Kreymborg & Anor v Sunshine Coast Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

LAND COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:Kreymborg & Anor v Sunshine Coast Regional Council [2016] QLC 33

PARTIES:A W Kreymborg & R L Cork

(applicants)

v

Sunshine Coast Regional Council

(respondent)

FILE NOs:LGR 510-14

DIVISION:General Division

PROCEEDING:  An appeal against a categorisation decision for differential general rates

DELIVERED ON:                  1 June 2016

DELIVERED AT:                   Brisbane

HEARD ON:  24 March 2015

HEARD AT:Brisbane

MEMBER:WL Cochrane

ORDERS:

1.   Application for determination of preliminary point allowed.

2.   The court finds:

a)   The appeal is incompetent.

b)   There is no basis upon which this Court has statutory jurisdiction to consider an appeal in the form brought by the applicants.

c)   There has been no decision on a proper objection by the applicants to the rating categories applying to the subject land, there having been no proper objection made.

3.   Appeal dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:                  Categorisation of and for differential rating – land use codes – use of the land – Local Government Regulation 2012 (s 92) – preliminary point – competency of appeal – whether objection actually made.  Whether decision by Chief Executive actually made.  Time for bringing of appeal.

APPEARANCES:                  Ms R Cork, self-represented for the applicants.

Mr Mark Cowan, Solicitor, in-house legal unit at Sunshine Coast Regional Council.

Background

  1. This is the decision in respect of a preliminary point raised by the respondents to an appeal against a categorisation of land located in the local government area of the Sunshine Coast Regional Council.

  2. On 27 November 2014 the applicants A W Kreymborg and R L Cork filed a notice of appeal against a categorisation decision said to be pursuant to s 92 of the Local Government Regulation 2012 (‘the LGR’).

  3. That section provides as follows:

    “92 Land owner’s appeal against decision

    (1)This section applies if the owner of rateable land wants to appeal against a decision of—

    (a)the local government not to allow a longer period for giving an objection notice; or

    (b)the chief executive officer on the owner’s objection to the rating category for the land.

    (2)The owner may appeal by filing an appeal notice in the Land Court registry, within 42 days after the day when the owner received notice of the decision.

    (3)The appeal notice must be in the form approved by the Land Court.

    (4)The owner must give a copy of the filed appeal notice to the local government, within 7 days after the appeal notice was filed.

    (5)If the owner fails to do so, it does not affect the making of the appeal, or the jurisdiction of the Land Court to decide the appeal, but the court may award costs against the owner for any adjournment that is caused by the owner’s failure.”

  4. This appeal is in respect of land which is described as Lot A AP17519 Plan PO232001 Parish of Bribie, has an area of 8,935 m2 and is otherwise located at Fraser Road Landsborough. 

  5. It is located in an area controlled, at the relevant time, by the Sunshine Coast Regional Council. 

The History of the Land

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kreymborg & Anor v Sunshine Coast Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QLC 33
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Land Court of Queensland, Kreymborg & Anor v Sunshine Coast Regional Council concerned a dispute over the rating category and subsequent appeal process for land owned by the applicants. The applicants, Mr Kreymborg and Ms Cork, sought to challenge the council's decision regarding the rating category for their land. The legal issues centred on whether the applicants had correctly lodged their appeal under the Local Government Regulation 2012, specifically section 92, and if the council had made a decision on a proper objection by the applicants. The court needed to determine if the appeal was competent, whether the applicants had made a proper objection to the rating categories, and if the decision was actually made by the Chief Executive Officer.

The court examined the procedural requirements for lodging an appeal, including the timeliness and correctness of the objection and the form of the appeal notice. It found that the applicants had not made a proper objection to the rating category, as required by the regulation. Additionally, the court considered whether the Chief Executive Officer had indeed made a decision on the applicants' objection. The court concluded that the appeal was not competent because the applicants had not followed the statutory requirements for lodging an objection and subsequent appeal. The applicants' failure to adhere to the prescribed form and timing for lodging the appeal rendered the appeal process ineffective. Consequently, the court dismissed the appeal.

The court ordered that the application for a determination of the preliminary point was allowed. It found that the appeal was incompetent, and there was no basis for the court to exercise jurisdiction over the appeal. The court also determined that no proper objection had been made by the applicants to the rating categories applying to the subject land, and therefore, there had been no decision by the Chief Executive Officer on such an objection. The appeal was dismissed, and no further action could be taken by the applicants under the current statutory framework.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Application for determination of preliminary point allowed.

2. The court finds:

a) The appeal is incompetent.

b) There is no basis upon which this Court has statutory jurisdiction to consider an appeal in the form brought by the applicants.

c) There has been no decision on a proper objection by the applicants to the rating categories applying to the subject land, there having been no proper objection made.

3. Appeal dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves an appeal by Mr Kreymborg and Ms Cork against the Sunshine Coast Regional Council regarding the categorisation and rating of their land, Lot A AP17519 Plan PO232001 Parish of Bribie, located at Fraser Road Landsborough. The land, with an area of 8,935 m2, is subject to the Local Government Regulation 2012. The appeal arose from the Council's decision not to allow a longer period for giving an objection notice and the Chief Executive's decision on the objection to the rating category for the land. The applicants filed an appeal notice on 25 November 2014. The land in question was initially granted a Permit to Occupy by the Department of Natural Resources and Mines to Ross Lenore Cork on 10 December 2007. There are discrepancies in the correspondence and affidavits regarding the exact dates and descriptions of the land, indicating confusion in the dialogue between the parties.

