Koninklijke Douwe Egberts B.V. v Nestec S.A

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Koninklijke Douwe Egberts B.V. v Nestec S.A. [2017] APO 22

Patent Application:                2011208837

Title:Method for providing information to a user from a capsule for the preparation of a beverage using a code

Patent Applicant:                   Nestec S.A.

Opponent:  Koninklijke Douwe Egberts B.V.

Delegate:  Xavier Gisz

Decision Date:  17 May 2017

Hearing Date:  Written submissions filed on 14 March 2017, 28 March 2017 and 4 April 2017

Catchwords:  PATENTS - opposition to the allowance of amendments under subsections 102(1), 102(2)(a) and 102(2)(b) of the Patents Act 1990 – amended claims in-substance disclosed – claim 16 does not fall within the scope of the accepted claims – amendment not allowed – costs awarded against applicant.

Representation:  Patent attorney for the applicant:  Shelston IP

Patent attorney for the opponent:  Davies Collison Cave Pty Ltd

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:                2011208837

Title:Method for providing information to a user from a capsule for the preparation of a beverage using a code

Patent Applicant:                   Nestec S.A.

Date of Decision:                   17 May 2017

DECISION

The amendment introduces a new claim (claim 16) which includes matter that would not in substance fall within the scope of the claims before amendment and thus does not comply with s 102(2)(a).

Subject to appeal I refuse the amendments.

I award costs in accordance with Schedule 8 of the Patents Regulations 1991 against the Applicant, Nestec S.A.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

  1. Patent application 2011208837 in the name of Nestec S.A. (the Applicant) was advertised as accepted on 5 November 2015. An opposition by Koninklijke Douwe Egberts B.V. (the Opponent) to the grant of a patent was filed on 5 February 2016.

  2. A Statement of Grounds and Particulars was filed on 5 May 2016. Evidence in support was filed on 5 August 2016.

  3. Amendments were proposed on 27 September 2016. Leave to amend was granted on 2 November 2016. The amendments were advertised for opposition on 17 November 2016. A Notice of Opposition to the amendments was filed on 17 January 2017. A Statement of Grounds and Particulars was filed on 17 February 2017.

  4. The Commissioner advised that the hearing would be on the basis of written submissions. The Opponent’s submissions were filed on 14 March 2017. The Applicant’s submissions were filed on 28 March 2017. The Opponent’s submissions in reply were filed on 4 April 2017.

    Grounds of Oppositions

  5. The Statement of Grounds and Particulars opposes the amendments under subsection 102(1) and paragraphs 102(2)(a) and 102(2)(b) of the Patents Act. Under paragraph 102(2)(b), it is asserted that the proposed amendments would not comply with subsections 40(2) or 40(3).

    The law

  6. As the request for examination of the patent application was filed before 15 April 2013, substantive amendments of the Patents Act brought about by the Intellectual Property Laws Amendment (Raising the Bar) Act 2012 do not apply to the present patent application.

  7. The relevant sections of the Patents Act in the current case are sections 102(1) and (2) as they existed prior to the introduction of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Koninklijke Douwe Egberts B.V. v Nestec S.A and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] APO 22
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved an opposition to amendments to a patent application by Nestec S.A. in opposition to Koninklijke Douwe Egberts B.V. The legal issues were whether the amendments were allowable under sections 102(1), 102(2)(a) and 102(2)(b) of the Patents Act 1990. The Applicant sought to introduce a new claim (claim 16) and amend several other claims. The Opponent argued that the amendments introduced new subject matter not disclosed in the specification as filed and would extend the scope of the patent monopoly. The court found that claim 16 did not comply with section 102(2)(a) as it was broader in scope than the claims before amendment. While some other amendments were allowable, the introduction of claim 16 warranted refusal of the amendments overall. The court awarded costs against the Applicant.
The key reasoning was that for an amendment to be allowable under section 102(2)(a), a new claim must in substance fall within the scope of the claims before amendment. The court found that claim 16 was broader in scope than the claims before amendment as it placed no limitation on the type of information provided to the user. This meant claim 16 did not comply with section 102(2)(a). While some other amendments were allowable, the introduction of the non-compliant claim 16 warranted refusal of the amendments overall. The court awarded costs against the Applicant in accordance with the Patents Regulations 1991.

