KJ RENFREY NOMINEES PTY LTD V CRYSTALCORP DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD
[2000] SASC 373
1................ JUDGE BURLEY:.......... In this matter the defendant has applied for leave to amend the defence, set-off and counterclaim, which I shall refer to as the defence. The proposed amendment is set out in the affidavit of Mr Bannister, sworn on 25 October 2000. The proposed amendment is as follows:-
“A.If contrary to the defendant’s assertion, the agreement referred to in paragraph 22 hereof was not an agreement to arbitrate, then, in the alternative, the defendant says:-
1...... the agreement was an agreement between the parties to have the issue of the alleged outstanding monies on progress claims 1 to 15 made subject to a binding expert determination; and
2...... in the further alternative, that the agreement was a covenant to be bound by the determination of Mr Popplewell as to what, if any monies were owing under progress claims 1 to 15 in circumstances where Mr Popplewell was not a party to the dispute.”
The application for leave to amend was opposed by the plaintiff. Mr Lane, counsel for the plaintiff, initially advanced submissions that the proposed amendment constituted an illegitimate withdrawal of an admission that had previously occurred in the defence in circumstances where, had a proper application for leave to withdraw an admission been made, that leave would have been refused. He also advanced submissions that the alternative pleading proposed by the defendant contradicted other aspects of the defendants defence in circumstances where under the provisions of Rule 46.09 the alternative plea could not be said to be legitimate.
I think that his argument is better dealt with by reference to the provisions of Rule 46.09. That rule provides:
“46.09(1) A party shall not plead an allegation of fact or a new ground or claim inconsistent with his previous pleading.
(2) Subclause (1) hereof does not affect the right of a party to make allegations in the alternative or to amend or apply for leave to amend a pleading.”
The cases referred to by the learned author in ‘Civil Procedure South Australia’ at pp8529 and 8535 remind me that pleading in the alternative can fall into two categories; one where the court will allow an alternative pleading and one where the court will not. Examples are given in the commentary under Rule 46.09 of both.
In my view the proposed pleading contended for by the defendant should be characterised, in the circumstances of this case, as being an inconsistent pleading which cannot be pleaded in the alternative. That conclusion arises on the following facts. The claim by the plaintiff is for a money sum said to be due under a construction contract entered into between the plaintiff and the defendant. In the statement of claim at paragraphs 21-24 an arbitration agreement is referred to. That has been included in the statement of claim because the plaintiff has rightly anticipated that the defendant would rely upon the arbitration agreement and its implementation in order to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read KJ Renfrey Nom P/L v Crystalcorp Developments P/L No. Scgrg-... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] SASC 373
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined whether the proposed amendment introduced inconsistent facts that contradicted the defendant's previous admissions. The defendant had previously admitted the existence of an arbitration agreement in its defence, yet the proposed amendment sought to argue that no such agreement existed. The court held that the proposed amendment was inconsistent and could not be pleaded in the alternative, as it introduced a factual contradiction. The court found that the amendment was not allowable because it would permit the defendant to argue two mutually exclusive positions regarding the arbitration agreement, which was impermissible under the rules governing alternative pleadings. Consequently, the court refused the defendant's application for leave to amend.
The final orders of the court were that the defendant's application for leave to amend its defence, set-off, and counterclaim was refused. This decision ensured that the court could proceed to determine the issues raised in paragraphs 21 to 24 of the plaintiff's statement of claim on the basis that an arbitration agreement had been entered into, without the defendant being able to argue otherwise at a later stage of the trial.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi