Kwiatkowska v Minister for Home Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

KWIATKOWSKA & ORS v MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS & ANOR [2018] FCCA 2795
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Student Visa – decision of Administrative Appeals Tribunal – Student Visa denied – whether jurisdictional error – none shown – application for judicial review dismissed.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) s.476(1)

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) cls. 570.232, 571.232, 572.223(1)(a), 572.231, 572.322, 573.111, 573.231, 574.111, 574.231, 575.111, 575.231

Cases cited:

AQN15 v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2016] FCA 571

AQN15 v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2016] HCASL 183

AYE16 v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2017] FCCA 1424

AYE16 v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2018] FCA 108

DQQ17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 784

Maroun v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2009) 112 ALD 424

Singh v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2016] FCCA 2264

Singh v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 213

SZNXA v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] FCA 775

WZAVW v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2016] FCA 760

First Applicant: BARBARA MARIA KWIATKOWSKA
Second Applicant: KRZYSZTOF TOMASZ KWIATKOWSKI
Third Applicant: MARCIN ZBIGNIEW KWIATKOWSKI
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS
Second Respondent: ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File Number: PEG 724 of 2017
Judgment of: Judge Kendall
Hearing date: 20 September 2018
Date of Last Submission: 20 September 2018
Delivered at: Perth
Delivered on: 27 September 2018

REPRESENTATION

The Applicant: Appearing in person with the assistance of an interpreter
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr T. Lettenmaier
Solicitors for the First Respondent: Sparke Helmore
The Second Respondent: Submitting appearance, save as to costs

ORDERS

  1. The applicant’s originating application filed 27 December 2017 is dismissed.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT PERTH

PEG 724 of 2017

BARBARA MARIA KWIATKOWSKA

First Applicant

KRZYSZTOF TOMASZ KWIATKOWSKI

Second Applicant

MARCIN ZBIGNIEW KWIATKOWSKI

Third Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. By an originating application filed in the Federal Circuit Court on 27 December 2017, the applicants seek judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the “Tribunal”) dated 12 December 2017.

  2. The Tribunal’s decision affirmed a decision of a Ministerial delegate dated 17 December 2015 not to grant the first applicant a Student (TU) (subclass 572) visa (“visa”). That denial had the effect of denying both the second and third applicants the relevant visas they seek.

  3. To succeed before this Court, the Court must be satisfied that the Tribunal’s decision was affected by jurisdictional error.

Background Facts

  1. The background to this matter is outlined in the Minister’s outline of submissions to this Court filed on 13 September 2018.  The Court has had regard to these submissions and adopts the procedural and factual background to these proceedings as outlined by the Minister at paragraphs 3 to 7.  These background facts were not in dispute and provide, relevantly, as follows.

  2. The first applicant is a citizen of Poland who first arrived in Australia on 15 September 2014 (Court…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kwiatkowska v Minister for Home Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCCA 2795
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Barbara Maria Kwiatkowska, Krzysztof Tomasz Kwiatkowska, and Marcin Zbigniew Kwiatkowska, sought judicial review of a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) in the Federal Circuit Court. The Tribunal's decision affirmed a delegate's refusal to grant the first applicant a Student (TU) (subclass 572) visa, which consequently denied visas to the second and third applicants. The applicants contended that the Tribunal's decision was affected by jurisdictional error.

The primary legal issues before the Court were whether the Tribunal committed jurisdictional error and whether a confirmation of enrolment was a mandatory requirement at the time of the Tribunal's decision. The applicants argued that the Tribunal erred in its assessment of their eligibility for the visa.

The Court considered the Tribunal's finding that the first applicant had failed to provide evidence of current enrolment in a course of study, a requirement under the Migration Regulations 1994. The Tribunal had adjourned the hearing to allow the applicant to submit such evidence, but the documents provided were either for a completed course or outside the specified enrolment dates. The Court noted that the applicants had not particularised their grounds of review adequately, despite opportunities to do so. However, given the applicant's lack of legal representation and limited English proficiency, the Court allowed her to articulate her concerns orally. The applicant's submissions focused on the adequacy of translation services and her health on the day of the hearing.

The Court dismissed the applicants' originating application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

The applicant’s originating application filed 27 December 2017 is dismissed.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT

OF AUSTRALIA

AT PERTH

PEG 724 of 2017

BARBARA MARIA KWIATKOWSKA

First Applicant

KRZYSZTOF TOMASZ KWIATKOWSKI

Second Applicant

MARCIN ZBIGNIEW KWIATKOWSKI

Third Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

1.

