Kinecho Pty Ltd & Ors v. Stevenson Transport Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 3 min read

[2004] QSC 057

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CIVIL JURISDICTION

FRYBERG J

No S6319 of 1998

KINECHO PTY LIMITED First Plaintiff

and

WILLIAM HAY and
MARGARITA HAY

and

STEVENSON TRANSPORT PTY LTD
(ACN 006 271 352)

and

LES CARLILE

Second Plaintiffs

First Defendant

Second Defendant

BRISBANE

..DATE 25/03/2004

ORDER

HIS HONOUR:  This is an application by the first plaintiff for leave to take a step in the proceedings and for the second plaintiff to be removed as a party to the proceedings.  It became apparent as soon as argument began that the first application was made only in the event that leave was required.  In my judgment, leave is not required.  The last step in the proceeding was further production of documents by the defendants which occurred this year.  Therefore, the preconditions for rule 389 to be engaged have not been made out. 

For the respondents, Mr Kent submitted that the production of documents being purely inter partes was not a step in the proceedings within the meaning of the rule.  He submitted by a parallel submission that such production does not advance the action.  Production of relevant documents which are required to be produced is something which is required by the rules and forms a precursor to other steps in the action; later steps cannot take place until disclosure has occurred. 

The giving of disclosure is therefore, in my view, something which does advance the proceedings.  It moves the action closer to the point of its conclusion.  The fact that it occurs between the parties does not seem to me to be a reason why this should not be the position.  The more steps that can be taken between the parties without the additional cost of involving the Court, the cheaper will be the litigation and it is, therefore, something to be encouraged.  It is certainly encouraged by the rules. 
I have noted a reference in the annotations to the rules to the decision in Paradise Grove Proprietary Limited v. Stubberfield [2000] QSC 214, but neither party provided me with a copy of that decision, nor did either in those circumstances have the gall to rely upon it and I do not take it into account beyond saying that here a good deal more than merely filing a list has occurred. The parties have had production of documents. In my view, it is unnecessary to make an order in accordance with paragraph 1 of the application.

The plaintiffs seek the removal of the second plaintiffs as parties.  That seems to me to be a matter of the plaintiffs' call in circumstances where the defendants neither consent to nor oppose that course.  And therefore, I am prepared to order it pursuant to rule 69:  order that the second plaintiffs, William Hay and Margarita Hay, be removed as parties to the proceeding. 

The draft order which has been placed before me provides for the remaining plaintiff to have leave to deliver an amended statement of claim.  It has not been demonstrated…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kinecho Pty Ltd & Ors v. Stevenson Transport Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] QSC 57
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Kinecho Pty Ltd and others initiated proceedings against Stevenson Transport Pty Ltd and Les Carlile in the Supreme Court of Queensland. The plaintiffs sought leave to take a procedural step and the removal of one of the plaintiffs, William Hay and Margarita Hay, from the proceedings. The matter was heard by Fryberg J, who delivered the judgment.

The court was required to decide whether the plaintiffs needed leave to take a step in the proceedings, specifically the production of documents, and whether the second plaintiffs should be removed from the case. The plaintiffs argued that the production of documents was a necessary step in the proceedings and that the second plaintiffs should be removed as they neither consented to nor opposed the removal.

Fryberg J found that leave was not required as the preconditions for rule 389 to be engaged had not been met. The judge further clarified that the production of documents between parties is an encouraged step in the litigation process, as it moves the action closer to its conclusion and reduces litigation costs. As for the removal of the second plaintiffs, the judge ruled that it was a matter for the plaintiffs' discretion, and since the defendants neither consented to nor opposed the removal, the court was prepared to order the removal.

The Supreme Court of Queensland ordered that William Hay and Margarita Hay be removed from the proceedings and that the costs of the application be costs in the cause. The court also allowed the remaining plaintiff to deliver an amended statement of claim.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case involves a legal dispute among several parties. Kinecho Pty Ltd, William Hay, Margarita Hay, and Stevenson Transport Pty Ltd are the main parties involved. The dispute arose from a matter initially filed in 1998 under case number S6319. The first plaintiff, Kinecho Pty Ltd, filed an application for leave to take a step in the proceedings and to remove the second plaintiffs, William Hay and Margarita Hay, from the case. The application was based on the recent production of documents by the defendants. The second plaintiffs neither opposed nor consented to being removed from the case.

The matter originated as a civil case filed in 1998 in the Supreme Court of Queensland. The case involved an application for leave to take a step in the proceedings and to remove certain parties. The application was heard and decided by Fryberg J. Prior to this application, the defendants had recently produced documents, which became a point of contention in the application. The case did not involve any prior appeals, judicial reviews, or interlocutory applications before this hearing.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is leave required for the first plaintiff to take the next step in the proceedings?
2. Should the second plaintiffs, William Hay and Margarita Hay, be removed as parties to the proceedings?

Held
1. The court concluded that leave is not required for the first plaintiff to take the next step in the proceedings, as the preconditions for rule 389 have not been met.
2. The court ordered that the second plaintiffs, William Hay and Margarita Hay, be removed as parties to the proceeding.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the first plaintiff's application for leave to take a step in the proceedings and the removal of the second plaintiffs from the proceeding. The court ruled that leave was not required, as the last step in the proceeding, the further production of documents by the defendants, occurred in the current year. The court emphasised that the production of relevant documents, as required by the rules, forms a precursor to other steps in the action and advances the proceedings towards its conclusion. This is encouraged by the rules, and it is beneficial for the litigation to be cheaper by taking more steps between the parties without involving the court. The court did not rely on the decision in Paradise Grove Proprietary Limited v. Stubberfield [2000] QSC 214 as neither party provided a copy of the decision and did not rely upon it. The court then ordered that the second plaintiffs, William Hay and Margarita Hay, be removed as parties to the proceeding, as it seemed to be a matter of the plaintiffs' call, with the defendants neither consenting to nor opposing the course. The court made an order for the remaining plaintiff to have leave to deliver an amended statement of claim, as it had not been demonstrated that leave was necessary. The court also ordered that the costs of the application be costs in the cause by consent. The binding legal principle established or applied by the decision is that the production of relevant documents is necessary for advancing the proceedings and taking more steps between the parties without involving the court is encouraged.