Kilmallock (ACT) Pty Ltd v World Blinds Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Kilmallock (ACT) Pty Ltd v World Blinds Australia Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1472  

File number(s): NSD 821 of 2022
Judgment of: RARES J
Date of judgment: 8 November 2022
Catchwords:  PATENTS – interlocutory injunction application – issues of validity and lack of novelty – balance of convenience – where accused product alleged to infringe patent – where patent to expire shortly – where lack of novelty claim alleged to be fraudulent – whether delay by patentee in seeking to prevent earlier alleged infringements by same accused product – whether balance of convenience favoured grant of interlocutory injunction - Held: interlocutory application dismissed.
Legislation:

Evidence Act1995 (Cth)

Patents Act 1990 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O’Neill (2006) 227 CLR 57

Beecham Group Ltd v Bristol Laboratories Pty Ltd (1968) 118 CLR 618

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336

Samsung Electronics Co Ltd v Apple Inc (2011) 217 FCR 238

Sanofi-Aventis Deutschland GmbH v Alphapharm Pty Ltd (2019) 139 IPR 409

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Patents and associated Statutes
Number of paragraphs: 51
Date of hearing: 8 November 2022
Counsel for the applicant: Mr E J C Heerey KC with Ms E Whitby
Solicitor for the applicant: Meyer West IP Pty Ltd
Counsel for the respondents: Mr A R Lang SC with Ms J McKenzie
Solicitor for the respondents:  Strathfield Law

ORDERS

NSD 821 of 2022
BETWEEN:

KILMALLOCK (ACT) PTY. LTD. (ACN 052 195 614)

Applicant

AND:

WORLD BLINDS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 650 294 483)

First Respondent

VIEWLUX PTY LTD (ACN 626 915 179) T/AS WORLD BLINDS NEWCASTLE

Second Respondent

CIANI QLD PTY LTD (ACN 642 876 506) T/AS WORLD BLINDS QUEENSLAND (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

RARES J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 NOVEMBER 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application for interlocutory relief be dismissed.

2.The applicant pay the respondents’ costs of the interlocutory application.

3.The proceeding be listed for case management on 18 November 2022.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
(Revised from the transcript)

RARES J:

  1. This is an application for an interlocutory injunction by one competitor against another in the sale of a type of blind, window shade or curtain.  The applicant, Kilmallock (ACT) Pty Ltd (which trades under the name of Pacific Wholesale Distributors), sells its blinds under the name “Veri shades”.  Kilmallock is an established business.  Kilmallock’s blinds use a patented connector product that it acquires under arrangements it has with its Korean suppliers.  Kilmallock is the registered owner of seven innovation patents.  The relevant patent for the purposes of the application for interlocutory relief is Australian innovation patent number 2015101931 (the 931 patent). 

  2. The 931 patent was filed on 31 December 2015 and is titled “Connector for blind-type curtain and blind-type curtain comprising same”.  It has priority dates of 15 January 2015 and 30 December…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kilmallock (ACT) Pty Ltd v World Blinds Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 1472
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Kilmallock (ACT) Pty Ltd v World Blinds Australia Pty Ltd, the Federal Court was presented with an interlocutory injunction application by Kilmallock, a patentee, against World Blinds Australia Pty Ltd, an alleged infringer of its patent. The dispute centred on the validity of the patent in question, the 931 patent, and the balance of convenience in granting the injunction. The respondents contested the patent's validity, claiming it lacked novelty, and argued that the balance of convenience favoured maintaining the status quo, given the existence of similar products in the market and Kilmallock's delay in enforcing its rights.

The legal issues before the court involved determining whether the patent was valid, whether there was a sufficient prima facie case for the grant of an interlocutory injunction, and where the balance of convenience lay. The court considered the untested evidence presented by both parties in affidavits and evaluated the principles for granting interlocutory injunctions in patent cases, particularly focusing on the likelihood of success at trial and the balance of inconvenience.

The court dismissed the interlocutory injunction application, finding that the respondents had raised valid concerns about the patent's novelty and that the balance of convenience did not favour granting the injunction. The court noted that damages would likely be an effective remedy and that the extensive forensic battle would delay the final hearing until after the patent's expiry. The court also highlighted that the evidence presented was untested and that any conclusive findings would only be possible after the trial.

The final orders of the court were to dismiss the application for interlocutory relief, order Kilmallock to pay the respondents' costs of the interlocutory application, and list the proceeding for case management.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for interlocutory relief be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondents’ costs of the interlocutory application.

