Khanna v Baweja; Baweja v Khanna

Link copied
Case Copied 86 min read

Civil and Administrative Tribunal


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Khanna v Baweja; Baweja v Khanna [2017] NSWCATCD 8
Hearing dates:14 December 2016
Decision date: 01 February 2017
Jurisdiction:Consumer and Commercial Division
Before: P French, General Member
Decision:

In matter numbers and RT 16/25681; RT 16/33565; and RT 16/44944 (the proceedings as a whole):

 

1. The tenant, Geeta Khanna, is granted leave to be represented at the hearing by Sanjeev Khanna.

 

2. Sanjeev Khanna’s application pursuant to section 77 of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 for an order from the Tribunal that would join him as a party to the proceedings is granted.

 

3. The tenant’s application under section 48 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 for a direction that would require the Divisional Registrar to issue a summons to the landlord is refused.

 

4. The landlord, Jaskeerat Baweja, is to make any application for costs by 13 February 2017 by filing that application with the Divisional Registrar and serving a copy of it on the tenant and Mr Khanna. Any such application must particularise the costs claimed and be supported where possible by evidence of those costs.

 

5. If the landlord makes any application for costs, the tenant and Mr Khanna are to file with the Divisional Registrar and serve on the landlord’s Managing Agent any submission they may wish to make in response by 27 February 2017.

  

6. Any application for costs made by the landlord will then be determined by the Tribunal as presently constituted on the papers after 27 February 2017.

 

In matter numbers and RT 16/25681 and RT 16/33565 (the tenant’s applications):

 

7. The tenant and Mr Khanna’s application for leave to further amend their claims is granted in part so as to allow Sanjeev Khanna to seeks orders from the Tribunal under section 77 of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 recognising him as a tenant and joining him as a party to the proceedings. This application is otherwise refused.

 

8. Sanjeev Khanna’s application pursuant to section 77 of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 for an order from the Tribunal that would recognise him as a tenant under the Residential Tenancy Agreement is refused.

 

9. The tenant’s application for an order pursuant to section 44(1)(b) of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 that the rent payable under the Residential Tenancy Agreement is excessive having regard to the reduction or withdrawal of goods, services or facilities provided with the residential premises, and an order that the rent not exceed a specified amount for a specified period, is dismissed on the basis that it is lacking in substance.

 

10. The tenant’s application for an order pursuant to section 44(1)(a) of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 for an order that the rent increase served on the tenant by notice dated 16 March 2016 is excessive and that the rent is not to exceed a specified amount from a specified day is dismissed on the basis that it is lacking in substance.

 

11. The tenant’s application…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Khanna v Baweja; Baweja v Khanna and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NSWCATCD 8
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Khanna and Baweja were involved in a dispute regarding a residential tenancy. Khanna claimed to be a tenant under a Residential Tenancy Agreement, while Baweja contended that the agreement was a forgery and that he was not the landlord. The case involved several legal issues, including the validity of the tenancy agreement, the reasonableness of a rent increase, the landlord's obligation to provide goods, services, and facilities, and the landlord's right to terminate the tenancy. The court had to decide whether the tenancy agreement was valid, whether the rent increase was reasonable, and whether the landlord had a right to terminate the tenancy.

The court found that the tenancy agreement was a forgery, but this did not affect the validity of the tenancy. The court also found that the rent increase was reasonable, as it was below the general market level of rents for comparable residential premises in the same locality. The court further found that the landlord had not reduced or withdrawn any goods, services, or facilities provided with the residential premises, and that the tenant had failed to establish that the goods, services, and facilities provided with the residential premises did not compare with those available in comparable residential premises rented at a higher rate. The court also found that the landlord had a superior estate in the land and had a right to terminate the tenancy. The court granted the landlord's application to terminate the tenancy and ordered the tenant to pay a daily occupation fee until the landlord took possession of the premises.

