Korber v Police No. Scciv-02-588

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

KORBER v POLICE
[2002] SASC 441

Magistrates Appeal:  Criminal

  1. MULLIGHAN J                 This appeal raises a point about a matter of procedure.

  2. The appellant pleaded guilty to having, on 9th February 2001 at Willaston, driven an unregistered motor vehicle, contrary to s 9 of the Motor Vehicles Act 1959, and to a further charge of driving an uninsured motor vehicle on the same occasion, contrary to s 102 of that Act. He was convicted of both charges and one penalty was imposed pursuant to s 18A of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988, namely a fine of $100. He was ordered to pay fees and a levy amounting to a further $180.70 and he was disqualified from holding or obtaining a licence to drive a motor vehicle for a period of two days.

  3. He appeals against the convictions despite his pleas of guilty. Before he entered the pleas, he took preliminary points as to the validity of the complaint on the same ground as was argued on his appeal. The learned Magistrate ruled against him and he entered his pleas because he acknowledged his guilt of the offences as charged.

  4. The appellant was not represented by counsel or a solicitor before the learned Magistrate or on the hearing of this appeal.

  5. He was charged on the one complaint by a member of the SA Police stationed at Elizabeth (“the complainant”). The document prepared was a complaint and summons in accordance with Form 2 of the Magistrates Court Rules. It is a form of a complaint. It need not be made on oath unless a special Act so requires.

  6. The appellant claims irregularity in the making and laying of the complaint. He was served with an unsigned copy of the complaint and summons on 6th June 2001 by a process server who swore an affidavit of service on that date. The complaint and summons indicate that the complaint was made on 7th June 2001 as that is the date typed on the form as the day upon which the complaint was made.

  7. In the complaint and summons filed at the Magistrates Court at Elizabeth that date has been altered to 8th June 2001 by the handwriting of the date “8th” written over the “7th”. On the face of these documents the appellant was served with the complaint and summons before the complaint was made.

  8. The complainant is a police prosecutor. I received, without objection, two affidavits of the complainant. The second affidavit was sworn on 21st June 2002. The completion of the hearing of the appeal was delayed due to the ill health of counsel. When the hearing was resumed, the appellant intimated that he did not want to cross-examine the complainant on the affidavits and neither he nor Mr Grant, who appeared for the respondent, made further submissions. I am able to accept as proved the matters set out in the affidavits.

  9. The complainant prepared the complaint and summons.

  10. The complainant says…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Korber v Police No. Scciv-02-588 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] SASC 441
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Korber v Police involves an appeal against the conviction of the appellant, who pleaded guilty to driving an unregistered and uninsured motor vehicle. The appellant argues that the complaint against him was invalid due to procedural irregularities, specifically that the complaint was not made and laid in accordance with the relevant legislation and regulations. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the complaint was validly made and laid, and whether the summons issued was valid. The court held that the complaint was not validly laid as it was not signed and dated by a Registrar, Deputy Registrar or Justice of the Peace as required by the Magistrates Court Rules. Consequently, the proceedings against the appellant were not properly instituted, and the appeal was allowed. The convictions, fines, fees, levy, and licence disqualification were set aside.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant, Korber, was charged with driving an unregistered and uninsured motor vehicle on 9 February 2001 at Willaston. He pleaded guilty to both charges, namely contravening s 9 and s 102 of the Motor Vehicles Act 1959. He was convicted and fined $100, ordered to pay fees and a levy of $180.70, and disqualified from holding or obtaining a licence to drive a motor vehicle for two days. Korber appeals against his convictions despite his pleas of guilty. He argues that the complaint against him was invalid, and hence the proceedings against him were not properly instituted.

On 7 June 2001, a member of the South Australia Police stationed at Elizabeth prepared a complaint and summons in accordance with Form 2 of the Magistrates Court Rules. The document was served on Korber on 6 June 2001. However, the date on the complaint and summons was altered to 8 June 2001 by hand. The document served on Korber bore the stamp of the signature of the complainant and his name, rank, police number and where he was stationed. However, it had no signature of a Justice of the Peace, and it appears that it was not signed in the presence of a Justice of the Peace, although Form 2 had been used which is appropriate for a complaint made on oath. The complainant says that some time before 6 June 2001 he drafted the complaint and summons. According to him, there was a practice followed by police prosecutors at that time of sending the complaint and summons to a process server for service on the defendant without first filing it in the Magistrates Court and without the summons being signed by the Registrar of the Court or a Justice of the Peace. Form 2 provides for the summons to be signed by the Registrar of the Court or a Justice of the Peace. Form 2 provides for the complaint to be made on oath and consequently had to be made before a Justice of the Peace or any other person qualified to take an oath. The complainant says that on 8 June he believed a complaint had to be filed at the Court on the date that it was made. He obtained a copy of the complaint and summons which he had earlier prepared and had been served on the appellant. This copy was generated by a computer. It did not contain his signature. He altered the date when the complaint was made in the manner which has been mentioned. He then placed the stamp of his signature and the other particulars on the document. The document filed at the Court was not a complaint made on oath as the jurat clause is blank and there is no signature of a Justice of the Peace. The making of the complaint and the placing of the stamp containing the signature of the complainant and the other information was not witnessed. The complainant acknowledges that he filed the complaint and summons without having appeared before a Justice of the Peace and making the complaint on oath. The original complaint and summons is on the Magistrates Court file. It indicates that the making of the complaint was not witnessed by the Registrar of the Court or a Justice of the Peace and the summons is not signed by the Registrar or a Justice of the Peace.

