DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Klinger & Anor v Body Corporate for Costa D’Ora Apartments [2007] QDC 300
PARTIES:
TREVOR KLINGER AND MELISSA KLINGER
Appellant
v
BODY CORPORATE FOR COSTA D’ORA APARTMENTS
Respondent
FILE NO/S:
No 47 of 2007
DIVISION:
Civil
PROCEEDING:
Appeal
DELIVERED ON:
14 September 2007
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
27 July 2007
JUDGES:
Searles DCJ
ORDER:
1. Appeal allowed.
2. Decision of Adjudicator Rosemann varied to:
(a) Declare under s 276 of the BCCM Act that:
(i) the Respondent was liable under regulation 109(1) of the Standard Module to maintain the balcony fascias of the Appellants’ lot in a good condition, including a structurally sound condition;
(ii) the Respondent was liable under regulation 109(2)(a) of the Standard Module to maintain, in a good condition, the waterproofing membranes on each of the balconies of the Appellants’ lot;
(iii) the Respondent was liable under regulation 109(2)(b) of the Standard to maintain, in a structurally sound condition, each of the balconies of the Appellants’ lot;
(iv) in breach of its obligation under s 109(1) and (2) of the Standard Module, the Respondent:
A. failed to maintain in a good condition, including in a structurally sound condition, the balcony fascias on the Appellants lot; and
B. failed to maintain in a good condition the waterproofing membranes on the Appellants’ lot; and
C. failed to maintain in a structurally sound condition the balconies on the Appellants’ lot.
(v) the Respondent is now liable to reimburse the Appellants for the cost of removing and replacing all tiles and screed on the Appellants’ balconies, such costs being reasonably incurred by the Appellants as a result of the need to repair and replace the balcony waterproofing membranes, and to effect structural repairs to the balconies.
(b) order that, pursuant to s 276 of the BCCM Act, the Respondent reimburse the Appellants for repairs which they carried out to their balcony fascias (being areas of common property) in the amount of $7,598;
(c) order that, pursuant to s 276 of the BCCM Act, the Respondent reimburse the Appellants the sum of $414 for structural repairs to the balconies;
(d) order that, pursuant to s 276 of the BCCM Act, the Respondent reimburse the Appellants the sum of $5,539 for costs incurred in repairing and replacing waterproofing membranes on the balconies;
(e) order that, pursuant to s 276 of the BCCM Act, the Respondent reimburse the Appellants the sum of $21,435 for costs incurred in removing and replacing all tiles and screed on the Appellants’ balconies.
3. That the Respondent pay the Appellants’ costs of and incidental to the appeal as accessed on the standard basis.
4. Order that the Appellants be exempt from any contribution to the above amounts ordered to be paid by the Body Corporate, including the costs of this appeal.
CATCHWORDS:
BODY CORPORATE AND COMMUNITY MANAGEMENT ACT 1997– ROLE OF ADJUDICATOR– FAILURE TO GIVE PROPER REASONS– INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE– IRRELEVANT CONSIDERATIONS– DENIAL OF NATURE JUSTICE – PROCEDURAL FAIRNESS
COUNSEL:
Ms S Moody for…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Klinger v Body Corporate for Costa D'Ora Apartments and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] QDC 300
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues addressed by the court were whether the Adjudicator's decision contained proper reasons, whether the decision was supported by sufficient evidence, and whether the Adjudicator considered irrelevant factors, thereby denying the Appellants procedural fairness. The Appellants contended that the Adjudicator failed to adequately address the evidence and made findings without a sound basis, which affected the outcome of the decision.
The court found that the Adjudicator's decision was flawed due to the absence of proper reasons, insufficient evidence, and the consideration of irrelevant factors. The court concluded that the Adjudicator had not provided adequate reasons for their findings and that the decision was based on insufficient evidence. Furthermore, the court held that the Adjudicator had considered irrelevant factors, which contributed to the denial of procedural fairness to the Appellants. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, and the decision of the Adjudicator was varied to reflect the Appellants' entitlement to reimbursement for various repairs and costs.
The court ordered that the Body Corporate reimburse the Appellants for costs related to balcony repairs and replacements, including the cost of repairing and replacing waterproofing membranes, structural repairs, and the removal and replacement of tiles and screed on the balconies. Additionally, the court ordered the Body Corporate to pay the Appellants' costs of and incidental to the appeal, and exempted the Appellants from any contribution to the amounts ordered to be paid by the Body Corporate.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Appeal allowed.
2. Decision of Adjudicator Rosemann varied to:
(a) Declare under s 276 of the BCCM Act that:
(i) the Respondent was liable under regulation 109(1) of the Standard Module to maintain the balcony fascias of the Appellants’ lot in a good condition, including a structurally sound condition;
(ii) the Respondent was liable under regulation 109(2)(a) of the Standard Module to maintain, in a good condition, the waterproofing membranes on each of the balconies of the Appellants’ lot;
(iii) the Respondent was liable under regulation 109(2)(b) of the Standard to maintain, in a structurally sound condition, each of the balconies of the Appellants’ lot;
(iv) in breach of its obligation under s 109(1) and (2) of the Standard Module, the Respondent:
A. failed to maintain in a good condition, including in a structurally sound condition, the balcony fascias on the Appellants lot; and
B. failed to maintain in a good condition the waterproofing membranes on the Appellants’ lot; and
C. failed to maintain in a structurally sound condition the balconies on the Appellants’ lot.
(v) the Respondent is now liable to reimburse the Appellants for the cost of removing and replacing all tiles and screed on the Appellants’ balconies, such costs being reasonably incurred by the Appellants as a result of the need to repair and replace the balcony waterproofing membranes, and to effect structural repairs to the balconies.
(b) order that, pursuant to s 276 of the BCCM Act, the Respondent reimburse the Appellants for repairs which they carried out to their balcony fascias (being areas of common property) in the amount of $7,598;
(c) order that, pursuant to s 276 of the BCCM Act, the Respondent reimburse the Appellants the sum of $414 for structural repairs to the balconies;
(d) order that, pursuant to s 276 of the BCCM Act, the Respondent reimburse the Appellants the sum of $5,539 for costs incurred in repairing and replacing waterproofing membranes on the balconies;
(e) order that, pursuant to s 276 of the BCCM Act, the Respondent reimburse the Appellants the sum of $21,435 for costs incurred in removing and replacing all tiles and screed on the Appellants’ balconies.
3. That the Respondent pay the Appellants’ costs of and incidental to the appeal as accessed on the standard basis.
4. Order that the Appellants be exempt from any contribution to the above amounts ordered to be paid by the Body Corporate, including the costs of this appeal.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi