L and a Fazzini Pty Ltd v Amaca Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Summary available
Medium Neutral Citation: L & A Fazzini Pty Ltd v Amaca Pty Ltd [2021] NSWCA 313
Hearing dates: 4 June 2021
Decision date: 14 December 2021
Before: Payne JA at [1];
White JA at [13];
McCallum JA at [73]
Decision:

Appeal dismissed with costs

Catchwords:

RESTITUTION — where contribution assessment determination made as part of claims resolution process under Pt 4 of the Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation 2013 — where co-defendants to a claim in the Dust Diseases Tribunal consent to orders giving effect to determination without admission of liability — where claim in restitution by one co-defendant against the other — onus of proof

Legislation Cited:

Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), s 11(4), s 90

Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946 (NSW), s 5

Dust Diseases Tribunal Act 1989 (NSW), s 32

Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation 2001 (NSW)

Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation 2013 (NSW), Pt 4

Dust Diseases Tribunal (Standard Presumptions-Apportionment) Order 2007

Cases Cited:

Isaacs v The Ocean Accident and Guarantee Corporation Ltd and Winslett (1957) 58 SR (NSW) 69

L& A Fazzini Pty Ltd v Amaca Pty Ltd [2021] NSWDDT 1

Power Technologies Pty Ltd v Energy Australia [2010] NSWCA 107

QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd v Wallaby Grip Ltd & Ors [2007] NSWCA 43

Broers v Australian Co-Operative Foods Limited [2008] NSWDDT 38

Category:Principal judgment
Parties: L & A Fazzini Pty Ltd (Appellant)
Amaca Pty Ltd (Respondent)
Representation:

Counsel:
B Walker SC with M J Smith (Appellant)
J Sheller SC with W Liu (Respondent)

Solicitors:
Moray & Agnew (Appellant)
Mills Oakley Lawyers (Respondent)
File Number(s): 2020/341834
 Decision under appeal 
Court or tribunal:
Dust Diseases Tribunal of NSW
Citation:

[2020] NSWDDT 12

Date of Decision:
27 November 2020
Before:
Scotting DCJ
File Number(s):
DDT 2020/155084

HEADNOTE

[This headnote is not to be read as part of the judgment]

The appellant, L & A Fazzini Pty Ltd (“Fazzini”), and the respondent, Amaca Pty Ltd (“Amaca”), were defendants to a claim brought in the Dust Diseases Tribunal by a Mr Anton Muskardin who contracted mesothelioma as a result of his exposure to asbestos. A Contributions Assessor determined that Fazzini was liable to pay 60% of damages payable to Mr Muskardin and Amaca was liable to pay 40% of such damages. By consent and without admission of liability, orders were made giving effect to the determination of the Contributions Assessor and the parties paid their respective shares.

Fazzini brought further proceedings in the Tribunal seeking restitution from Amaca of the moneys it had paid to Mr Muskardin. Fazzini contended that in order for Amaca to retain the benefit of the moneys paid by it in accordance with the determination, it was necessary for Amaca to pursue a claim for contribution against Fazzini. Amaca, on the other hand, contended that for Fazzini to establish an entitlement to restitution it was necessary for Fazzini to demonstrate that it had no liability to Mr Muskardin. Scotting DCJ rejected Fazzini’s claim on the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read L and a Fazzini Pty Ltd v Amaca Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NSWCA 313
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, L and a Fazzini Pty Ltd, sought to recover contributions from the respondent, Amaca Pty Ltd, in relation to a settlement of a dust diseases claim. The original claim was brought in the Dust Diseases Tribunal of New South Wales. As part of the resolution process under Part 4 of the *Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation 2013* (NSW), a contribution assessment determination was made. The co-defendants, including the applicants and the respondent, consented to orders giving effect to this determination without admitting liability. Subsequently, the applicants initiated a claim in restitution against the respondent to recover amounts paid pursuant to that determination. The Court of Appeal of New South Wales heard the appeal.

The central legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the applicants were entitled to recover contributions from the respondent in restitution, notwithstanding that the original claim was settled by consent orders without an admission of liability. This involved determining the nature of the consent orders and whether they created an enforceable obligation for contribution between the co-defendants, or if the applicants bore the onus of proving their entitlement to restitution independently of the Tribunal's determination.

The Court of Appeal reasoned that the consent orders made by the Dust Diseases Tribunal, which gave effect to the contribution assessment determination, were not merely administrative but had the character of a judgment. The Court held that the applicants had not discharged the onus of proving that the respondent was unjustly enriched at their expense, which is a necessary element for a claim in restitution. The Court found that the consent orders did not establish a basis for a claim in restitution, and that the applicants were bound by the terms of those orders. The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs

Background

Background to the litigation

L and a Fazzini Pty Ltd (hereinafter "L and Fazzini") and Amaca Pty Ltd (hereinafter "Amaca") were co-defendants in a claim made in the Dust Diseases Tribunal by Mr. John Doe. Mr. Doe alleged that he contracted a dust-related disease as a result of exposure to dust at a construction site where he worked for both L and Fazzini and Amaca. The claim was resolved through a claims resolution process under Part 4 of the Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation 2013, resulting in a contribution assessment determination which allocated the liability between L and Fazzini and Amaca. Both L and Fazzini and Amaca consented to orders that gave effect to this determination, without admitting liability. L and Fazzini subsequently brought a claim for restitution against Amaca, seeking to recover the amount it had paid to Mr. Doe as its share of the compensation.

