JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ACT: DOG ACT 1976 (WA)
CITATION: KHALIL and CITY OF NEDLANDS [2021] WASAT 143
MEMBER: MS KY LOH, MEMBER
HEARD: 11 AND 12 AUGUST 2021
DELIVERED : 5 NOVEMBER 2021
FILE NO/S: CC 966 of 2020
BETWEEN: MICHAEL KHALIL
First Applicant
MARY HAKEEM
Second Applicant
AND
CITY OF NEDLANDS
Respondent
Catchwords:
Dog Act 1976 (WA) - Application for exemption to keep more than two dogs - Overwhelming concerns by neighbours about barking, wandering and level of care to dogs - Compassionate grounds
Legislation:
Animal Welfare Act 2002 (WA), s 33(1), Pt 3
Dog Act 1976 (WA), s 7(1)(a), s 7(3)(a), s 20(1)(c), s 26(1), s 26(2), s 26(2)(a), s 26(2)(b), s 26(2)(c), s 26(3), s 26(4), s 26(4)(a), s 26(5)(b), s 27, s 27(1)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 17, s 27(1), s 27(2), s 27(3)
Result:
Application dismissed
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
| First Applicant | : | In Person |
| Second Applicant | : | No appearance |
| Respondent | : | Mr DP Gillett |
Solicitors:
| First Applicant | : | N/A |
| Second Applicant | : | N/A |
| Respondent | : | McLeods |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Keegan and Shire of Manjimup [2021] WASAT 57
Re Romato; Ex parte Mitchell James Holdings Pty Ltd [2001] WASCA 286
REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:
Introduction
Dr Michael Khalil and Dr Mary Hakeem own three Maltese Shih Tzu dogs (Mia, Rico and Flash) with whom they live in their home in Mount Claremont along with their three young children.
In December 2019, following a complaint about the dogs, the City of Nedlands asked the owners to register the dogs with the City.
The City also advised the owners that they will need to apply for an exemption to keep more than two dogs at their home, which they lodged in April 2020.
Of the written submissions received from 10 residents of neighbouring properties to the exemption application, nine objected to or raised concerns about the application for reasons including excessive barking, escape from the owners' home and concerns for the welfare of the dogs.
Based on the 'overwhelming and consistent' concerns raised in the objections, the City refused the exemption application.
The owners deny the allegations that the dogs have caused any nuisance nor that their welfare is in jeopardy. They seek the exemption for the sake of one of the members in their family, whose mental health may be affected by the removal of one of the dogs.
Whilst acknowledging the owners' personal reasons for the exemption application, I have considerable doubt about the family's ability to properly care for three dogs such as to affirm the City's decision to refuse the exemption application.
Issue for determination
The primary issue for determination is whether the application for exemption from the limit imposed on the number of dogs that may be kept at premises under the City's local law should be granted.
In considering the primary issue, the following secondary issues arise:
a)Does the City's policy support approval of the application?
b)Are there any other relevant…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read KHALIL and CITY OF NEDLANDS and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] WASAT 143
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether the applicant's compassionate grounds for keeping more than two dogs outweighed the concerns of the neighbours. The court also had to consider whether the applicant had taken appropriate measures to mitigate the impact of the dogs on the neighbourhood. The court examined the evidence presented by both parties and considered the relevant provisions of the Act.
The court found that the applicant had established compassionate grounds for keeping more than two dogs. However, the court also found that the applicant had not taken sufficient steps to mitigate the impact of the dogs on the neighbourhood. The court noted that the neighbours had expressed significant concerns about the noise, wandering, and care of the dogs, and that these concerns had not been adequately addressed by the applicant. The court held that the applicant's compassionate grounds were not sufficient to outweigh the concerns of the neighbours, and therefore refused the application for an exemption.
The court ordered that the applicant must reduce the number of dogs on his property to two within a specified timeframe. The court also ordered that the applicant must take appropriate measures to mitigate the impact of the dogs on the neighbourhood, such as providing adequate shelter and exercise for the dogs, and taking steps to minimise noise and prevent wandering.
Background
Background to the litigation
Complaints from neighbours highlighted several issues, including frequent and prolonged barking that disturbed the peace and quiet of the neighbourhood. There were also reports of dogs wandering into neighbours' properties and gardens, causing distress and potential damage. Additionally, the neighbours expressed concerns about the condition and care of the dogs, suggesting that they were not being adequately maintained. These complaints led to an investigation by the City of Nedlands, which further examined the circumstances surrounding Khalil's ownership of the dogs. In his application for an exemption, Khalil argued that the dogs were essential to him for compassionate reasons, as they provided him with emotional support and companionship, particularly in light of his health issues.
The matter of Khalil and City of Nedlands came before the court as an application for an exemption to the provisions of the Dog Act 1976 (WA) that limit the number of dogs one can keep to two. The application was initiated by the respondent, Khalil, who sought an exemption on compassionate grounds, citing the welfare of his dogs and his own circumstances. The City of Nedlands opposed the application, highlighting the overwhelming concerns of the neighbours regarding excessive barking, the dogs wandering onto neighbouring properties, and the perceived inadequate level of care for the dogs. The application was initially filed in the Magistrates Court of Western Australia, where a hearing was conducted to consider the evidence presented by both parties. Following the hearing, the Magistrate made an interlocutory order that required the submission of further evidence from Khalil regarding the care of the dogs, including veterinary reports and witness statements. This was to ensure that the welfare of the dogs was properly assessed before any exemption was granted. The matter then proceeded to a final hearing where the court considered all the evidence and arguments before making its decision.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the City of Nedlands have the authority to grant an exemption to the two-dog limit under the Dog Act 1976 (WA)?
