Kraguljac v A & B Property Developments Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

KRAGULJAC v A & B PROPERTY DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD (No 2)

[2008] SASC 301

Reasons of Judge Burley a Master of the Supreme Court

6 November 2008

EQUITY - EQUITABLE REMEDIES - INJUNCTIONS - MANDATORY INJUNCTIONS

Contract for sale of land - dispute as to whether contract on foot - contract provides for access to site by plaintiff to obtain environmental assessment - access denied by defendant - plaintiff seeks interlocutory mandatory injunction and other injunctive relief - whether irreparable harm if injunctive relief refused - access to site necessary because inextricably linked with application for finance - in absence of finance likely failure of suit for specific performance - whether other means to avoid potential harm - plaintiff could apply for a split trial - held: no immediate necessity to make orders sought - application refused.

ABC v O'Neill (2006) 227 CLR 57; Jakudo Pty Ltd v South Australian Telecasters Ltd (1997) 60 SASR 440 , applied.
Secured Income Real Estate (Australia) Ltd v St Martins Investments Pty Ltd (1979) 144 CLR at 596, considered.

KRAGULJAC v A & B PROPERTY DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD (No 2)
[2008] SASC 301

  1. JUDGE BURLEY: These proceedings have been brought by the plaintiff to enforce a contract dated 16 January 2007 for the sale by the defendant to the plaintiff of land known as Lot 21, Jetty Road, Largs Bay (the contract). The defendant has purported to terminate the contract and the plaintiff has lodged a caveat on the title to the land. The defendant has warned the caveat. Earlier this year I dealt with the plaintiff’s application for an order extending the time for removal of the caveat pursuant to the provisions of s 191 of the Real Property Act 1886.  On 18 June 2008 I granted that application.

  2. By application dated 19 August 2008 the plaintiff seeks the following orders:

    1A mandatory injunction requiring the Defendant to provide the Plaintiff, its agents, servants, contractors, consultants and subcontractors with access to the land comprised in Certificate of Title Volume 5507 Folio 13 described as allotment 21 in File Plan 4493 (“Lot 21”), and allotments 26 (“Lot 26”), 27 (“Lot 27”) and 28 (“Lot 28”) in File Plan 4493 and comprised in Certificate of Title Volume 5966 Folio 445 for the purpose of:

    1.1erecting advertising signage relating to the Purchaser’s proposed intention to market the land to prospective tenants and/or Purchasers;

    1.2taking prospective tenant’s (sic) and purchasers on to the land to inspect the land; and

    1.3undertaking any environmental assessments or building inspections of the land and its improvements.

    2An order restraining the Defendant, and an injunction granted restraining the Defendant, whether by its officers, employees, agents or otherwise, until further order, from:

    2.1interfering in any way with the free and unrestricted access to and over and egress from, the land the subject of this application in paragraph 1; and

    2.2interfering with, or impeding in any way, the Plaintiff or its agents, servants, contractors,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kraguljac v A & B Property Developments Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] SASC 301
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Kraguljac v A & B Property Developments Pty Ltd (No 2) concerns a dispute over a contract for the sale of land. The plaintiff, Mr Kraguljac, sought equitable remedies, including an interlocutory mandatory injunction and other injunctive relief, against the defendant, A & B Property Developments Pty Ltd, after the defendant denied the plaintiff access to the site for an environmental assessment. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiff would suffer irreparable harm if the injunctive relief was refused, and whether there were other means to avoid any potential harm. Specifically, the court had to determine if access to the site was necessary because it was inextricably linked with the plaintiff’s application for finance, and if the absence of finance would likely result in the failure of a suit for specific performance. Additionally, the court considered whether there were alternative measures the plaintiff could take to mitigate any harm.

The court examined the terms of the contract and the specific condition precedent that required the defendant to clear the site of rubbish, materials, and property and to level the piles of dirt. The court noted that the plaintiff could potentially apply for a split trial as an alternative measure. After considering the arguments presented by both parties, the court found that there was no immediate necessity to make the orders sought. Consequently, the application was refused, as the plaintiff had not demonstrated that the denial of access would lead to irreparable harm or that there were no other means to avoid potential harm. The court concluded that the plaintiff could explore other options, such as a split trial, to address the issue.