Background

Background to the litigation

Patent application 2011208837, filed by Nestec S.A., pertains to a method for providing information to a user from a capsule for the preparation of a beverage using a code. The application was advertised as accepted on 5 November 2015. Subsequently, Koninklijke Douwe Egberts B.V. filed an opposition against the grant of a patent on 5 February 2016. The opposition was supported by a Statement of Grounds and Particulars filed on 5 May 2016, and evidence in support on 5 August 2016. Amendments to the patent were proposed on 27 September 2016, with leave to amend granted on 2 November 2016. These amendments were advertised for opposition on 17 November 2016, and a Notice of Opposition to the amendments was filed on 17 January 2017. The Opponent's Statement of Grounds and Particulars in response to the amendments was filed on 17 February 2017. The Commissioner advised that the hearing would be based on written submissions, which were filed by the Opponent on 14 March 2017, by the Applicant on 28 March 2017, and by the Opponent in reply on 4 April 2017.

The matter came before the Australian Patent Office as an opposition to the grant of a patent filed by Koninklijke Douwe Egberts B.V. against Nestec S.A.'s patent application 2011208837. The opposition was filed on 5 February 2016, with a Statement of Grounds and Particulars and evidence in support filed on 5 May 2016 and 5 August 2016, respectively. Nestec S.A. proposed amendments to the patent on 27 September 2016, which were granted leave to amend on 2 November 2016. The amendments were advertised for opposition on 17 November 2016, with a Notice of Opposition filed by Koninklijke Douwe Egberts B.V. on 17 January 2017. The Statement of Grounds and Particulars opposing the amendments was filed on 17 February 2017. The Commissioner decided the matter on the basis of written submissions, which were filed by the Opponent on 14 March 2017, by the Applicant on 28 March 2017, and by the Opponent in reply on 4 April 2017.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the amendment of claim 3 comply with subsections 102(1), 102(2)(a) and 102(2)(b) of the Patents Act 1990?
2. Does the proposed new claim 16 comply with subsections 102(1), 102(2)(a) and 102(2)(b) of the Patents Act 1990?
3. Does the amendment of claim 28 comply with subsections 102(1), 102(2)(a) and 102(2)(b) of the Patents Act 1990?

Held
1. The court refused the amendments to the patent claims, subject to appeal.
2. The amendment of claim 3 was allowed as it complied with subsections 102(1), 102(2)(a) and 102(2)(b) of the Patents Act 1990.
3. The proposed new claim 16 was not allowed as it did not comply with subsections 102(1), 102(2)(a) and 102(2)(b) of the Patents Act 1990.
4. The amendment of claim 28 was allowed as it complied with subsections 102(1), 102(2)(a) and 102(2)(b) of the Patents Act 1990.
5. Costs were awarded against the Applicant, Nestec S.A.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the amendments to the patent claims in light of the provisions of the Patents Act 1990, specifically sections 102(1) and 102(2). The court found that claim 3 was allowable as it was in substance disclosed in the specification as filed, and it fell within the scope of the claims before amendment. The court also found that the amendment was clear and fairly based on the description, and it complied with the requirements of section 40 of the Patents Act 1990.

The court found that the proposed new claim 16 was not allowable as it included matter that would not in substance fall within the scope of the claims before amendment. The court found that the claim introduced new subject matter that was not disclosed in the specification as filed, and it did not fall within the scope of the broadest claim before amendment. The court also found that the amendment to the preamble of claim 16 was clear and fairly based on the description, and it complied with section 40 of the Patents Act 1990, but it did not comply with section 102(2)(a) as it was broader in scope than the claims before amendment.

The court found that the amendment of claim 28 was allowable as it was in substance disclosed in the specification as filed, and it fell within the scope of the claims before amendment. The court found that the amendment was clear and fairly based on the description, and it complied with the requirements of section 40 of the Patents Act 1990. The court found no aspect of claim 28 that extended beyond the scope of the claims as accepted.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that an amendment to a patent claim is not allowable if it includes matter that would not in substance fall within the scope of the claims before amendment, or if it is broader in scope than the claims before amendment. The court found that the proposed new claim 16 did not comply with this principle, while the amendment of claim 28 did comply with this principle. The court also found that the amendment of claim 3 complied with this principle as it was in substance disclosed in the specification as filed, and it fell within the scope of the claims before amendment.