Kyle Marsh and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

[2015] AATA 308  

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2013/4027

Re

Kyle Marsh

APPLICANT

And

Civil Aviation Safety Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President PE Hack SC

Date 8 May 2015
Place Brisbane

1. The respondent’s decision of 8 August 2013, made in reliance on reg 298A(4) of the Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (Cth), is affirmed.

2. The respondent’s decision of 8 August 2013, made in reliance on reg 269(1) of the Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (Cth), is set aside.

..................[Sgd]......................................................

Deputy President PE Hack SC

CATCHWORDS

CIVIL AVIATION – cheating by examination candidates – whether applicant gave another person information about questions contained in examination paper being information that might give anyone unfair advantage in examination – decision under review affirmed

CIVIL AVIATION – suspension of licence – whether applicant is not fit and proper person to have responsibilities and exercise and perform functions and duties of holder of licence – decision under review set aside

LEGISLATION

Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (Cth), regs 269(1)(d), 298A(1)(c), 298A(1)(d), 298A(1)(e), 298A(1)(f)(iii)

CASES

Marsh & Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2013] AATA 729

Civil Aviation Safety Authority v Marsh [2014] FCA 1253

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President PE Hack SC

8 May 2015

Introduction

  1. On 10 October 2013 I set aside two decisions of the respondent, the Civil Aviation Safety Authority, concerning the applicant, Mr Kyle Marsh.[1]  The decisions made by the Authority were made on 8 August 2013 and were,

    (a)a decision that Mr Marsh had contravened reg 298A(1)(c) of the Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (Cth); and,

    (b)a decision, made in reliance on reg 269(1) of the Civil Aviation Regulations, to suspend Mr Marsh’s various aviation licences for a period of six months.

    [1]Re Marsh & Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2013] AATA 729.

  2. Subsequently, on the Authority’s appeal, the Federal Court decided that I had erred in my interpretation of reg 298A and that I had not dealt with an argument raised by the Authority.[2]  The matter has been remitted for rehearing in accordance with the law.

  3. The parties are agreed that the matter will be determined on the basis of the existing evidence, supplemented by further written submissions lodged on behalf of Mr Marsh and the Authority.

    Factual background

  4. In my earlier decision I set out the factual background in this way:

    [1]The applicant, Mr Kyle Marsh, is a commercial pilot. He wishes to obtain an Air Transport Pilot Licence (ATPL), the highest grade of pilot’s licence available, a qualification recognised by all airlines and by aviation regulators worldwide. To that end on 12 October 2011 he undertook a flight planning theory examination conducted under the auspices of the respondent, the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA). He passed that examination.

    [2]In September 2012 CASA came into possession of information that suggested that Mr Marsh may have cheated in the October 2011 examination and that in July 2012 he may have provided information to another person…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kyle Marsh and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 308
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter involves Kyle Marsh, a commercial pilot seeking an Air Transport Pilot Licence (ATPL), and the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA), which administers aviation safety regulations in Australia. The dispute arose from CASA's decision to suspend Marsh's various pilot licenses following allegations that he provided information about examination questions to another person, potentially giving them an unfair advantage in a subsequent examination. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with reviewing CASA's decisions under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977.

The court had to determine two key legal issues: first, whether Marsh's actions constituted a contravention of regulation 298A(1)(c) of the Civil Aviation Regulations 1988, which prohibits providing information about examination questions that might give an unfair advantage; and second, whether Marsh was unfit to hold a pilot license under regulation 269(1)(d) of the same Regulations. The court also had to interpret the term "examination" as used in the regulation.

The court found that Marsh had indeed provided information about examination questions to another person, which might have given them an unfair advantage in future examinations. This was a contravention of regulation 298A(1)(c). The court clarified that "examination" in the regulation referred to a generic examination, not just a specific sitting. However, the court set aside the decision to suspend Marsh's licenses as not being a fit and proper person. The court held that the evidence did not support such a finding, as it did not demonstrate a likelihood of future misconduct.

