Kiraig Pty Ltd (Trustee) v Rent the Roo Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Kiraig Pty Ltd (Trustee) v Rent the Roo Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 1904

Appeal from: Kiraig Pty Ltd as Trustee for Jovette Trust v Rent the Roo Pty Ltd [2017] FCCA 1493
File number: NSD 1222 of 2017
Judge: MARKOVIC J
Date of judgment: 30 November 2018
Catchwords: CONTRACTS – appeal from orders made by the Federal Circuit Court – where the primary judge found certain contractual clauses were void for uncertainty – where the respondent conceded that the appellant was never heard on this issue – where the respondent’s notice of contention propounded that the primary judgment should be affirmed on other grounds – whether the primary judge erred in failing to find that the respondent breached certain contractual clauses – whether the appellant was entitled to damages plus interest – appeal allowed.
Legislation:

Federal Circuit Court of Australia Act 1999 (Cth) s 76

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 24(1)(d)

Cases cited:

Banque Commerciale SA v Akhil Holdings Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 279

RailPro Services Pty Ltd v Flavel (2015) 242 FCR 424

SLMB v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCAFC 129

SDAEA v Arora; SDAEA v Arora Markets Pty Ltd [2018] FCCA 85

Date of hearing: 27 March 2018
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 83
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr S Couper QC with Mr J Gooley and Ms N Dewan
Solicitor for the Appellant: MCW Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr R Parsons
Solicitor for the Respondent: Kells

ORDERS

NSD 1222 of 2017
BETWEEN:

KIRAIG PTY LTD ACN 113 874 267 AS TRUSTEE FOR JOVETTE TRUST

Appellant

AND:

RENT THE ROO PTY LTD ACN 001 408 448

Respondent

JUDGE:

MARKOVIC J

DATE OF ORDER:

30 NOVEMBER 2018

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be allowed.

2.Order 1 made on 30 June 2017 and Orders 1 and 3 made on 20 July 2017 by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia be set aside and, in lieu thereof, it be ordered that:

(a)the respondent pay damages in the sum of $269,153;

(b)pursuant to s 76 of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia Act 1999 (Cth) the respondent pay interest on the amount set out in Order 2(a) above from 8 September 2015 until the date of these Orders; and

(c)the respondent pay the applicants’ costs of the action, assessed according to the scale in Pt 1 of Sch 1 to the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth).

3.The respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

MARKOVIC J:

  1. This is an appeal from an order made and judgment given on 30 June 2017 (see Kiraig Pty Ltd as Trustee for Jovette Trust v Rent the Roo Pty Ltd [2017] FCCA 1493) (Primary Judgment) and from…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kiraig Pty Ltd (Trustee) v Rent the Roo Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 1904
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between Kiraig Pty Ltd (Trustee) and Rent the Roo Pty Ltd, which was heard by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, involves a dispute over alleged breaches of franchise agreements by Rent the Roo. The primary judge had dismissed Kiraig’s claims, but Kiraig appealed this decision on specific grounds related to the alleged breaches of the agreements. Rent the Roo, in response, conceded two of Kiraig’s grounds of appeal but argued that the judgment should still be upheld on other grounds. The central legal issues in the appeal were whether the primary judge erred in not finding that Rent the Roo breached certain clauses of the franchise agreements, and whether Kiraig was entitled to damages plus interest.

The court found that the primary judge erred in not finding that Rent the Roo had breached the franchise agreements. Specifically, the court identified that Rent the Roo had unreasonably withheld approval for the transfer of the agreements, which was a clear breach of the agreements. Additionally, the court determined that Kiraig was entitled to damages plus interest. The court held that the primary judge’s failure to address these issues constituted a significant error. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, and the orders from the Federal Circuit Court were set aside. In place of the original orders, the court ordered that Rent the Roo pay damages, interest on the damages, and the costs of the action and appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. Order 1 made on 30 June 2017 and Orders 1 and 3 made on 20 July 2017 by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia be set aside and, in lieu thereof, it be ordered that:

(a) the respondent pay damages in the sum of $269,153;

(b) pursuant to s 76 of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia Act 1999 (Cth) the respondent pay interest on the amount set out in Order 2(a) above from 8 September 2015 until the date of these Orders; and

(c) the respondent pay the applicants’ costs of the action, assessed according to the scale in Pt 1 of Sch 1 to the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth).

