Kirchner v ITT Water and Wastewater Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Kirchner v ITT Water & Wastewater Limited [2010] QSC 413

PARTIES:

GARY WILLIAM KIRCHNER

(Plaintiff)

v

ITT WATER & WASTEWATER LIMITED ACN 000 832 922

(Defendant)

FILE NO:

BS 12966 of 2009

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

5 November 2010

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

7-8 September 2010

JUDGE:

McMurdo J

ORDER:

Judgment for the plaintiff against the defendant in the sum of $315,281.28.

CATCHWORDS:

DAMAGES – MEASURE AND REMOTENESS OF DAMAGES IN ACTIONS FOR TORT – MEASURE OF DAMAGES – PERSONAL INJURIES – LOSS OF EARNINGS AND EARNING CAPACITY – RE-EMPLOYMENT OF WORKER – where the plaintiff was injured in the course of his employment by the defendant and suffered head injuries – where the defendant admits liability – where the plaintiff worked for the defendant for a year after the accident, with earnings similar to before the accident – where the plaintiff subsequently left the defendant’s employ and has since had multiple jobs, each less remunerative than when he was employed by the defendant – whether the plaintiff’s reduced earnings are a result of his injuries.

COUNSEL:

M Grant-Taylor SC with A L Brook for the plaintiff

R Myers for the defendant

SOLICITORS:

South Queensland Law for the plaintiff

Hede Byrne and Hall Solicitors for the defendant

  1. The plaintiff, Mr Kirchner, was injured in the course of his employment by the defendant company on 5 September 2006.  He fell down a manhole into a concrete sewerage pump station.  He suffered a fracture of the occipital region of his skull and a frontal subdural haematoma with associated contusions.

  1. He was hospitalised for about a week.  No surgery was required.  He was then 26 years old.  He returned to work after a couple of months and stayed with the defendant, although performing lighter duties, until the end of 2007.  He has had other work since.  But his case is that he is unable to work a full week, at least week in week out, because he suffers headaches, dizziness, loss of balance and has impaired memory and concentration.  What is clear is that he has lost completely his sense of smell. 

  1. The defendant admits liability and that Mr Kirchner suffered those head injuries.  For this assessment of damages, the issues are essentially the extent of impairment of his earning capacity and the losses from that impairment. 

  1. Mr Kirchner left school at the end of grade 11.  He did some labouring work and also some work in the retail field.  But until he worked for the defendant, his work history was poor.  For the two or three years prior to then, he was largely unemployed.  He commenced with the defendant in September 2004, working effectively as a labourer.  He worked as a subcontractor, although he was full time with the defendant.  I will return to the evidence of witnesses who worked with him, but overall he had good work history with the defendant.  He found this job through…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kirchner v ITT Water and Wastewater Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] QSC 413
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Kirchner v ITT Water and Wastewater Limited, the plaintiff, Kirchner, was injured in the course of his employment by the defendant, ITT Water and Wastewater Limited, suffering head injuries. The defendant admitted liability for the injuries. The primary issue before the court was whether the plaintiff’s reduced earnings following his departure from the defendant's employ were a consequence of the injuries sustained in the workplace incident. The court had to determine if the injuries had an impact on the plaintiff’s earning capacity and whether the subsequent reduction in income was a result of those injuries.

The court examined the evidence of the plaintiff's employment history post-injury, including the year he worked for the defendant with earnings comparable to those before the accident, and his subsequent employment in roles that were less lucrative. The court considered whether the plaintiff’s diminished earning capacity was attributable to the injuries. Given the plaintiff's inability to secure employment with the same remuneration levels as before the incident, the court concluded that the injuries had indeed affected his earning capacity.

Having found that the plaintiff’s reduced earnings were a result of the injuries, the court awarded damages. The judgment quantified the plaintiff's loss of future earnings and other compensatory elements, resulting in a total award of $315,281.28 against the defendant. This amount reflected the plaintiff's loss of earning capacity due to the injuries sustained in the workplace incident.

Orders

Orders of the court

Judgment for the plaintiff against the defendant in the sum of $315,281.28.

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiff, Mr Kirchner, was employed by ITT Water and Wastewater Limited. During his employment, Mr Kirchner suffered a head injury due to an incident at work. The defendant admitted liability for the injury, which occurred in the course of Mr Kirchner's employment. After the accident, Mr Kirchner continued to work for ITT Water and Wastewater Limited for another year, earning a salary comparable to what he earned before the incident. Subsequently, Mr Kirchner left the defendant’s employ and took up multiple jobs, each of which paid less than his previous employment with ITT Water and Wastewater Limited. This change in employment and income level has continued to the present.

This case came before the court as a claim for damages related to the personal injuries sustained by Mr Kirchner. The matter proceeded on the basis that the defendant admitted liability for the injury. The primary focus of the trial was the quantification of damages, specifically the loss of future earnings and earning capacity attributable to the injuries. The court examined evidence regarding Mr Kirchner's employment history and earnings before and after the accident, including his re-employment and subsequent job changes.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the reduction in Mr Kirchner's earnings following his departure from ITT Water and Wastewater Limited is attributable to his injuries.
2. How to properly measure Mr Kirchner's loss of future earnings and earning capacity in light of his varied employment history post-injury.

Held
1. The court concluded that the reduction in Mr Kirchner's earnings following his departure from ITT Water and Wastewater Limited is attributable to his injuries.
2. The court determined that Mr Kirchner's loss of future earnings and earning capacity should be measured based on the varied employment history post-injury, considering all relevant factors.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering the first issue, the court acknowledged that Mr Kirchner's initial period of employment post-injury with ITT Water and Wastewater Limited showed no significant impact on his earnings as a result of his injuries. However, the court focused on the subsequent employment history, which demonstrated a consistent decline in earnings and earning capacity. The court emphasised that the varied employment history was relevant in assessing the true extent of Mr Kirchner's injury-related losses. By examining the totality of the plaintiff's post-injury employment, the court was able to discern a pattern that pointed to the injuries as the cause of the reduced earnings. This finding aligns with established principles of assessing damages for personal injury, where the court must consider all factors that might impact the plaintiff's earning capacity following the injury. The binding principle established here is that in cases of personal injury, the assessment of damages must take into account the full employment history post-injury to accurately determine the impact of the injuries on the plaintiff's earning capacity.

In addressing the second issue, the court held that Mr Kirchner's loss of future earnings and earning capacity should be measured by considering his varied employment history post-injury. The court rejected the argument that only the period immediately following the injury should be considered, emphasising the importance of a comprehensive assessment. The court applied the principle that damages should reflect the true loss suffered by the plaintiff, which in this case included all employment periods following the injury. The authorities relied upon supported the approach of considering the entire post-injury employment history in assessing damages. The ratio decidendi here is that in cases involving personal injury and varied employment history post-injury, damages should be assessed based on the full employment history to accurately reflect the impact of the injuries on the plaintiff's earning capacity. This decision follows established case law that supports a comprehensive approach to assessing damages in personal injury actions.