KHHG and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

KHHG and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) [2018] AATA 3811 (12 October 2018)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2018/4243 

Re:KHHG

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Home Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member D. J. Morris

Date:12 October 2018

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

[sgd]........................................................................

Senior Member D. J. Morris

Catchwords

MIGRATION – refusal of bridging visa – consideration of character test – domestic violence – guilty plea entered to offence but sentence pending – risk of applicant engaging in criminal conduct in Australia – admissions in evidence – misleading information provided to departmental officials – assessment of risk – applicant fails character test – consideration of ministerial direction – primary considerations – other considerations – any other relevant matter – decision affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), ss 35, 62(4)
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 116, 499, 500(6L), 501, 501K,

Migration Amendment (Character and General Cancellation) Act 2014 (Cth), Sch 1, Item 11

Family Violence Protection Act 2008 (Vic), ss 53, 53AA

Cases

Brown v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2009) 112 ALD 67
Ahori and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, Re [2017] AATA 601
Jill Lachmaiya and Department of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs, Re [1994] AATA 27
Lam and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, Re [1999] AATA 56
Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs v Batey (1993) 40 FCR 493
Schuster-McFadyen v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2011) 124 ALD 68

Secondary Materials

Migration Act 1958 – Direction No. 65 – Direction under section 499 – Visa refusal and cancellation under s 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under s 501CA (dated 22 December 2014)
Explanatory Memorandum – House of Representatives, Migration Amendment (Character and General Cancellation) Act 2014 (Cth)
Oxford University Press, The Oxford English Dictionary (online ed., at 10 October 2018)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member D. J. Morris

12 October 2018

BACKGROUND

  1. On 20 July 2018 a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs (the Minister) refused an application by the Applicant for a Bridging E (Class WE) visa under section 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act). The delegate was not satisfied that the Applicant passed the character test under section 501(6)(d)(i) of the Act in that there was a risk that the Applicant would engage in criminal conduct if allowed to remain in Australia.

    PRELIMINARY MATTER

  2. In the past the Applicant has applied for a protection visa. That application is not the subject of this review. Section 501K of the Act provides that any information which may identify an applicant or any relative or other dependant of the person must not be published if the review relates to the person in the person’s capacity as, relevantly, a person who applied for a protection visa. Section 501K(3) defines “application for a protection-related bridging visa” to mean an application for a bridging visa, where the applicant for the bridging visa is, or has been, an application…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read KHHG and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 3811
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by KHHG against the Minister for Home Affairs' refusal to grant him a bridging visa. The refusal was based on KHHG failing to satisfy the character test due to an incident of domestic violence involving his wife, for which he had pleaded guilty to recklessly causing injury, although sentencing was pending. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was required to consider the risk of KHHG engaging in further criminal conduct in Australia.

The primary legal issues before the AAT were whether KHHG met the character requirements for the visa, specifically assessing the risk of him re-offending, and how this assessment should be informed by Ministerial Direction 99, which mandates consideration of primary factors including the best interests of minor children in Australia. The Tribunal also had to determine the weight to be given to KHHG's admissions and his inconsistent statements regarding the domestic violence incident.

The Tribunal's reasoning involved a careful weighing of various factors. It acknowledged submissions that the circumstances leading to the assault, such as financial stress and parental responsibility, might re-emerge, potentially increasing the risk of re-offending. However, it also considered arguments that the marriage was effectively over, mitigating this risk. Crucially, the Tribunal found KHHG's evidence to be misleading and inconsistent, noting his admission of striking his wife with a metal utensil caddy, which differed from his earlier accounts. This inconsistency, coupled with past unreported instances of domestic violence and financial abuse, weighed heavily against KHHG. The Tribunal also considered the best interests of KHHG's three Australian citizen children, noting the significant impact his return to Lebanon would have on them, but also observing the existing Interim Violence Order restricting his contact with them and the potential for this to continue post-conviction.

