Keynes v Rural Directions Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Keynes v Rural Directions Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 1964

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – pleadings – contract for sale and purchase of barley – second “washout” contract entered into – obligation sought to be avoided contained in washout contract – challenge to obligation pleaded in relation to contract for sale and purchase

Held: pleading deficient in relation to identifying source of obligation sought to be avoided – statement of claim struck out. 

Commercial Arbitration and Industrial Referral Agreements Act1986 (SA) s 53
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 761A, 913B, 1022C
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 31A

TIMOTHY DOUGLAS KEYNES, ELIZABETH JANE KEYNES, CHRISTOPHER JOHN MCCOURT and ROBERT NEVILLE KEYNES v RURAL DIRECTIONS PTY LTD, GRAIN POOL PTY LTD, ABB GRAIN LTD, GLENCORE GRAIN PTY LTD and GRAINCORP AG FINANCE LTD

SAD 110 of 2008

BESANKO J
23 DECEMBER 2008
ADELAIDE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

SAD 110 of 2008

BETWEEN:

TIMOTHY DOUGLAS KEYNES
First Plaintiff

ELIZABETH JANE KEYNES
Second Plaintiff

CHRISTOPHER JOHN MCCOURT
Third Plaintiff

ROBERT NEVILLE KEYNES
Fourth Plaintiff

AND:

RURAL DIRECTIONS PTY LTD
First Defendant

GRAIN POOL PTY LTD
Second Defendant

ABB GRAIN LTD
Third Defendant

GLENCORE GRAIN PTY LTD
Fourth Defendant

GRAINCORP AG FINANCE LTD
Fifth Defendant

JUDGE:

BESANKO J

DATE OF ORDER:

23 DECEMBER 2008

WHERE MADE:

ADELAIDE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The plaintiffs’ amended statement of claim against the fourth defendant be struck out.

2.Further consideration of the fourth defendant’s notice of motion dated 20 November 2008 be adjourned to a date to be fixed.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


The text of entered orders can be located using eSearch on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

SAD 110 of 2008

BETWEEN:

TIMOTHY DOUGLAS KEYNES
First Plaintiff

ELIZABETH JANE KEYNES
Second Plaintiff

CHRISTOPHER JOHN MCCOURT
Third Plaintiff

ROBERT NEVILLE KEYNES
Fourth Plaintiff

AND:

RURAL DIRECTIONS PTY LTD
First Defendant

GRAIN POOL PTY LTD
Second Defendant

ABB GRAIN LTD
Third Defendant

GLENCORE GRAIN PTY LTD
Fourth Defendant

GRAINCORP AG FINANCE LTD
Fifth Defendant

JUDGE:

BESANKO J

DATE:

23 DECEMBER 2008

PLACE:

ADELAIDE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. The fourth defendant, Glencore Grain Pty Ltd, has brought an application in this proceeding against the plaintiffs, seeking the following orders (relevantly):

    (1)That, pursuant to s.53(1) of the Commercial Arbitration and Industrial Referral Agreements Act (SA) 1986, this proceeding as against the Fourth Respondent be stayed and, further, the matters raised in this proceeding by the Applicants as against the Fourth Respondent be referred to arbitration with the National Agricultural Commodity Marketing Association Limited (“NACMA”) within 30 days;

    (2)Alternatively, that pursuant to Order 20 Rule 5 of the Federal Court Rules, this proceeding as against the Fourth Respondent be stayed or dismissed;