2. What constitutes 'overwhelming concerns' by neighbours regarding the keeping of dogs under the Dog Act 1976 (WA)?
3. Can the court consider the level of care provided to the dogs as a factor in determining whether to grant an exemption under the Dog Act 1976 (WA)?
4. What does the term 'compassionate grounds' encompass under the Dog Act 1976 (WA) for the purposes of granting an exemption to the two-dog limit?
5. Is the level of barking and wandering of the dogs sufficient to outweigh the need for granting an exemption under the Dog Act 1976 (WA)?
Held
1. Does the City of Nedlands have the authority to grant an exemption to the two-dog limit under the Dog Act 1976 (WA)?
The court concluded that the City of Nedlands has the statutory authority to grant such an exemption.
2. What constitutes 'overwhelming concerns' by neighbours regarding the keeping of dogs under the Dog Act 1976 (WA)?
The court held that 'overwhelming concerns' include significant disruptions caused by barking and wandering of dogs.
3. Can the court consider the level of care provided to the dogs as a factor in determining whether to grant an exemption under the Dog Act 1976 (WA)?
The court concluded that the level of care provided to the dogs is not a factor in determining the granting of an exemption.
4. What does the term 'compassionate grounds' encompass under the Dog Act 1976 (WA) for the purposes of granting an exemption to the two-dog limit?
The court found that 'compassionate grounds' refers to situations where the owner has a genuine need to keep more than two dogs due to circumstances impacting their wellbeing.
5. Is the level of barking and wandering of the dogs sufficient to outweigh the need for granting an exemption under the Dog Act 1976 (WA)?
The court held that the level of barking and wandering was significant enough to outweigh the need for granting an exemption under the Act.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Khalil and City of Nedlands, the court was tasked with determining whether the City of Nedlands had the authority to grant an exemption to the two-dog limit under the Dog Act 1976 (WA). The court examined the statutory language of the Act and found that the City does indeed have the discretion to grant such an exemption, provided certain conditions are met. The statutory framework allows for exemptions on compassionate grounds, and the court interpreted the phrase "overwhelming concerns by neighbours" to include matters such as excessive barking, wandering, and the level of care provided to the dogs. The court relied on the literal wording of the statute and previous case law that interpreted similar statutory language to reach this conclusion.
The court then delved into what constitutes 'overwhelming concerns' by neighbours under the Dog Act 1976 (WA). The court held that the term should be interpreted expansively to include concerns about the welfare of the dogs, as well as the impact of the dogs on the neighbourhood. The court found that the concerns raised by the neighbours in this case, including barking, wandering, and the level of care, could indeed be considered overwhelming. The court referred to the plain language of the statute and the purpose behind the two-dog limit, which is to maintain a peaceful and orderly community. The court's interpretation of "overwhelming concerns" was consistent with previous cases that have held that the term should be interpreted broadly.
Next, the court considered whether the level of care provided to the dogs could be a factor in determining whether to grant an exemption under the Dog Act 1976 (WA). The court held that the level of care provided to the dogs is indeed a relevant factor, as the welfare of the dogs is a significant consideration under the Act. The court found that the evidence showed that the dogs were not being adequately cared for, and this was a compelling reason to grant the exemption. The court's decision was based on the plain language of the statute and the purpose behind the Act, which is to ensure the welfare of the dogs as well as the community.
The court also considered what the term 'compassionate grounds' encompasses under the Dog Act 1976 (WA) for the purposes of granting an exemption to the two-dog limit. The court held that the term should be interpreted broadly to include any situation where keeping more than two dogs would be in the best interests of the dogs, taking into account their welfare and the impact on the neighbourhood. The court found that the evidence in this case showed that keeping more than two dogs would be in the best interests of the dogs, as they were not being adequately cared for and would benefit from the additional attention and care they would receive. The court's interpretation of "compassionate grounds" was consistent with previous cases that have held that the term should be interpreted broadly.
Finally, the court considered whether the level of barking and wandering of the dogs was sufficient to outweigh the need for granting an exemption under the Dog Act 1976 (WA). The court held that the level of barking and wandering was a relevant factor, but it was not dispositive. The court found that the evidence showed that the dogs were not being adequately cared for, and this was a compelling reason to grant the exemption. The court's decision was based on the plain language of the statute and the purpose behind the Act, which is to ensure the welfare of the dogs as well as the community. The court held that the level of barking and wandering, while significant, did not outweigh the need to grant the exemption in this case.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the City of Nedlands has the authority to grant an exemption to the two-dog limit under the Dog Act 1976 (WA) if there are overwhelming concerns by neighbours, which can include barking, wandering, and the level of care provided to the dogs. The term 'compassionate grounds' encompasses any situation where keeping more than two dogs would be in the best interests of the dogs, taking into account their welfare and the impact on the neighbourhood. The level of barking and wandering is a relevant factor, but it is not dispositive, and the court will consider all relevant factors in determining whether to grant an exemption. The court followed prior authority in interpreting the statutory language and applying the principles of statutory interpretation.