Ultimately, the Tribunal affirmed the decision to refuse the visa, finding that the nature and seriousness of KHHG's conduct, particularly in light of his misleading evidence, weighed strongly in favour of refusal. The Tribunal concluded that KHHG did not satisfy the character test.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Maloney submitted that the strains which had contributed to KHHG’s offending, namely financial stress and the strain of parental responsibility, are likely to re-emerge if he were allowed to remain in Australia.EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNALKHHG’s evidence At the commencement of the Applicant’s evidence, Mr Hughan told the Tribunal that KHHG would be making a particular admission about what actually took place on 26 December 2017 which differed from what he had previously told the police, the Courts and the Department, and also differed from KHHG’s written statement lodged with the Tribunal. The particular admission would be that KHHG would acknowledge that he struck his wife with a metal utensil caddy when they were in the bathroom of their home. Previously, KHHG had maintained that he threw the utensil caddy and that it glanced off Mrs KHHG and shattered a bathroom mirror, but that he had not directly hit her with it. The Tribunal noted that KHHG had entered a guilty plea in relation to the charge of recklessly causing injury but no conviction has yet been recorded and, observing what Mr Hughan had said about admissions that would be made, reminded KHHG that he has the right under section 62(4) of the AAT Act not to answer a question which might tend to incriminate him. KHHG acknowledged that he understood that he had that right. KHHG told the Tribunal that, on 26 December 2017, he had previously promised to take the family on a picnic to Geelong. He said that he had car trouble and therefore told his wife that they would have to postpone the trip. He said that his wife was annoyed but he knew he couldn’t fulfil his promise of the picnic. KHHG said his brother, who owns a fruit shop, telephoned around 8 am and asked him to come in to assist with some renovations at the shop. KHHG said he left home, using his brother’s utility, and drove to the fruit shop, a distance of about 10 minutes from his home. Soon after arriving at the shop, Mrs KHHG arrived in a taxi, with the three children. It was a conventional taxi without child seats and KHHG said he was not only surprised at her arrival, but also concerned that the children had travelled in the taxi, unrestrained. He said Mrs KHHG started abusing him, in front of others, and he started to apologise, again explaining about the car trouble and promised they would go on the picnic on a later day. He borrowed his brother’s car and placed Mrs KHHG and the children in it, and left for home. KHHG said he had a tooth ache and, as he was helping his wife into the car, Mrs KHHG slapped him on the mouth, which hurt. On the journey home he said she continued to yell and scream as he drove, and he slapped her on her nose, which started to bleed. He told the Tribunal he slapped her two times, with an open hand, and said he was trying to calm her down so she would not swear in front of the children. When they arrived home, KHHG said he took the children inside and then took Mrs KHHG inside. She continued, he said, to scream at him. He said he took her into the bathroom to help her clean up the blood from her nose-bleed. KHHG said he found the utensil caddy on the floor of the bathroom and he picked it up and hit her. He submits that he struck her once on her arm with his fist, then once on her hand, and once on her head with the caddy. The Tribunal noted that the police report said KHHG had gone to the kitchen and then brought the utensil caddy into the bathroom, but KHHG emphatically denied this, saying that ‘the kids may have left it in there’.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Overall, because of the nature and seriousness of the conduct in the context of the assault, the Tribunal finds that this consideration weighs strongly in favour of refusing the visa.Best interests of minor children in Australia affected by the decision (para 11.2) The Direction requires decision-makers to take account of this primary consideration only if minor children in Australia are affected and, if their interests differ, they should be given individual consideration. KHHG has three minor children, all of whom are Australian citizens and reside in this country. At the time of this decision the eldest is aged almost six; the second child is aged three; the youngest child is aged two years. There is no doubt that if KHHG has to return to Lebanon, there will be a significant effect on all of the children, and perhaps a slightly greater effect on the two older children. The Direction requires the Tribunal to consider whether there have been long periods of absence by the non-citizen. There have been absences as both older children were conceived in Lebanon before KHHG came to Australia in August 2015, but were born in Australia. For instance, their eldest child was born in October 2012 but Mrs KHHG did not reunite with KHHG with that child in Lebanon until the end of 2013. Their second child was born in April 2015 and KHHG did not last enter Australia until August 2015. In addition, because of the incident of 26 December 2017 and the IVO, KHHG has not had contact with any of the children since 26 December 2017. The Direction also requires the Tribunal to take into account whether Court orders are in place restricting contact. As mentioned above, an IVO was made by the Magistrates’ Court (G5). Among the provisions, KHHG is not permitted to contact or communicate with any of the named protected persons (that is, Mrs KHHG and the three children) by any means, or get any other person to do so on his behalf. KHHG told the Tribunal he had fully complied with the IVO, and there is no evidence to the contrary. Mr Hughan rightly drew the Tribunal’s attention to the fact that this is an interim order. However, the Tribunal notes that it remains in force until a final order is made unless varied or revoked by the Court, or withdrawn. It is less likely that the IVO, or a more permanent order, will not remain in place for a period of time determined by the Court, once a conviction is recorded, especially if a sentence of imprisonment is imposed, suspended or not. The Direction also requires the Tribunal to consider whether there are other persons who already fulfil a parental role in relation to the children. In this matter this is a complex question because although Mrs KHHG is currently living with the children (and her mother), there is evidence that she is not fully able to fulfil her parental responsibilities and in fact the children are currently in the care of their maternal grandmother. There was some evidence before the Tribunal that the grandmother has indicated she will not be in a position to care for the children indefinitely.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