3. The proceeding be listed for case management on 18 November 2022.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondents assert that, despite their infringement of the two claims, first, the claims lack novelty within the meaning of s 7(4) and (5)(a) of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth), secondly, there is no sufficient prima facie case to support the grant of an interlocutory injunction, and thirdly, the balance of convenience favours maintaining the status quo, in particular, by reason of the existence in the market of similar or identical infringing products to the accused product for a considerable period of years before 27 September 2022, when Kilmallock commenced this proceeding, and Kilmallock’s delay in enforcing its rights before that. BACKGROUND The parties put on a considerable volume of evidence for the present hearing, but the facts presently necessary for the purpose of considering interlocutory relief are centred on the nature of the respondents’ challenges to the validity of the 931 patent and where the balance of convenience lies. Immediately prior to establishing the respondent companies, Mr Ryu was involved with his brother-in-law, Kwang Min Park, in companies that traded, among others, under the corporate name Ciani Pty Ltd and business names related to it. Earlier, in May 2014, Mr Ryu was trading in his own account. He asserted that he began importing and selling blind products called Curvers from World Blinds Co Ltd that operated in South Korea (World Blinds Korea). The chief executive officer of World Blinds Korea, Jun-Seok Cho, has made two affidavits. Mr Cho gave evidence that he had been chief executive officer of World Blinds Korea since 2006. He said that, from May 2014, his company began exporting Curvers products to Mr Ryu in Australia. He attached a ledger showing such sales including products in 2014 that the respondents say match, or should be inferred to include, Curvers blinds that came to be installed in the Sydney home of Vicki Syrras in December 2014. THE SAGA OF MS SYRRAS’ BLINDS Ms Syrras gave evidence that, in about November 2014, her son recommended replacing some old blinds in her home and introduced her to his neighbour, Mr Ryu, as a person who operated the business of selling and installing such blinds and curtains. She recalled that she thought it was a good idea that the family home be improved before the forthcoming 2014 Christmas. She said that in about mid-December 2014, after earlier taking measurements, Mr Ryu came back to her house and installed the new vertical blinds there. After that simple domestic event, in October 2022 Ms Syrras became embroiled in a series of visits by persons interested in the state of her blinds for the purposes of this proceeding and her blinds have wound up being tendered as an exhibit. The connector pieces at the top of Ms Syrras’ blinds, as they currently exist, comprise separate male and female pieces. However, the male and female pieces were manufactured in a mould in which they had been joined by a thin line of plastic between and at the top of each so as to make it possible to fold them over to join the two together. The way in which Ms Syrras’ blinds are configured has the male piece affixed by glue at one end of a length of curtain and, at the other end of the length of curtain, the female piece is also affixed by glue to the fabric which is then able to be moved across so that the male and female pieces can be joined together leaving a length of curtain hanging down but fixed between the two.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The resolution of the issue of whether or not, as a matter of fact, the male and female connectors were or were not joined by a hinge at the time of the priority dates would be fatal to one side’s case or the other, in the sense that if there were in the market unhinged or unjoined male and female connector parts, such as the respondents say Mr Ryu supplied to Ms Syrras before Christmas 2014, the 931 patent lacks novelty. Alternatively, if the male and female parts on Mrs Syrras’ blinds were hinged when supplied to her, the defence of lack of novelty necessarily fails, and the admitted infringement will then be unanswered.THE EVIDENCE OF KILMALLOCK’S DELAY On 10 December 2019, Mr Meyer’s firm, Meyer West IP, wrote to Ciani Sydney Pty Ltd claiming infringement of several of Kilmallock’s patents, seeking undertakings that the conduct would cease and advising that, failing receipt of those undertakings by 19 December 2019, Kilmallock would be seeking interlocutory injunctive relief. The letter did not allege infringement of the 931 patent, but related to three other patents in issue in this proceeding, and did not make any claims against Mr Ryu or any of the current personal respondents. It is common ground that this letter came to Mr Ryu’s contemporaneous attention in his capacity as a then-principal of the Ciani businesses. After that letter went unanswered, on 21 January 2020, Mr Meyer caused it to be emailed to other entities associated with Ciani Sydney, but again received no response. On 8 April 2020, he sent a further email attaching the 10 December 2019 letter to Ciani Newcastle and yet again received no response. On 28 May 2020, Meyer West IP sent a letter addressed to nine persons, including Mr Ryu, Mr Park and various Ciani companies, alleging infringement of three other patents the subject of this proceeding (but not the 931 patent) and attached a draft statement of claim. Mr Ryu took the attitude that it was not necessary to respond to any of the letters of demand and no response arrived. As I have noted, the Commissioner then undertook a re-examination of the patent, ultimately leaving it in place with some not presently relevant amendments. In May 2021, Mr Ryu had a falling out with his brother-in-law Min Park, who was also a co-director and shareholder in Ciani Pty Limited. Mr Ryu then