Korean Group Pty Ltd v Cho Han Management Pty Ltd (in Liquidation)

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

KOREAN GROUP PTY LTD v CHO HAN MANAGEMENT PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION)

[2008] SASC 137

Reasons of Judge Burley a Master of the Supreme Court

22 May 2008

CORPORATIONS

Application to set aside statutory demand - defendant/creditor trustee of trading trust - incurred debts in course of trading - plaintiff liable to indemnify defendant - whether debts incurred in capacity of trustee - alleged genuine dispute not established - application dismissed.

Corporations Act 2001 Sections 459G and 459H, referred to.
Bentham Management Pty Ltd v Union Finance Pty Ltd (2007) 247 LSJS 103; Eyota Pty Ltd v Hanave Pty Ltd (1994) 12 ACSR 785 at 787; John Holland Construction and Engineering Pty Ltd v Kilpatrick Green Pty Ltd (1994) 14 ACSR 250 at 253; Spencer Constructions Pty Ltd v G & M Aldridge Pty Ltd (1997) 76 FCR 452 at 464; Eng Mee Yong v Letchumanan (1989) AC 331 at 341; South Australia v Wall (1980) 24 SASR 189 at 194, considered.

KOREAN GROUP PTY LTD v CHO HAN MANAGEMENT PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION)
[2008] SASC 137

  1. JUDGE BURLEY:            By originating process filed on 14 January 2008 the plaintiff has applied for an order setting aside a statutory demand dated 21 December 2007 served by the defendant upon the plaintiff.  The plaintiff contends that there is a genuine dispute in relation to the alleged debt.

  2. A copy of the statutory demand is exhibited to the affidavit of Mr Han sworn on 14 January 2008 (Exhibit KJH 2).  It was accompanied by an affidavit of Mr George Divitkos, sworn on 21 December 2007.  Paragraphs 7.1 to 7.6 of the affidavit are as follows:

    7.1The Creditor [defendant] was the trustee of the Korean Property Trust by virtue of a Trust Deed dated 18 April 2006 whereby Andy Choi as Settlor of the trust appointed the Creditor as trustee (‘Trust Deed”),

    7.2That Mr Ki Jun Han is the sole specified beneficiary of the Korea Property Trust.

    7.3On 22 January 2007, Mr Ki Jun Han, the Appointee named under the Trust Deed, removed the Creditor as the trustee of the Korea Property Trust and appointed the Debtor company [plaintiff] as the new trustee pursuant to a “Deed of Retirement and Appointment of a New Trustee” dated 22 January 2007)”Deed of Retirement.  The Deed of Retirement is an agreement between Ki Jun Han as Appointor for and on behalf of the Korea Property Trust, and the Debtor company.  Now shown to me and exhibited hereto and marked D4’ is a true copy of the Deed of Retirement.

    7.4Under Clause 22 of the Trust Deed, the Appointor is authorised and empowered to remove a trustee of the Korea Property Trust and to appoint a new trustee in its place, at his discretion.

    7.5Pursuant to clause 5 of the Deed of Retirement, the Debtor company agreed to indemnify and hold harmless the Creditor in respect of any and all claims, costs and liabilities whether actual or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Korean Group Pty Ltd v Cho Han Management Pty Ltd (in Liquid... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] SASC 137
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Korean Group Pty Ltd v Cho Han Management Pty Ltd (in Liquidation) involves a dispute between the plaintiff, Korean Group Pty Ltd, and the defendant, Cho Han Management Pty Ltd, which is in liquidation. The primary issue is whether the plaintiff's case, which asserts that the defendant contracted either in its own right or on behalf of another trust, is plausible and warrants further investigation. The dispute hinges on the facts surrounding the leasing of premises at 30 North Terrace, Kent Town by the defendant to establish a Korean Market, and the subsequent financial dealings related to this lease.

