King v Electoral Commissioner No. Scgrg-97-1670 Judgment No. S6557

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

KING v ELECTORAL COMMISSIONER

Court of Disputed Returns

Prior J

The Petitioner was a candidate at the South Australian Parliamentary Election held on 11 October 1997. He seeks an order declaring the election of the Liberal candidate for the District of Davenport void and an order requiring a new election to be held. This Court has power to make those orders pursuant to s107(1)(c) of the Electoral Act 1985. A number of other orders sought are orders that this Court cannot make. They are not orders identified within that section. In these proceedings the court has no power to make any orders apart from those authorised by that section.

The petition alleges that certain irregularities occurred during the electoral period for the District of Davenport.  Those alleged irregularities are said to have "caused the Australian Democrats candidate not to gain the seat for the Davenport District".  It is alleged that the irregularities complained of "caused considerably less first preference votes going to the Independents and boosted the vote for the Liberal Party and hence caused significant less preference votes (from the excluded candidates) being allocated to the Australian Democrats candidate".

The petitioner claims that "the most significant irregularity affecting the Davenport Democrat vote was the pre-election, concentrated (regularly repeated) media advertisement by the Liberal Party that (words to the effect) ‘a vote for an Independent was a vote for the Labor Party’". 

The petitioner was one of three Independent candidates seeking election to the House of Assembly in the electoral District of Davenport. He describes the conduct complained of as a "most inaccurate and misleading advertisement" "clearly contrary to s113 of the Electoral Act" as his second preferences and those of another Independent were allocated to the Democrat candidate and that "69 per cent of the only other Independent votes ended up as Democrat votes". On this basis the petitioner claims that votes for the Independent candidates "were overwhelmingly votes for the Democrat candidate".

The petition refers to a pre-election poll showing some 40 per cent of voters "were intending to vote for alternatives to the two major parties" and says that the fact that this did not occur "is considered to be due essentially to the above inaccurate and misleading advertising.  Liberal voters (disenchanted with the Liberal Party’s performance) were influenced to stay with the Liberals in order to prevent Labor getting back into power". The petitioner says that the advertisements "could readily have accounted for at least 900 voters . . . voting for or giving 2nd preference votes to the Liberal candidate".  If some 900 votes were not received by the Liberal candidate they "would have ended up as Democrat votes and caused the Democrat to win the seat of Davenport".

The successful candidate for the District of Davenport was the Liberal Party’s candidate, Mr Iain Evans.  He required the distribution of preferences in accordance with s96 of the Act to gain election.  An Independent candidate, Ms Seaman, received the lowest number of first preference votes.  Her…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read King v Electoral Commissioner No. Scgrg-97-1670 Judgment No.... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] SASC 6557
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The petitioner, Mr King, was a candidate at the South Australian Parliamentary Election held on 11 October 1997. He sought an order declaring the election of the Liberal candidate for the District of Davenport void and an order requiring a new election to be held. This Court has power to make those orders pursuant to s107(1)(c) of the Electoral Act 1985. The petitioner claimed that certain irregularities occurred during the electoral period for the District of Davenport. Those alleged irregularities are said to have caused the Australian Democrats candidate not to gain the seat for the Davenport District. The petitioner relied upon opinions given by Mr Hepworth and Mr McCarthy. Mr Hepworth, a lecturer in politics at the University of South Australia for some six years, expressed the opinion that the overall effect of the advertisements and other material distributed before the election, including those leaflets with respect to Mr Marshall, could have been to influence a number of electors who would, in previous elections, have given their first preference vote to the Liberal candidate to change their intention of voting for a Democrat or Independent candidate at the election, sufficient to have varied the result of the election in the electorate of Davenport. Mr McCarthy is a lecturer in politics at the University of Adelaide. He expressed an opinion in an affidavit that the advertisement in The Advertiser on 11 October, which spoke of a vote for a Labor candidate, Independent candidate or Democrat candidate, could see Mr Rann as premier, clearly states that a vote for an Independent is a vote for Labor. The petitioner relied upon a number of complaints of irregularities during the election. The Electoral Commissioner received a complaint about an advertisement on 9 October. The Commissioner took action in accordance with an established protocol. A similar advertisement appeared in The Advertiser newspaper on 10 October. Significantly, ‘GIVES YOU" was not in that advertisement. Instead of the exhortation to "Put Labor Last", "Premier Rann?" appeared below the photographs of Mr Rann and Mr Bannon. On the next page of that newspaper, another advertisement urged voters to "Put Labor Last". Above those words was a photograph of Mr Rann. The advertisement was headed with the title "Premier Rann?". A reference to preferences and the election being close appeared between the first line of the advertisement and the last three. The advertisements of 10 October, were repeated in The Advertiser the next day. They were again on opposite pages but the order of appearance was reversed. Advertisements were also placed in two other newspapers circulating in the Davenport district on or about 9 October. Those advertisements were in the same form as that in The Advertiser of 9 October. Mr Marshall also complains of two leaflets distributed in the District of Davenport two days before the election. One was said to have been printed and authorised by A Seaman of 16 Hovea Street Blackwood. In this document, the Independent, Ms Seaman, appeared to urge voters to give their first preferences to her and to put Mr Marshall last. The pamphlet asserted that it seemed wrong to the author for Mr Marshall "to claim to be a Liberal while clearly supporting the Democrats with his preferences to the detriment of the Liberals". The second pamphlet was said to be authorised by B Nicol of 67 Heather Road Stirling. Barbara Eva Evans says she authorised the leaflet. Her maiden name was Nicol. Mrs Evans admits that she served on Mr Iain Evans’ campaign committee and says that some nine thousand copies of this leaflet were distributed on or about 8 or 9 October through Australia Post. Mrs Evans does not seek to explain why she did not disclose her married name on the leaflet she admits responsibility for, nor does she claim that this was something she has done on other occasions. The Electoral Commissioner has made some inquiries with respect to the complaint about this material. Perhaps some legislative action is needed to control conduct of this kind in the future. The Court found that the "Put Labor Last" campaign was not one in which one could properly infer that a vote for an Independent was a vote for the Labor Party. That was the petitioner’s fundamental complaint. However, that complaint was understandable with respect to the advertisements published in Messenger newspapers on or about the same day as that in The Advertiser of 9 October, the effect of which was to convey the impression that a vote for anyone other than a Liberal Party candidate was a vote for the Labor Party. The Court did not think that the advertisements which appeared on 10 and 11 October conveyed that impression. On the material before the court, it was established that those advertisements in breach of s113 were neither likely to, nor did they affect the result of the election in the District of Davenport in the sense of causing Mr Evans and not someone else to be elected. The petitioner had established that the advertisement in The Advertiser on 9 October and those in Messenger newspapers contained statements purporting to be statements of fact that were inaccurate and misleading to a material extent. Whilst finding that the advertisements just described did contain statements purporting to be statements of fact that were inaccurate and misleading to a material extent in breach of s113, the Court made no such finding with respect to any other advertisement complained of. The Court dismissed the petition.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established