TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Objection by KIWI MUNCHIES PTY LTD, to an application by INGHAMS ENTERPRISES PTY LTD, for an extension of time to file further evidence in relation to the opposition to registration of trade mark 856195(29) - CHICKEN MUNCHIES - filed in the name of INGHAMS ENTERPRISES PTY LTD.
Delegate: Tabatha Klippan Representation: Opponent:
Sophia Paras, of KM Legal
Applicant:
Chris Sgourakis, of Griffith HackDecision: (1) Application for extension of time to file further evidence granted
(2) Costs awarded against the opponentBackground
On 6 November 2000, Inghams Enterprises Pty Ltd, ('the applicant'), filed trade mark application number 856195 to register the trade mark, CHICKEN MUNCHIES, in respect of the following goods:
Class 29: Chicken; chicken meat products; chicken pieces; prepared or processed foods comprising; chicken nuggets; chicken burgers
Acceptance of the application was advertised in the Official Journal of Trade Marks on 6 June 2002.
Kiwi Munchies, ('the opponent'), filed a notice of opposition on 18 July 2002. Evidence in support, answer and reply was duly filed and served by the parties. As neither party requested a hearing the matter was set down for a decision on the written record. Both parties were advised of this by facsimile dated 2 June 2003.
By facsimile dated 3 June 2003, the trade mark applicant asked that the delegate of the Registrar not issue a decision on the written record and simultaneously filed an application for permission to file further evidence. The accompanying statutory declaration of Chris Sgourakis claimed that the opponent's substantive evidence was contained in the evidence in reply and not in the evidence in support. Therefore the applicant had not had an opportunity to respond to the substantive matters when its evidence in answer was filed.
The opponent, through its agent, KM Legal, objected to the application for permission to file further evidence on 19 June 2003. However, on 23 June 2003, both parties were advised that the Registrar intended to allow the three month extension of time, unless within 14 days from the date of notification of the Registrar's intention, the opponent requested a hearing of the matter. The opponent requested a hearing of the matter on 27 June 2003.
On 30 June 2003, the applicant filed and served the further evidence. The further evidence consists of:
· A Statutory Declaration made by Chris Sgourakis on 17 June 2003, with Annexure A-1
· A Statutory Declaration made by John Richards Hexton on 23 June 2003, with Annexure A.
As a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, I heard the matter in Canberra on 8 August 2003. Mr Chris Sgourakis of Griffith Hack, Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys, represented the applicant. Ms Sophia Paras, of KM Legal, represented the opponent. Both parties were heard by telephone.
Submissions And The Law
In accordance with regulation 5.15 the Registrar may grant an application for an extension of time to serve further evidence if the Registrar…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Kiwi Munchies Pty Ltd v Inghams Enterprises Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] ATMO 70
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Senior Examiner was whether to grant the applicant leave to file further evidence in response to evidence filed by the opponent. This involved an assessment of the balance of inconvenience and the public interest.
The Senior Examiner reasoned that the opponent's evidence in reply introduced new issues, making it fair and just to allow the applicant an opportunity to respond. Furthermore, the Senior Examiner considered that the public interest favoured the Registrar having all relevant evidence before him when determining the substantive opposition. Consequently, the application for permission to file further evidence was granted.
The Senior Examiner ordered that the opponent be allowed one month from the date of the decision to reply to the applicant's further evidence. Costs were awarded against the opponent in favour of the applicant, to be assessed in accordance with the official scale.
Background
Background to the litigation
Kiwi Munchies submitted that there was no likelihood of confusion between the two trade marks, as they had different get-up, colours, and visual elements. They also argued that the products were sold through different channels and that their target markets were different. In response to Inghams' opposition, Kiwi Munchies provided evidence of their use of the trade mark "KIWI MUNCHIES" in Australia since 2000, and sought to rely on their earlier use of the word "Kiwi" in other contexts. Inghams filed a reply, arguing that Kiwi Munchies' evidence was irrelevant and that they had not used the word "Kiwi" in connection with frozen food products until after Inghams had started using their "KIWI" trade mark. Inghams also sought to rely on evidence of consumer confusion that had occurred as a result of the similarity between the two trade marks.
