Kostandy and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

Kostandy and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2025] ARTA 1047 (21 July 2025)

Applicant/s:  Maged Sobhy Naguid Kostandy

Respondent:  Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Tribunal Number:                2025/3787

Tribunal:Deputy President O'Donovan

Place:Brisbane

Date:21 July 2025

Decision:Pursuant to section 105 of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth), the Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Statement made on 21 July 2025 at 4:42pm

Catchwords

MIGRATION – whether to revoke the mandatory cancellation of applicant’s visa – character test – substantial criminal record – fraud  – Direction no. 110 – primary and other considerations – protection of Australian community – nature and seriousness of criminal offending – risk to the Australian community should the Applicant commit further offences or engage in other serious conduct – strength, nature and duration of ties to Australia – best interests of minor children in Australia – expectations of the Australian community – extent of impediments if removed – citizen of Egypt – pending application for leave to appeal against conviction –  children Australian citizens living in Egypt – Coptic Christians facing discrimination – decision under review affirmed

Legislation

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 499, 500, 501.

Cases

HZCP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2019) 273 FCR 121

R v Kostandy [2024] QCA 190

Secretary to the Department of Justice and Regulation v LLG [2018] VSCA 155

Secondary Materials

Direction No. 110: Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA

Statement of Reasons

  1. The applicant was born in Egypt. He completed his education there, including university studies, and graduated as an industrial pharmacist. Between 2006 and 2014, he lived in Dubai. In 2008 he was granted an Australian skilled visa based on his qualifications as a pharmacist, and between 2008 and 2014, he and his wife spent periods of time in Australia. The periods he spent in Australia were relatively brief as he continued to work in Dubai. He did however come to Australia with his wife for the delivery of each of his children. Consequently, they are Australian citizens.[1] His wife was granted Australian citizenship in 2020.

    [1] G-Documents, G15, 87-88.

  2. From 2014, the applicant began spending the majority of his time in Australia. He was based initially in Sydney where his brother lived, but moved with his family to the Gold Coast in early 2014. He has never held a job in Australia. He has lived off his personal savings and earnings from a medical supply business he operates which is based in the middle east.

  3. While living on the Gold Coast, the applicant made friends through the Coptic Orthodox Church. From 2017 through to 2018 he perpetrated a very significant fraud on a number of these friends.[2]

  4. In late 2019 his wife and children went to Egypt for a holiday to visit family and became stranded there when COVID-19 related restrictions on travel were introduced. In early…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kostandy and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affa... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 1047
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court involved the applicant, Kostandy, who was contesting the mandatory cancellation of their visa under the Migration Act. The applicant, an Egyptian citizen with substantial criminal history, sought to have the visa cancellation revoked. The Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs was the respondent. The court had to decide whether to uphold or revoke the mandatory cancellation of Kostandy's visa, focusing on the character test, their criminal record, and other considerations relevant to the protection of the Australian community.

The primary legal issues were whether the mandatory visa cancellation should be revoked considering Kostandy's criminal record, which included multiple instances of fraud, and the balance of other factors such as the protection of the Australian community and the applicant's ties to Australia. The court examined the nature and seriousness of Kostandy's criminal conduct, the risk of reoffending, and other considerations specified in the relevant Direction.

The court found that Kostandy's criminal activities, though not involving physical harm, constituted serious conduct that the Australian community needed protection from. The court noted the substantial nature of the fraud, the consistency of witness accounts, and the absence of any significant mitigating factors. While considering the strength of Kostandy's ties to Australia and the best interests of their minor children, the court concluded that these factors did not sufficiently outweigh the primary considerations of community protection and expectations. Therefore, the court affirmed the decision to maintain the visa cancellation.

No specific final orders were mentioned in the text, but the decision affirmed the visa cancellation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

