La Costa D Oro Pty Ltd v Karananos

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

La Costa D Oro Pty Ltd & Anor v Karananos [2021] QSC 167

PARTIES:

LA COSTA D ORO PTY LTD ACN 643 877 267 AS TRUSTEE FOR THE LA COSTA D ORO TRUST
(first plaintiff)
THE DEVELOPMENT COLLECTION PTY LTD ACN 627 786 798 AS TRUSTEE FOR THE DEVELOPMENT COLLECTION TRUST
(second plaintiff)
v
JENNY KARANANOS
(defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 648 of 2021

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

20 July 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

11 June 2021

JUDGE:

Williams J

ORDER:

The orders of the Court are that:

1.     The defendant’s application dated 20 May 2021 is dismissed.

2. Pursuant to rules 375 and 377(1)(c) of the UCPR, the plaintiffs have leave to amend the Claim and Statement of Claim as set out in Exhibit “NJK1” to the Affidavit of Nathan James Kershler sworn 24 May 2021.

Further, the Court directs that:

3.     The parties are to confer on the appropriate costs order and, if agreed, a draft order is to be provided to my Associate.

4.     If the parties are unable to agree on the appropriate costs order, then each party is to provide brief written submissions on costs within 7 days.

CATCHWORDS:

REAL PROPERTY – TORRENS TITLE – CAVEATS AGAINST DEALINGS – REMOVAL – PARTICULAR CASES – where the second plaintiff and the defendant entered into an unconditional contract for the sale of residential land at Paradise Point – where the plaintiff requested a change to the buying entity under the contract and asked if the defendant would enter into a deed of rescission and new contract of sale to effect the name change – where the defendant verbally agreed to rescind the contract and enter into a new contract with the first plaintiff as the new buying entity – where a dispute arose in relation to the payment of the last instalment of the deposit – where the defendant purported to terminate the original contract in December 2020 – where the first plaintiff lodged caveats over the property in December 2020 claiming an estate in fee simple as purchaser – where the plaintiffs sent to the defendant a draft originating application seeking relief in respect of the agreement with the first plaintiff and alternatively the original contract with the second plaintiff – where the defendant withdrew the purported termination of the original contract – where the defendant filed an application in April 2021 to have the caveats lodged by the first plaintiff removed – where consent orders were made dismissing the application in respect of the caveats lodged by the first plaintiff – where the second plaintiff lodged caveats over the property in April 2021 asserting an interest in the performance of the contract of sale – where the defendant applies to have the caveats lodged by the first plaintiff removed – where the defendant applies to remove the two caveats lodged by the first plaintiff – whether the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read La Costa D Oro Pty Ltd v Karananos and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QSC 167
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

La Costa D Oro Pty Ltd v Karananos involved a dispute over real property between the plaintiffs and the defendant, which was heard in the Supreme Court. The plaintiffs sought to enforce a contract for the sale of residential land, while the defendant argued that the contract had been terminated. The plaintiffs lodged caveats over the property to protect their interests, and the defendant sought to have the caveats removed.

The central legal issues before the court were whether the plaintiffs had established a serious question to be tried regarding their claimed interests in the property, and whether the balance of convenience favoured maintaining the caveats. The court also had to decide whether the plaintiffs should be granted leave to amend their pleadings to better reflect the parties' positions and the evolving issues in the case.

The court found that the plaintiffs had demonstrated a serious question to be tried regarding their interests in the property, and that the balance of convenience favoured maintaining the caveats. The court noted that the issues in dispute between the parties had evolved significantly since the original contract was entered into, and that the parties' positions had shifted over time. The court also granted the plaintiffs leave to amend their pleadings to more accurately reflect the current state of the litigation and the issues in dispute between the parties.

The orders of the court were that the defendant's application to remove the caveats was dismissed, and that the plaintiffs were granted leave to amend their pleadings as set out in the affidavit of Nathan James Kershler. The court also directed the parties to confer on an appropriate costs order and to provide brief written submissions on costs if they were unable to agree.

Orders

Orders of the court

The orders of the Court are that:

1. The defendant’s application dated 20 May 2021 is dismissed.

2. Pursuant to rules 375 and 377(1)(c) of the UCPR, the plaintiffs have leave to amend the Claim and Statement of Claim as set out in Exhibit “NJK1” to the Affidavit of Nathan James Kershler sworn 24 May 2021.

Further, the Court directs that:

3. The parties are to confer on the appropriate costs order and, if agreed, a draft order is to be provided to my Associate.

4. If the parties are unable to agree on the appropriate costs order, then each party is to provide brief written submissions on costs within 7 days.

