Kuthyar v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 65 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Kuthyar v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 110

MIGRATION – Hindu from Kashmir – application for a protection visa – fear of persecution because of applicant's past association with Muslim militants, because he is a Hindu from Kashmir, because his parents were killed by Muslim separatists, because he was forcibly converted to Islam and circumcised, and because of his HIV infection – whether the Refugee Review Tribunal failed to set out findings on material questions of fact and to refer to the evidence or any other material upon which its findings of fact were based

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 476(1)(a), 430(1)(c), 430(1)(d)

Applicant A v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs [1997] 190 CLR 225; 142 ALR 331, approved
Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs v Eshetu [1999] 162 ALR 577, approved
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Sarrazola [1999] 166 ALR 641, applied
Chokov v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 823, applied
AAA v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 1699, referred to
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Zamora [1998] 51 ALD 1, approved

DEEPAK KUTHYAR v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

N 1029 OF 1999

EINFELD J
11 FEBRUARY 2000
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 1029 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

DEEPAK KUTHYAR
Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
Respondent

JUDGE:

EINFELD J

DATE OF ORDER:

11 FEBRUARY 2000

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.the application for judicial review be allowed

2.the decision of the Tribunal be set aside and the matter be remitted to a differently constituted Tribunal for a fresh hearing

3.the respondent pay the applicant's costs

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders are dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 1029 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

DEEPAK KUTHYAR
Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
Respondent

JUDGE:

EINFELD J

DATE:

11 FEBRUARY 2000

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. The applicant is a 34 year old Hindu from Kashmir in Northern India who has been diagnosed with HIV infection.  He arrived in Australia on 14 May 1995 and on 8 August lodged an application for a protection visa with the respondent's department (although in a letter from the department to the applicant dated 16 October 1997, it was incorrectly stated that this application was lodged on 8 August 1997).  On 16 October 1997 a delegate of the Minister refused to grant a protection visa and on 18 June 1998 the applicant appealed to the Refugee Review Tribunal.  The Tribunal affirmed the delegate's decision on 18 August 1999 and by application on 13 September 1999, the applicant applied to this Court for judicial review of the Tribunal's decision.  The success of his application depends on whether there was relevant legal error in the Tribunal's rejection of his contention that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kuthyar v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 110
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Kuthyar sought judicial review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal, which found that he did not qualify for a protection visa. The Tribunal had determined that Kuthyar’s account of events in his home country of India was not credible. The Federal Court was required to determine whether the Tribunal had erred in law in reaching its conclusion about the applicant’s credibility, and whether the Tribunal had failed to consider relevant material, or had made an error of law in its consideration of relevant material. The Court found that the Tribunal had failed to appropriately consider the applicant’s limited English language skills and post-traumatic stress disorder in evaluating his credibility, and that it had erred in concluding that the applicant had lied about certain aspects of his account. The Court allowed the application for judicial review, set aside the Tribunal’s decision, and remitted the matter to a differently constituted Tribunal for a fresh hearing. The Court also ordered that the respondent pay the applicant’s costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. the application for judicial review be allowed

2. the decision of the Tribunal be set aside and the matter be remitted to a differently constituted Tribunal for a fresh hearing