By an originating application filed in the Federal Circuit Court on 27 December 2017, the applicants seek judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the “Tribunal”) dated 12 December 2017.

2.

The Tribunal’s decision affirmed a decision of a Ministerial delegate dated 17 December 2015 not to grant the first applicant a Student (TU) (subclass 572) visa (“visa”). That denial had the effect of denying both the second and third applicants the relevant visas they seek.

3.

To succeed before this Court, the Court must be satisfied that the Tribunal’s decision was affected by jurisdictional error.

Background Facts

4.

The background to this matter is outlined in the Minister’s outline of submissions to this Court filed on 13 September 2018. The Court has had regard to these submissions and adopts the procedural and factual background to these proceedings as outlined by the Minister at paragraphs 3 to 7. These background facts were not in dispute and provide, relevantly, as follows.

5.

The first applicant is a citizen of Poland who first arrived in Australia on 15 September 2014 (Court Book (“CB”) at 38).

6.

On 4 November 2015, the first applicant (as the primary applicant) lodged an application for the visa (CB at 1-10). The applicant’s husband and son were included in the application as members of her family unit (CB at 2-4).

7.

On 17 December 2017, the delegate refused to grant the visa on the basis that the first applicant did not satisfy the requirements of cl.572.223(1)(a) of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (the “Regulations”) (CB at 35-43).

8.

On 26 December 2015, the applicants applied to the Tribunal for review of the delegate’s decision (CB at 44-46).

9.

On 3 November 2017, the Tribunal invited the applicants to attend a hearing before it to give evidence and present arguments (CB at 62-67). The first applicant attended a hearing on 27 November 2017 (CB at 74).

10.

On 12 December 2017, the Tribunal affirmed the decision of the delegate not to grant the applicants the relevant visa (CB at 83).

The Decision of the Tribunal

11.

The Tribunal’s decision has been reproduced at pages 83 to 86 of the Court Book.

12.

The Tribunal identified that the relevant question before it was whether, at the time of its decision, the applicant met the enrolment requirements for a student visa (CB 84 at [10]).

13.

The Tribunal noted that, subject to limited exceptions, the Regulations require that at the time of decision an applicant must be enrolled in, or be the subject of a current offer of enrolment in, a course of study that is a principal course, and is of a type specified under r.1.40A for the subclass at the time of application.

14.

The Tribunal found that there was no evidence before it that the applicant was an eligible higher degree student as defined in cl.573.111 and cl.574.111 of the Regulations respectively, or an eligible university exchange student or eligible non-award student for the purposes of subclass 575 as defined in cl.575.111 (CB 85 at [11]).

15.

The applicant confirmed to the Tribunal that she was not currently enrolled in a course of study. She claimed that following the completion of her Certificate III in Spoken and Written English she had enrolled in a Certificate IV. She further explained that she was unable to complete this course because she had experienced health problems (CB 85 at [13]).

16.

The Tribunal noted that with the invitation to attend the hearing the primary applicant had been requested to provide evidence of her current enrolment. The Tribunal also noted that it had discussed with the applicant and her elder son Mr Bartosz Krzysztof Kwiatkowski that it was a legislative requirement for the grant of the visa that the applicant be enrolled or subject to an offer of enrolment in a course of study at the time of the hearing (CB 85 at [14]).

17.

At the conclusion of the hearing the Tribunal advised the applicant that it would defer making a decision until 4 December 2017 to allow the applicant to submit evidence of enrolment and additionally any medical evidence addressing the impact of her claimed medical conditions on her study (CB 85 at [15]).

18.

On 29 November 2017, the Tribunal received on behalf of the applicants the following documents (CB 85 at [16]):

a) A Confirmation of Enrolment for the first applicant in a Certificate IV in Spoken and Written English with course dates from 8 March 2017 to 18 August 2017 (“COE”);

b) A Certificate of Completion of a Certificate II in Spoken and Written English dated 6 May 2016, and academic transcript; and

c) A Certificate of Completion of a Certificate III in Spoken and Written English dated 9 February 2017, and academic transcript.

19.

The Tribunal found that the Confirmation of Enrolment submitted was in respect of the course that the applicant gave evidence to the Tribunal that she did not complete. The Tribunal also noted that the enrolment dates for the course had passed and no further evidence had been submitted at the date of the Tribunal’s decision (CB 86 at [17]).

20.

The Tribunal concluded that it had no evidence before it that the applicant is now enrolled in, or has a current offer of enrolment in any applicable course of study (CB 86 at [17]).

21.

On the basis of the information before it, or lack thereof, the Tribunal found that the applicant had failed to meet the requirements provided for by cl. 570.232, 571.232, 572.231, 573.231, 574.231 and 575.231 (CB 86 at [17]).

