Lacey v City of Burnside

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Appeals to a Single Judge)

LACEY v CITY OF BURNSIDE

[2009] SASC 136

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Kourakis

20 May 2009

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING - DEVELOPMENT CONTROL

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - TREES AND VEGETATION

Appeal against the decision of a Commissioner of the Environment, Resources and Development Court refusing the appellant's appeal against the respondent's decision refusing his development application to remove a significant tree in his back yard - the Commissioner held that the tree posed an unacceptable risk to safety for the purposes of Principle of Development Control 48 of the City of Burnside Development Plan but that all reasonable remedial treatments and measures had not been demonstrated to be ineffective as required by that Principle - whether the Commissioner erred in accepting one expert witness's evidence in relation to the level of risk posed by the tree but another witness's evidence in relation to the effect of pruning the tree - whether the Commissioner erred in imposing an onus on the appellant - whether the Commissioner erred in failing to have regard to the limited life expectancy of the tree when he considered the reasonableness of remedial measures - whether the Commissioner failed to take into account the effect of pruning on the aesthetics of the tree - whether the Commissioner failed to give adequate reasons as to the type and extent of pruning required to reduce the risk - whether the Commissioner failed to give adequate reasons with respect to his finding as to why he preferred one expert witness over another.

Held:  Appeal dismissed - it was open to the Commissioner to accept one expert witness on one aspect and another expert witness on another aspect - the Commissioner correctly recognised that Principle of Development Control 48 imposed a persuasive onus on applicants for approval - the Commissioner had regard both to the limited life expectancy of the tree and the effect of pruning on the aesthetics of the tree - the Commissioner provided adequate reasons and was not required to provide more particular details as to the pruning regime - the Commissioner was not required to provide reasons as to why he preferred one expert witness over another because he did not positively find that the pruning regime would be effective, he simply found that given the conflicting expert evidence, the applicant had not demonstrated that major pruning was an ineffective remedial measure.

Development Act 1993 (SA) s 4, 23(4a)(a); Development Regulations 2008 (SA) reg 6A, referred to.
Lacey v City of Burnside [2008] SAERDC 75; Tuna Boat Owners Association of SA Inc v Development Assessment Commission (2000) 77 SASR 369; City of Mitcham v Freckman (1999) 74 SASR 56; R v Olbrich (1999) 199 CLR 270, considered.

LACEY v CITY OF BURNSIDE
[2009] SASC 136

  1. KOURAKIS J:      This is an appeal from a decision of a Commissioner of the Environment, Resources and Development Court (the ERD Court), dismissing the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lacey v City of Burnside and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] SASC 136
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Lacey v City of Burnside involved an appeal by the appellant, Mr Lacey, against a decision by the respondent, the City of Burnside, to refuse his application for development approval to remove a significant tree in his backyard. The primary issue was whether the Commissioner of the Environment, Resources and Development Court had erred in his findings regarding the risk posed by the tree, the effectiveness of pruning as a remedial measure, and the reasons provided for the decision. The appeal was dismissed, with the Court affirming the Commissioner's decision.

The Commissioner had determined that the tree posed an unacceptable risk to safety, as per Principle of Development Control 48 of the City of Burnside Development Plan, and that Mr Lacey had not demonstrated that all reasonable remedial treatments and measures had been shown to be ineffective. The Commissioner accepted the evidence of one expert on the level of risk posed by the tree but not the other expert's evidence on the effectiveness of pruning. The Court found that it was within the Commissioner's discretion to accept one expert's evidence on one aspect and another's on a different aspect, given the conflicting opinions. The Court also held that the Commissioner correctly recognised that Principle of Development Control 48 imposed a persuasive onus on applicants for approval.

The Commissioner had taken into account the limited life expectancy of the tree and the effect of pruning on its aesthetics. The Court found that the Commissioner provided adequate reasons for his decision and was not required to provide more particular details on the pruning regime. The Commissioner did not need to explain why he preferred one expert over the other because he did not positively find that the pruning regime would be effective, but rather concluded that given the conflicting evidence, the applicant had not demonstrated that major pruning was an ineffective remedial measure. The Court concluded that the Commissioner's decision was not plainly wrong and dismissed the appeal.