The court had to determine whether the plaintiff had demonstrated a plausible contention that would necessitate further investigation into whether the defendant had indeed contracted in its own right or on behalf of another trust. The plaintiff's case relied heavily on the assertions of Mr Han, the defendant's former secretary, who claimed that the defendant had engaged in the lease and financial transactions in its own right or as trustee for the Han Family Trust. The defendant, on the other hand, provided evidence suggesting that the dealings were conducted as trustee of the Korea Property Trust. The court noted that the defendant's evidence was somewhat equivocal, and the lease itself did not specify the capacity in which the defendant was acting.

The court concluded that the plaintiff's case was not sufficiently plausible to warrant further investigation. The plaintiff had not presented clear and consistent evidence to support the contention that the defendant had contracted in its own right or as trustee for another trust. The documentary evidence, including the loan application and security offered for the loan, indicated that the defendant had acted in its capacity as trustee of the Korea Property Trust. Consequently, the court found that the plaintiff had not demonstrated a genuine dispute that required investigation.

In light of the above, the court dismissed the application to set aside the statutory demand. The decision underscored the importance of clear and consistent evidence in establishing a plausible contention, particularly in the context of corporate capacities and contractual dealings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

It was submitted by Mr Livesey QC, counsel for the defendant, that the evidence relied upon by the plaintiff was “equivocal, lacking in precision, inconsistent with undisputed contemporary documents ….. [and] inherently improbable”. The Facts In his written submission, Mr Livesey provided a “Chronology of Key Events” which summarised the affidavit evidence concerning the events leading to the defendant’s service upon the plaintiff of the statutory demand. Most of the following summary is taken from paragraph 10 of Mr Livesey’s written submission. I shall identify the material disputes of fact. From 2006 the defendant’s sole director was Ms Yang Suk Han. Her brother, Mr Ki Jun Han was the secretary of the defendant. The defendant was the trustee of the Korea Property Trust until 22 January 2007. On 24 March 2006 the defendant offered to lease part of certain premises at 30 North Terrace, Kent Town from a company called The Tribune Pty Ltd. Mr Han wanted to set up and conduct a Korean Market at those premises. According to the defendant, the offer to lease the premises was made by the defendant in its capacity as trustee of the Korea Property Trust. This is apparent from the affidavit of Mr Gaetjens, sworn on 19 March 2008, paragraph 12. Mr Han, whose affidavits were filed in support of the application to set aside the statutory demand, denied that there were any dealings between The Tribune Pty Ltd and the defendant in its capacity as trustee of the Korea Property Trust. The plaintiff’s case was that such dealings were conducted by the defendant either in its own right (that is, not as a trustee) or, alternatively, as trustee for another trust called the Han Family Trust. The dispute between the parties is principally a factual dispute. It is by reference to the facts that a determination must be made whether the plaintiff’s case gives rise to a plausible contention which requires investigation. If it does, a genuine dispute exists. However, if in deciding what conclusions may be drawn from the facts it is clear that they do not give rise to a plausible contention, it cannot be said that a genuine dispute has been demonstrated by the plaintiff. I say “conclusion” to be distinguished from “finding”. It is not my function on an application such as this to make final findings of fact, but I must examine the evidence to see if it is possible to conclude that the plaintiff’s contention that the defendant contracted in its own right or on behalf of another trust is plausible and requires investigation. The onus is on the plaintiff to demonstrate that its contention is plausible . There is only Mr Han’s assertion that the defendant contracted in its own right or as trustee for another trust. The defendant’s evidence concerning the dealings between the defendant and The Tribune Pty Ltd is, to some extent, equivocal. The actual lease entered into does not state that the defendant as lessee entered into the lease either in its own right or on behalf of the Korea Property Trust or on behalf of another trust. It appears that some of those who acted on behalf of the defendant either assumed or were instructed that the defendant was acting in its capacity as trustee of the Korea Property Trust. I shall return to this aspect of the matter. More importantly, after the lease was entered into, it is apparent from the documentation exhibited to various affidavits that the defendant sought short-term finance so as to operate a Korean Market from the leased premises in Kent Town. A loan application for $400,000 was made by the defendant in its capacity as trustee of the Korea Property Trust. Mr Han signed the loan declaration on behalf of the defendant in its capacity as trustee of the Korea Property Trust. A property at Modbury, owned by the defendant in its capacity as trustee of the Korea Family Trust was offered as security for the loan.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established