In addition to the above, the court also considered several other applications made by the parties. The court granted the tenant's application to be represented by her husband at the hearing, but refused the tenant's application to join her husband as a party to the proceedings. The court also refused the tenant's application to require the landlord to pay compensation for damage and loss incurred as a result of the landlord's breach of the Residential Tenancy Agreement, and the tenant's application to declare the Notice of Termination of the Residential Tenancy Agreement to be of no effect on the basis that it was retaliatory. The court granted the landlord leave to make an application for costs, and directed the parties to file their submissions in relation to the application for costs by specified dates.

In summary, the court found in favour of the landlord on the main issues in the case, and granted the landlord's application to terminate the tenancy. The court also considered several other applications made by the parties, and made orders in relation to those applications. The court's decision provides guidance on the legal issues that can arise in residential tenancy disputes, and the principles that should be applied in resolving those issues.

Orders

Orders of the court

In matter numbers and RT 16/25681; RT 16/33565; and RT 16/44944 (the proceedings as a whole):

1. The tenant, Geeta Khanna, is granted leave to be represented at the hearing by Sanjeev Khanna.

2. Sanjeev Khanna’s application pursuant to section 77 of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 for an order from the Tribunal that would join him as a party to the proceedings is granted.

3. The tenant’s application under section 48 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 for a direction that would require the Divisional Registrar to issue a summons to the landlord is refused.

4. The landlord, Jaskeerat Baweja, is to make any application for costs by 13 February 2017 by filing that application with the Divisional Registrar and serving a copy of it on the tenant and Mr Khanna. Any such application must particularise the costs claimed and be supported where possible by evidence of those costs.

5. If the landlord makes any application for costs, the tenant and Mr Khanna are to file with the Divisional Registrar and serve on the landlord’s Managing Agent any submission they may wish to make in response by 27 February 2017.

6. Any application for costs made by the landlord will then be determined by the Tribunal as presently constituted on the papers after 27 February 2017.

In matter numbers and RT 16/25681 and RT 16/33565 (the tenant’s applications):

7. The tenant and Mr Khanna’s application for leave to further amend their claims is granted in part so as to allow Sanjeev Khanna to seeks orders from the Tribunal under section 77 of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 recognising him as a tenant and joining him as a party to the proceedings. This application is otherwise refused.

8. Sanjeev Khanna’s application pursuant to section 77 of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 for an order from the Tribunal that would recognise him as a tenant under the Residential Tenancy Agreement is refused.

9. The tenant’s application for an order pursuant to section 44(1)(b) of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 that the rent payable under the Residential Tenancy Agreement is excessive having regard to the reduction or withdrawal of goods, services or facilities provided with the residential premises, and an order that the rent not exceed a specified amount for a specified period, is dismissed on the basis that it is lacking in substance.

10. The tenant’s application for an order pursuant to section 44(1)(a) of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 for an order that the rent increase served on the tenant by notice dated 16 March 2016 is excessive and that the rent is not to exceed a specified amount from a specified day is dismissed on the basis that it is lacking in substance.

11. The tenant’s application for an order pursuant to 187(1)(d) of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 for an order from the Tribunal that would require the landlord to pay the tenant compensation for damage and loss incurred as a result of the landlord’s breach of the Residential Tenancy Agreement is dismissed on the basis that it is misconceived and lacking in substance.

12. The tenant’s application for an order pursuant to section 115 of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 declaring that the Notice of Termination of the Residential Tenancy Agreement dated 27 June 2016 is of no effect on the basis that it is retaliatory is refused.

In matter number RT 16/44944 (the landlord’s application):

13. The Residential Tenancy Agreement is terminated in accordance with section 85 of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 as the landlord has served a 90 day notice for termination of a periodic agreement.

14. The Residential Tenancy Agreement is terminated immediately and possession is to be given to the landlord on the date of termination.

15. The order for possession is suspended until 27 February 2017.

16. The tenant shall pay the landlord a daily occupation fee at the rate of $72.85 per day from the day after the date of termination, namely 31 January 2017 until the date vacant possession is given to the landlord.

17. Within 60 days of the date for possession of the premises specified in these orders the landlord may request the relisting of the application to determine the amount of the occupation fee owing.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.