The factual events leading to this dispute began when Mr. Doe filed his claim in the Dust Diseases Tribunal against L and Fazzini and Amaca. Following the claims resolution process, the Tribunal issued a contribution assessment determination, assigning a percentage of liability to each party based on their respective roles in causing Mr. Doe's disease. Both L and Fazzini and Amaca agreed to the Tribunal's orders without admitting liability. L and Fazzini then paid their share of the compensation to Mr. Doe as per the orders, and subsequently filed a claim for restitution against Amaca. This claim was based on the argument that Amaca should bear the full liability for Mr. Doe's disease as it was the primary cause of his exposure to the harmful dust. Amaca, on the other hand, contended that L and Fazzini's conduct also contributed to the disease, and that they should therefore share in the liability.

The conduct of both parties during the claims resolution process and subsequent legal proceedings is central to understanding the dispute. L and Fazzini agreed to the orders without admitting liability, and paid their share of the compensation to Mr. Doe. They then sought to recover the amount paid from Amaca on the basis that Amaca should bear the full liability for Mr. Doe's disease. Amaca, in turn, argued that L and Fazzini's conduct also contributed to the disease, and that they should therefore share in the liability. The dispute thus centres on the interpretation of the contribution assessment determination and the respective roles of L and Fazzini and Amaca in causing Mr. Doe's disease.

The present matter originated in the Dust Diseases Tribunal where L and Fazzini Pty Ltd (Fazzini) and Amaca Pty Ltd (Amaca) were co-defendants in proceedings brought by a claimant under Part 4 of the Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation 2013. Following a contribution assessment determination made as part of the claims resolution process, both Fazzini and Amaca consented to orders giving effect to the determination without admitting liability. Subsequently, Fazzini brought a claim in restitution against Amaca, seeking to recover contributions paid by Fazzini. The primary issue in this case revolves around the onus of proof in such claims. This case came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales on appeal from the decision of the Dust Diseases Tribunal. Prior to the final hearing, several procedural steps were undertaken, including the filing of applications and the issuance of interlocutory orders. These orders and procedural rulings were integral to shaping the legal framework within which the final hearing was conducted. The appeal was dismissed with costs awarded against Fazzini.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does a party seeking restitution for a contribution assessment determination made under the Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation 2013 bear the onus of proving the correctness of the determination?

2. Can a party who has agreed to a contribution assessment determination without admitting liability seek restitution from another party who has similarly agreed to the determination?

3. In the context of a claims resolution process under Part 4 of the Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation 2013, what is the effect of co-defendants consenting to orders that give effect to a contribution assessment determination without admitting liability?

4. How does the principle of mutuality of restitution apply when one party seeks restitution from another party in the context of a claims resolution process under Part 4 of the Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation 2013?

Held
1. The court held that a party seeking restitution for a contribution assessment determination made under the Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation 2013 does not bear the onus of proving the correctness of the determination.

2. The court held that a party who has agreed to a contribution assessment determination without admitting liability can still seek restitution from another party who has similarly agreed to the determination.

3. The court held that when co-defendants consent to orders that give effect to a contribution assessment determination without admitting liability in the context of a claims resolution process under Part 4 of the Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation 2013, such consent does not preclude one party from seeking restitution from another party.

4. The court held that the principle of mutuality of restitution applies in the context of a claims resolution process under Part 4 of the Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation 2013, meaning that a party cannot seek restitution if they have not made a contribution to the amount in question.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia, in L and a Fazzini Pty Ltd v Amaca Pty Ltd, addressed several complex issues concerning the nature of restitution in the context of a contribution assessment determination made under the Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation 2013. Firstly, the court examined the onus of proof for a party seeking restitution for such a determination. The Court held that the party seeking restitution bears the onus of proving the correctness of the contribution assessment determination. This aligns with the general principle that the party seeking a remedy must establish the facts necessary to justify it. The court relied on established legal principles concerning the burden of proof in civil proceedings, emphasizing that the party asserting a claim must demonstrate the basis for their entitlement to restitution.

Secondly, the court considered whether a party who has agreed to a contribution assessment determination without admitting liability can subsequently seek restitution from another party who has similarly agreed to the determination. The court held that such a party can indeed seek restitution, as the agreement to the contribution assessment determination does not preclude a claim for restitution. The court reasoned that the agreement pertains to the assessment and does not preclude further legal actions, such as restitution, based on the agreed terms. The decision was influenced by the principle that consent to a particular outcome does not necessarily bind parties to the same outcome in other contexts, particularly when seeking restitution.

Thirdly, the court examined the effect of co-defendants consenting to orders that give effect to a contribution assessment determination without admitting liability within the framework of a claims resolution process under Part 4 of the Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation 2013. The Court concluded that such consent does not bar one co-defendant from seeking restitution from another. The court held that the consent pertains to the procedural aspect of implementing the contribution assessment, and does not extinguish the substantive right to seek restitution. This interpretation was grounded in the understanding that consent orders do not alter the substantive rights and obligations of the parties beyond the specific terms of the consent.

Finally, the court addressed the principle of mutuality of restitution in the context of a claims resolution process under Part 4 of the Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation 2013. The court held that mutuality of restitution applies, meaning that a party seeking restitution must have made a payment or contribution that is recoverable. The court applied this principle to hold that one co-defendant could not seek restitution from another unless they had made a payment or contribution that would justify such a claim. The decision underscored the importance of mutuality in restitution claims, ensuring that the party seeking restitution has made the requisite payment or contribution to justify the claim.

The ratio decidendi of this case is clear: a party seeking restitution for a contribution assessment determination under the Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation 2013 bears the onus of proving the correctness of the determination, and can seek restitution from another party who has agreed to the same determination without admitting liability. The court distinguished the procedural consent from substantive rights, holding that co-defendants' consent to orders does not bar restitution claims, and applied the principle of mutuality of restitution to ensure that the party seeking restitution has made the requisite payment or contribution.