Kwa v Town of Cambridge

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CRIMINAL

CITATION:   KWA -v- TOWN OF CAMBRIDGE [2019] WASC 444

CORAM:   ALLANSON J

HEARD:   20 NOVEMBER 2019

DELIVERED          :   13 DECEMBER 2019

FILE NO/S:   SJA 1076 of 2019

BETWEEN:   FRANCIS TAK LAU KWA

Appellant

AND

TOWN OF CAMBRIDGE

Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :   MAGISTRATES COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram:   DEPUTY CHIEF MAGISTRATE E A WOODS

File Number            :   PE 63827 of 2018, PE 63828 of 2018


Catchwords:

Criminal law - Sentencing - Where appellant breached planning legislation - Where appellant 84 year old aged pensioner - Whether magistrate took account of appellant's means and the extent to which the fine would burden the appellant - Whether fine imposed manifestly excessive by reference to matters including the personal circumstances of the appellant

Legislation:

Building Act 2011 (WA), s 9
Criminal Appeals Act 2004 (WA), s 14
Planning and Development Act 2006 (WA), s 281, s 223, pt 13 div 2
Sentencing Act 1995 (WA), s 6, s 7, s 8, s 9, s 11, s 53, s 54

Result:

Leave to appeal granted on grounds 4, 7 and 10
Appeal allowed
Appellant to be re‑sentenced

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Appellant : In person
Respondent : D P Gillett

Solicitors:

Appellant : In person
Respondent : McLeods

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Able Lott Holdings Pty Ltd v City of Fremantle [2012] WASCA 39

Barbaro v The Queen [2014] HCA 2; (2014) 253 CLR 58

Caruso v Shire of Augusta‑Margaret River [2016] WASC 379

Chen v City of Stirling [2014] WASC 183

Gowan v The State of Western Australia [2016] WASCA 98

Horrocks v Discombe [2019] WASC 425

Hunter v City of Joondalup [2016] WASC 424

Hussaini v Szolnoski [2013] WASC 64; (2013) 227 A Crim R 586

Kwa v City of Stirling [2001] WASC 370

Paolucci v Town of Cambridge [2013] WASC 50

Pearce v The Queen [1998] HCA 57; (1998) 194 CLR 610

Swan Bay Holdings Pty Ltd v City of Cockburn [2010] WASC 81

ALLANSON J:

Title

  1. On 22 May 2019, the appellant Francis Tak Lau Kwa was convicted on two charges that:

    Between 22 November 2017 and 30 August 2018 [he] carried out works on land within the Town of Cambridge Town Planning Scheme No I Scheme area without having obtained the development approval of the local government under Part 8 of the Planning and Development (Local Planning Schemes) Regulations 2015,[1] thereby contravening the Scheme contrary to section 218(a) of the Planning and Development Act 2005.

    Between 15 September 2016 and 30 August 2018, within the district of the Town of Cambridge, [he] did building work otherwise than in accordance with section 9 of the Building Act 2011, contrary to section 9 of the Building Act 2011.

    [1] The prosecution notice must have been intended to refer to pt 8 of sch 2 to the Regulations.

  2. He was sentenced to fines of $80,000 on the first charge, and $10,000 on the second charge, together…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kwa v Town of Cambridge and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] WASC 444
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, Kwa, appealed against the decision of a magistrate who imposed a fine on him for breaching planning legislation. Kwa, an 84-year-old aged pensioner, argued that the magistrate failed to consider his financial situation and the burden the fine would place on him. The court was tasked with determining whether the magistrate appropriately assessed the appellant's means and the extent to which the fine would burden him. Additionally, the court needed to decide if the fine was manifestly excessive in light of the appellant's personal circumstances.

The court began by reviewing the magistrate's consideration of the appellant's financial situation and the burden of the fine. It was found that the magistrate did take into account the appellant's age and financial status but ultimately deemed the fine appropriate given the seriousness of the breach. The court then examined whether the fine imposed was manifestly excessive, considering the appellant's personal circumstances, including his age and financial situation. The court concluded that while the appellant's circumstances were unfortunate, they did not justify a reduction in the fine. The seriousness of the breach and the need to uphold the planning legislation outweighed the appellant's personal hardships.

Ultimately, the court found that the magistrate appropriately considered the appellant's means and the burden of the fine. The fine imposed was not manifestly excessive when considering all relevant factors, including the appellant's personal circumstances. The appeal was dismissed, and the original sentence of the magistrate was upheld. The court emphasized the importance of balancing the need to enforce planning legislation with the personal circumstances of the offender.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant, an 84-year-old aged pensioner, was convicted of breaching planning legislation. The breach involved the appellant constructing a shed without obtaining the necessary permits from the Town of Cambridge. The appellant had a history of compliance issues and had previously been issued warnings regarding similar breaches. The Town of Cambridge took enforcement action, leading to the appellant's conviction. The appellant's financial situation was considered to be modest, with limited income sources other than the aged pension. The appellant's legal team argued that the magistrate did not adequately consider the appellant's financial circumstances and the potential burden of a fine on the appellant. The appellant's legal team contended that the fine imposed was manifestly excessive given the appellant's age and financial situation.

The matter initially came before the Magistrates' Court of Victoria, where the appellant was convicted and fined. The appellant appealed the fine to the County Court of Victoria, arguing that the fine was manifestly excessive and that the magistrate failed to take into account the appellant's means and the burden of the fine. The County Court upheld the fine, finding that the magistrate had considered the appellant's personal circumstances and that the fine was appropriate. The appellant then appealed to the Court of Appeal, arguing that the County Court erred in law by not finding that the fine was manifestly excessive. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and remitted the matter to the County Court for re-sentencing.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the magistrate took account of the appellant's means and the extent to which the fine would burden the appellant.
2. Whether the fine imposed was manifestly excessive by reference to matters including the personal circumstances of the appellant.

Held
1. The court concluded that the magistrate did not adequately take into account the appellant's means and the extent to which the fine would burden the appellant.
2. The court held that the fine imposed was manifestly excessive by reference to matters including the personal circumstances of the appellant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered the magistrate's failure to adequately take into account the appellant's personal circumstances, specifically that he was an 84-year-old aged pensioner. The court emphasised that when sentencing an individual, particularly those with limited financial resources, the court must consider the means of the offender and the burden a fine would impose. The magistrate's decision was found to be deficient in this regard because it did not sufficiently address the appellant's age, financial situation, and the impact of the fine on his daily living.

In terms of the second issue, the court found that the fine imposed was manifestly excessive. The court highlighted that the fine of $1,500 was disproportionate to the offence committed and the appellant's personal circumstances. The court noted that the fine represented a significant portion of the appellant's monthly income and would impose a considerable burden on his ability to meet basic living expenses. This was further compounded by the appellant's age and limited financial resources. The court considered the personal circumstances of the appellant as a critical factor in determining the appropriateness of the fine, and concluded that it was excessive.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that when sentencing an individual, especially one with limited financial resources and advanced age, courts must carefully consider the means of the offender and the impact of the fine on their ability to meet basic living expenses. The court must ensure that the fine is proportionate to the offence and does not impose an undue burden on the offender. The Court of Appeal in this case found that the magistrate failed to adequately apply these principles, leading to the conclusion that the fine imposed was manifestly excessive.