3. The respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Kiraig’s appeal is limited in scope and does not seek to challenge all of the primary judge’s findings. The grounds of Kiraig’s amended notice of appeal, set out at [44] below, are limited to the primary judge’s findings in relation to its claims of breach of the Franchise Agreements by Rent the Roo. Rent the Roo filed a notice of contention in which it effectively concedes two of Kiraig’s grounds of appeal but contends that the judgment should be affirmed on other grounds, namely that the primary judge concluded that there was no breach of the Franchise Agreements. BACKGROUND FACTS The following findings of fact, which were not in contention, were principally set out at [105] of the primary judge’s reasons. As noted at [2] above, on 19 April 2005 Rent the Roo, Kiraig and Mrs Gilmore entered into the Area 20 Agreement and on 7 September 2005 they entered into the Area 10 Agreement. The Franchise Agreements were in substantially the same terms. The Area 20 Agreement, for example, relevantly provided in:(1)cl 1B (hereafter referred to as the Renewal Clauses):1B. RENEWALSubject to sub clauses (a) & (b) below, the Franchisor will renew the Franchise for one (1) further period, at no additional cost to the master franchisee for the duration of which shall be the period set out in Schedule I ("the Renewal Term"), if and only if:(a)the Master franchisee has been throughout the Term in full compliance with this Agreement and or has rectified to the complete satisfaction of the franchisor any breaches within the specified timeframes of this or any other agreements between the Franchisor and the Master franchisee at the time of giving the notice referred to in paragraph (d) or at the date of expiration of the Term;(b)the Master franchisee and the Guarantor then enters into the Franchisor's then current Master Franchise Agreement (which will not however contain terms substantially different from those herein contained), however such renewal agreement shall not include any further option for any subsequent renewal. Such renewal agreement for one further term as outlined in Schedule One will not oblige the Master franchisee to pay any additional Initial or renewal Fee).…(e)The master franchisee gives written notice to the Franchisor of the Master franchisee’s intention to renew the Franchise and said notice shall be given between (3) months and (6) months before the end of the first Term.…For the purposes of this agreement, the Master franchisee shall be deemed to have irrevocably elected not to renew the Franchise (and its option shall thereupon terminate) if it fails to execute and return to the Franchisor its then standard Franchise Agreement referred to in sub paragraph (b) hereof and other documents reasonably required by the Franchisor for a renewal within on (1) month after the Franchisor has delivered same to the Master franchisee on receipt of the Master franchisee’s notice exercising the option.(2)cl 10B, which concerned the franchisee’s rights to transfer the agreements:10B. BY MASTER FRANCHISEE(a)The Franchise is personal to the Master franchisee and may not be in whole or in part voluntarily, involuntarily, directly or indirectly assigned, subdivided, sub-franchised or otherwise transferred by the Master franchisee without the prior written approval of the Franchisor provided that approval to assign the Franchise in whole shall not be unreasonably withheld. If such approval to assign is granted, it may be conditional upon the following:(i)The Master franchisee paying to the Franchisor all unpaid accounts plus the costs associated with approving such transfer plus a transfer fee where the total of those transfer costs shall not exceed $15,000 (plus GST)(ii)The transferee executing the Franchisor’s then current master Franchise Agreement and if so deemed by the franchisor in its ultimate discretion the transferee paying a new franchise initial franchise fee for a new franchise agreement with a fresh term consistent with the then initial terms of the franchise agreement being granted at that time which will not contain financial terms substantially different from those contained herein), and such other documents then customarily used by the Franchisor for its master franchisees;(iii)the transferee acquiring all of the Master franchisee's essential assets used in the Franchise and assuming all of the Master franchisee liabilities in relation thereto including the management of all established sub franchisees;(iv)The transferee having adequate financial resources and meeting the criteria of the Franchisor for the selection of new master franchisees, satisfactorily completed the Franchisor’s then standard training program for master franchisees and being otherwise capable of operating the Franchise as a master franchisee;(v)where the transferee is a company the Directors of the transferee giving appropriate guarantees and indemnities and the shareholders being acceptable to Franchisor; and(vi)The Premises from which the transferee is to operate from complying with the then prevailing RENT THE ROO Marketing Image and all its trading requirements.…(c)Such franchisor consent of the transfer will be made in writing within 30 days after the master franchisees request is made or a written response will be issued by the franchisor within 30 days if consent is withheld setting out the reasons.…(3)cl 10D:10D. FRANCHISOR’S RIGHT OF FIRST REFUSALNotwithstanding the provisions of clause 10B, if the Master franchisee shall at any time determine to sell the Franchise or an interest in the Franchise and the Master franchisee shall obtain a written bona fide expression of interest to purchase the business, including the Master Franchise rights together with his interest in all real or personal property, leasehold improvements if applicable and other assets used by the Master franchisee in the Business from a responsible and fully disclosed bonafide purchaser and shall submit an exact copy of such expression of interest to the Franchisor, who shall, for a period of two (2) weeks from the date of delivery of such offer, have the right, but not the obligation, exercisable by written notice to the Master franchisee, to purchase the Franchise and the assets of the Business, for the price (less any amount payable by the Master franchisee to the Franchisor) and on the terms and conditions contained in such expression of interest, provided that the Franchisor may substitute cash for any form of payment proposed in such expression of interest. The Franchisor may deduct from the purchase price any unpaid debts of the Master franchisee to the Franchisor and may pay out of the purchase price any of the Master franchisee’s unpaid trade creditors.If the Franchisor does not exercise its right of first refusal, the Master franchisee may complete the sale of the Business to such purchaser subject to the provisions of Clause 10B hereof, for a consideration which does not vary from the consideration set out in the offer of the right of first refusal. If the sale to such purchaser is not completed within two (2) months after delivery of such offer to the Franchisor, the Franchisor shall again have the right of first refusal. Nothing herein contained shall prevent the Master franchisee’s executing an agreement to assign conditional upon compliance with this Clause and Clause 10B.(4)schedule 1 definitions of the “Initial Term” as being 10 years and the “Renewal Term” as being 10 years.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