incorporated World Blinds Australia. In February 2022, Mr Ryu resigned as a director of Ciani. In late March or early April 2022, Mr Taylor contacted Mr Meyer, informing him that Ciani had made contact and suggested a meeting at their offices in Lidcombe. Mr Taylor asked Mr Meyer to come to the meeting with him. On 5 April 2022, Mr Taylor and Mr Meyer met at the Lidcombe office of Ciani with Min Park, Andrew “Andy” Park, the managing director of another company, Dae Sang Techroll Australia Pty Ltd, and two other persons connected with a business trading as Blind Fairy. During the meeting, Mr Meyer and Mr Taylor appear to have become aware of the existence of Mr Ryu’s new company World Blinds Australia, and that it was part of a group in which Mr Kwak was also involved dealing in the accused product, about which they were negotiating with Ciani. Mr Meyer and Mr Taylor said that, during the meeting, they learnt that Mr Ryu and his new group were sourcing products from World Blinds Korea through a number of companies and that Mr Ryu was asserted to be “the mastermind” and “running the show at Ciani” before his departure. Min Park asserted that his own role involved the production of blind products at Ciani and asserted that he was not involved in its active management but that, as a result of the falling out, Mr Ryu had “played him” and was now competing with his business. Andrew Park told Mr Meyer and Mr Taylor at the meeting that he had been told that Mr Ryu was telling concerned customers that he, Mr Ryu, had used and installed Curvers products well before the patents were filed and that the earlier use would provide a defence against any infringement action being taken by Kilmallock.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In all of the circumstances, I am of opinion that it is not appropriate to grant Kilmallock an interlocutory injunction. Damages are likely to be an effective remedy, even though it is likely, given the present scale of the forensic battle, that a final hearing and judgment cannot be expected before the expiry of the 931 patent in light of the volume of work necessary to prove or defend the current allegations of fraud and lack of novelty. CONCLUSION For these reasons, I am of opinion the application for an interlocutory injunction should be dismissed with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Kilmallock submitted that there was no evidence that the respondents would be significantly inconvenienced or damaged if they had to seek an alternative supplier of products that did not infringe and that the balance of convenience favoured the preservation of its rights as patentee, given that it may never be compensated properly or at all for the harm done if an interlocutory injunction were not granted, and ultimately it were found entitled to relief. CONSIDERATION The findings that I have expressed above are simply findings on the basis of the untested evidence of each side, as put forward in affidavits to which I was taken without the benefit of any witness being subjected to cross-examination, far less, given the allegations of fraud, the parties being able to test witnesses in the witness box or me having any opportunity to observe or them. Therefore, nothing in these reasons reflects any ultimate or concluded finding or view that I have reached on the issues between the parties. Such concluded findings will only be possible once all the material on which each side relies has been admitted into evidence at the trial. There was no relevant objection taken for the purposes of the hearing today as to the form of evidence, its relevance or admissibility on a final hearing. In Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O’Neill (2006) 227 CLR 57 at 68 [19], Gleeson CJ and Crennan J agreed with the explanation of the organising principles for the grant of an interlocutory injunction that Gummow and Hayne JJ gave (at 81-84 [65]-[72]). In particular, their Honours applied and affirmed the principles in Beecham Group Ltd v Bristol Laboratories Pty Ltd (1968) 118 CLR 618 which, importantly, involved a claim for an interlocutory injunction in a patent case (unlike O’Neill 227 CLR 57 which was a claim for an interlocutory injunction in a defamation proceeding). Gummow and Hayne JJ said (227 CLR at 81-82 [65]): The relevant principles in Australia are those explained in Beecham Group Ltd v Bristol Laboratories Pty Ltd ((1968) 118 CLR 618). This Court (Kitto, Taylor, Menzies and Owen JJ) said that on such applications the court addresses itself to two main inquiries and continued ((1968) 118 CLR 618 at 622-623):“The first is whether the plaintiff has made out a prima facie case, in the sense that if the evidence remains as it is there is a probability that at the trial of the action the plaintiff will be held entitled to relief … The second inquiry is … whether the inconvenience or injury which the plaintiff would be likely to suffer if an injunction were refused outweighs or is outweighed by the injury which the defendant would suffer if an injunction were granted.”By using the phrase “prima facie case”, their Honours did not mean that the plaintiff must show that it is more probable than not that at trial the plaintiff will succeed; it is sufficient that the plaintiff show a sufficient likelihood of success to justify in the circumstances the preservation of the status quo pending the trial. That this was the sense in which the Court was referring to the notion of a prima facie case is apparent from an observation to that effect made by Kitto J in the course of argument ((1968) 118 CLR 618 at 620). With reference to the first inquiry, the Court continued, in a statement of central importance for this appeal ((1968) 118 CLR 618 at 622):“How strong the probability needs to be depends, no doubt, upon the nature of the rights [the plaintiff] asserts and the practical consequences likely to flow from the order he seeks.”