3. the respondent pay the applicant's costs

Note: Settlement and entry of orders are dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant’s claims were set out in written submissions to the department, and in oral evidence presented to the Tribunal at its hearing on 21 December 1998. The evidence was presented in three statutory declarations: the first statement (of 16 December 1998), one of 21 June 1999 (the second statement – created after his receipt of a letter from the Tribunal dated 24 May 1999 following its further research into several matters raised in the application, which put to him concerns about the inaccuracy of his account of an abduction and the ensuing events), and one of 13 September 1999 (the third statement – requesting an early hearing in this Court for reason of his medical condition). Written submissions were also made on the applicant's behalf by his solicitor on 21 December 1998 (the first submission) and 29 January 1999 (the second submission).Undisputed facts Some facts appear to have been accepted by the Tribunal. The applicant was born on 12 January 1965 in Belman in the state of Karnataka which is located in the central area of southern India. From 1969 he and his parents lived in Baba Mohalla near the Charar-e-Sharief Mosque, which is 45 kilometres south west of Srinagar in Kashmir state. His father had told him that he left Karnataka because he became involved in a property dispute with his brother, the applicant's uncle, after their father's death, and that his uncle had attempted to poison his father. He was also told that his father's family had never accepted his mother because she was Catholic, not Hindu. The applicant has therefore never had contact with his relatives in Karnataka state. When he left school, he worked in Baba Mohalla in the family’s business, a canteen which served drinks and snacks to tourists and other visitors. His application showed that he is able to speak, read and write Hindi, Kannada and English, although in the first statement, he wrote that he was able to speak only a few words of Kannada – the state language of Karnataka. At the hearing before the Tribunal, the applicant revealed that he also speaks a little Urdu. The passport with which the applicant travelled to Australia was issued in Bombay on 11 January 1995. It showed the applicant’s permanent address as Belman in Karnataka state, and that his visa was issued in New Delhi on 21 April 1995. In the first statement the applicant stated that he arrived in Australia with a 3 month visa. He did not know anything about the Australian system in relation to refugees and he did not obtain any legal advice. A Bangladeshi, with whom he shared a flat, told him what he knew about the system and helped him to complete his application. He therefore had no legal advice with regard to what to include.Other evidence presented On 9 December 1996 the department wrote to the applicant to inform him that the photocopies of documents in relation to the past and present situation in Kashmir which were indicated on his application as attached were in fact not provided. The applicant was asked to provide those documents, which he did on 31 December 1996. The decision of the Tribunal stated that the content of those documents was taken into account in the section of the reasons for decision which sets out information about India relevant to the applicant’s claims. Some further documents were provided by the applicant in April 1997, which were then included with the first statement. Some of the correspondence, which was before the Tribunal and before this Court, is included here so as to introduce various characters who play a role in the matter. Other correspondence in relation to the applicant appears elsewhere in the course of these reasons for judgment.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In the first statement the applicant stated that he arrived in Australia with a 3 month visa. He did not know anything about the Australian system in relation to refugees and he did not obtain any legal advice. A Bangladeshi, with whom he shared a flat, told him what he knew about the system and helped him to complete his application. He therefore had no legal advice with regard to what to include.Other evidence presented On 9 December 1996 the department wrote to the applicant to inform him that the photocopies of documents in relation to the past and present situation in Kashmir which were indicated on his application as attached were in fact not provided. The applicant was asked to provide those documents, which he did on 31 December 1996. The decision of the Tribunal stated that the content of those documents was taken into account in the section of the reasons for decision which sets out information about India relevant to the applicant’s claims. Some further documents were provided by the applicant in April 1997, which were then included with the first statement. Some of the correspondence, which was before the Tribunal and before this Court, is included here so as to introduce various characters who play a role in the matter. Other correspondence in relation to the applicant appears elsewhere in the course of these reasons for judgment. The departmental file included a report dated 24 December 1996 from a social worker, Hayley Symon, at St Vincents Hospital, Sydney. Ms Symon stated that the report was prepared in order to support the applicant’s application for permanent residency, and that in July 1996 he had presented at the hospital and was referred for counselling. Ms Symon stated:Mr Kuthyer [sic] has been known to me since July 1 1996, when he presented to this hospital with a medical complication. During his medical assessment the doctor noted that Mr Kuthyer [sic] seemed depressed and anxious. The doctor referred him to the social work department for counselling.During the counselling sessions it became obvious to me that Mr Kuthyer [sic] was suffering from associated features of past [presumably “post”] traumatic stress. Some of the symptoms he experienced were recurrent distressing dreams, anxiety, depression and difficulty sleeping. At times during our therapeutic relationship Mr Kuthyer [sic] felt suicidal and felt that his life had no meaning and value.During our sessions Mr Kuthyer [sic] shared his history and the events that had taken place in his life.He stated that he had to flee from Kashmir on the 17 November 1994, as his life was in danger. His village was fire-bombed and twenty four people died, including both his parents. The reason for this bombing was that Mr Kuthyer [sic] had fled from a Kashmir separatist terrorist training camp, where he was forced to under go [sic] a circumcision and convert to the muslim [sic] faith, and forced to engage in terrorist activities. Mr Kuthyer [sic] went to the police to ask for protection, however the police informed the terrorist group. The group took revenge by burning his home and killing his family. This terrorist group are [sic] unaware that Mr Kuthyer [sic] has escaped with his life.Mr Kuthyer [sic] fled to Bombay where Junior Chamber international assisted him with his passage to Australia.These events have had a major psychological impact on Mr Kuthyer [sic]. He constantly feels unsafe, anxious and depressed. He constantly mourns his family who he was unable to bury and farewell in a traditional way.At this point Mr Kuthyer [sic] has begun to rebuild his life. He is employed at MacDonald [sic] and is constantly receiving promotions. He has also developed a small friendship network, and is beginning to integrate into Australian society.Ms Symon added that she would strongly support Mr Kuthyar’s application for residency and would be willing to assist in any way possible.