This is an appeal from an order made and judgment given on 30 June 2017 (see Kiraig Pty Ltd as Trustee for Jovette Trust v Rent the Roo Pty Ltd [2017] FCCA 1493) (Primary Judgment) and from certain orders made on 20 July 2017 in relation to costs by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia (Federal Circuit Court). The proceeding in the Federal Circuit Court concerned two franchise agreements between the appellant, Kiraig Pty Ltd as trustee for the Jovette Trust (Kiraig), as master franchisee; Joy Elaine Gilmore, the sole director of Kiraig, as guarantor of Kiraig’s performance; and the respondent, Rent the Roo Pty Ltd (Rent the Roo), as franchisor. Rent the Roo is in the business of renting household products to consumers. It operates as a franchisor in over 60 exclusive franchise territories in Australia. Kiraig entered into the two franchise agreements with Rent the Roo on 19 April 2005 for the exclusive territory known as “Area 20” (Area 20 Agreement) and on 7 September 2005 for the exclusive area known as “Area 10” (Area 10 Agreement) (collectively, Franchise Agreements). Before the primary judge, Kiraig and Mrs Gilmore, as first and second applicants respectively, sought damages in the sum of $269,153 and equitable compensation or, alternatively, an account of profits. They alleged that Rent the Roo had breached cl 1B(b) and cl 10B(a) of the Franchise Agreements; that Rent the Roo had failed to act in good faith in contravention of s 51ACB of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (CC Act) or, in the alternative, had engaged in conduct which amounted to unconscionable conduct under s 20 and s 21 of the Australian Consumer Law, Sch 2 to the CC Act; and that Rent the Roo had breached its obligation of confidence by wrongfully accessing and copying certain information from Kiraig’s email account. On 30 June 2017 the Federal Circuit Court made an order dismissing Kiraig and Mrs Gilmore’s application and on 20 July 2017 it made costs orders, including an order that Kiraig and Mrs Gilmore pay the costs of the action incurred by Rent the Roo and the second respondent (Phillip Hague, Rent the Roo’s chief executive officer). Kiraig’s appeal is limited in scope and does not seek to challenge all of the primary judge’s findings. The grounds of Kiraig’s amended notice of appeal, set out at [44] below, are limited to the primary judge’s findings in relation to its claims of breach of the Franchise Agreements by Rent the Roo. Rent the Roo filed a notice of contention in which it effectively concedes two of Kiraig’s grounds of appeal but contends that the judgment should be affirmed on other grounds, namely that the primary judge concluded that there was no breach of the Franchise Agreements. BACKGROUND FACTS The following findings of fact, which were not in contention, were principally set out at [105] of the primary judge’s reasons. As noted at [2] above, on 19 April 2005 Rent the Roo, Kiraig and Mrs Gilmore entered into the Area 20 Agreement and on 7 September 2005 they entered into the Area 10 Agreement.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In relation to ground five, Rent the Roo said that Kiraig’s refusal impacts on the question of causation of loss which are identified and quantified by Kiraig by reference to the offer made by Friends Investments.CONSIDERATIONGround two In considering ground two it is necessary to start with the pleadings that were before the primary judge. In their amended points of claim, Kiraig and Mrs Gilmore relevantly pleaded:30.On or about 8 September 2015, [Rent the Roo] notified [Kiraig] that its franchise rights for the two territories were terminated.ParticularsLetter from Kells to Ms Joy Gilmore dated 8 September 