Kim Fisher v Sandara Rotheraine

Link copied
Case Copied 3 min read
CITATION: Kim Fisher v Sandara Rotheraine [2009] NSWDC 269
 
JUDGMENT DATE: 

31 August 2009
JURISDICTION: District Court of New South Wales
JUDGMENT OF: Cogswell SC DCJ
DECISION: The evidence is admissible
CATCHWORDS: CIVIL LAW - evidence - admissibility of medical report - whether assumptions in report need to be established to civil standard - are doctor's examinations and observations sufficient
LEGISLATION CITED: Evidence Act 1995 s 76
CASES CITED: Rhoden v Wingate [2002] NSWCA 165
PARTIES: Kim Fisher
Sandara Rotheraine
FILE NUMBER(S): 2662/05
COUNSEL: Ms Welsh
Mr B Kelleher
SOLICITORS: Brydens Compensation Lawyers
Hunt & Hunt

JUDGMENT
1. Ms Welsh, who appears for the plaintiff, has tendered a medical report as part of her case. It is a report of Dr Max Ellis, dated 8 April 2009. It contains, on the last page, this assertion: “In the accident, her right knee suffered ligamentous and cartilaginous injury.” Based upon that diagnosis, the author, Dr Ellis, expressed the opinion that the plaintiff required an MRI examination and arthroscopy, and provided an estimate of the cost of such investigations, which was $6,000.

2. Mr Kelleher, who appears for the defendant, objects to the passage which I quoted. His objection is that that passage breaches the opinion rule which is contained in s 76 of the Evidence Act 1995.

3. Ms Welsh relies upon the exception to the opinion rule provided by s 79, which is that a person with specialised knowledge based upon the person’s training, study or experience may express an opinion about a topic.

4. Mr Kelleher’s objection is that although Dr Ellis has specialised knowledge based upon training, study or experience, the doctor has not expressed in the report any basis upon which the diagnosis of right knee ligamentous and cartilaginous injury could be based. Mr Kelleher points to passages in the report, and in earlier reports, which record Dr Ellis examining Ms Fisher’s right knee and noting, for example, swelling and restricted movements. In particular, the doctor noted in examinations that no internal derangement could be demonstrated.

5. Ms Welsh argues that a factual basis for the opinion expressed does not have to be in terms of, for example, the results of radiological examinations. Such an opinion may be informed by an examination of a patient and observations.

6. Mr Kelleher referred me to the judgment of the Court of Appeal in Rhoden v Wingate [2002] NSWCA 165, in particular the judgment of Heydon JA, as his Honour then was. His Honour said at [86]:

      “ When assessing the admissibility of expert opinions, it is not the case that an opinion is only admissible if at the close of the case of the party relying on it the evidence establishes each of the assumptions on which it is based on the balance of probabilities. The primary evidence relating to those assumptions might be controversial. Which parts of the primary evidence are to be accepted, and what the correct conclusions from the primary evidence are, are matters…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kim Fisher v Sandara Rotheraine and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NSWDC 269
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court was a dispute between Kim Fisher and Sandara Rotheraine, where the primary issue was the admissibility of a medical report in evidence. The court had to determine whether the assumptions made in the report needed to be established to a civil standard, and whether the doctor's examinations and observations were sufficient to support the conclusions drawn in the report. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland.

The legal issues the court needed to address were whether the assumptions made by the doctor in the medical report were required to be established to a civil standard, and if the doctor's examinations and observations were sufficient to support the conclusions in the report. The court had to consider the applicable legal principles regarding the admissibility of expert evidence and whether the doctor's report met the necessary requirements.

The court found that the assumptions made by the doctor in the report did not need to be established to a civil standard, as the doctor's examinations and observations were sufficient to support the conclusions drawn in the report. The court held that the doctor's professional expertise and the thoroughness of the examination and observations provided a reliable basis for the conclusions. The court also noted that the report was prepared for the purpose of the proceedings and was relevant to the issues in the case. As a result, the evidence was deemed admissible.

The court ordered that the evidence in question be admitted. The court found that the assumptions made by the doctor in the report did not need to be established to a civil standard, and that the doctor's examinations and observations were sufficient to support the conclusions drawn in the report. The court considered the report to be relevant and reliable, and thus admissible in the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

The evidence is admissible

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established