Decision

Reasons for decision

EINFELD J
The first submission summarised the applicant's claims as consisting of:· fear of persecution by militant Kashmiri separatists because of imputed political opinion and religion· fear of persecution by Indian authorities because of imputed political opinion· fear of vilification and severe discrimination by ordinary people, service providers and agencies, and of inability to access adequate medical treatment, because he is a member of the particular social group of HIV sufferers· unreasonableness of the option to relocate in India, outside Kashmir, because of compelling logistic, economic, linguistic, cultural and social barriersThe Tribunal’s conclusions The Tribunal found as “not true” that the applicant:· was kidnapped or enslaved as claimed· undertook a mission for the militants in November 1994 to his home area as claimed· lost his parents in the circumstances claimed· encountered, while in Bombay in early 1995, a militant he knew from the camp The Tribunal did not accept the proffered circumstances of the circumcision. It did not consider that the authorities in India would regard the applicant as having had the association with the militants he claims to fear they would. Nor did the Tribunal accept that the Indian authorities would have any interest in whether the applicant had been in Australia, on what type of visa, or that he had lodged an application for asylum, as claimed in the second statement. To determine that accounts of this detail and particularity are untrue is to assert, not that the applicant had erred or been inconsistent, but that he lied about them. In fact the delegate made no adverse findings as to the applicant's truthfulness about the matters, but found that the circumstances surrounding his claims were "unusual". The Court has often expressed the need to scrutinise with care such rejections by an inquisitorial tribunal to determine their correctness in law. With all the benefits for the ascertainment of truth available in adversarial proceedings, and this society’s experience with them, rejection of cases as fabricated and fraudulent is not common. It should not be resorted to by tribunals which are both interrogator and judge without ample grounds. At the hearing before the Tribunal on 21 December 1998, the applicant explained that some things which were included in his early submissions may have been misunderstood or misinterpreted by the friend who had been helping him. He explained that he had only recently arrived in Australia and that his competence in the English language was somewhat limited at that time. The second submission stated that the applicant’s facility with English had, not surprisingly, improved with time since his arrival, largely as a result of his employment with McDonalds. The submission made was:It is not in doubt that the applicant's English ability is now quite good, and was good enough to communicate with the Tribunal at the hearing. However, even now it is not "perfect". The applicant speaks with an accent, and his language does not flow with the rhythm of a person for whom English is a first language. I note that [sic] Tribunal was not without concern about the applicant's ability to effectively communicate during the hearing, and at two points point [sic] an adjournment was briefly considered, before it was decided that it would not be necessary.It is submitted that it would be dangerous in the extreme to draw adverse inferences as to he [sic] applicant's credibility based upon inconsistent statements on the face of the visa application forms, which the evidence indicates was prepared by an applicant who (a) at that time had limited English ability (b) suffers from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (b) [presumably (c)] was without professional advice or assistance (c) [presumably (d)] was completing the form without the aid of an interpreter, using a non Hindu speaking flatmate for assistance.The Tribunal introduced its conclusions with the following paragraph:It is appropriate here to state that inconsistencies, omissions or additions to the evidence provided by an applicant in the course of the refugee determination process can occur for many reasons. In this case, it has been submitted that the applicant's command of English in the months after his arrival was not good and a declaration from his supervisor which attests this has been provided. As well, it is claimed that the applicant was helped in completing the application form by a person from Bangladesh who did not speak the applicant's main language (Hindi), that the applicant was traumatised and that he did not have professional assistance. I accept that all of these factors can contribute to statements of claims varying as the refugee determination process proceeds. It is also possible that variations can reflect that the evidence is not entirely truthful. The Tribunal is required to make findings of fact on applications for refugee status and this frequently involves an assessment of the credibility of what the applicant has said. The Tribunal went on to say in relation to this issue:As indicated in the description of the applicant's evidence, there were some significant differences in the claims made in the initial application and submissions and those made later but variations in the applicant's claims as first made some three months after his arrival and those made in later declarations and submissions are not the primary reasons why I do not accept that the applicant has given a truthful account of what happened to him although have contributed to my doubt about some particular matters.Although these differences are not particularly material to the case, and were not a primary reason for the Tribunal's rejection of the applicant's claims, they have no doubt, as conceded by the respondent at the hearing in this Court, coloured its approach to the applicant's case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: EINFELD J

Full text does not contain this section.