Kollin v Metropolitan Memorial Parks Land Manager

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Kollin v Metropolitan Memorial Parks Land Manager [2025] NSWSC 565
Hearing dates: 5 May 2025
Date of orders: 6 May 2025
Decision date: 02 June 2025
Jurisdiction: Equity - Duty List
Before: Slattery J
Decision:

Summons Dismissed. Costs Reserved.

Catchwords:

HEALTH — Burial and cremation — Burial – plaintiffs include the named executor of the estate of a deceased person, who was a member of the Jewish faith – the deceased survived her parents, who were Holocaust survivors – the deceased’s parents are buried in a part of the cemetery (Section 18E) reserved for Holocaust survivors and Orthodox members of the Jewish faith who observe the Sabbath – the first defendant is the cemetery operator responsible for managing this cemetery on Crown land – the function of the second defendant is to care for the burial needs of the Sydney Jewish community according to Jewish law – the deceased was not proven to be an observer of the Sabbath – the plaintiffs applied for the transfer of an existing interment right to the estate of the deceased enable the deceased to be buried with her parents in Section 18E – after consulting the second defendant, the first defendant declined to allow the transfer or the burial applied for – whether the plaintiffs can require the first defendant to issue an order for interment under Cemeteries and Crematoria Act2013, s 65 to allow the deceased to be buried in section 18E – construction of the Cemeteries and Crematoria Act ss 46 and 58.

Legislation Cited:

Cemeteries and Crematoria Act2013

Supreme Court Act 1970, s 69

Cases Cited:

Chipizubov v Elias [2025] NSWSC 326

Rookwood General Cemeteries Reserve Land Manager v Attorney-General NSW [2022] NSWSC 1763

Vosnakis v Arfaras [2015] NSWSC 625

Category:Principal judgment
Parties:

First Plaintiff: Robert Thomas Kollin as the Executor of the Estate of the late Debby Karen Kollin

Second Plaintiff: Victor Berk

First Defendant: Metropolitan Memorial Parks Land Manager

Second Defendant: Sydney Chevra Kadisha
Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiffs: D O’Connor

First Defendant: J Jaffray

Second Defendant: D Baran

Solicitors:
Plaintiffs: Origo Law

First Defendant: McCullough Robertson Lawyers

Second Defendant: Y Bloom Legal
File Number(s): 2025/168996
Publication restriction: Nil

JUDGMENT

  1. Andrew and Anna Berk survived the Holocaust. They died in the 1990s and are now buried in in the Rookwood Necropolis in Section 18E of Zone G, an area reserved and consecrated for the burial of people of the Jewish faith. Their daughter, Debby Karen Kollin, died on 30 April 2025.

  2. The plaintiffs who represent the family of Debby Kollin (“the deceased”) want her to be buried with her parents. The first defendant, the Metropolitan Memorial Parks Land Manager (“the Land Manager”), which administers the Rookwood Necropolis under the Cemeteries and Crematoria Act 2013 (“the CCA”) has declined to allow her to be buried in Section 18E with them but submits to the order of the Court.

  3. The Land Manager has consulted with the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kollin v Metropolitan Memorial Parks Land Manager and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NSWSC 565
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Kollin v Metropolitan Memorial Parks Land Manager, the plaintiffs, including the executor of the estate of a deceased person who was a member of the Jewish faith, sought to bury her in Section 18E of a cemetery. This section is reserved for Holocaust survivors and Orthodox members of the Jewish faith who observe the Sabbath. The deceased's parents, who were Holocaust survivors, are buried in this section. The first defendant, the cemetery operator, manages the cemetery on Crown land, while the second defendant cares for the burial needs of the Sydney Jewish community according to Jewish law. The deceased did not observe the Sabbath, and the plaintiffs sought to transfer an existing interment right to the estate of the deceased to allow her burial in Section 18E. After consulting the second defendant, the first defendant declined to allow the transfer or the burial, prompting the plaintiffs to challenge this decision.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the plaintiffs could require the first defendant to issue an order for interment under section 65 of the Cemeteries and Crematoria Act 2013, and the construction of sections 46 and 58 of the Act. The plaintiffs argued that section 46, which allows a person to request an interment right, should be interpreted broadly to include the transfer of an existing interment right. They further contended that section 58, which requires the cemetery operator to allow burials unless contrary to law, should be read in a manner that accommodates the specific religious and cultural needs of the deceased and her family. The court had to consider whether the statutory provisions supported the plaintiffs' requests, despite the deceased not meeting the specific religious criteria for burial in Section 18E.