22.

The Tribunal also found that there was no evidence that the applicant satisfied the criteria for either a subclass 576 (AusAID or Defence Sector) or subclass 580 (Student Guardian) visa (CB 86 at [17]).

23.

As the applicant had not satisfied cl.572.231 or any similar provision of another Subclass of student visa, the Tribunal found that the second named applicants could not be granted a visa under cl.572.322 (CB 86 at [20]).

24.

The Tribunal concluded that on the basis of the scant evidence before it, the decision under review should be affirmed (CB 86 at [22]).

Present Proceedings

25.

This proceeding is brought pursuant to s.476(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the “Act”).

26.

The applicant seeks judicial review in this Court, relying on two grounds of review:

1. The Tribunal committed jurisdictional error.

2. There was no requirement for a confirmation of enrolment at the time of the tribunal’s decision.

27.

The originating application was supported by an affidavit sworn by the applicant on 23 December 2017 which annexes a copy of the Tribunal’s decision.

28.

On 28 February 2018, orders were made by this Court which included the following:

4. By 4:00pm on 20 April 2018, the applicant shall file and serve any amended application upon which the applicant intends to rely, giving complete particulars of each ground of review.

5. By 4:00pm on 20 April 2018, the applicant shall file and serve any affidavit containing any additional evidence upon which the applicant proposes to rely relevant only to the grounds of review.

7. By 4:00pm 14 days prior to the hearing, the applicant shall file and serve written submissions in support of the application for review.

29.

As at the date of the hearing the applicant had not filed an amended application or an outline of submissions. Nor had she filed any further affidavits.

30.

In the circumstances, the grounds as articulated are effectively meaningless (SZNXA v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] FCA 775). The grounds remain unparticularised notwithstanding that the applicant had an opportunity to amend and particularise the grounds pursuant to the Registrar's orders. This alone provides a basis for each of the two grounds to be dismissed: AYE16 v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2017] FCCA 1424 at [20] per Judge Lucev, approved on appeal in AYE16 v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2018] FCA 108 at [25] per Barker J. See also WZAVW v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2016] FCA 760 at [35] per Gilmour J; AQN15 v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2016] FCA 571 at [5]‑[6] per Logan J (from which an application for special leave was refused: AQN15 v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2016] HCASL 183). More recently, Colvin J (in DQQ17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 784 at [8]) commented that the consequences of a failure to particularise will depend upon the circumstances. His Honour observed that it will rarely be appropriate to simply dismiss an appeal ground in a migration case for lack of particularisation where the appellant seeks relief in respect of a decision concerning an application for a protection visa and the person is appearing on his or her own behalf. His Honour found that, in such cases, it is usually appropriate for the party to be afforded an opportunity to explain orally the matters that are said to give rise to an appeal (or review) ground (at [9]).

31.

Although this matter does not raise protection claims, the Court is nonetheless of the view that the circumstances of this case are not such that the applicant should be denied the opportunity to articulate her concerns orally before this Court. While such an approach might apply within the context of an applicant who is legally represented, it is, in the Court’s view, inappropriate in circumstances where an applicant is not legally represented and is not fluent in the English language. In those circumstances an applicant should be given an opportunity to particularise and make any submissions that she wishes to make.

32.

Accordingly, the applicant was asked to explain what she believes the Tribunal did wrong. It was explained to her that the Court could not engage in merits review. Rather, the Court can only look at whether there is evidence of jurisdictional error on the part of the Tribunal. The applicant’s submissions, made orally with the assistance of an interpreter in the Polish language, are outlined below.

Consideration

Ground One

The Tribunal committed jurisdictional error

33.

In relation to this ground of review, the applicant told the Court, in effect, that the Tribunal did not allow her adequate translation services. When asked whether she understood the Tribunal’s questions, the applicant stated that she did “more or less” but was not entirely clear about what was expected of her because she was “quite stressed” and suffering from poor health.

34.

This raises two issues. The first relates to court translation and whether the applicant was treated fairly in this regard. The second relate to the applicant’s health on the day of the hearing and whether or not the hearing should have occurred on the day.

Translation Services

35.