    (3)Alternatively, in the event of the proceeding not being stayed, that the Court grant judgment in favour of the Fourth Respondent pursuant to section 31A of the Federal Court…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Keynes v Rural Directions Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 1964
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Keynes v Rural Directions Pty Ltd involves a dispute between the plaintiffs, the first and second plaintiffs, and the fourth defendant. The plaintiffs seek damages from the fourth defendant for breach of a contract for sale and purchase of barley, as well as seeking a declaration that the contract is void or an order for the return of moneys paid under the contract. The contract was governed by the NACMA Trade Rules, which include a clause requiring any disputes to be resolved through arbitration before legal proceedings can be commenced. The fourth defendant has moved to strike out the plaintiffs' amended statement of claim, arguing that it is otherwise defective and that the plaintiffs have failed to comply with the arbitration requirement.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiffs' amended statement of claim against the fourth defendant was defective and should be struck out. A secondary issue was the proper interpretation of sections in Ch 7 of the Corporations Act, although the court refrained from expressing an opinion on this matter due to the defective nature of the pleadings. The court found that the arbitration clause in the NACMA Trade Rules was a condition precedent to the right of either party to bring any legal proceedings, and that the plaintiffs had not complied with this requirement. The court further noted that the plaintiffs' amended statement of claim was plainly otherwise defective, and therefore struck it out. The court also adjourned further consideration of the fourth defendant's notice of motion to a later date.

The court's reasoning was that the arbitration clause in the NACMA Trade Rules was clear and unambiguous, and required any disputes to be resolved through arbitration before legal proceedings could be commenced. The plaintiffs had not complied with this requirement, and therefore their amended statement of claim was defective. The court also found that the plaintiffs' amended statement of claim was otherwise defective, and therefore struck it out. The court's outcome was that the plaintiffs' amended statement of claim against the fourth defendant was struck out, and further consideration of the fourth defendant's notice of motion was adjourned to a later date.

The final orders of the court were that the plaintiffs' amended statement of claim against the fourth defendant be struck out, and that further consideration of the fourth defendant's notice of motion be adjourned to a date to be fixed. These orders effectively dismiss the plaintiffs' claims against the fourth defendant, and leave the parties in the position they were in before the proceedings commenced.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The plaintiffs’ amended statement of claim against the fourth defendant be struck out.