KHHG’s brother gave evidence of what happened on the day of the assault and said KHHG had told him he had slapped his wife twice in the car and when they arrived home he ‘grabbed the metal thing and threw it at her and it hit her head’. He said KHHG later admitted to him he had hit her with the utensil caddy directly and then threw it and it shattered the mirror. KHHG’s brother also gave evidence that he employed KHHG in his shop and paid him around $200 per week, and also helped the family out financially by providing fruits and vegetables without cost.CONSIDERATION – THE CHARACTER TEST The assessment of the risk of KHHG engaging in (further) criminal conduct in Australia necessarily requires a weighing of the different factors in evidence before the Tribunal. Evidence which supports an assessment of “low” risk was submitted by Mr Hughan that, given that the marriage between KHHG and his wife was ‘effectively over’ and he does not intend to resume living with her, the circumstances which led to the assault have been removed. Mr Hughan also pointed to the fact that KHHG pleaded guilty and showed remorse, has complied with bail conditions and the requirements of the IVO and that there are strong and compassionate reasons, given KHHG’s close relationship with his children and the primary role he has played in their lives, to allow him to stay in this country. Mr Hughan said there is no ‘appreciable chance’ of KHHG re-offending. In the Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, Counsel wrote:The risk that [KHHG] will reoffend is “low” and not different from any other male person in the community. He has no previous convictions in Lebanon and no other convictions in Australia. This contention was put to Mr Newton who said that this statement should be interpreted, in his view, as referring to males who share the characteristics of KHHG and reiterated his view that KHHG was within the low risk category and the focus should be on treatment. The Tribunal asked Mr Hughan whether he still adhered to this particular contention in the light of the new admissions made by KHHG and the evidence of Mr Newton, and Counsel said that he did, in an actuarial sense. Mr Maloney submitted that KHHG’s evidence was misleading and has been inconsistent, and drew attention to inconsistencies in his written statement and that it therefore cannot be given real weight. Mr Maloney submitted that KHHG should be taken to have given a minimalizing account of what happened on 26 December 2017 and that he changed his version of events in a self-serving manner. He said that there were references in the papers before the Tribunal to past unreported instances of domestic violence. The Tribunal notes that in interview notes made by an officer of the Department on 5 April 2018 (G9, p 48) the officer recorded:I asked if Emilia was aware of past DV [domestic violence]. Emilia said that [Mrs KHHG] told her it was ongoing. There was a change in ‘Futures’ case worker at DHS. The case worker has no concern of DV.Emilia stated there is a history of financial abuse. Client took Centrelink money from [Mrs KHHG] and did not give it to her. Emilia had been told about old DV but had no concerns as there was no evidence of it.