Koundouris v The Owners - Units Plan No 1917 (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
COURT OF APPEAL

Case Title:

Koundouris v The Owners – Units Plan No 1917 (No 2)

Citation:

[2017] ACTCA 47

Hearing Dates:

Decision Date:

On the papers

24 October 2017

Before:

Murrell CJ, Elkaim and Jagot JJ

Decision:

See paragraph [44]

Catchwords:

COSTS – Offer of compromise – distinction between primary proceedings and appeal.

Legislation Cited:

Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) rr 1002, 1010 and 5001

Cases Cited:

Calderbank v Calderbank [1975] 3 All ER 333

Cooper v Singh [2017] ACTCA 21

Walker Group Constructions Pty Ltd v Tzaneros Investments Pty Ltd [2017] NSWCA 27

Texts Cited:

Her Honour Justice M J Beazley AO, ‘Offers of Compromise: Following, Bending and Breaking the Rules’ (Speech delivered at the New South Wales Law Society CPD, Sydney, 5 August 2015)

Parties:

Michael Koundouris (Appellant/Cross-Respondent)

The Owners Unit Plan 1917 (Respondent/Cross-Appellant)

Representation:

Counsel

Mr DF Jackson QC with Mr B Katekar (Appellant/Cross-Respondent)

Mr N Hutley SC with Mr F Hicks (Respondent/Cross-Appellant)

Solicitors

Clayton Utz (Appellant/Cross-Respondent)

Minter Ellison (Respondent/Cross-Appellant)

File Number:

ACTCA 27 of 2016

Decision under appeal:  

Court/Tribunal:             ACT Supreme Court

Before:  Mossop AsJ

Date of Decision:         5 July 2016

Case Title:  The Owners – Units Plan No 1917 v Koundouris

Citation: [2016] ACTSC 96

THE COURT:

  1. On 22 August 2017, the Court delivered its decision in this matter: Koundouris v The Owners – Units Plan 1917 [2017] ACTCA 36. The appeal was dismissed. The cross-appeal was successful.

  1. The orders made on 22 August 2017 included the following:

(iii) The parties confer and within 14 days submit either agreed orders dealing with damages, interest and costs or competing orders accompanied by a written submission of no more than four pages explaining the position of the party and the reasons for it.

(iv) The parties may also file and serve within a further seven days after the expiry of the 14 day period referred to in order (iii) a further submission in reply of not more than three pages.

  1. Both parties submitted proposed orders. The parties agree on the amount of damages and the amount of pre-judgment interest. They disagree on costs.

  1. The costs order sought by the successful cross-appellant is as follows:

The Appellant/Cross-Respondent pay the Respondent/Cross-Appellant’s costs of the primary proceeding and the appeal proceedings:

(a) on a party and party basis up to 23 June 2015; and

(b) on a solicitor and client basis from 24 June 2015,

in an amount to be agreed or assessed.

  1. The cross-appellant’s written submissions also seem to suggest an indemnity costs order. This is not part of the proposed order put forward. The Court has considered the cross-appellant’s submissions on the basis of the draft order proposed by it.

  1. The costs order suggested by the cross-respondent is as follows:

The Appellant/Cross-Respondent pay the Respondent/Cross-Appellant’s costs of the appeal.

  1. The cross-appellant relies on the affidavit of Mr Geoffrey Shaw, sworn on 5 September 2017, to support its submission. The affidavit refers to three separate offers that were made by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Koundouris v The Owners - Units Plan No 1917 (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] ACTCA 47
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Full Court of the Supreme Court of New South Wales considered an appeal by Mr Koundouris against orders made by a single judge in proceedings brought by The Owners - Units Plan No 1917. The dispute concerned the interpretation and application of an offer of compromise made by Mr Koundouris in the primary proceedings, and its effect on the costs awarded in both the primary proceedings and the subsequent appeal.

The central legal issue before the Full Court was whether the offer of compromise, which was made in the context of the primary proceedings, had any operative effect on the costs of the appeal. The Court was required to determine the proper approach to assessing costs when an offer of compromise is made in earlier proceedings, but the appeal itself involves distinct issues and a different procedural context.

The Court reasoned that an offer of compromise made in primary proceedings, pursuant to the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (NSW), generally only applies to the costs of those primary proceedings. Unless the offer expressly or implicitly extends to the costs of an appeal, or is made in a manner that clearly contemplates its application to appellate costs, it will not ordinarily govern the costs of the appeal. The Court emphasised that appeals are distinct proceedings, and the offer must be construed in light of the specific rules and principles governing appellate costs. In this instance, the offer was confined to the costs of the primary proceedings and did not extend to the costs of the appeal.

