Laird v Laird

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMON LAW DIVISION

JUDICIAL REVIEW AND APPEALS LIST

S ECI 2020 03564

NEALE DOUGLAS LAIRD Applicant
v 
SUSAN ELIZABETH LAIRD Respondent

---

JUDGE:

Gorton J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

14 September 2021

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

7 October 2021

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

Laird v Laird

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2021] VSC 645

---

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – Appeal from a decision of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal as to costs – Guardianship proceeding – Whether Tribunal’s decision infected by error – Where Tribunal relied on unserved additional submissions – Appeal allowed – Whether to redetermine or remit – Decision to re-exercise costs discretion.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Applicant Self-represented litigant
For the Respondent Mr S Clement Davies Collison Cave Law

TABLE OF CONTENTS

A.  Background................................................................................................................................... 1

B.  The applicants filed additional submissions that were not provided to Neale.............. 2

C.  The various VCAT proceedings and Neale’s undertaking.................................................. 3

C.1.The 2015 application............................................................................................................ 3

C.2.The 2017 application and Neale’s undertaking............................................................... 3

C.3.The 2018 rehearing before the vice president.................................................................. 6

C.4.The determination of the application for costs by the senior sessional member........ 7

D.  Was the Tribunal’s decision to order costs against Neale infected by error of law?..... 8

D.1.The finding that Neale had breached his undertaking.................................................. 8

D.2.The reliance on the additional unserved submissions................................................... 8

E.  Remittance or redetermination?.............................................................................................. 10

F.  The power to order costs........................................................................................................... 11

G.  What costs order should be made?......................................................................................... 12

G.1.The proceeding before the senior member..................................................................... 14

G.2.The hearing before the vice president............................................................................. 18

G.3.The reconstitution of the Tribunal and the application for costs before the senior sessional member............................................................................................................................... 22

H.  Disposition.................................................................................................................................. 23

HIS HONOUR:

A.  Background

  1. Ellen Laird,[1] who died on 25 December 2020 as a widow in her nineties, owned a farming property.  Mrs Laird[2] had seven children: Neale, Euan, Clyde, Eric, Stuart, David and Susan.  For many years, Neale, who is the applicant in this proceeding, lived with his mother on the property.  On 23 November 2015, Mrs Laird appointed Neale and her lawyer, John Natoli, as joint attorneys for financial matters and Neale as her sole attorney for personal matters.  Under Mrs Laird’s will, Neale and Stuart were to inherit the farm property, and their siblings were to inherit the balance of the estate.  Mrs Laird needed a significant amount of expensive care. 

    [1]This application for leave to appeal arises out of proceedings in the Guardianship List at the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal. The Tribunal itself anonymised the persons involved. The person whose decision-making capacity was in issue has since died. The proceeding in this Court was commenced using the parties’ real names. Neither party in this Court sought a pseudonym order. Accordingly, I will refer to the persons involved by their real names.

    [2]The parties informed me that that she preferred ‘Mrs’ to ‘Ms’.

  1. At the times that are relevant to this dispute, Neale considered that his mother retained decision-making capacity and took various steps that he…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Laird v Laird and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] VSC 645
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal before the court involved a decision made by the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal regarding costs in a guardianship proceeding. The appellant, Laird, challenged the tribunal's decision, contending that it was flawed due to the tribunal's reliance on additional submissions that had not been served on all parties. The court was tasked with determining whether the tribunal's decision was infected by error and, if so, whether it should redetermine or remit the costs issue.

The central legal issue was whether the tribunal's reliance on unserved additional submissions constituted a significant error that infected the decision. The court had to assess whether the procedural irregularity was such that it undermined the fairness or correctness of the tribunal's determination of costs. Additionally, if an error was found, the court needed to decide whether the appropriate remedy was to redetermine the issue or to remit it to the tribunal for reconsideration.

In examining the tribunal's decision, the court found that the procedural irregularity of relying on unserved submissions did indeed constitute a significant error that infected the decision. The court held that this procedural flaw undermined the fairness and correctness of the tribunal's determination of costs. Consequently, the court determined that it was not appropriate to redetermine the issue itself but rather to remit the matter to the tribunal to re-exercise its discretion on the costs issue, ensuring that all submissions were properly served and considered. The court allowed the appeal and directed the tribunal to re-exercise its costs discretion in accordance with the law and the evidence properly before it.