QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
CITATION:
Keyton WA for Qld Pty Ltd v Sonerson [2024] QCAT 324
PARTIES:
KEYTON WA AND QLD PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE FOR KEYTON WA AND QLD TRUST (applicant)
v
ALLAN SONERSON (respondent)
APPLICATION NO/S:
OCL074-22
MATTER TYPE:
Other civil dispute matters
DELIVERED ON:
5 August 2024
HEARING DATE:
On the papers
HEARD AT:
Brisbane
DECISION OF:
Member King-Scott
ORDERS: 1. I order that Mr Sonerson:
(a) not engage in behaviour that brings the Village into disrepute and/or detracts from or interferes with the rights, peace and enjoyment and privacy of other residents of the Village including behaviour of an abusive, aggressive, intimidatory, threatening, bullying, demeaning and/or harassing kind.
(b) not engage in conduct that materially impedes Village staff and/or agents from performing their duties;
(c) not engage in abusive, aggressive, intimidatory, threatening, bullying, demeaning and/or harassing behaviour towards Village staff, contractors or agents, residents, their visitors or guests.
2. I make the following declarations:
(a) That Mr Sonerson’s conduct as described in these reasons has brought the Village into disrepute and amounts to a material breach of his Contract with the Applicant;
(b) That Mr Sonerson’s abuse, disrespect, harassment and intimidation of the Applicant’s staff and residents as described in these reasons amounts to a breach of s 136 of the Retirement Villages Act 1999 (Qld) and clause 12 of the Lease (which breach is a material breach in accordance with Clause 20.4 of the Lease).
CATCHWORDS: ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – where applicant was an operator of a retirement village – where respondent resided in a retirement village – where the respondent engaged in abusive conduct towards other residents and staff – whether appropriate that matter be heard on the papers – declaratory relief
Retirement Villages Act 1999 (Qld)
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act2009 (Qld)
Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission (1992) 175 CLR 564
Randall v Body Corporate for Runaway Cove Bayside [2011] QCATA 10
APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION: This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to s 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act2009 (Qld) REASONS FOR DECISION
The Applicant, which is the operator of Hibiscus Retirement Resort, Nambour, has applied to have one of its residents, Alan Sonerson, desist in his abusive behaviour towards employees, contractors, residents, visitors or guests, or any other person on the village premises. The operator also seeks a declaration that the Mr Sonerson is in breach of the Retirement Villages Act 1999 (Qld) and his Lease.
History of proceeding
This matter was listed for an on the papers hearing on 13 October 2023.
The Application is supported by an undated affidavit of Debra Ann Winter filed in the Tribunal on 22 November 2022. Ms Winter deposes in her affidavit to a number of matters that are no longer relevant or correct. I do not direct any personal criticism towards Ms Winter in making the following observations.
The…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Keyton WA for Qld Pty Ltd v Sonerson and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] QCAT 324
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Tribunal examined the scope of its power to make declarations under Section 60 of the Act, noting that the power was limited and did not allow for declarations without accompanying orders unless expressly provided by an enabling act. The Tribunal also referenced previous decisions, including Randall v Body Corporate for Runaway Cove Bayside, which clarified that the Tribunal could not make declarations without associated orders unless explicitly granted. Additionally, the Tribunal considered the High Court's decision in Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission, which outlined the conditions for granting declaratory relief, such as the requirement that the relief be directed to resolving legal controversies and not hypothetical questions. Given these considerations, the Tribunal found that it had jurisdiction to make orders regarding Sonerson's conduct and additional declarations relating to his actions.
The Tribunal concluded that Sonerson's conduct, as described in the complaints, constituted a breach of his contract with the operator and violated specific provisions of the Retirement Villages Act 1999 (Qld) and the lease agreement. Therefore, the Tribunal ordered that Sonerson refrain from engaging in conduct that brings the village into disrepute or interferes with the rights of other residents and staff. Additionally, the Tribunal made declarations acknowledging the breaches committed by Sonerson. These orders and declarations were intended to address the specific issues raised by the complaints and to ensure compliance with the legal standards governing the operation of the retirement village.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. I order that Mr Sonerson:
(a) not engage in behaviour that brings the Village into disrepute and/or detracts from or interferes with the rights, peace and enjoyment and privacy of other residents of the Village including behaviour of an abusive, aggressive, intimidatory, threatening, bullying, demeaning and/or harassing kind.
(b) not engage in conduct that materially impedes Village staff and/or agents from performing their duties;
(c) not engage in abusive, aggressive, intimidatory, threatening, bullying, demeaning and/or harassing behaviour towards Village staff, contractors or agents, residents, their visitors or guests.
2. I make the following declarations:
(a) That Mr Sonerson’s conduct as described in these reasons has brought the Village into disrepute and amounts to a material breach of his Contract with the Applicant;
(b) That Mr Sonerson’s abuse, disrespect, harassment and intimidation of the Applicant’s staff and residents as described in these reasons amounts to a breach of s 136 of the Retirement Villages Act 1999 (Qld) and clause 12 of the Lease (which breach is a material breach in accordance with Clause 20.4 of the Lease).
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Section 60 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) provides for such relief as follows:60Declarations(1) The tribunal may make a declaration about a matter in a proceeding—(a)instead of making an order it could make about the matter; or(b)in addition to an order it could make about the matter.(2) The tribunal may make an order it considers necessary or desirable to give effect to a declaration under subsection (1).(3) A declaration under subsection (1) is binding on the parties to the proceeding mentioned in the declaration.(4) The tribunal’s power under subsection (1) is in addition to, and does not limit, any power of the tribunal under an enabling Act to make a declaration.(5) The tribunal’s power to act under subsection (1) or (2) is exercisable only by a legally qualified member. It has been held previously by the Appeal Tribunal in Randall v Body Corporate for Runaway Cove Bayside[10] that s 60 does not give the Tribunal power:Simply to make a declaration, not ancillary to, or in lieu of, another order which it could make’. That is, it does not have a power similar to that of the Supreme Court that is confirmed by s 128 of the Supreme Court Act 1995 (Qld). In the absence of an expressed power to entertain a proceeding simply for the purposes of giving a declaration, it does not have the power to grant and make a declaration unless such power is expressly given to it by an enabling act.[10][2011] QCATA 10 at [31]-[34]. In Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission[11] in speaking of the judicial power to make declarations the High Court stated: It is now accepted that superior courts have inherent power to grant declaratory relief. It is a discretionary power which ‘[i]t is neither possible nor desirable to fetter ... by laying down rules as to the manner of its exercise’. However, it is confined by the considerations which mark out the boundaries of judicial power. Hence, declaratory relief must be directed to the determination of legal controversies and not to answering abstract or hypothetical questions. The persons seeking relief must have ‘a real interest’ and relief will not be granted if the question ‘is purely hypothetical’, if relief is ‘claimed in relation to circumstances that [have] not occurred and might never happen’ or if ‘the court’s declaration will produce no foreseeable consequences for the parties’.[12](footnotes and citations omitted)[11][1992] 175 CLR 564.[12]Ibid 581. The application is brought in the Tribunal exercising its original jurisdiction, pursuant to s 191 of the Act, where there is a retirement village issue about an enforcement order or a payment order. It follows then, in my view, that the Tribunal has jurisdiction to make the orders sought that Mr Sonerson not engage in conduct complained of, and consequently, declarations in addition to those orders relating to the conduct of Mr Sonerson. The conduct alleged against Mr Sonerson arises from complaints by several residents and staff members. Mr Sonerson rejects a lot of the allegations and justifies his conduct in respect of other matters.