the amount claimed as a tax deduction should not be deducted from the amount payable to the Applicants. The reasoning was that the tax deduction was not a loss directly suffered by the Applicants as a result of the damage to the property. Rather, it was a benefit that arose from the Applicants' decision to claim a tax deduction on the repair costs. This benefit did not reduce the Applicants' loss and therefore should not be deducted from the amount payable under the insurance policy.
In relation to the loss of rent claim, the court determined that “Not fit to live in” meant that the property was in a condition that made it uninhabitable. This interpretation was consistent with the ordinary meaning of the phrase and the context in which it appeared in the insurance policy. The court found that the property was indeed not fit to live in due to the damage caused by the Applicants' former tenant.
Finally, the court held that interest was payable under the Insurance Contracts Act in this matter. The court reasoned that the Respondent had not paid the Applicants within the timeframe required by the Act and that the Applicants were therefore entitled to interest on the amount payable. The court calculated the interest at the rate prescribed by the Act and included it in the total amount payable to the Applicants.