ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
KOUNDOURIS v CONSTRUCTION OCCUPATIONS REGISTRAR & ORS (Administrative Review) [2015] ACAT 92
AT 99/2013
Catchwords: ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – rectification order – water ingress – façade cracking – whether rectification order made outside the ten year time limit
Legislation cited: Building Act 1972 ss 37, 40A, 41A
Construction Occupations (Licensing) Act 2004 ss 34, 35, 36, 38, 40
Subordinate
Legislation: Australian Standard 3700 s 2.5.2.2
Building Code of Australia 1996, Volume 1, Amendment number 11 ss FP1.3, FP1.4
Tribunal: President W.G. Stefaniak AM RFD
Senior Member G. Lunney SC
Senior Member G. Trickett
Date of Orders: 23 December 2015
Date of Reasons for Decision: 23 December 2015
ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL AT 99/2013
BETWEEN:
RE: MICHAEL KOUNDOURIS
Applicant
AND:CONSTRUCTION OCCUPATIONS REGISTRAR
Respondent
AND:ROBERT FARRELL
First Party Joined
AND:EDWARD PURRER
Second Party Joined
AND:THE OWNERS - UNITS PLAN 2340
Third Party Joined
TRIBUNAL: President W.G. Stefaniak AM RFD
Senior Member G. Lunney SC
Senior Member G. Trickett
DATE:23 December 2015
ORDER
The rectification order made by the Registrar will be set aside and another substituted. The matter will be listed for settling a rectification order. The respondent should circulate a draft order to the parties not later than two weeks prior to the listed hearing date. The other parties should circulate suggested amendments not later than five days prior to the hearing date.
……signed………..
President W. G Stefaniak AM RFD
for and on behalf of the Tribunal
ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL AT 99/2013
BETWEEN:
RE: MICHAEL KOUNDOURIS
Applicant
AND:CONSTRUCTION OCCUPATIONS REGISTRAR
Respondent
AND:ROBERT FARRELL
First Party Joined
AND:EDWARD PURRER
Second Party Joined
AND:THE OWNERS - UNITS PLAN 2340
Third Party Joined
TRIBUNAL: Senior Member G. Lunney SC
Senior Member G. Trickett
DATE:22 July 2016
This Rectification Order under the Construction Occupations (Licensing) Act 2004 (COLA) is made in substitution for an Order of 21 November 2013 by the Construction Occupations Registrar after review by the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal of that Order.
In this Order the following abbreviations are used
‘EC’ refers to the Executive Committee, the owners, Units Plan No. 2340
‘Diagnostech’ or ‘the Diagnostech Report’ refers to a report dated 17 August 2012 prepared by Diagnostech Pty Ltd and which was annexed to a notice issued pursuant to Section 34 of COLA in this matter.
‘COLA’ refers to the Construction Occupations (Licensing) Act 2004.
‘the builder’ refers to Michael Aristidis Koundouris.
‘the parties’ refers to the parties to ACAT proceeding AT99/2013
‘the residents’ refers to the residents of Block 24 Section 43 Turner in the ACT.
‘the Assessor’ refers to the individual appointed pursuant to Clause 5.
This Order is issued to Michael Aristidis Koundouris the holder of an ‘A’ class builder’s licence of 3 Torrens Street Braddon ACT in the Territory. It relates to building work undertaken by him at Block 24 Section 43 Turner in the Territory.
ORDER
The work the subject of the Order is to be completed…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Koundouris v Construction Occupations Registrar & Ors (Admin... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] ACAT 92
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were whether the rectification order was issued outside the permissible time frame and if the specified measures for addressing water ingress and façade cracking were appropriate and enforceable. The court had to consider statutory provisions governing the time limits for issuing such orders and evaluate the adequacy of the proposed rectification works as detailed in the order.
The court examined the statutory framework governing the issuance of rectification orders, determining that the order in question was indeed made beyond the ten-year limit. However, the court also assessed the details of the rectification works outlined in the order. It found that for cracks wider than 15mm, the rectification work should be overseen by a qualified structural engineer engaged by the builder. The court emphasized the necessity for waterproofing measures on specific balconies and mandated detailed inspection protocols to ensure the work's effectiveness. The court concluded that while the timing was an issue, the specified rectification works were generally appropriate and should be enforced with modifications to comply with the statutory time frame.
The court set aside the existing rectification order and directed the Registrar to circulate a draft of a new order to the parties, with suggested amendments to be submitted by the other parties prior to the hearing. This ensures that the new order is both timely and legally compliant.
Orders
Orders of the court
The rectification order made by the Registrar will be set aside and another substituted. The matter will be listed for settling a rectification order. The respondent should circulate a draft order to the parties not later than two weeks prior to the listed hearing date. The other parties should circulate suggested amendments not later than five days prior to the hearing date.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
For cracks in the brickwork greater than 15mm wide the rectification work is to be determined by a qualified structural engineer engaged by the builder.Penetration of water from balconies into habitable units The balconies to Units 26, 28, 29 & 30 shall be exposed and a torch-on membrane applied as set out in the Diagnostech Pty Ltd report at T348-T352 and attached as Appendix 1 titled “Waterproofing Works – Level 3 Balcony Deck Waterproofing Works”; Clauses 3.1.1 to 3.1.9 inclusive. Ceramic tiles are to match existing tiles. Water testing is to be carried out for the full extent of the membraned areas by water ponding for 36 hours and inspecting the ceiling spaces below. Work is to be rectified if leaks appear. The appointed Assessor is to inspect work as a minimum: prior to membrane application, prior to installation of tile bedding at the end of the ponding period, and at completion of tiling with control joints installed. Tiles and bedding presently used as a cover should be disposed of by the builder. Undertake remediation works as described and to standard described in Appendix 2 ‘Internal Repair Work’, items 2.2 and 2.3 Work to be done is set out in the table set out below. The podium area of the basement roof including the roof to the Waste Management area; the inside of the planter boxes, and the set down covered front northwest garden area outside Unit 2, including the walls from the set down up to the adjacent podium roof, shall be exposed and a torch on membrane applied as described in the section related to “Penetration of Water from Balconies into Habitable Units” above. Concrete pavers and sand presently used as a cover should be disposed of by the builder. The membrane is to extend up to the outside face of the ground floor walls at the podium level, however unlike the work to the balconies no existing wall material and thresholds are to be demolished. The surface of the podium including the roof to the Waste Management area shall be tiled with non-slip ceramic tiles of a neutral colour satisfactory to the EC and laid to fall away from the building. The area of membrane to be covered with earth, including the walls, should have a protection board laid on top of it prior to back filling. For methodology refer to pages T364 (Corroded Steel Repair) and T783 (Structural Steel Work Finish numbered F3) from the Tribunal Documents attached hereto as appendixes 3 and 4. Adjust method as appropriate for specific situations. Rust shall be removed using power or hand tools including wire brushes, needle gun, sanding, etc. Where surfaces have previously been painted the adjacent painted areas that are unsound shall be removed and the sound areas shall be sanded to a feather edge termination. Surfaces shall then be cleaned to remove contaminants. Priming: Affected steel to basement, other than the lintel beam to Waste Management entry, shall be coated with Luxaprime zinc phosphate to a dry film thickness of 75 microns. The appointed Assessor shall inspect all work prior to application of the finishing coats.