Kingsford Machinery & Stix Farms Pty Ltd v Marks

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Civil)

KINGSFORD MACHINERY & STIX FARMS PTY LTD v MARKS

[2012] SASC 65

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Kourakis

27 April 2012

MAGISTRATES - APPEALS AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT

LANDLORD AND TENANT - LEASES AND TENANCY AGREEMENTS - CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION

Appeal from judgment of a magistrate – appellant (plaintiff) and respondent (defendant) made various claims and counter-claims with respect to lease agreements over agricultural land made between the parties – whether the terms of the lease were confined to the written documents – whether the lease agreement, properly construed, gave rise to various alleged obligations on the appellant and respondent – whether there was any failure to meet any alleged obligations – whether the respondent incurred loss under the first agreement as a result of the appellant’s failure to provide functioning irrigation equipment – whether any such loss was compromised by agreement – whether the respondent incurred loss under the second and third agreements as a result of the appellant’s failure to provide functioning irrigation equipment – whether the extent of loss claimed by the respondent was reasonable in the circumstances.

Held: Appeal allowed – reasons of the Magistrate inadequate – remitted to the Magistrates Court for rehearing save for those findings on the issues raised by paragraphs 5, 7 and 8 of the appellant’s (plaintiff) Statement of Claim.

Phu Hor Ong v Wu You Yang Pty Ltd (2008) 103 SASR 9, considered.

KINGSFORD MACHINERY & STIX FARMS PTY LTD v MARKS
[2012] SASC 65

Magistrates Appeal Civil:

  1. KOURAKIS J:                   The appellant, Kingsford Machinery and Stix Farms Pty Ltd (Stix Farms) is the owner of rural land near Alawoona on the Loxton to Pinaroo road (the farm).  Mr Tigani is the principal of Stix Farms.  Stix Farms leased part of the farm, and granted associated licences to use water and irrigation equipment, to the respondent Mr Doug Marks (Mr Marks), for three onion growing seasons in 2007-8, 2008-9, 2009-10.  A lease agreement was made for each of those growing seasons. 

  2. The rent for the last season was not paid in full.  Stix Farms brought an action in the Magistrates Court against Mr Marks to recover the rent.  Mr Marks did not dispute the non payment of the rent but he defended the action on the basis that he was not the lessee.  He contended that the lessee was a trust, a contention to which I will return shortly.  Mr Marks also counterclaimed against Stix Farms for breaching of the terms of each of the lease agreements by failing to provide the irrigation equipment in good working order. 

  3. Stix Farms, by its final amended claim, also sought damages for Mr Marks’ failure to return some of the irrigation equipment at the end of the third season and his failure to insure some sheds on the farm which were damaged by storm in that season.  Mr Marks disputed each of the additional claims. As to the first…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kingsford Machinery & Stix Farms Pty Ltd v Marks and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] SASC 65
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal, Kingsford Machinery & Stix Farms Pty Ltd v Marks, involved the interpretation and enforcement of lease agreements for agricultural land between the parties. The appellant, Kingsford Machinery & Stix Farms Pty Ltd, sought to enforce certain terms of the lease agreements against the respondent, Marks, who disputed the enforceability and the existence of certain obligations. The primary dispute centred on whether the lease agreements were confined to the written documents and whether any oral agreements could be considered. Further, the appellant claimed that the respondent suffered losses due to the appellant's failure to provide functioning irrigation equipment, while the respondent argued that any losses were either mitigated or non-existent.

The court was required to determine whether the lease agreements were strictly limited to the written documents or if oral agreements could be considered. The court also needed to decide whether the lease agreements gave rise to specific obligations, and if so, whether either party had failed to meet these obligations. Additionally, the court had to assess whether the respondent had suffered any losses due to the appellant's failure to provide functioning irrigation equipment and whether these losses were reasonable.

The Supreme Court found that the reasons provided by the Magistrate were inadequate for several reasons. The court held that the Magistrate’s reasons for dismissing the claim made by Stix Farms were too broad and did not sufficiently address the specific issues at hand. The court also noted that while the Magistrate's decision to dismiss the claim could be upheld, it would have been preferable to explicitly address the evidence related to the insurance term and the oral agreements. The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, finding that the reasons provided by the Magistrate were insufficient. Consequently, the matter, excluding the claims raised in paragraphs 5, 7, and 8 of the appellant’s Statement of Claim, was remitted to the Magistrates Court for rehearing. This decision ensures that the proper legal standards are applied in determining the enforceability and interpretation of the lease agreements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Magistrate’s short reasons for dismissing this part of the claim made by Stix Farms are widely enough expressed to cover both alternative constructions of the term. It would have been better to attempt a construction of the insurance term and to refer to the evidence, or lack of it, bearing on its application. Nonetheless, the plaintiff’s claim must, as I have explained, fail on either view. I affirm the Magistrate’s dismissal of that part of Stix Farms’ claim.Extraneous Evidence Mr Tigani gave evidence that Mr Marks signed the written lease agreement to which I have referred. None of the documents actually executed by him were put into evidence. No issue was taken at trial, nor on appeal, about the absence of the executed documents. It was accepted that Mr Marks had bound himself to the terms of the written documents to the extent that those terms were not varied or supplemented by oral agreement. It is to the evidence of those oral agreements which I now turn. It is convenient to set out at the same time the conduct of the parties in execution, or purported execution, of their contractual responsibilities. Mr Tigani testified that the lease in the first period was for 160 acres of land together with the house, water license and pivots. Mr Tigani testified that at the commencement of the first season he provided two pivots, two gensets and two pumps. He testified that Mr Marks wanted the pivot in “tip top shape.” Mr Tigani engaged a firm, Benparts Pty Ltd (Benparts), which serviced the pivots at a cost of $19,000. The principal of that firm is Mr Bennett. Mr Tigani testified that he saw both systems successfully commissioned by Benparts. He said that everything was working fine when Mr Bennett tested and fired up the pivot system in August 2007. Mr Bennett was called by Stix Farms. Mr Bennett testified that, at the request of Stix Farms, Benparts moved one of the pivots from one circular cultivation patch to another and made both pivots operational. Benparts also automated the connection between the water pump and the driver of the pivots such that if the pivot arm stopped operating so too did the water pump. A letter from Mr Bennett to Mr Tigani was received into evidence in which Mr Bennett confirmed that both generators were fully serviced and in good operational order at the commencement of the first season. In his evidence Mr Bennett referred to the two pivot irrigation systems as the Lindsay and Valley pivots. It was the Lindsay pivot which was moved from one patch to another. Mr Bennett testimonially confirmed the contents of his letter to the effect that after completing his work both of the pivot systems were in a fair and reasonable operational condition for their age. At the same time that Benparts serviced the irrigation systems for Stix Farms, the company was also engaged by Mr Marks to install computerised control panels which were supplied by him, on the Lindsay and Valley pivots. Computerised control panels allow the rate of rotation of the pivot arm to be controlled, varied or reversed, as required, so that water could be applied in quantities which optimised the growth of the crops. The existing control panels on the irrigation equipment supplied by Stix Farms were placed in a shed on the farm.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In my view this finding should be affirmed. Mr Tigani was not in a position to, and his evidence did not, contradict the testimony of the Marks brothers. In my view the Magistrate correctly decided the ninth issue and has adequately explained his reasons.Conclusion The matter other than the claims made in paragraphs 5, 7 and 8 of the plaintiff’s Statement of Claim is remitted to the Magistrates Court for rehearing.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established