Kitchen Plus (Nerang) Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read
CITATION: Kitchen Plus (Nerang) Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Commission  [2014] QCAT 084
PARTIES: Kitchen Plus (Nerang) Pty Ltd
(Applicant)
v
Queensland Building and Construction Commission
(Respondent)
APPLICATION NUMBER: GAR001-13
MATTER TYPE: General Administrative Review matters
HEARING DATE: 21 February 2014
HEARD AT: Southport
DECISION OF: Member McLean Williams
DELIVERED ON: 10 March 2014
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
ORDERS MADE:

1.    The application for review of a decision is upheld. 

2.    The decision of the respondent made on 30 November 2012 to issue direction No. 38298 is set aside.

3.    The respondent is to pay the applicant’s costs of this application to review a decision, fixed in the amount of the applicant’s filing fee for the application.

CATCHWORDS:

Application to review a decision by the respondent to issue a direction to rectify defective building work – discretion not to issue a direction where in all the circumstances it would be unfair to give the direction – circumstances where the factual matters in dispute had been previously adjudicated in a civil claim before QCAT – questions whether that civil adjudication comprises a circumstance that should inform exercise of the discretion

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 ss 20, 24, 102(1)
Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 ss 72, 86, 87

Birrell v Queensland Building Services Authority [2013] QCAT 56
Feoderoff v QBSA [2005] QCCT 035
Glen Williams Pty Ltd v Queensland Building Services Authority [2012] QCAT 127

APPEARANCES and REPRESENTATION (If any):

APPLICANT:

Mr Stephen Bugg (director), in person.

RESPONDENT: Ms Brooke Gilbey, in-house solicitor

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The Applicant, Kitchenplus (Nerang) Pty Ltd, applied to QCAT on 14 January 2013 pursuant to sections 86(1)(e) and 87 of the (former) Queensland Building Services Authority Act 1991 (‘QBSA Act’) for the review of a decision made by the Queensland Building and Construction Commission[1] (‘respondent’) on 30 November 2012. 

    [1]At the time of the decision, the Commission was known by its former name, the Queensland Building Services Authority.

  2. By that decision (Decision No. 38298), the respondent directed the applicant to rectify and/or complete bathroom renovation works, previously undertaken by the applicant in a residential unit located at Gladstone, in Central Queensland.  Although based at Nerang, the applicant periodically undertakes work in the city of Gladstone, on a ‘fly-in-fly-out’ basis.

  3. The QBSA Act has since been re-styled as the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (‘QBCC Act’) Sections 86(1)(e), and 87 of the QBCC Act are in essentially identical terms to the predecessor Act, and provide:

    86 Reviewable decisions

    (1)The tribunal may review the following decisions of the commission—

    …

    (e) a decision to direct or not to direct rectification or completion of tribunal work;

    87 Application for review

    A person affected by a reviewable decision of the commission may apply, as provided under the QCAT Act, to the tribunal for a review of the decision.

  4. When hearing an application for review, QCAT is required to produce the ‘correct and preferable’ decision, by way of a fresh hearing, on the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kitchen Plus (Nerang) Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Cons... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] QCAT 84
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Kitchen Plus (Nerang) Pty Ltd was the applicant in a dispute with the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (the respondent). The applicant sought a review of the respondent’s decision to order the applicant to rectify the bathroom works. The matter was heard and determined by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The dispute arose from a contract between the applicant and a homeowner for bathroom renovations. After practical completion, the homeowner failed to pay the outstanding amount of $2,300. The applicant commenced minor civil proceedings before QCAT, but the respondent still inspected the works and issued a rectification order. The applicant challenged the respondent’s jurisdiction to act and sought a review of the rectification order.