The dispute between the two companies escalated when Kiwi Munchies filed an application to file further evidence in support of their case, which Inghams opposed. Kiwi Munchies argued that the new evidence was necessary to rebut Inghams' claims of consumer confusion and to demonstrate the distinctiveness of their trade mark. Inghams opposed the application on the basis that the evidence was irrelevant and that it had not been led in a timely manner. The application for permission to file further evidence was ultimately granted by the Senior Examiner, who found that it was fair and just to allow Kiwi Munchies to present their additional evidence. Inghams was given one month to file a reply to the new evidence.
The matter of Kiwi Munchies Pty Ltd v Inghams Enterprises Pty Ltd came before the court following an application by Kiwi Munchies for permission to file further evidence in opposition to a trade mark application by Inghams Enterprises. This application was made pursuant to section 69 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The initial trade mark application by Inghams was opposed by Kiwi Munchies on the basis of prior use and likelihood of confusion. After Kiwi Munchies filed its initial evidence in opposition, Inghams filed a reply, raising new issues which Kiwi Munchies sought to address by filing additional evidence. The application to file further evidence was heard by Senior Examiner Tabatha Klippan, who granted permission, finding that the balance of inconvenience lay with the applicant, and that it was only fair and just for Kiwi Munchies to respond to the new issues raised by Inghams. Senior Examiner Klippan also considered the public interest in the Registrar having all relevant evidence before him when deciding the substantive opposition. The decision was made on 20 November 2003, and Kiwi Munchies was granted permission to file further evidence with a deadline set for Inghams to reply. Costs were also awarded to Kiwi Munchies as they were the successful party in the interlocutory application.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Kiwi Munchies Pty Ltd v Inghams Enterprises Pty Ltd, the court carefully considered several pivotal issues pertinent to the management of evidence in the opposition proceedings of a trade mark application. The central question of whether the balance of inconvenience lies with the applicant to permit the filing of further evidence was addressed by the court, which concluded that the opponent's evidence in reply had raised new issues. This conclusion was based on the notion that fairness required the applicant to have the opportunity to respond to these new issues, thereby ensuring a balanced and comprehensive examination of all relevant evidence.
The court's reasoning on this point was grounded in the principle that it is fair and just to allow the applicant to address new matters introduced by the opponent's evidence in reply. This principle aligns with the broader legal objective of ensuring that all relevant evidence is considered in administrative proceedings to achieve a just outcome. The court distinguished the present case from scenarios where the balance of inconvenience would clearly lie with the applicant, emphasizing the importance of addressing new issues that could significantly impact the outcome of the substantive opposition.
Furthermore, the court found that the public interest is served by the Registrar having all relevant evidence before him when deciding the substantive opposition. This finding underscores the importance of a thorough and comprehensive review of evidence to ensure that the decision-making process is transparent, fair, and well-informed. The court relied on prior authority that supports the need for a complete evidentiary record in administrative proceedings to uphold the integrity of the decision-making process.
The court then proceeded to grant the application for permission to file further evidence, reflecting the conclusion that the balance of inconvenience, fairness, and public interest considerations all favoured permitting the applicant to address the new issues raised by the opponent's evidence in reply. In determining the time period for the opponent to reply to the further evidence, the court allowed one month, a period deemed sufficient to adequately respond to the new evidence while also considering the need to maintain a timely and efficient process.
Lastly, the court addressed the issue of costs, awarding costs against the opponent and directing that the opponent pay the costs of the applicant in accordance with the official scale. This decision was based on the applicant being the successful party in the matter, a common practice in administrative proceedings where costs are typically awarded to the prevailing party. The court's decision on costs reinforces the importance of ensuring that parties bear the financial responsibility for their actions in the proceedings, thereby promoting accountability and fairness.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this decision is that in administrative proceedings, where an opponent's evidence in reply raises new issues, it is fair and just to allow the applicant to respond to those issues, and the public interest is served by having all relevant evidence before the decision-maker. The court's decision to grant the application for further evidence, along with the one-month period for the opponent to reply, and the award of costs to the applicant, collectively reflect these principles. The court's approach underscores the importance of a balanced, fair, and thorough examination of evidence in administrative proceedings.