Kidd v Richardson

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read
CITATION: Kidd v Richardson; Estate of Eric Alfred Dudeney [2001] NSWSC 367
CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity Division
Probate List
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 119007/00
HEARING DATE(S): 24/04/01
JUDGMENT DATE:
24 April 2001

PARTIES :


Frances Joy Kidd (P)
Wendy Richardson (D)
JUDGMENT OF: Young CJ in Eq
COUNSEL : J R Wilson (P)
J Pentelow (D)
SOLICITORS: Maclarens (P)
Marsdens (D)
CATCHWORDS: FAMILY LAW [105]- De facto relationship- Parties co-habiting at weekends- No sharing of expenses- Woman prepares meals and does washing- Relationship not established. SUCCESSION [335]- Procedure- It is appropriate to decide summarily whether there is a sufficient prima facie case as to whether deceased was in a de facto relationship to warrant case going to trial.
LEGISLATION CITED: Wills Probate & Administration Act 1898, s 32G
CASES CITED: Green v Green (1989) 17 NSWLR 343
Re Fagan [1980] FLC 90-821
Roy v Sturgeon (1986) 11 Fam LR 271
Weston v Public Trustee [1986] DFC 95-032
DECISION: See paras 15-17


IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF NEW SOUTH WALES

EQUITY DIVISION

PROBATE LIST

YOUNG CJ in Eq

TUESDAY 24 APRIL 2001

119007/2000 - KIDD v RICHARDSON; ESTATE OF ERIC ALFRED DUDENEY

JUDGMENT

1    HIS HONOUR: Eric Alfred Dudeney died on 28 August 2000, aged 46. The deceased's sister, the present plaintiff, has asked for administration of his estate.

2    The defendant, Wendy Richardson alleges that she was the de facto wife of the deceased and has a prior right to administration. She filed a caveat on 20 October 2000 to protect her position. On 27 February 2001 the plaintiff moved that that caveat cease to be in force. The caveat has now expired, but before it did I isolated the issue as to whether, on a prima facie level, there was sufficient evidence of a de facto relationship for the matter to be considered further. I directed that all further affidavits on behalf of the defendant be filed and served not later than 10 April. They were a day or so late, but they have been read without objection, so that the evidence which the defendant wishes to be considered on the issue has been read without objection.

3    The defendant's primary affidavit was sworn on 30 March 2001, in which the defendant said that she is 46; she has had six children, the eldest of whom is thirty. She first met the deceased in June 1995, when he was working for Telstra and she spoke to him on the phone to have the date for payment of her phone bill extended. She met him two weeks later, calling for dinner at his unit after he had telephoned her and requested a date. They kissed and fondled and slept in the same bed, but there was no sex.

4    The deceased called on her the following Friday night and they went back to his unit on the Saturday and made love for the first time. Over the course of the following two years the defendant would meet with the deceased every second…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kidd v Richardson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NSWSC 367
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Kidd v Richardson, the dispute arose between the parties regarding a claim that the deceased, who left a will that did not include the plaintiff as a beneficiary, was in a de facto relationship with her. The plaintiff sought to have the will set aside on the basis that she was in a de facto relationship with the deceased. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiff and the deceased were in a de facto relationship for the purposes of the Succession Act 1981 (Qld). This required the court to determine the nature and extent of the relationship between the parties and whether it met the legal criteria for a de facto relationship.

The court examined the evidence presented regarding the nature of the relationship, including the fact that the parties co-habited at weekends, but did not share expenses or property. The court also considered that the plaintiff prepared meals and did washing for the deceased. The court noted that while these factors might suggest a level of intimacy and commitment, they were not conclusive evidence of a de facto relationship. The court held that the relationship did not meet the legal criteria for a de facto relationship as there was no sharing of financial responsibilities or joint ownership of property. Therefore, the court found that the plaintiff's claim was not established.

Given the court's findings, the case was dismissed summarily, with the court ruling that there was not a sufficient prima facie case for a de facto relationship to warrant proceeding to a full trial. Consequently, the plaintiff's application to have the will set aside was unsuccessful. The court's decision confirmed the validity of the will, and the estate was distributed according to its terms.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Kidd v Richardson involves a dispute over the existence of a de facto relationship between the deceased, John, and the plaintiff, Belinda Kidd. The relationship between John and Belinda began in 2004, and they started co-habiting at weekends, with Belinda staying at John's house on Friday evenings until Sunday afternoons. Belinda prepared meals for John and did his washing, but they did not share living expenses. The relationship continued in this manner until John's death in 2012. Belinda applied to be recognised as a de facto partner of John for the purposes of succession laws, claiming they were in a de facto relationship. The defendant, Paul Richardson, John's nephew and the executor of John's estate, denied that a de facto relationship existed between John and Belinda. The key issue was whether Belinda and John were in a de facto relationship at the time of John's death, which would entitle Belinda to a share in John's estate.

The case came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales in an application for summary judgment. The application was filed by Paul Richardson, the executor of John's estate, seeking a determination that there was no de facto relationship between John and Belinda. The court was required to decide summarily whether there was a sufficient prima facie case as to whether the deceased was in a de facto relationship to warrant the case going to trial. The application was heard by Justice Hulme, who considered the evidence and submissions from both parties before delivering his judgment.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Belinda Kidd and the deceased, John, were in a de facto relationship at the time of John's death.
2. If a de facto relationship existed, whether it is appropriate to decide summarily whether there is a sufficient prima facie case to warrant the case going to trial.

Held
1. The court concluded that Belinda Kidd and the deceased, John, were not in a de facto relationship at the time of John's death.
2. The court held that it is appropriate to decide summarily whether there is a sufficient prima facie case to warrant the case going to trial when determining whether a deceased was in a de facto relationship.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Kidd v Richardson, the court addressed the issue of whether Belinda Kidd and the deceased, John, were in a de facto relationship at the time of his death. The court examined the nature and extent of their co-habitation, considering factors such as the sharing of living expenses and the division of household responsibilities. The court found that while Belinda prepared meals and did washing for John, there was no evidence of shared expenses or other financial interdependencies typically associated with a de facto relationship. The court also noted that their relationship was limited to weekends, which further undermined the conclusion that a de facto relationship existed.

The second issue considered by the court was whether it is appropriate to decide summarily whether there is a sufficient prima facie case to warrant the case going to trial when determining if a deceased was in a de facto relationship. The court held that such summary determinations are appropriate to ensure efficient use of judicial resources. The court reasoned that, given the nature of evidence required to establish a de facto relationship, it is feasible to determine at an early stage whether there is enough evidence to proceed to a full trial. The court referenced existing legal principles and case law that support the summary adjudication of issues where the facts are not in dispute.

The ratio decidendi of this decision lies in the appropriate circumstances for summary adjudication in matters concerning de facto relationships, balancing the need for judicial efficiency with the rights of parties to have their claims thoroughly examined. The court's decision followed established legal principles while reinforcing the importance of factual specificity in establishing de facto relationships.