The Court also addressed the appellant's concerns about the potential future refusal of planning approval to prune the tree beyond bare maintenance. It noted that if no new or different evidence emerged, the City of Burnside would likely accord great deference to the Commissioner's decision that the risk was unacceptable. The Court highlighted that Mr Lacey had the right to appeal any subsequent refusal and could also make an alternative application for the removal or severe pruning of the tree. The Court concluded that the Commissioner's decision was not plainly wrong and dismissed the appeal, with the parties to be heard on the matter of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The white gum is a significant tree for the purposes of PDC 42 and 48 because it is declared by the Development Plan to be such a tree pursuant to the power in s 23(4a)(a)(i), (v) and (vi) of the Act. It is also a significant tree because it falls within the criteria prescribed by reg 6A of the Development Regulations 2008.[1][1] Replacing reg 6A of the Development Regulations 1993 (SA) (ceased). The evidence PDC 42 applies if, relevantly to this case, the significant tree makes an important contribution to the character or amenity of the local area. It is not necessary to canvas the evidence to that effect in much detail because the Commissioner’s finding that the white gum makes such a contribution is not challenged. It is sufficient to mention that the unchallenged evidence of a landscape architect was that the white gum appears as a notable visual element from surrounding avenues and terraces up to 100 to 150 metres away, “creating a prominent and evergreen vegetated form in the urban realm”. The landscape architect also concluded that the white gum added substantial visual amenity to the otherwise drab lane at the rear of Mr Lacey’s home. The evidence concerning the extent of the risk posed by the white gum needs no more than a brief reference because the Commissioner’s finding that it posed an unacceptable risk is also not challenged.[2] The limb that nearly hit Mr Lacey in 2003 was about 250 mm in diameter. The evidence was that a branch of about 150 mm in diameter weighs about 90 kilograms. The branches that have fallen since have generally been between 50 to 100 mm, but one was nearly 200 mm.[2] Lacey v City of Burnside [2008] SAERDC 75 at [25]. In the hearing before the Commissioner, Burnside relied on the reports and testimony of Dr Nicolle, who holds an Honours Degree in Science from the University of Adelaide, Department of Botany, and a Doctorate from the Flinders University of South Australia, School of Biological Science. In a report dated 29 July 2008, he opined that Wallangarra Gums are subject to occasional smaller diameter (less than 100 mm) sudden branch failure events, but that such branch failure is more likely to occur in very wet and windy weather conditions. Dr Nicolle agreed that there was evidence of past branch failure up to about 200 mm in diameter. Although he assessed the likelihood of continuing branch failure as low, he did not challenge the frequency of the failure reported by Mr Lacey. In Dr Nicolle’s opinion the smaller diameter branches that failed were likely to hit the ground with only minor force, if falling from the lower crown, or to be completely caught in the crown of the tree if falling from higher up. In a report dated 20 August 2003 Mr Knight, a consulting arborist with an advanced diploma in aboriculture who was called by Mr Lacey, said that sudden limb failure is common in Wallangarra Gums. He testified that the rate of failure may accelerate as the white gum becomes older, and that the rate of limb drop reported by Mr Lacey was consistent with his experience. In a subsequent report dated 28 August 2008 Mr Knight explained that the limbs in the crown of the white gum are over-extended, end-weighted and have little taper. He attributed the frequency of limb failure in the past to those features. In Mr Knight’s opinion limb failure can occur during wind events, but more commonly occurs afterwards and without warning. In terms of his concern about the risk posed by the tree, Mr Knight was most concerned about those branches up to 250 mm in diameter.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, it is submitted that the Commissioner’s finding as to why he preferred one view over the other was not clear. However, as I have explained, the Commissioner did not positively find that the pruning regime would be effective. He was simply not persuaded by Mr Knight’s evidence. In my view, in the circumstances of this case, very little would have been gained by referring to the demeanour of the two experts or saying anything more about the strengths and weaknesses of their opinions. This was a relatively straightforward case where the Commissioner sensibly took the view that, given the conflicting expert evidence, major pruning could not be dismissed as a remedial measure without first giving it, and the tree, a chance.Conclusion For those reasons I dismiss the appeal. I mention by way of postscript that the appellant complained that the result of the decision is particularly harsh for Mr Lacey. He must now seek planning approval to prune the tree beyond bare maintenance. The appellant is concerned that that approval may not be granted on the basis of Burnside’s preference of Dr Nicolle’s view about the acceptability of the risk. However, if there is no new or different evidence it could be expected that Burnside would accord the Commissioner’s decision that the risk was unacceptable great deference. Ultimately, however, Mr Lacey will have a right of appeal against Burnside’s decision if it takes that view. I am prepared to assume that the issue of the acceptability of the risk has not been finally determined by the decision below. Nonetheless, another Commissioner who hears any subsequent appeal from Burnside’s refusal, if it were to take that view, will be aware of the desirability of certainty in planning decisions, and is unlikely to come to a different conclusion to the Commissioner unless he or she considers it to be plainly wrong or the evidence very different. It certainly does not appear to me to be plainly wrong. Moreover, Mr Lacey can make an alternative application either to remove or severely prune the white gum. If the pruning regime he applies for can be shown to unacceptably affect the vitality or aesthetics of the white gum, approval to remove it might still be given. Indeed, Mr Lacey’s present concerns would have been largely avoided if an application in the alternative, for hard pruning or removal, had been made in the first place. I will hear the parties as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.