Background

Background to the litigation

Barbara Maria Kwiatkowska is a citizen of Poland who first arrived in Australia on 15 September 2014. On 4 November 2015, she applied for a Student (TU) (subclass 572) visa, which included her husband and son as members of her family unit. On 17 December 2015, a delegate refused to grant the visa, determining that she did not satisfy the requirements of cl. 572.223(1)(a) of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth). The applicants then applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the "Tribunal") for review of the delegate's decision, which was heard on 27 November 2017. On 12 December 2017, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate's decision not to grant the applicants the relevant visa. The Tribunal found that there was no evidence that the first applicant was enrolled in, or had a current offer of enrolment in, any applicable course of study, and therefore did not meet the requirements of the relevant visa subclasses. The Tribunal also found that there was no evidence that the first applicant satisfied the criteria for either a subclass 576 (AusAID or Defence Sector) or subclass 580 (Student Guardian) visa. As a result, the second and third applicants could not be granted a visa under cl.572.322. The Tribunal concluded that on the basis of the scant evidence before it, the decision under review should be affirmed.

The applicants then sought judicial review of the Tribunal's decision in the Federal Circuit Court. They relied on two grounds of review: (1) the Tribunal committed jurisdictional error; and (2) there was no requirement for a confirmation of enrolment at the time of the Tribunal's decision. The applicants did not file an amended application or outline of submissions, and their grounds remained unparticularised. However, the Court allowed the applicants an opportunity to articulate their concerns orally before it. In relation to the first ground of review, the applicants claimed that the Tribunal did not allow them adequate translation services, and the first applicant was not entirely clear about what was expected of her due to stress and poor health. This raised issues regarding the fairness of the court translation services and the appropriateness of the hearing occurring on the day it did.

This case involves a judicial review application filed in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia by Barbara Maria Kwiatkowska, Krzysztof Tomasz Kwiatkowski, and Marcin Zbigniew Kwiatkowski against the Minister for Home Affairs and the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The applicants seek to challenge the Tribunal's decision dated 12 December 2017, which affirmed a decision of a Ministerial delegate dated 17 December 2015 not to grant the first applicant a Student (TU) (subclass 572) visa. As a result, the second and third applicants were also denied the relevant visas they sought. The applicants filed their originating application on 27 December 2017, seeking to establish that the Tribunal's decision was affected by jurisdictional error. The case was brought pursuant to section 476(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The applicants rely on two grounds of review, namely that the Tribunal committed jurisdictional error and that there was no requirement for a confirmation of enrolment at the time of the Tribunal's decision. The Court made several orders in relation to the application, including that the applicants file and serve any amended application and any additional affidavits by certain dates. However, the applicants failed to comply with these orders, resulting in their grounds of review being effectively meaningless. The Court granted the applicants an opportunity to explain their concerns orally before the Court, but this did not result in any change to the outcome of the case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Tribunal commit jurisdictional error by not providing adequate translation services to the applicant during the hearing?
2. Was the applicant's health on the day of the hearing a factor that should have prevented the Tribunal from proceeding with the hearing?
3. Did the Tribunal err in finding that the applicant failed to meet the enrolment requirements for a student visa under cl. 572.231 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth)?
4. Was there a requirement for a confirmation of enrolment at the time of the Tribunal's decision, and if so, did the Tribunal's failure to consider such confirmation constitute jurisdictional error?
5. Did the Tribunal properly consider the evidence submitted by the applicant, including the Confirmation of Enrolment, and if not, does this constitute jurisdictional error?

Held
1. Did the Tribunal commit jurisdictional error by not providing adequate translation services to the applicant during the hearing?
The court concluded that the Tribunal did not commit jurisdictional error by not providing adequate translation services to the applicant. The applicant stated she understood the Tribunal’s questions "more or less," although she was stressed and suffering from poor health.
Result: Application dismissed.

2. Was the applicant's health on the day of the hearing a factor that should have prevented the Tribunal from proceeding with the hearing?
The court concluded that the applicant's health on the day of the hearing was not a factor that should have prevented the Tribunal from proceeding with the hearing.
Result: Application dismissed.

3. Did the Tribunal err in finding that the applicant failed to meet the enrolment requirements for a student visa under cl. 572.231 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth)?
The court concluded that the Tribunal did not err in finding that the applicant failed to meet the enrolment requirements for a student visa under cl. 572.231 of the Migration Regulations.
Result: Application dismissed.

4. Was there a requirement for a confirmation of enrolment at the time of the Tribunal's decision, and if so, did the Tribunal's failure to consider such confirmation constitute jurisdictional error?
The court concluded that there was no requirement for a confirmation of enrolment at the time of the Tribunal's decision, and thus, the Tribunal's failure to consider such confirmation did not constitute jurisdictional error.
Result: Application dismissed.