2. Further consideration of the fourth defendant’s notice of motion dated 20 November 2008 be adjourned to a date to be fixed.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The plaintiffs seek damages in the sum of $173,340 from the fourth defendant. That sum is calculated by reference to the difference between a price of $365 per tonne and the contract price of $203 per tonne multiplied by the quantity to be delivered under the contract for sale and purchase (that is, 1,070 tonnes). In the alternative, the plaintiffs seek an order under s 1022C(1) of the Corporations Act, declaring the contract for sale and purchase to be void, or an order under s 1022C(2) of the Corporations Act for the return of any moneys which have been paid, as a washout cost, under the contract for sale and purchase. There is a reference in paragraph 56 of the amended statement of claim to the fact that, by reason of a production failure, the contract for sale and purchase has been washed out and that, as a result of that fact, they have suffered loss and damage. There was a washout agreement between the plaintiffs and the fourth defendant and it is described in the following paragraph (at points 2 and 3). The thrust of the plea in paragraph 56 of the amended statement of claim is not a denial of the obligation under the washout agreement, but rather an acceptance of the obligation for the purpose of establishing loss and damage. It may well be that the plea in paragraph 56 was framed mainly with an eye to the plaintiffs’ case against the first defendant.The evidence The fourth defendant has put evidence before the Court from its chief financial officer. The substance of the evidence does not appear to be in dispute. It establishes the following.1.On or about 4 June 2007, the first and second plaintiffs entered into a contract with the fourth defendant under which the first and second plaintiffs would supply 1,070 metric tonnes of barley at a price of $203 per metric tonne to the fourth defendant between 1 November 2007 and 31 December 2007. This is the contract for sale and purchase. The trade rules governing the contract for sale and purchase were said to be the National Agriculture Commodity Marketing Association (“NACMA”) Trade Rules. The first defendant negotiated the contract with the fourth defendant on behalf of the applicants. It is said that the contract for sale and purchase resulted from detailed negotiations on the telephone. The contract is evidenced by a document entitled “Purchase Contract‑NTP” issued by the fourth defendant and by a document entitled a “Confirmation of Trade” document issued by the first defendant on behalf of the plaintiffs. The latter document provides that disputes relating to the contract are to be resolved through “[a]rbitration as per NACMA Trade Rules”.It seems clear from the documents that the contract for sale and purchase was governed by the NACMA Trade Rules.2.In late August 2007, a Mr Loman of the first defendant, acting on behalf of the first and second plaintiffs, advised a representative of the fourth defendant that the first and second plaintiffs would not be in a position to deliver the required tonnage and meet their obligations under the contract for sale and purchase. The first defendant had been instructed by the first and second plaintiffs to give a notice of default under r 17 of the NACMA Trade Rules and to seek the fourth defendant’s agreement to close off the contract. Rule 17 provides a mechanism whereby a seller who becomes aware that he will not be able to meet the contract can advise the buyer who can then elect between various courses of action. One option available to the buyer is to close out the contract, based on the current market price. This is known as washing out the contract.3.On 30 August 2007, the parties agreed to wash out the contract for sale and purchase under r 17.1(1)(c) of the NACMA Trade Rules, and under that agreement the first and second plaintiffs agreed that they would be jointly liable to the fourth defendant for the sum of $173,340, being the difference between the agreed price and the then prevailing price of $365 per metric tonne. I will refer to this agreement as the washout agreement.A number of documents evidencing the agreement passed between the parties, including a “Confirmation of Trade” issued by the first defendant on behalf of the plaintiffs.4.On 6 August 2008, the solicitors acting for the plaintiffs wrote to the fourth defendant and said, among other things, the following.Counsel advised our clients that your company should also be joined as a respondent in the action because of the failure to deliver a product disclosure statement and a correct statement of advice to our clients. However, our clients have always regarded Rural Directions as the party primarily responsible for the position in which they have been placed and would rather not have to proceed against your company as a party to the action provided that you are prepared to await the outcome of the action against Rural Directions. No agreement was reached and ultimately the plaintiffs issued this proceeding against, among others, the fourth defendant.5.The plaintiffs have not paid the washout price under the washout agreement to the fourth defendant.6.The fourth defendant has been, and remains, ready and willing to do all things necessary for the proper conduct of arbitration in respect of the dispute between the parties.7. Rule 26.0 of the NACMA Trade Rules is in the following terms.Rule 26.0 Arbitration:1)The NACMA Dispute Resolution Rules form an integral part of these NACMA Trade Rules of which all parties subject to these NACMA Trade Rules shall be deemed to be cognisant.2)If any dispute arises out of or relates to any contract subject to these Trade Rules or the breach, termination or subject matter of a contract, the dispute shall be submitted to and settled by Arbitration in accordance with the NACMA Dispute Resolution Rules in the edition current at the date of the establishment of the Terms of Trade in the contract, such rules forming an integral part of the contract and of which both parties to the contract shall be deemed to be cognisant.3)Neither party to a dispute, nor any persons claiming under either of them, shall bring any action or any legal proceedings against the other in respect to any such dispute until arbitrated in accordance with the NACMA Dispute Resolution Rules.4)It is expressly agreed and declared within these NACMA Trade Rules that the obtaining of an award through NACMA arbitration shall be a condition precedent to the right of either party or of any persons claiming under either of them to bring any action or other legal proceedings against the other of them in respect of any such dispute.

Decision

Reasons for decision

BESANKO J
The fourth defendant’s second argument raises questions of law about the proper interpretation of sections in Ch 7 of the Corporations Act. In circumstances in which the plaintiffs’ amended statement of claim is plainly otherwise defective, I refrain from expressing an opinion on those questions of law. They may not arise, or, if the plaintiffs re‑plead their case against the fourth defendant, they may arise in a different context from that presently pleaded.Conclusion For the above reasons, the plaintiffs’ statement of claim against the fourth defendant will be struck out and further consideration of the fourth defendant’s notice of motion dated 20 November 2008 will be stood over to a date to be fixed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BESANKO J

Full text does not contain this section.