Kumar v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeal: Criminal)

KUMAR v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

[2023] SASC 93

Judgment of the Honourable Justice McDonald 

16 June 2023

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT

The appellant was subject of an intervention order that was imposed on 26 March 2019.  That order was made for the protection of the appellant’s former wife, his daughter AT and his son ST.  The appellant was charged with and found guilty of four counts of breaching the intervention order, with all four counts relating to his daughter AT.  The basis of the charges were in relation to four unanswered telephone calls on the smartphone application WhatsApp, and two ‘likes’ on AT’s Instagram account.

The appellant appeals his convictions on the basis that the Magistrate erred in finding that he could exclude, as a reasonable possibility, that the various communications were made accidentally or by another person.  Alternatively, it was contended that the WhatsApp calls could never amount to more than an attempt to contact the protected person and as such did not contravene the order.  Equally, even if the appellant was responsible for the Instagram ‘likes’ they did not amount to communications.

Held:

1.      The appeal is allowed on Grounds 1 and 5.

2.      The matter be remitted back to the Magistrates Court for a retrial.

Police v Hill (2005) 93 SASR 307; R v Trotter (1979) 22 SASR 64; R v Pfennig (1992) 57 SASR 507; Police v Beukes (2011) 205 A Crim R 406; Police v Vishal Kumar [2022] SAMC 135; Wondimu v Police [2019] SASC 62, considered.

KUMAR v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
[2023] SASC 93

Criminal to Magistrates Appeal: Criminal

  1. MCDONALD J:      On 26 March 2019, the appellant became the subject of an intervention order.  The order was made for the protection of the appellant’s former wife, his daughter AT, and his son ST.  The intervention order relevantly contained the following term.

    4.The Defendant must not contact or communicate with the protected person(s) either directly or, indirectly in any way (including phone, letter, cards, SMS messages, e-mail, facsimile, Facebook, Skype etc) except with respect to contact and access to children pursuant to any order or direction of the Family Law Court or other Courts exercising jurisdiction under the Family Law Act.

  2. The appellant was charged with and subsequently found guilty of four counts of breaching the intervention order.  All four counts related to his daughter AT.

  3. The basis of the charges were four unanswered telephone calls made on the WhatsApp application and two ‘likes’ on AT’s Instagram account.  It was alleged that the appellant initiated each of these communications.

  4. The appellant challenges his convictions on the basis that the Magistrate erred in finding that he could exclude as a reasonable possibility that the various communications relied upon by the prosecution were made accidentally (‘pocket calls’) or by another person with access to the appellant’s mobile phone.  Alternatively, it was contended that the missed WhatsApp…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kumar v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] SASC 93
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Kumar v Commissioner of Police involved the appellant contesting charges under an intervention order, which prohibited him from engaging in specified behavior towards the protected persons. The key dispute centered on whether the appellant had intentionally made missed WhatsApp calls and liked Instagram posts, actions that were alleged to violate the terms of the intervention order. The matter was heard in the higher court following an appeal from the decision of the Magistrates Court.

The court was tasked with determining several legal issues, including the necessity of expert evidence to establish the operation of common mobile telephones, social media platforms, and smartphone applications. Additionally, the court had to assess the extent to which non-expert evidence from a witness familiar with these technologies could be relied upon. The court also needed to decide whether an attempt to make a telephone call or 'liking' an Instagram post constituted a 'contact' under the intervention order. Finally, the court had to determine if, based on the admissible evidence, it was open to exclude as a reasonable possibility that the Instagram likes and WhatsApp calls were made accidentally.

The court found that the evidence presented was insufficient to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant's actions were intentional. The court determined that the Magistrate had erred by not excluding as a reasonable possibility that the appellant’s actions were accidental, particularly given the familiarity of the witness with the technology in question. Consequently, the appeal was allowed on specified grounds, and the matter was remitted back to the Magistrates Court for retrial.

The final orders of the court included allowing the appeal on Grounds 1 and 5, and remitting the matter back to the Magistrates Court for a new trial. The decision underscored the importance of clear and convincing evidence to establish intentionality in actions that involve common technologies, and highlighted the need for careful consideration of the possibility of accidental actions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Between them, these grounds raise a number of issues for consideration. These are:·To what extent is expert evidence necessary to establish the operation of mobile telephones, social media platforms and smartphone applications that are in common usage in the community?·To what extent can the court rely on non-expert evidence from a witness who is familiar with mobile telephones, social media platforms and smartphone applications that are in common usage in the community?·Does an attempt to make a telephone call amount to a “contact” under the terms of an intervention order?·Does the act of ‘liking’ an Instagram post amount to a “contact” under the terms of the intervention order?·On the basis of the admissible evidence before the Magistrate, was it open to exclude as a reasonable possibility that the Instagram likes and the WhatsApp calls were made accidentally?The evidence The witnesses who were called to give evidence at trial were AT, the appellant’s former wife ART, Inspector Marieka Mysko, who is employed by the Australian Border Force, and the investigating officer Detective Brevet Sergeant Ashwin Menon. A recorded interview with the appellant was played during the evidence of Sergeant Menon. The evidence fell within relatively narrow confines and much of it is not contentious. It was an agreed fact that on 26 March 2019 an Intervention Order was confirmed in the Magistrates Court sitting in Adelaide preventing the appellant engaging in certain behaviour towards the protected persons. AT gave evidence that subsequent to this she had received 4 missed WhatsApp calls on her mobile phone and had become aware of two ‘likes’ on her Instagram account that the prosecution alleged were made by the appellant. The first telephone call was made at 2:11 pm on 30 March 2020. AT was aware of this call being made to her telephone, however she did not answer as ‘Dad’ had come up on the caller ID. It was AT’s evidence that she had previously saved the appellant’s mobile telephone number under ‘Dad’. AT’s evidence was supported by a screen shot that she had taken of the history log of the phone call showing the date and time that she had received it.[4][4] Exhibit P4. The next 3 calls were made to AT’s mobile phone on 1 July 2020. Again her evidence was supported by a screen shot that she had taken that showed that those calls were made between 7:41 am and 7:42 am.[5][5] Exhibit P5. It was not disputed that AT had received the 4 missed calls on her mobile phone at the time and date alleged. There was also no dispute that the telephone number the appellant was using at that time was recorded in AT’s telephone as ‘Dad’, that his telephone had made those calls and the screen shot accurately depicted the call log. The issue that arose was the circumstances in which those calls had come to be made and in particular whether the prosecution could prove beyond reasonable doubt that they resulted from an intentional act by the appellant.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It follows that in the event that both forms of communication could be proved to be the product of the appellant’s deliberate conduct then they would be sufficient to amount to a contact for the purposes of condition 4.Conclusion1. The appeal is allowed on Grounds 1 and 5.2. The matter is remitted back to the Magistrates Court for retrial.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.