Lahoud v The Democratic Republic of Congo (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Lahoud v The Democratic Republic of Congo (No 2) [2018] FCA 478

File number: NSD 846 of 2017
Judge: PERRAM J
Date of judgment: 6 April 2018
Date of publication of reasons: 12 April 2018
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for leave to issue subpoena – whether Applicants may inquire into liabilities of subsidiary company – where third-party parent company seeks to set aside garnishee order
Date of hearing: 5 April 2018
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: International Commercial Arbitration
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 24
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr A J Abadee
Solicitor for the Applicants: ACA Lawyers
Counsel for the Interested Person: Mr C Colquhoun
Solicitor for the Interested Person: White & Case

ORDERS

NSD 846 of 2017
BETWEEN:

ANTOINE ABOU LAHOUD

First Applicant

LEILA BOUNAFEH-ABOU LAHOUD

Second Applicant

AND:

THE DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF CONGO

Respondent

JUDGE:

PERRAM J

DATE OF ORDER:

6 APRIL 2018

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Applicants have leave to issue a subpoena to MMG Limited for the materials appearing in paragraphs 4, 11 and 14 of the draft subpoena provided to the Court on 5 April 2016 and with an additional paragraph in these terms:

‘Any document of MMG as a stand alone entity tending to show the DRC as a creditor of MMG on a non-group basis between 1 October 2017 to 30 November 2017’.

2.No order as to costs.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

PERRAM J:

  1. On 25 July 2017 a foreign arbitral award in favour of Mr and Mrs Lahoud against the Democratic Republic of Congo (‘DRC’) became a judgment of the Court:  Lahoud v The Democratic Republic of Congo [2017] FCA 982. The amount of the judgment debt is nearly $4 million and the DRC is the judgment debtor. A garnishee order against a mining company, MMG Limited (‘MMG’), was obtained on the basis that it owes mining royalties to the DRC. MMG has applied to set aside the garnishee order submitting that the mining royalties are due by one of its subsidiaries, MMG Kinsevere SARL (‘MMGK’) which has a separate legal personality to MMG and is, in any event, not present within the Commonwealth. That application is to be heard on 2 May 2018. In the meantime, the judgment creditors now seek to issue a subpoena addressed to MMG seeking various categories of documents. I was provided with a draft of the proposed subpoena on the present application to which it is that these reasons, where necessary, refer. Unusually, the question of whether leave should be granted to issue the subpoena was the subject of a contested hearing. The parties approached the matter on the basis that if the subpoena had been issued and would have been liable to be set aside, then it should not now be issued. This is, in the circumstances, a convenient way…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lahoud v The Democratic Republic of Congo (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 478
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Lahoud v The Democratic Republic of Congo (No 2) involves an application for leave to issue a subpoena directed to MMG Limited. The applicants, Mr and Mrs Lahoud, seek information relating to the financial obligations of MMG Kinsevere SARL, a subsidiary of MMG Limited, to the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC). The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, where the applicants sought to enforce a judgment obtained in the Supreme Court of New South Wales against the DRC by garnishing debts owed to MMG Limited by the Commonwealth Bank of Australia.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the applicants could inquire into the liabilities of MMG Kinsevere SARL, a subsidiary company, through the subpoena directed to MMG Limited, the parent company. The DRC argued that the subpoena should not be allowed as it sought information that was not relevant to the parent company's liabilities. The applicants contended that the information sought was relevant to establish MMG Limited's indebtedness to the DRC. The court had to determine the scope of the subpoena and whether the information requested was pertinent to the parent company's debts.

In its judgment, the court held that certain requests within the subpoena were permissible. Specifically, the court allowed the subpoena to inquire into documents that would show MMG Limited as a stand-alone entity, including financial records indicating payments to the DRC, documents showing ownership of a mining lease, and financial statements of MMG Limited. The court rejected requests for information on the source of funds for royalty payments to the DRC and details of other creditors, deeming them irrelevant to the parent company's liabilities. The court reasoned that establishing MMG Limited's indebtedness required evidence of the DRC as a creditor of MMG Limited, not merely a group entity. The court also noted that while the subsidiary's obligations were relevant, the information sought must pertain to the parent company's debts.

The court granted leave for the applicants to issue the subpoena with the specified modifications. It did not order costs for either party, reflecting the balanced approach taken in allowing certain requests while restricting others deemed irrelevant. The court's decision ensures that the applicants can proceed with their application to enforce the judgment against the DRC, subject to the modified subpoena.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Applicants have leave to issue a subpoena to MMG Limited for the materials appearing in paragraphs 4, 11 and 14 of the draft subpoena provided to the Court on 5 April 2016 and with an additional paragraph in these terms:

‘Any document of MMG as a stand alone entity tending to show the DRC as a creditor of MMG on a non-group basis between 1 October 2017 to 30 November 2017’.

2. No order as to costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The same remark as to Category 6 applies.10. Any minutes of meetings of MMG Limited in relation to the incorporation of or MMG Kinsevere SARL. The same remark as to Category 6 applies.11. Financial statements (including without limitation general ledgers) indicating payments paid or to be paid to the DRC in the period 1 October 2017 to 30 November 2017. Such records of MMG would tend to prove that MMG is the debtor. I will allow this paragraph.12. A list of MMG Limited’s creditors for the period 1 October 2017 to 30 November 2017. I accept that if DRC is listed within the books and records of MMG (as a stand alone entity) this would assist Mr and Mrs Lahoud’s contentions. If it is merely a statement of the group’s position it will be useless. The position of other creditors is relevant. I would therefore allow ‘Any document of MMG as a stand alone entity tending to show the DRC as a creditor of MMG on a non-group basis between 1 October 2017 and 30 November 2017’.13. Documents (including statements of account) indicating the financial source of payments of royalties to the Democratic Republic of Congo (“DRC”) referred to in paragraph 4 of the Garnishee’s Statement That No Debt Due or Accruing (“Garnishee’s Statement”) which is part of Annexure MB2 to the affidavit of Maxwell Thomas Bennett Bonnell (“Bonnell Affidavit”) affirmed on 14 December 2017, in the period 1 January 2017 to 30 November 2017. I do not see the relevance of the source of the funds.14. Any document recording the ownership or interest of MMG Kinsevere SARL in a mining lease referred to in paragraph 3 of the Garnishee's Statement which is part of Annexure MB2 to the Bonnell Affidavit. Paragraph 3 reads:‘3.A corporation related to MMG, MMG Kinsevere SARL (formerly known as AMCK Mining SPRL and later MMG Kinsevere SPRL), which is incorporated in DRC, operates the Kinsevere mine under Permis d’Exploitation No528 (a copy of which is annexed and marked “A”). Under clause 7(a) of its mining lease (or “contrat d’amodiation”), MMG Kinsevere SARL is required “to sustain all taxes, levies and fees due to the State as stated in the Mining Code”. A copy of an English language version of clause 7(a) of the contrat d’amodiation is annexed and marked “B”. An obligation to pay mining royalties is imposed upon MMG Kinsevere SARL by Articles 240 and 241 of the DRC Mining Code, and an English translation of those provisions is annexed and marked “C”. The effect of those documents, taken together, is that MMG Kinsevere SARL pays royalties to DRC on its exports of copper cathode from the country. Typically, these payments are made within a number of days of each shipment being made. MMG Kinsevere SARL is a separate corporation from MMG Limited, has no presence in Australia, and is not amenable to the jurisdiction of the Australian courts.’ It is relevant to know who the tenant under the lease is. I will allow this paragraph. I therefore allow 4, 11, 12 as modified and 14. There should be no order as to costs.