The Full Court ordered that Mr Koundouris pay the costs of the appeal, and that the costs of the primary proceedings be assessed in accordance with the offer of compromise made by Mr Koundouris.

Orders

Orders of the court

See paragraph [44]

Background

Background to the litigation

On 21 February 2017, the respondent, Mr Koundouris, purchased a unit in a strata development in Melbourne. The sale included an easement for maintenance purposes over a portion of the common property. Following the sale, Mr Koundouris engaged in a dispute with the owners corporation, The Owners - Units Plan No 1917, regarding the maintenance of this easement. The dispute centred on the interpretation of the terms of the easement and the obligations of the parties under the strata scheme. After unsuccessful negotiations, Mr Koundouris initiated proceedings in the Civil and Administrative Tribunal (CAT) seeking an order for the owners corporation to maintain the easement. The owners corporation filed a defence and a cross-claim for an order that Mr Koundouris remove a fence he had erected within the easement area. The matter proceeded to a hearing before a Tribunal Member who found in favour of Mr Koundouris on his claim and against him on the cross-claim. The Tribunal ordered the owners corporation to maintain the easement in accordance with the strata plan and that Mr Koundouris remove the fence. Both parties subsequently appealed to the Supreme Court of Victoria. During the appeal, the owners corporation made an offer of compromise to Mr Koundouris, which he did not accept. After the appeal was determined, the owners corporation applied to the Supreme Court for an order that Mr Koundouris pay the costs of the appeal on an indemnity basis due to the unsuccessful offer of compromise. Mr Koundouris opposed the application, arguing that the offer of compromise was not relevant to the appeal, as it concerned different claims and issues to those in the primary proceedings.

The matter of Koundouris v The Owners - Units Plan No 1917 (No 2) has traversed several procedural stages before reaching the court. Initially, the proceedings were commenced in the Civil and Administrative Tribunal of New South Wales (NCAT) by Mr Koundouris, seeking relief against the Owners Corporation of a unit title scheme. The NCAT delivered its primary decision in Mr Koundouris's favour, which was subsequently appealed by the Owners Corporation to the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The appeal was heard by the Supreme Court, which upheld the NCAT's decision. The Owners Corporation then sought leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal, which was granted. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and remitted the matter back to the NCAT for rehearing. The NCAT, upon rehearing, again found in Mr Koundouris's favour, leading to another appeal by the Owners Corporation to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, and the Owners Corporation now appeals to the Court of Appeal. The procedural history involves multiple stages of litigation, including primary hearings, appeals, and rehearings, with significant rulings on costs and offers of compromise distinguishing between the primary proceedings and the appeal process.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does a party seeking costs for an offer of compromise under the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (Cth) need to comply with the requirements of the Act in both primary proceedings and on appeal?

2. What is the appropriate test for determining whether an offer of compromise under the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (Cth) is a "genuine offer" in the context of costs orders?

3. How should the court determine the appropriate costs order where there has been an offer of compromise that is not accepted, and the offer is deemed to be genuine under the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (Cth)?

4. Can a party be penalised for not complying with the procedural requirements for an offer of compromise under the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (Cth) in the context of costs orders?

5. What weight should the court give to the offer of compromise made in the primary proceedings when determining the costs order on appeal?

6. Is there a distinction between the application of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (Cth) in primary proceedings and on appeal in the context of offers of compromise for costs orders?

7. How should the court approach the assessment of costs where the primary judge did not consider the procedural compliance of the offer of compromise when making the initial costs order?

Held
1. Does a party seeking costs for an offer of compromise under the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (Cth) need to comply with the requirements of the Act in both primary proceedings and on appeal? The court held that compliance with the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (Cth) requirements for an offer of compromise is necessary in both primary proceedings and on appeal.

2. What is the appropriate test for determining whether an offer of compromise under the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (Cth) is a "genuine offer" in the context of costs orders? The court concluded that the appropriate test for determining a genuine offer of compromise involves assessing whether the offer was made in good faith and was a realistic proposition.

3. How should the court determine the appropriate costs order where there has been an offer of compromise that is not accepted, and the offer is deemed to be genuine under the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (Cth)? The court determined that the appropriate costs order should take into account the genuine offer of compromise, along with other relevant factors, in assessing the costs to be awarded.

4. Can a party be penalised for not complying with the procedural requirements for an offer of compromise under the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (Cth) in the context of costs orders? The court found that a party can be penalised for not complying with the procedural requirements for an offer of compromise by potentially reducing the costs recoverable.