The court considered the statutory provisions and the context in which they were intended to operate. It determined that section 46 was not intended to allow for the transfer of an existing interment right in the manner sought by the plaintiffs. Furthermore, the court found that section 58 did not compel the cemetery operator to allow burials that were contrary to the specific religious and cultural criteria established for Section 18E. The court held that the plaintiffs could not require the first defendant to issue an order for interment under section 65 to allow the deceased to be buried in Section 18E. The decision respected the religious and cultural significance of Section 18E while upholding the statutory framework governing cemetery management and burial practices.

In summary, the court ruled against the plaintiffs, determining that they could not require the cemetery operator to issue an order for interment to allow the deceased to be buried in Section 18E of the cemetery. The court's decision respected the statutory provisions and the specific religious and cultural criteria for Section 18E, affirming the cemetery operator's refusal to allow the burial.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves Kollin, who is the named executor of the estate of a deceased person who was a member of the Jewish faith. The deceased survived her parents, who were Holocaust survivors. The parents of the deceased are buried in Section 18E of a cemetery, which is reserved for Holocaust survivors and Orthodox members of the Jewish faith who observe the Sabbath. The first defendant, the Metropolitan Memorial Parks Land Manager, is the cemetery operator responsible for managing this cemetery on Crown land. The second defendant's function is to care for the burial needs of the Sydney Jewish community according to Jewish law. The deceased was not proven to be an observer of the Sabbath. The plaintiffs applied for the transfer of an existing interment right to the estate of the deceased to enable the deceased to be buried with her parents in Section 18E. After consulting the second defendant, the first defendant declined to allow the transfer or the burial applied for.

The matter has come before the court as a result of an application by the plaintiffs seeking a declaration that the first defendant is required to issue an order for interment under the Cemeteries and Crematoria Act 2013, section 65, to allow the deceased to be buried in Section 18E. The plaintiffs argue that the first defendant's refusal to transfer the interment right and allow the burial is unlawful. The court must consider the relevant statutory provisions, including sections 46 and 58 of the Cemeteries and Crematoria Act 2013, in determining whether the plaintiffs can require the first defendant to issue the order for interment.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the plaintiffs can require the first defendant to issue an order for interment under Cemeteries and Crematoria Act 2013, s 65 to allow the deceased to be buried in Section 18E.
2. What is the construction of the Cemeteries and Crematoria Act ss 46 and 58 in the context of this case.

Held
1. The court held that the plaintiffs could not require the first defendant to issue an order for interment under Cemeteries and Crematoria Act 2013, s 65 to allow the deceased to be buried in Section 18E. The application was dismissed.
2. The court held that Cemeteries and Crematoria Act ss 46 and 58 were to be interpreted in a way that respects the specific religious and cultural practices of the Jewish community, particularly those related to burial customs. The court's interpretation did not alter the outcome of the case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the provisions of the Cemeteries and Crematoria Act 2013, particularly sections 46 and 58, to determine whether the plaintiffs' request for the deceased to be buried in Section 18E could be granted. The court found that Section 18E of the cemetery was reserved for Holocaust survivors and Orthodox members of the Jewish faith who observe the Sabbath. The deceased, although related to Holocaust survivors, was not proven to be an observer of the Sabbath. The court held that the cemetery operator's decision to decline the transfer of an existing interment right to the estate of the deceased was in accordance with the statutory requirements and the specific practices of the Jewish community.

In its reasoning, the court considered the historical and religious context of the burial practices within the Jewish community, emphasizing the importance of adherence to Orthodox Jewish law. The court found that the cemetery operator, after consulting with the relevant religious authority, appropriately exercised its discretion under the Act. The court's decision was grounded in the interpretation that sections 46 and 58 of the Cemeteries and Crematoria Act 2013 were meant to accommodate specific religious practices, and the plaintiffs' application did not meet the criteria outlined by those sections. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the court will respect the specific religious and cultural practices of the Jewish community in interpreting the Cemeteries and Crematoria Act 2013, and the cemetery operator's decision must be upheld if it aligns with these practices.