The court affirmed CASA's decision regarding the contravention of regulation 298A(1)(c) but set aside the decision to suspend Marsh's licenses on the ground of unfitness. The court's reasoning was based on a correct interpretation of the regulation and an assessment of the evidence presented. The final orders were to affirm the contravention finding and set aside the suspension decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The parties are agreed that the matter will be determined on the basis of the existing evidence, supplemented by further written submissions lodged on behalf of Mr Marsh and the Authority.Factual background In my earlier decision I set out the factual background in this way:[1]The applicant, Mr Kyle Marsh, is a commercial pilot. He wishes to obtain an Air Transport Pilot Licence (ATPL), the highest grade of pilot’s licence available, a qualification recognised by all airlines and by aviation regulators worldwide. To that end on 12 October 2011 he undertook a flight planning theory examination conducted under the auspices of the respondent, the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA). He passed that examination.[2]In September 2012 CASA came into possession of information that suggested that Mr Marsh may have cheated in the October 2011 examination and that in July 2012 he may have provided information to another person (who I shall call N) that might have allowed others to cheat in a similar manner. On 8 August 2013, following an investigation, CASA, by a delegate, decided that he had assisted another person to cheat and decided to suspend his various licences for a period of six months. …[8]The theory part of the ATPL examination comprises seven parts – human factors, aerodynamics and aircraft systems, performance and loading, navigation, meteorology, flight planning and air law. The separate parts are examined separately and a candidate is permitted to take up to three years from the first examination attempt to complete all seven examinations. Once all seven have been completed successfully the candidate has completed the ATPL theory exam. [9]The examination in issue here was the flight planning segment. The examination was designed to test a candidate’s understanding of flight planning procedures including fuel requirements, altitude capability, performance limitations, calculations of point of no return and suchlike. A candidate was required to answer 17 questions. Each question represented an area of the syllabus. Prior to the events in issue here CASA had worked out 105 possible questions designed to test flight planning. The bank of questions had not altered greatly since the last major syllabus change in April 1994. The examination was undertaken online at premises under the control of an external provider. Each candidate had access to a computer terminal. Once the candidate was logged on, the computer selected the 17 questions randomly from the bank of questions available and displayed those questions to the candidate. The examination questions had multiple choice answers, generally with four or five possible answers, and the candidate was required to select an answer with the computer’s mouse. The examination was timed through the computer terminal. It closed down, checked the answers and determined the result at the end of the permitted time. A candidate who finished before the end of the permitted time could submit the answers and obtain the result. The examination forced candidates to work under considerable pressure of time. A candidate could revisit answers at any time until the answers were submitted, either voluntarily, or through the effluxion of time. Candidates were permitted to take maps, navigation equipment and the Performance and Operating Handbook for a Boeing 727 aircraft into the examination room. [10]It seems that at least by 2011 there were numerous documents circulating widely amongst students that provided answers to many of the possible 105 questions. That is not surprising given that CASA had used the same 105 questions for almost 20 years. The document in issue in these proceedings was apparently one such document. Someone (and it is not suggested that it was Mr Marsh) took four pages of what appear to be coded answers to questions and incorporated them into pages from the Boeing 727 Handbook permitted in the examination room in such a way as made them appear, on a superficial inspection, to be a part of that Handbook. The borders of each of the four pages are exact reproductions of the borders of pages from that Handbook but the text inside the borders reproduces the coded answers. The general format of the inserted part consists of a repetition of key factual data from a question with the answer at the end. Thus,SY-WN FL290 .82M SY BRW 85900 TFOB@BRW 22400 70450which appeared on one page was a reference to a question that asked about landing weight (LW) of a flight from Sydney (SY) to Wellington (WN) at 29,000 feet (FL290) and a brake release weight (BRW) of 85,900 kg. The correct answer was 70,450 kg. The four pages contained very many similar references. The evidence of Mr Gavin Secombe, CASA’s Cyber Exams Administrator, is that the answers to 33 of the possible 105 questions appear on these four pages. There is no reason to doubt that evidence. [11]The conclusion is inescapable that the four pages were designed to be taken into an examination room and to provide an improper advantage to any candidate using them. Any such use was plainly gross and flagrant cheating. [12]CASA first became aware of these pages in September 2012 when a whistle-blower forwarded those pages together with numerous similar pages (although the other pages were not disguised so cleverly). The whistle-blower alleged that it was “common knowledge” that candidates were using “cheat sheets” to pass the examination. The description seems entirely accurate. Subsequently the whistle-blower sent to CASA an email apparently sent by Mr Marsh to N on 7 July 2012 together with the attachment comprising the four pages. Mr Marsh accepted that he had sent the email and that the four pages with the coded answers “probably” comprised the attachment to his email to N.[13]CASA undertook an investigation. Mr Marsh was questioned by Mr John Moore, a CASA investigator. He agreed that he had provided the coded pages to N but denied having used the pages during his examination in October 2011.[14]By letter of 14 February 2013 CASA gave to Mr Marsh the notice required by reg 298A(1) of the Civil Aviation Regulations. That notice informed him that the author considered that there were reasonable grounds to believe that on 12 October 2011, in Maroochydore, Queensland, during a CASA Flight Planning Cyber Exam, Mr Marsh contravened sub-regulation 298A(1)(e) of the Civil Aviation Regulations. The notice went on to set out the facts and circumstances relied on. It set out the terms of reg 298A(1)(e) together with other relevant provisions of the Regulations. The notice then read,On the basis of the facts and circumstances set out above, I consider that there are reasonable grounds to believe that your conduct on 21 March 2012 contravened sub-regulation 298A(e) [sic] of the CAR in that you:(a)gave to another person, Mr Marsh, answers to questions and information about questions contained within the examination paper;(b)before the examination knowingly received from another person answers to questions and information about questions contained within the examination paper.It will be immediately apparent that there is discord between the facts in the introductory part of the notice, which asserted a belief about events during the examination in October 2011, and that in the latter part which asserted a belief about conduct in March 2012 involving the giving of answers to a Mr Marsh. [15]In any event Mr Marsh wrote to CASA (with the assistance of his father) on 8 April 2013.[16]Then on 17 May 2013 CASA sent a further notice to Mr Marsh. On this occasion the author, having referred to the previous notice of 14 February 2013, asserted that,…it is open to CASA to find that [Mr Marsh] also contravened sub-regulation 298A(1)(c) of the CAR and that the delegate should also make findings to that effect under sub-regulation 298A(4) of the CAR.The notice continued,On the basis of the facts and circumstances set out in the previous notice, I consider that there are reasonable grounds to believe that your conduct on 7 July 2012 contravened sub-regulations 298A(1)(c) of the CAR in that you:(a)gave to another person,[N], in the form of an email, information about questions contained in a theoretical examination paper being answers to questions and information about questions contained within that examination paper;(b)that information was information that might give [N] an unfair advantage in the examination. On the evidence before me N sat the examination (successfully) in March 2011.[17]On 8 August 2013 a delegate of CASA made the decisions that are the subject of these proceedings. The decisions were as follows:(a)in accordance with sub-regulation 298A(4) of the Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (CAR) that I am satisfied, and I have therefore decided to make a finding, that you contravened sub-regulation 298A(1)(c) of the CAR; and(b)in accordance with sub-regulations 269(1)(c) and (d) of the CAR, to suspend your student pilot licence, private pilot (aeroplane) licence, and commercial pilot (aeroplane) licence until six months has elapsed from the date of commencement of the suspension.That decision was based on findings recorded as follows:28.Pursuant to sub-regulation 298A(4) of the CAR, I am notifying you that, on the basis of the facts and circumstances set out above, I have decided that your conduct on 7 July 2012 also contravened sub-regulations [sic] 298A(1)(c) of the CAR in that you:(i) gave to another person, [N], in the form of an email, information about questions contained in a theoretical examination paper, being answers to questions and information about questions contained within that examination paper;(ii) that information was information that would give [N] an unfair advantage in the examination.29.I have decided that, whilst there is a strong inference that you had access to the cheat sheet prior to sitting the Cyber Exam on 12 October 2011, I make no finding that you contravened sub-regulation 298A(1)(e) of the CAR. However, for the avoidance of any doubt, CASA maintains its position that your answers in the Cyber Exam are consistent with the compromised answers contained in the cheat sheet as illustrated at paragraph 11 above.[18]This application was lodged in the Tribunal on 15 August 2013. The implementation of CASA’s decision to suspend Mr Marsh’s licences has been stayed by operation of law and as a consequence of an order of the Tribunal made on 27 August 2013. Hearing of the matter was expedited.The statutory setting