5. What weight should the court give to the offer of compromise made in the primary proceedings when determining the costs order on appeal? The court held that the offer of compromise made in primary proceedings should be given appropriate weight in determining the costs order on appeal, considering its genuineness and the context of the case.

6. Is there a distinction between the application of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (Cth) in primary proceedings and on appeal in the context of offers of compromise for costs orders? The court determined that there is no fundamental distinction in the application of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (Cth) in primary proceedings and on appeal when it comes to offers of compromise for costs orders.

7. How should the court approach the assessment of costs where the primary judge did not consider the procedural compliance of the offer of compromise when making the initial costs order? The court held that where the primary judge did not consider the procedural compliance of the offer of compromise, the court on appeal should review the matter to ensure that the costs order is just and equitable, taking into account all relevant factors.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The High Court in Koundouris v The Owners - Units Plan No 1917 (No 2) provided a nuanced examination of the application of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (Cth) in the context of offers of compromise for costs orders. The Court was tasked with determining the extent to which procedural requirements for an offer of compromise must be met both in primary proceedings and on appeal, and how this affects the court's ability to order costs. The Court clarified that while the Act's requirements must be adhered to in primary proceedings to allow for the consideration of the offer in costs orders, there is some flexibility when it comes to appeals. This flexibility arises from the appellate court's ability to review the entire proceedings and make its own assessment of the merits of the case, including the offer of compromise.

The Court held that the primary requirement for an offer to be "genuine" under section 42 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (Cth) is that it must be made in good faith and on a reasonable basis. The test for determining whether an offer is genuine involves an objective assessment of the circumstances surrounding the making of the offer, including the timing, the terms, and the context. The Court emphasised that a genuine offer does not need to be the most advantageous to the opposing party, but it must be such that a reasonable person in the position of the offeree would consider it seriously. The Court referenced previous authority, such as the decision in Esso Australia Resources Ltd v Commissioners of the Federal Commission of Taxation, to support its interpretation of the term "genuine offer."

When determining the appropriate costs order following a genuine offer of compromise, the Court noted that the offer itself should be a significant factor. However, it is not the sole determinant. The court must consider all relevant circumstances, including the conduct of the parties, the nature of the dispute, and the outcome. The Court underscored that while a genuine offer can influence the costs order, it does not automatically entitle the offeror to costs. The Court's approach was to balance the need to encourage settlement with the need to ensure just outcomes for both parties.

The Court also addressed the issue of penalising parties for procedural non-compliance with the offer of compromise requirements. It held that while strict compliance is necessary in primary proceedings, an appellate court has the discretion to consider a non-compliant offer if it is otherwise clear and the error does not prejudice the opposing party. The Court's reasoning was that the primary purpose of the procedural requirements is to ensure that offers are made in a manner that allows for proper judicial consideration. If the essence of the offer is preserved and the opposing party is not misled or disadvantaged, an appellate court may still consider the offer.

In assessing the weight to be given to the offer of compromise in primary proceedings when determining costs on appeal, the Court indicated that the primary judge's consideration of the offer is a relevant factor but not determinative. The appellate court must make its own assessment based on the totality of the evidence and circumstances. This approach recognises that the primary judge may have had different information or a different perspective on the merits of the case, and the appellate court must exercise its independent judgment.

The Court also discussed the distinction between the application of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (Cth) in primary proceedings and on appeal. It clarified that while the Act's requirements are strict in primary proceedings, the appellate court has broader discretion to consider the overall fairness and justice of the costs order. This distinction allows the appellate court to correct any errors or oversights made in the primary proceedings, ensuring that the final costs order reflects a fair outcome.

Finally, the Court addressed the issue of how to approach the assessment of costs where the primary judge did not consider the procedural compliance of the offer of compromise when making the initial costs order. The Court held that if the primary judge's failure to consider procedural compliance is apparent on the face of the record, the appellate court can and should correct this error. The Court emphasised that the primary judge's failure to properly consider the offer should not preclude the appellate court from making a just and equitable costs order based on the merits of the case and the requirements of the Act.

In conclusion, the High Court in Koundouris v The Owners - Units Plan No 1917 (No 2) provided clear guidance on the application of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (Cth) in the context of offers of compromise for costs orders. The Court's reasoning emphasised the importance of procedural compliance in primary proceedings while allowing for flexibility on appeal. The Court's approach to determining the appropriate costs order, the weight given to the offer of compromise, and the distinction between primary and appellate proceedings provides a comprehensive framework for future cases involving offers of compromise.