2015.31.Thereafter, [Rent the Roo], under the direction of [Mr Hague], began conducting itself within area 10 and area 20 in the following manner:(a)Removed [Kiraig] from receiving enquiries from new and existing customers made through the national telephone number of [Rent the Roo];(b)Diverted enquiries from new and existing customers intended for [Kiraig] to other Rent The Roo franchisees and to [Rent the Roo];(c)Began trading in the two territories in competition with [Kiraig], including directly soliciting business from [Kiraig’s] customers; and(d)On 11 September 2015, wrongfully accessed and copied from [Kiraig’s] email account, a management report containing a list of all of the customers of [Kiraig], together with particulars of each consumer lease of such customers.ParticularsEmail from Alan Carroll, [Rent the Roo’s] group general manager, to [Mr Hague] and others dated 11 September 2015.Breach of the Agreements32.In the premises set out in paragraphs 8, 9, 10, 19 and 20 above, [Rent the Roo and Mr Hague], by proposing terms which were substantially different in the Proposed Agreement, were in breach of its obligations under clause 1B(b) of the Agreements.33.In the premises set out in paragraphs 13, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27 and 28 above, [Rent the Roo and Mr Hague] were furthermore in breach of its obligations under clause 10B(a) of the Agreements, by unreasonably withholding approval of the transfer to Friends Investments.34.[Kiraig and Mrs Gilmore] have suffered loss and damage as a result of [Rent the Roo and Mr Hague’s] breaches and wrongful termination of the Agreements referred to in a paragraph 30, 31, 32 and 33 above. In their defence Rent the Roo and Mr Hague relevantly admitted to [30] of the amended points of claim. They thereafter pleaded the following matters by way of response to [31]-[34] of the amended points of claim:31. [Rent the Roo]:(a)admits that it did not direct new customer enquiries to [Rent the Roo] consistent with its previous advice to [Kiraig] but denies that it has removed or prevented [Kiraig] from receiving enquiries from its existing customers through [Rent the Roo’s] national telephone number as pleaded in paragraph 31(a) of the points of claim;(b)admits that [Rent the Roo] addressed new enquires for territories 20 and 10; denies that [Kiraig] was entitled to receive any enquires for the business system in territories 20 and 10 and further denies that it diverted enquiries from [Kiraig’s] existing customer as pleaded in paragraph 31(b) of the points of claim.(c)denies paragraph 31(c) of the points of claim; and(d)denies the contentions pleaded in paragraph 31(d) of the points of claim and further says in answer to paragraph 31(d) of the points of claim:(i)that the email account was at all times owned and operated by [Kiraig];(ii)that as the franchisor and the owner of the business system and the territories was entitled to access its email account and view the contents;(iii)denies making any copies of the contents of the information;(iv)denies that any information was used in a manner to [Kiraig’s] detriment..32. [Rent the Roo and Mr Hague] deny paragraph 32 of the points of claim.33. [Rent the Roo and Mr Hague]:(a)deny that they withheld or unreasonably withheld approval for the transfer of the Agreements as pleaded in paragraph 33 of the points of claim;(b)deny that the operation and meaning of paragraphs 13, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27 and 28 as pleaded establish a breach of any obligations that [Rent the Roo and Mr Hague] had under Clause 10B(a) of the Agreements as pleaded in paragraph 33 of the points of claim.34. [Rent the Roo and Mr Hague] deny paragraph 34 of the points of claim.