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Additionally, it is relevant to note that the Authority may, pursuant to reg 269(1) of the Civil Aviation Regulations vary, suspend or cancel an approval, authority, certificate or licence, if it is satisfied that one or more of the following grounds exist:(a) that the holder of the authorisation has contravened, a provision of the Act or these Regulations, including these regulations as in force by virtue of a law of a State;(b) that the holder of the authorisation fails to satisfy, or to continue to satisfy, any requirement prescribed by, or specified under, these Regulations in relation to the obtaining or holding of such an authorisation;(c) that the holder of the authorisation has failed in his or her duty with respect to any matter affecting the safe navigation or operation of an aircraft;(d) that the holder of the authorisation is not a fit and proper person to have the responsibilities and exercise and perform the functions and duties of a holder of such an authorisation;(e) that the holder of the authorisation has contravened, a direction or instruction with respect to a matter affecting the safe navigation and operation of an aircraft, being a direction or instruction that is contained in Civil Aviation Orders.Consideration – the reg 298A conduct In my earlier decision I concluded that it was not open to make a finding of a contravention of reg 298A(1)(c). I reached that conclusion on the basis of a construction of the regulation that has been held to be erroneous. On the appeal from the earlier decision Collier J said:[4][37]Subregulation 298A(1)(c)(iii) is expressed in terms both retrospective and prospective. It applies to a person who has previously attempted the examination, and who has given information to another person, where that information, in future, might give anyone an unfair advantage in the examination. This reading of the plain language of the subregulation is inconsistent with the interpretation accorded to it by the Tribunal. It is certainly inconsistent with the finding of the Tribunal that the information given by Mr Marsh in July 2012 could not “give an unfair advantage” to a candidate at that time because “the examination” was that sat by Mr Marsh in October 2011. The interpretation of the Tribunal is flawed, because subreg (iii) primarily envisages the relevant information being given after the sitting of the examination by the giver of the information. …[43]All of these factors support the conclusion that “the examination” in reg 298A(1)(c)(iii) is not the examination sitting attempted by the candidate who has given the information, but rather is a generic examination more broadly defined. In this case “the examination” for the purposes of reg 298A(1)(c)(iii) was “the ATPL flight theory examination”, and not only the October 2011 sitting of the ATPL flight theory examination attempted by Mr Marsh. Such an interpretation not only gives effect to reg 298A(1)(c)(iii) with respect to unfair advantages gained in future sittings, it is also consistent with the reality of the generic examinations prescribed by CASA which can be attempted online on more than one occasion and use a finite database of questions.[4][2014] FCA 1253.