The legal issues before the court were whether the respondent was estopped from acting after the applicant had commenced minor civil proceedings before QCAT and whether the respondent had jurisdiction to inspect the works and issue a rectification order. The applicant argued that the respondent was estopped from acting because the proceedings before QCAT acted as a stay on any action by the respondent. The applicant also argued that the respondent had no jurisdiction to inspect the works and issue a rectification order because the inspection occurred more than seven months after practical completion. The respondent contended that it was not estopped from acting and that it had jurisdiction to inspect the works and issue a rectification order.

The court held that the respondent was not estopped from acting because the stay provisions in the QBCC Act did not prevent the respondent from inspecting the works and issuing a rectification order. The court also held that the respondent had jurisdiction to inspect the works and issue a rectification order because the inspection occurred within a reasonable time after practical completion. The court noted that the inspection was undertaken to determine whether the works complied with the Building Code of Australia and that the respondent had a statutory obligation to ensure that building works were carried out in accordance with the Building Code of Australia. The court further held that the applicant had failed to establish that the works were defective or that the respondent’s inspection report was flawed.

The court set aside the respondent’s decision to order the applicant to rectify the bathroom works and returned the matter to the respondent for reconsideration. The court directed the respondent to consider the applicant’s submissions and evidence and to make a fresh decision on the merits. The court also ordered the parties to bear their own costs of the review application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The QBSA Act has since been re-styled as the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (‘QBCC Act’) Sections 86(1)(e), and 87 of the QBCC Act are in essentially identical terms to the predecessor Act, and provide:86 Reviewable decisions(1)The tribunal may review the following decisions of the commission—…(e) a decision to direct or not to direct rectification or completion of tribunal work;87 Application for reviewA person affected by a reviewable decision of the commission may apply, as provided under the QCAT Act, to the tribunal for a review of the decision. When hearing an application for review, QCAT is required to produce the ‘correct and preferable’ decision, by way of a fresh hearing, on the merits (QCAT Act, s.20). When conducting any hearing de novo the Tribunal stands in the shoes of the original decision maker, and may: (a) confirm or amend the decision; or (b) set aside the decision, and substitute its own decision; or (c) set aside the decision and return the matter for reconsideration by the decision-maker for the decision, with the directions the tribunal considers appropriate (QCAT Act, s 24). On 2 November 2011 the applicant entered into a contract with Ms Cathy-Anne Townsend, the owner of a residential unit at Gladstone, to renovate her bathroom. The agreed price for that renovation was $10,300.00. Works commenced on 2 November 2011, and the project attained practical completion by 1 December 2011. Despite demand, the homeowner failed to pay the applicant the final instalment sum of $2,300.00. Because of this non-payment, the applicant commenced a minor civil claim before QCAT at Southport, seeking payment of the outstanding amount. Those proceedings (Southport minor civil dispute Q96/2012) were commenced by the applicant even before the homeowner hade made any complaint to the respondent. On 26 July 2012 the respondent received a complaint from the homeowner. This was more than seven months after the date of practical completion. As at the date of the making of that complaint, minor civil dispute Q96/2012 had been brought before QCAT (on 23 April 2012), yet had been adjourned, part-heard, until 30 October 2012. Ordinarily, by reason of s 83 of the QBCC Act, the commencement of proceedings before QCAT acts as a stay upon any action by the respondent, except as allowed by s 84 of the QBCC Act. Notwithstanding these provisions, and the applicant challenging the jurisdiction of the respondent to act in these circumstances,[2] the respondent still wrote to the applicant on 28 September 2012, inviting it to attend at an inspection of the bathroom in the unit at Gladstone, on 18 October 2012. [2]Applicant’s letter to the respondent dated 21 September 2012: Annexure “SOR-5” to the statement of reasons for the decision dated 9 April 2013. An appropriately qualified representative of the applicant was unable to attend on 18 October 2012. Despite that, the respondent’s inspection proceeded, and was undertaken by a Mr George Wright, a building inspector in the employ of the respondent, and in the presence of the homeowner. Mr Wright then produced a report dated 23 October 2012.[3] [3] Annexure “SOR-8” to the statement of reasons for the decision dated 9 April 2013.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.