Kyren Pty Ltd v Cinema Place Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

KYREN PTY LTD v CINEMA PLACE PTY LTD

Judgment of The Honourable Chief Justice Doyle

8 September 2004

REAL PROPERTY - EASEMENTS - PARTICULAR EASEMENTS AND RIGHTS - RIGHTS OF WAY

Plaintiff owner of five allotments of land - two allotments adjoin defendant's land which is subject to the right of way - plaintiff constructing large building extending over all five allotments - whether plaintiff entitled to exercise right of way over defendant's land by having motor vehicles deliver materials to building site - whether plaintiff entitled to bring vehicles onto the defendant's land to carry out work on building's exterior - whether when building is complete shop tenants are able to exercise right of way by having vehicles deliver goods - whether the proposed use of the right of way is excessive - whether the proposed use is within the scope of the right of way.

Real Property Act 1889 (SA) s 89, Schedule 5, referred to.
Gallagher v Rainbow (1994) 179 CLR 624; Robmet Investments Pty Ltd v Don Chen Pty Ltd (1997) 8 BPR 15,461 ; Deanshaw and Deanshaw v Marshall (1978) 20 SASR 146; Elliott v Renner [1923] St R Qd 172; Bond and Leitch v Delfab Investments Pty Ltd (1980) 26 SASR 462; Lawrence v Griffiths (1987) 47 SASR 455; Peacock v Custins [2001] 2 All ER 827; Jelbert v Davis [1968] 1 WLR 589; Shean Pty Ltd v Owners of Corinne Court 290 Stirling Street, Perth Strata Plan 12821 (2001) 25 WAR 65, considered.

KYREN PTY LTD v CINEMA PLACE PTY LTD
[2004] SASC 268

Civil

  1. DOYLE CJ           Kyren Pty Ltd (“Kyren”) is the registered proprietor of five allotments of land that form a single parcel of land lying between Frome Street and Vaughan Place in Adelaide.  Two of these allotments (“the dominant tenements”) abut Vaughan Place, which is a private road.

  2. Kyren has a “free and unrestricted right of way” over part of Vaughan Place in its capacity as registered proprietor of the dominant tenements.  Vaughan Place is owned by Cinema Place Pty Ltd (“Cinema”).

  3. Vaughan Place runs approximately 65 metres in a north-south direction off the northern side of Rundle Street.  It then makes a right-angled turn and runs approximately 74 metres in an east-west direction to Frome Street. 

  4. Cinema is the proprietor of the north-south section only.  That is the part of Vaughan Place over which the relevant right of way exists. For present purposes, the east-west section can be ignored.  (This summary ignores some of the title details, but they are of no significance to the present case).

  5. Kyren is erecting a substantial building on its land.  The building extends over all five allotments.  When the building is complete it will provide premises at ground level to be used as shops, facing onto Vaughan Place.

  6. Kyren claims to be entitled to exercise its right of way over Vaughan Place by having motor vehicles deliver building materials to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kyren Pty Ltd v Cinema Place Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] SASC 268
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Kyren Pty Ltd, the owner of five allotments of land, brought an action against Cinema Place Pty Ltd, the owner of adjoining land, over the right of way on Vaughan Place. Kyren sought to construct a large building across all five allotments and wished to use the right of way for the delivery of materials, as well as to perform work on the building's exterior. Additionally, Kyren intended for shop tenants to use the right of way to deliver goods to the shops once the building was complete. Cinema opposed the use of the right of way, claiming it was excessive and beyond the scope of the easement.

The court had to determine whether Kyren was entitled to use the right of way for the proposed purposes and whether the use was excessive or within the scope of the right of way. The court found that the proposed use was within the scope of the right of way and was not excessive. The court held that Kyren was entitled to exercise the right of way in the manner proposed, including bringing motor vehicles onto Vaughan Place for loading and unloading.

The court declared that Kyren was entitled to exercise a free and unrestricted right of way over the relevant part of Vaughan Place, including the use of motor vehicles for the purposes mentioned above. The court also found that Cinema had infringed and obstructed the exercise of Kyren's right of way by refusing access to Vaughan Place. However, the court did not consider it necessary to grant a more prescriptive declaration regarding the permissible exercise of the right of way, as this could lead to future disputes. The court expected Cinema to cease obstructing Kyren's rights and accept the consequences of the court's conclusions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

DOYLE CJ
I therefore conclude that the fact that the building being erected extends to allotments other than the dominant tenements does not, of itself, entitle Cinema to obstruct Kyren in the exercise of its right of way.Conclusion I am satisfied that Kyren is entitled to exercise its right of way, in the manner proposed by it, in connection with the erection of the building that it is erecting on the dominant tenements, and in connection with the occupation of the two proposed commercial premises at the ground floor of that building. It is appropriate to declare that Kyren is entitled to exercise a free and unrestricted right of way over the relevant part of Vaughan Place. It is also appropriate to grant a declaration that Kyren is entitled to exercise that right of way in connection with the erection of the building now being erected on the dominant tenements and in connection with the occupation of the proposed retail tenancies. It is appropriate to declare further that that exercise of the right of way includes the bringing of motor vehicles on to Vaughan Place and causing those motor vehicles to stand on Vaughan Place for the purpose of loading and unloading those vehicles. A further declaration should be granted that Cinema has infringed and obstructed the exercise of Kyren’s right of way by refusing it access to Vaughan Place. In the circumstances, and subject to further submissions, I consider that it is not appropriate to grant a declaration in more prescriptive terms as to the nature and extent of the permissible exercise of the right of way. If disputes arise they will have to be dealt with. Passing reference was made in evidence and in submissions to metal frames that Cinema has erected on Vaughan Place in connection with the street market. I understand that these are used to support temporary covering or cladding around the stalls. There is an issue as to whether the frames erected adjacent to the dominant tenements constitute an obstruction to the right of way, but I have not heard sufficient evidence to enable me to make findings on that matter. Nor have I heard any evidence yet on the question of damages. At this stage it does not seem necessary to enjoin Cinema from interfering with Kyren’s rights. At this stage I assume that Cinema will cease its obstruction to Kyren exercising its right of way, and will accept the consequences of my conclusions. As I have already indicated, I realise that there is scope for further disputes to arise between the parties, but on the information before me I am not able to deal with the matter in a manner that will avoid that possibility.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DOYLE CJ

Full text does not contain this section.