In light of these matters (any one of which is damaging enough to the applicant’s credibility), I have approached the applicant’s evidence with scepticism. Generally speaking, if the applicant is the only source of information on a controversial issue, I have treated that evidence as insufficient to establish the fact. If any detail of the applicant’s account is contradicted by any document, I have either disregarded the applicant’s account or based my findings on the alternative source. In relation to the applicant’s offending, there are multiple witnesses who gave versions of events that were largely consistent with each other. I am satisfied that the material of that kind extracted in the Court of Appeal decision[18] gives an accurate picture of the applicant’s offending and I have used that material as the basis for many of my findings. [18] R v Kostandy [2024] QCA 190.Facts I have outlined my broad factual findings at the start of these reasons. Where other factual matters are relevant, I identify them in the context of analysing the relevant considerations. Where a finding is controversial, I have referenced the evidence on which the finding is based. CONSIDERATION Primary considerations Protection of the Australian Community When examining this consideration, I am required to keep in mind that the safety of the Australian community is the highest priority of the Australian Government. To that end, the Government is committed to protecting the Australian community from harm as a result of criminal activity or other serious conduct by non-citizens. Remaining in Australia is a privilege that Australia confers on non-citizens in the expectation that they are and have been law abiding, will respect important institutions and will not cause or threaten harm to individuals or the Australian community. In the present case the offending did not involve any physical harm to the victims. The impact was purely financial. It is however criminal activity that the Australian community should be protected from. When analysing this consideration I need also to give specific consideration to: (a)The nature and seriousness of the applicant's conduct to date; and (b)The risk to the Australian community, should the applicant commit further offences or engage in other serious conduct. Nature and seriousness of the conduct In considering the nature and seriousness of the conduct there are factors to which I must have regard specified in paragraphs 8.1.1(1)(a)-(h) of the Direction. Before applying those factors, I will set out my findings concerning the applicant’s criminal offending. On 5 June 2023 the applicant was convicted of five counts of fraud after a trial in the District Court. The charges against the applicant were pursuant to s 408C(1)(c) and (d) of the Criminal Code. Four of the charges were that he dishonestly induced people (who were his friends) to deliver bank credits to him in the value of at least $100,000. The fifth was that he dishonestly induced another friend to give him a bank credit to a value of at least $30,000.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I am not satisfied that a likely consequence of the applicant’s release into the community with his visa restored is that his family will return to Australia. Having concluded that that is an unlikely prospect, the matters raised concerning his family add no weight to the case for the revocation of the visa cancellation.CONCLUSION Informed by the principles in paragraph 5.2 of the Direction, I have taken into account the considerations identified in sections 8 and 9 of the Direction which are relevant to this decision and all the other considerations that the applicant has advanced. The following considerations weigh in favour of a decision to affirm the cancellation of the visa: (a)Protection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct; (b)The expectations of the Australian community. The following considerations weigh in favour of setting aside the cancellation but only weakly: (a)The strength, nature and duration of the applicant's ties to Australia; (b)The best interests of minor children; (c)The extent of impediments if the applicant is removed. The family violence consideration, the impediments the applicant may face if deported consideration, and the impact on Australian business interests consideration are all neutral. The other factors the applicant has raised add little or no weight to the case for revocation. In circumstances where two primary considerations, the protection of the Australian community and the expectations of the Australian community weigh against the applicant and no other consideration pulls significantly the other way, I am not satisfied that there is another reason to revoke the cancellation of the applicant’s visa. The decision under review is affirmed.Dates of hearing: 7, 8 and 9 July 2025 Representative for the applicant: Self-represented litigant Solicitors for the respondent: Sparke Helmore Lawyers

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I have outlined my broad factual findings at the start of these reasons. Where other factual matters are relevant, I identify them in the context of analysing the relevant considerations. Where a finding is controversial, I have referenced the evidence on which the finding is based. CONSIDERATION Primary considerations Protection of the Australian Community When examining this consideration, I am required to keep in mind that the safety of the Australian community is the highest priority of the Australian Government. To that end, the Government is committed to protecting the Australian community from harm as a result of criminal activity or other serious conduct by non-citizens. Remaining in Australia is a privilege that Australia confers on non-citizens in the expectation that they are and have been law abiding, will respect important institutions and will not cause or threaten harm to individuals or the Australian community. In the present case the offending did not involve any physical harm to the victims. The impact was purely financial. It is however criminal activity that the Australian community should be protected from. When analysing this consideration I need also to give specific consideration to: (a)The nature and seriousness of the applicant's conduct to date; and (b)The risk to the Australian community, should the applicant commit further offences or engage in other serious conduct. Nature and seriousness of the conduct In considering the nature and seriousness of the conduct there are factors to which I must have regard specified in paragraphs 8.1.1(1)(a)-(h) of the Direction. Before applying those factors, I will set out my findings concerning the applicant’s criminal offending. On 5 June 2023 the applicant was convicted of five counts of fraud after a trial in the District Court. The charges against the applicant were pursuant to s 408C(1)(c) and (d) of the Criminal Code. Four of the charges were that he dishonestly induced people (who were his friends) to deliver bank credits to him in the value of at least $100,000. The fifth was that he dishonestly induced another friend to give him a bank credit to a value of at least $30,000. The first count concerned George and Lillian Ibrahim, who were friends of the applicant and his family from the Gold Coast Coptic Christian church. The applicant told Mr Ibrahim that he wanted funding for a business opportunity which would involve him purchasing medical supplies for over-the-counter medicines from overseas; getting approval from the Therapeutic Goods Administration to sell the drugs in Australia, and then importing and selling the drugs in Australia. In response the Ibrahim’s transferred the applicant $100,000. There was in fact no business opportunity and the applicant used the money for his own purposes. The second count concerned the applicant approaching Emad Tadros, in October 2018 to invest in the same medical supplies importation scheme. Mr Tadros invested $30,000. The third count concerned the applicant dishonestly inducing the Ibrahim’s to give him bank credits at least to the value of $100,000 at the beginning of 2018. They paid the money thinking they were investing in a business venture based on importing adult diapers into Australia. The applicant said he had a contract with Chemist Warehouse to supply them with the diapers and the sales to Chemist Warehouse would yield good profits. No such opportunity existed.