The appellant did not attend the Court on 3 July 2001. He wrote to the Court seeking copies of the complaint and summons, the statement of allegations against him and the notes of the investigating officers. He drew attention to some irregularities in the laying of the complaint without specifying them. The hearing of the complaint was adjourned to 22 November 2001. A fresh summons was issued by the Court and served on the appellant. This summons was signed by a Justice of the Peace and is not defective in any respect. The original summons was plainly a nullity. It had never been issued by the Court. It was not signed by the Registrar or a Justice of the Peace. It was served before the complaint was made and laid. However, this is a matter of no consequence because when the complaint was heard the appellant was present at Court in obedience to the subsequent summons. The jurisdiction of the Court does not depend upon a summons being issued but upon the making of a complaint.

The appeal before the South Australian Supreme Court in Korber v Police concerns a challenge to the procedural validity of a complaint and summons issued by the SA Police against the appellant, Korber. The appeal was filed against the decision of the Magistrates Court which upheld the validity of the complaint and the subsequent conviction of Korber on two charges: driving an unregistered and uninsured motor vehicle. The appellant, represented pro se, contends that the complaint was improperly made and laid, and that the summons was issued before the complaint was made and filed. The appeal to the Supreme Court followed the appellant's pleas of guilty and subsequent appeal against his convictions. The procedural history involves the appellant raising preliminary points about the validity of the complaint before entering his pleas of guilty, which were rejected by the Magistrate. The appeal to the Supreme Court is grounded in the argument that the procedural irregularities rendered the complaint invalid and the proceedings against the appellant unlawful. The Court examined the statutory and regulatory requirements for making and laying complaints, concluding that the process was not properly followed, leading to the appeal being allowed and the convictions being set aside.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MULLIGHAN J
Issues
1. Whether the complaint was validly made and executed in accordance with the relevant statutory and regulatory requirements.
2. Whether the summons was validly issued and served on the appellant.
3. Whether the irregularities in the process of issuing the complaint and summons rendered the proceedings against the appellant invalid.
4. Whether the court had jurisdiction to hear the complaint despite the irregularities in the complaint and summons process.

Held
1. Whether the complaint was validly made and executed in accordance with the relevant statutory and regulatory requirements.
The court concluded that the complaint was not validly executed as it was not laid before a Registrar, Deputy Registrar, or Justice of the Peace and was not signed by such a person. Result: Appeal allowed.

2. Whether the summons was validly issued and served on the appellant.
The court concluded that the original summons was invalid as it was not issued by the Court or signed by the Registrar or a Justice of the Peace, but the fresh summons issued was valid. Result: Appeal allowed in relation to the original summons, no determination on the fresh summons.

3. Whether the irregularities in the process of issuing the complaint and summons rendered the proceedings against the appellant invalid.
The court concluded that the irregularities in the process of issuing the complaint and summons rendered the proceedings against the appellant invalid. Result: Appeal allowed.

4. Whether the court had jurisdiction to hear the complaint despite the irregularities in the complaint and summons process.
The court concluded that the irregularities did not affect the court's jurisdiction to hear the complaint as the appellant attended court in response to the valid fresh summons. Result: No determination.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MULLIGHAN J

In this appeal, the court was tasked with determining whether the complaint and summons process followed statutory and regulatory requirements, and whether these irregularities invalidated the proceedings against the appellant. The court began by examining whether the complaint was validly made and executed in accordance with the relevant statutory and regulatory requirements. The court highlighted that while the complaint did not need to be made on oath, it must be signed by the complainant and witnessed by a Justice of the Peace, as per Rule 12.03 of the Magistrates Court Rules. The court found that the complaint in this case was signed by the complainant but was not witnessed by a Justice of the Peace, rendering it invalid. This decision was based on the principle that the act of laying a complaint before a Justice of the Peace is a necessary formality to ensure the validity of the complaint, as discussed in The Queen v Manos; Ex Parte Samuels.

Next, the court considered whether the summons was validly issued and served on the appellant. It was noted that the original summons was defective as it was not signed by a Justice of the Peace and was served before the complaint was made. However, the court found that this irregularity was inconsequential because the appellant was subsequently served with a valid summons and attended court. The court relied on the precedent set in Electronic Rentals Pty Ltd v Anderson, which held that the jurisdiction of the Court depends on the making of a complaint, not the issuance of a summons.

The court then addressed whether the irregularities in the complaint and summons process rendered the proceedings against the appellant invalid. The court held that since the complaint was not validly laid and signed by a Justice of the Peace, the proceedings were not instituted correctly. The irregularity in the complaint process was deemed significant enough to invalidate the entire proceeding. This aligns with the principle that the laying of a complaint is an integral part of the system, as articulated in The Queen v Manos; Ex Parte Samuels.

Lastly, the court assessed whether it had jurisdiction to hear the complaint despite the irregularities. The court concluded that while the appellant was eventually served with a valid summons and attended court, the initial invalid complaint meant the proceedings were not correctly instituted. Therefore, the court lacked jurisdiction to convict the appellant on the charges presented. The court's decision underscores the importance of procedural formalities in legal proceedings, and it set aside the convictions, fines, and orders against the appellant.