In light of the above, the court did not grant the mandatory injunction and other injunctive relief sought by the plaintiff. The court’s decision underscored the need for the plaintiff to establish a clear and immediate risk of irreparable harm and to exhaust all other available remedies before seeking injunctive relief. The court's refusal to grant the relief highlights the importance of demonstrating a compelling necessity for such remedies in equitable contexts.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

All of the affidavits were received on the application without objection.Background Facts The following is taken from my reasons published on 18 June 2008.A copy of the contract is Exhibit GK3 to the first affidavit of the plaintiff. The parties used the Law Society form of contract for the sale and purchase of land. The contract price for the land is $6 million. The contract provided for a deposit of $70,000. Paragraph 3 of Annexure A to the contract is as follows:3 Conditions Precedent3.1This agreement is subject to the vendor removing all its property, materials and rubbish from the land and upon the vendor levelling all the piles of dirt currently situated on the land as agreed between the parties.3.2The vendor will use its best endeavours to complete the work contemplated in clause 3.1 above immediately upon the execution of this agreement.3.3The parties agree that this condition precedent is for the benefit of the purchaser and that subject to 3.4 below, the purchaser may elect to settle the land and undertake to remove any rubbish, materials or property of the vendor from the land.3.4The vendor agrees to pay the purchaser the costs of removing and disposing or storage (as appropriate) of any rubbish, materials or property of the vendor left on the land after the settlement date.Paragraph 8 of Annexure A is as follows:8 Settlement date8.1Settlement date under this agreement is to be within 90 days from the vendor satisfying the condition precedent pursuant to clauses 3.1 and 3.2 of this agreement, or earlier, as mutually agreed to by both parties. Before turning to counsels’ submissions, I should mention that the application is brought in the context that the plaintiff seeks the relief set out in Part 2 of the statement of claim as follows:(1) A declaration that the purported notice of termination was invalid and of no effect.(2) A mandatory injunction requiring the defendant to remove forthwith and without further delay all of its property, materials and rubbish from the land and to level all piles of dirt situated on the land.(3)A mandatory injunction requiring the defendant to provide access to the land pursuant to the licence granted by special condition 12.(4) Orders for specific performance of the contract as follows:4.1That pursuant to special condition 12 the defendant permit to have access to the land on reasonable notice the plaintiff’s environmental consultants, sales agent and valuers;4.2That pursuant to special condition 3.1 the defendant remove all of its property, materials and rubbish from the land and level the piles of dirt on the land;4.3That subsequently the defendant complete the contract in accordance with the terms of the contract, namely 90 days after the defendant clears the land. This application (and the plaintiff’s claim in paragraph 4.1 of the prayer for relief) rely upon the provisions of special condition 12 of the contract which is as follows:Access to land before settlement.12.1 The vendor grants to the purchaser and its servants, agents, contractors and invitees with effect from the date of the agreement a non-exclusive licence to enter upon the land prior to the date of settlement for purpose of:12.1.1Erecting advertising signage relating to the purchaser’s proposed intention to market the land to prospective tenants and/or purchasers;12.1.2Taking prospective tenant’s purchasers to inspect the land;12.1.3Undertaking any Environmental Assessment or building inspections of the property; and12.1.4Undertaking such renovations or improvements to the land as approved by the vendor at the written request of the purchaser.12.2 The purchaser agrees not to commence or undertake any works on the land that require or will result in any physical alteration to the land, without first having obtained the prior written approval of the vendor, which approval will not be unreasonably withheld.12.3 If the agreement is terminated other than due to a fault of the vendor, the purchaser must at its cost:12.3.1do everything necessary in the reasonable opinion of the vendor to remove any signage or alterations the purchaser has made to the land; and12.3.2restore the land to its original state as it was prior to the purchaser entering on to it.12.4 If the purchaser does not comply with clause 12.3 within 2 weeks of the termination of the agreement, the vendor may carry out the removals and restorations to the land.12.5 The reasonable costs of doing this are recoverable as a debt due by the purchaser to the vendor.12.6 The purchaser released the vendor from all liability which the vendor might otherwise have for any loss suffered by the purchaser or its employees, servants, agents or contractors on the land during the period of the licence. However, this release does not apply if the loss is caused by the wilful or negligent act or omission of the vendor, its servants, agents or contractors.12.7 The consideration for the licence is the deposit paid by the purchaser to the vendor pursuant to this agreement.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established