The matter was brought before the court as an appeal against the Sunshine Coast Regional Council's decision on the rating category for the land. The applicants filed an appeal notice within the 42-day period as required by the Local Government Regulation 2012. The appeal was contested on the basis of its competency and whether a proper objection was made by the applicants to the rating categories applying to the land. The court was required to determine if it had statutory jurisdiction to consider the appeal and whether the decision by the Chief Executive was actually made. The court ultimately dismissed the appeal, finding it incompetent and lacking a proper objection to the rating categories.

Decision

Reasons for decision

That section provides as follows:“92 Land owner’s appeal against decision(1)This section applies if the owner of rateable land wants to appeal against a decision of—(a)the local government not to allow a longer period for giving an objection notice; or(b)the chief executive officer on the owner’s objection to the rating category for the land.(2)The owner may appeal by filing an appeal notice in the Land Court registry, within 42 days after the day when the owner received notice of the decision.(3)The appeal notice must be in the form approved by the Land Court.(4)The owner must give a copy of the filed appeal notice to the local government, within 7 days after the appeal notice was filed.(5)If the owner fails to do so, it does not affect the making of the appeal, or the jurisdiction of the Land Court to decide the appeal, but the court may award costs against the owner for any adjournment that is caused by the owner’s failure.” This appeal is in respect of land which is described as Lot A AP17519 Plan PO232001 Parish of Bribie, has an area of 8,935 m2 and is otherwise located at Fraser Road Landsborough. It is located in an area controlled, at the relevant time, by the Sunshine Coast Regional Council. In order to understand the substance of this appeal and the importance of the preliminary point it is necessary to outline the background history of the holding of land by each of Mr Kreymborg and Ms Cork. As set out later in these reasons, the applicants attached to their Notice of Appeal a letter dated 25 November 2014 setting out what they said was the basis of their appeal. In that letter of 25 November 2014 there is reference to correspondence sent to the respondent Local Government dated 4 June 2014. A copy of that letter is attached to the appeal documentation and it sets out something of the history of the land holdings. Some of the material filed in affidavit form seems to contradict what is evidenced by some of the documents exhibited to other affidavits. A good example of that is that in correspondence to the Council dated 4 June 2014 attached to her appeal documentation Ms Cork says:“That on 18/10/2008 DNRM (Department of Natural Resources and Mines) granted a Permit to Occupy.” In the affidavit of Mr Cowan he exhibits a Permit to Occupy which is in fact 10 December 2007. Possibly nothing turns upon those discrepancies but they are indicative of some of the confusion which has been attached to the dialogue between the parties in this matter. On 10 December 2007 the Department of Natural Resources and Mines granted to Ross Lenore Cork as permittee a permit to occupy land described as Lot A on Crown Plan AP17519 County of Canning, Parish of Bribie within the Local Government Area of the Sunshine Coast Regional Council and having an area of about 0.8935 ha. A plan of Lot A attached to exhibit MDC1 to the affidavit of Mr Mark Cowan sworn 16 February 2015[1] shows that the Permit to Occupy is over land otherwise described as Hardwood Road. [1] Exhibit 5 (Affidavit of Mark Damien Cowan – 16 February 2015) EX MDC-1, pp 9 – 13.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by considering whether the objection actually made by the applicants was proper and in compliance with the Local Government Regulation 2012. The court examined the correspondence and documentation provided by the applicants and found discrepancies in the dates and details provided. Despite these discrepancies, the court focused on whether the objection was made in the required form and within the prescribed time frame. The court concluded that the objection was not properly made as it did not comply with the Local Government Regulation 2012.

Next, the court considered whether the decision by the Chief Executive was actually made as required by the Local Government Regulation 2012. The court examined the evidence provided by the applicants and found that there was no evidence of a decision being made by the Chief Executive regarding the rating category for the land. The court concluded that there had been no decision made by the Chief Executive in accordance with the Local Government Regulation 2012.

The court then considered whether the appeal was brought within the statutory time limit of 42 days as required by the Local Government Regulation 2012. The court found that the appeal was indeed brought within the required time frame. However, the court noted that the appeal was incompetent due to the improper objection and lack of a decision by the Chief Executive.

Finally, the court considered whether it had statutory jurisdiction to consider the appeal in the form brought by the applicants. The court found that there was no basis upon which it had jurisdiction to consider the appeal in the form brought by the applicants, as the objection was not properly made and there was no decision by the Chief Executive. The court concluded that the appeal was incompetent and dismissed it.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that an appeal against a decision regarding the rating category for land must be based on a proper objection made in compliance with the Local Government Regulation 2012 and a decision made by the Chief Executive. If either of these requirements is not met, the appeal is incompetent and the court does not have jurisdiction to consider it. Additionally, the court must ensure that the appeal is brought within the statutory time limit of 42 days as required by the Local Government Regulation 2012.