Background

Background to the litigation

The two applications were dealt with together in submissions as it was accepted that the two applications were interconnected.Procedural background Supreme Court proceedings were commenced on behalf of the first and second plaintiffs originally by way of an Originating Application where they were named as the first and second applicants. On 19 January 2021 it was ordered that the proceedings continue as if started by claim. On 16 February 2021 an Amended Claim and Statement of Claim were filed. On 19 March 2021 the defendant filed a Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence. The material read in respect of the two applications includes the pleadings and the following documents on the Court file:(a)affidavits filed in relation to the Originating Application;(b)affidavits filed in relation to an application dated 7 April 2021 by the defendant to remove two caveats lodged by the first plaintiff;(c)affidavits filed in support of the current application by the defendant to remove the two caveats lodged by the second plaintiff; and(d)affidavits filed in support of the current application to amend the Amended Claim and Statement of Claim.Application to remove caveats Section 122(1)(a) of the Land Title Act provides that a caveat may be lodged by a person claiming an interest in a lot. “Interest” is defined in Schedule 1 to the Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld) to mean:“(a) a legal or equitable estate in the land or other property; or(b) a right, power or privilege over, or in relation to, the land or other property”. Section 127 of the Land Title Act deals with the removal of caveats and states as follows:“(1) A caveatee may at any time apply to the Supreme Court for an order that a caveat be removed.(2) The Supreme Court may make the order whether or not the caveator has been served with the application, and may make the order on the terms it considers appropriate.” The applicable principles on an application to remove a caveat are not controversial. An application to remove a caveat requires:(a)The caveator to show a serious question to be tried as to whether its claimed interests exist; and(b)The balance of convenience favours maintenance of the caveat.[1][1]Re Jorss’ Caveat [1982] Qd R 458 cited with approval in HSBC Bank Australia Ltd v Wang [2021] QSC 58 at [4] per Holmes CJ; Burman v AGC (Advances) Ltd [1994] 1 Qd R 123 at 127-8. The application is heard summarily[2] and the burden of proof is:(a)upon the caveatee to show that the facts upon which the caveat is said to rest do not support a claim to an estate or interest in land; and(b)then, upon the caveator to show that issues exist which so tend to support a fairly arguable title to justify the prevention of dealings with the land until they have been decided in appropriate proceedings.[3][2]Goodwin v Gilbert [2000] QSC 309 at [15] citing Genrich v Maitland Holdings Pty Ltd [1982] Qd R 58 at 68.[3]Genrich v Maitland Holdings Pty Ltd [1982] Qd R 58 at 69. A key consideration is what constitutes a caveatable interest. The defendant relies on the following statement of principle:“[w]hat is necessary is that there be an interest in respect of which equity will give specific relief against the land itself …”.[4][4]Composite Buyers Ltd v Soong (1995) 38 NSWLR 286.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The plaintiffs submit there is no evidence that the defendant is suffering any particular inconvenience, and this is to be balanced with the second plaintiff being at risk of losing the benefit of the Original Contract.Consideration What is clear from a consideration of the evidence in this matter is that the issues in dispute between the parties have varied considerably over the period since the Original Contract was entered into on 18 August 2020. It is also apparent from the correspondence in evidence that over time the position of the parties has changed, and it is not clear that full consideration has been given to the various legal issues that have arisen. It appears that the following matters are relevant to the issues in dispute between the parties:(a)What is the status of the Original Contract?(i)It was allegedly terminated on 21 December 2020 by the defendant but the termination was “withdrawn” on 14 January 2021. Are there any legal implications arising from that?(ii)The defendant’s position after the withdrawal of the termination was that it remained on foot but terminated on 23 February 2021 on the basis that the second plaintiff had repudiated the Original Contract by its pleaded case in the Amended Claim and Statement of Claim. Was the defendant entitled to terminate the Original Contract on that basis?(iii)The second plaintiff maintains that the Original Contract remains on foot, there was no repudiation justifying termination and consequently the second plaintiff affirmed the Original Contract on 24 February 2021. Has the Original Contract been affirmed?(iv)The second plaintiff maintains it was “ready willing and able” to settle the Original Contract and alleges it took appropriate steps to settle the Original Contract. Did the second plaintiff comply with its obligations to settle the Original Contract?(v)Is the second plaintiff entitled to specific performance of the Original Contract?(b)In respect of the October Agreement:(i)Was there a binding agreement as alleged by the plaintiffs?(ii)If so, what were its terms?(iii)Did the defendant repudiate the October Agreement by its correspondence of 18 January 2021?(iv)Was the first plaintiff justified in accepting the repudiation by the defendant and terminating the October Agreement on 18 January 2021?(v)Is the first plaintiff entitled to the relief claimed in respect of the October Agreement? The issues outlined above in respect of the October Agreement are currently dealt with in the Amended Claim and Statement of Claim. However, the application to amend the pleadings seeks to amend what constitutes the “October Agreement” with the proposed pleading being that the agreement was reached on or about 12 November 2020 (that is, after the draft documents had been provided rather than before that time). The issues in respect of the Original Contract are not dealt with in the Amended Claim and Statement of Claim and the application to amend the pleadings seeks to address this. Currently, the Statement of Claim pleads that the Original Contract was entered into between the second plaintiff and the defendant.