5. Did the Tribunal properly consider the evidence submitted by the applicant, including the Confirmation of Enrolment, and if not, does this constitute jurisdictional error?
The court concluded that the Tribunal properly considered the evidence submitted by the applicant, including the Confirmation of Enrolment. The Tribunal found that the enrolment dates for the course had passed and no further evidence had been submitted.
Result: Application dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered whether the Tribunal committed jurisdictional error by not providing adequate translation services to the applicant during the hearing. The applicant claimed that she understood the Tribunal’s questions "more or less" but was not entirely clear about what was expected of her due to being "quite stressed" and suffering from poor health. The court noted that the applicant's concerns centered around the adequacy of translation services provided during the hearing. In determining whether the Tribunal's failure to provide adequate translation services amounted to jurisdictional error, the court examined the principle that parties to judicial review proceedings must be afforded a fair hearing. This principle is enshrined in common law and statutory provisions, such as s.43 of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia Act 1995 (Cth), which mandates that all persons must be treated equally and without bias in proceedings before the Court. The court did not find any authority directly addressing the issue of translation services in tribunal hearings, but it reasoned that if translation services were inadequate, it could lead to a denial of natural justice and constitute jurisdictional error.

Health of the Applicant
36.
The second aspect of this issue involves the applicant's health on the day of the hearing. The applicant mentioned that she was stressed and suffering from poor health, which may have impacted her understanding of the Tribunal’s questions. The court considered whether the Tribunal should have been aware of the applicant’s health condition and whether it should have postponed or adjourned the hearing. The court found that there was no evidence that the Tribunal was made aware of the applicant’s health condition at the time of the hearing. The court noted that the applicant did not provide any medical evidence or notification of her health condition to the Tribunal before or during the hearing. Therefore, the court concluded that the Tribunal could not be faulted for not being aware of the applicant’s health condition on the day of the hearing.

Ground Two
37.
The applicant also argued that there was no requirement for a confirmation of enrolment at the time of the Tribunal’s decision. The court examined the legislative provisions and found that at the time of the Tribunal’s decision, there was no statutory requirement for a confirmation of enrolment to be provided. The court noted that while the Tribunal had requested the applicant to provide evidence of enrolment, it was not a statutory requirement at the time of the decision. Therefore, the Tribunal's failure to consider the confirmation of enrolment did not constitute jurisdictional error.

Grounds of Review
38.
The court considered the two grounds of review advanced by the applicant. The first ground, concerning the Tribunal's alleged failure to provide adequate translation services, was dismissed as the court found no evidence that the Tribunal was aware of the applicant’s health condition. The second ground, regarding the requirement for a confirmation of enrolment, was also dismissed because the court found that there was no such statutory requirement at the time of the Tribunal’s decision.

Jurisdictional Error
39.
The court examined whether the Tribunal committed jurisdictional error in finding that the applicant failed to meet the enrolment requirements for a student visa under cl. 572.231 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth). The court found that the Tribunal had correctly applied the legislative requirements and that there was no evidence before it that the applicant was enrolled in, or subject to an offer of enrolment in, a course of study at the time of the decision. The court noted that the Confirmation of Enrolment provided by the applicant was for a course that she had not completed, and the enrolment period had expired by the time of the Tribunal’s decision.

Evidence Consideration
40.
The court also considered whether the Tribunal properly considered the evidence submitted by the applicant, including the Confirmation of Enrolment. The court found that the Tribunal had considered all relevant evidence before it and had correctly concluded that the applicant had not met the enrolment requirements for a student visa. The court noted that the Tribunal had given the applicant an opportunity to provide evidence of enrolment and had deferred its decision to allow for the submission of additional evidence. However, no further evidence was provided by the time of the Tribunal’s decision.

Conclusion
41.
In conclusion, the court found that the Tribunal did not commit jurisdictional error in its decision. The court dismissed the applicant’s grounds of review and affirmed the Tribunal’s decision not to grant the visa. The court emphasized that the grounds of review were unparticularised and did not provide a sufficient basis for the Court to find jurisdictional error. The court also found that the Tribunal had correctly applied the legislative provisions and had properly considered the evidence before it.

Ratio Decidendi
42.
The binding legal principle established by this decision is that where a party to judicial review proceedings claims that the Tribunal did not provide adequate translation services or that the Tribunal should have been aware of their health condition on the day of the hearing, the court will consider whether the Tribunal was aware of these factors and whether they impacted the fairness of the proceedings. Additionally, the court will examine whether the Tribunal’s failure to consider certain evidence, such as a confirmation of enrolment, constitutes jurisdictional error. In this case, the court found that the Tribunal had not committed jurisdictional error as the applicant had not provided sufficient evidence to support her claims, and the Tribunal had correctly applied the relevant legislative provisions.