Kevin Edward Smith v Scott Lutiger T/As Scott Doney Autos

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read
CITATION: Kevin Edward Smith & Anor v Scott Lutiger T/As Scott Doney Autos & Anor [2000] NSWSC 233 revised - 4/04/2000
CURRENT JURISDICTION: Supreme Court
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 3910/98
HEARING DATE(S): 20 March 2000
JUDGMENT DATE: 20 March 2000

PARTIES :


Kevin Edward Smith & Anor v Scott Lutiger - T/As Scott Doney Autos & Anor
JUDGMENT OF: Hodgson CJinEq at 1
COUNSEL : Mr P Beale for the plaintiffs
Mr D K L Raphael for the defendants
SOLICITORS: Kacin Safi & Halligan for the plaintiffs
A R Walmsley & Co for the defendants
CATCHWORDS: Trusts and Trustees - Invalid appointment of new trustee - Lease granted by new trustee - Tenant holding over from month to month - New trustee gives one month's notice - Whether registered proprietor entitled to possession.
LEGISLATION CITED: Rea Property Act
Trustee Act ss6, 8
Conveyancing Act s 127
CASES CITED: Retravision NSW Ltd v Copeland (Young J, 8/10/97)
DECISION: See Orders 48-55 of judgment

    THE SUPREME COURT
    OF NEW SOUTH WALES
    EQUITY DIVISION

    CORAM: HODGSON CJ in Equity

    Monday, 20 March 2000

    3910/99: KEVIN EDWARD SMITH & ANOR v SCOTT LUTIGE R T /A s SCOTT DONEY AUTOS & ANOR

    JUDGMENT

    1 HIS HONOUR: The first plaintiff, Mr Smith, is the registered proprietor under the Real Property Act of property Unit 1, 34-36 Plasser Crescent, St Marys. The second plaintiff, Tresaire, a company controlled by Mr Smith, was purportedly appointed a new trustee of a trust called the Plasser Property Trust by a deed dated 1 July 1996.

    2   The defendants, Mr and Mrs Lutiger, are in occupation of the property, having gone into occupation pursuant to a lease between Scott Doney Autos as lessee and Plasser Property Trust as lessor, apparently executed on 29 September 1996.

    3   In these proceedings, the plaintiffs seek possession of the property and damages. The defendants claim that either they are entitled to remain under an agreement for lease, which will not expire until the end of 2000, or they are entitled to remain under a lease from month to month, which has not been validly terminated.

    OUTLINE OF FACTS

    4   I will commence with an outline of facts which are not in dispute.

    5   The property was apparently acquired by Mr Smith and his then wife in about 1992. By a trust deed dated 7 May 1994, Plasser Property Trust was established, and Mr and Mrs Smith were appointed trustees. The deed contained no provision for the number of trustees to be less than two.

    6   By a deed dated 1 July 1996 Mr and Mrs Smith purportedly retired as trustees and appointed Tresaire the new trustee of the Trust.

    7   A lease was executed on 29 September 1996 between the Plasser Property Trust as lessor and Scott Doney Autos as lessee for one year, commencing 1 January 1997, with an option for a further year. It appears that Scott Doney Autos is a business name under which the defendants trade. The lease was signed by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kevin Edward Smith v Scott Lutiger T/As Scott Doney Autos and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] NSWSC 233
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved Kevin Edward Smith, the plaintiff, and Scott Lutiger trading as Scott Doney Autos, the defendant. The dispute centred around the validity of a trustee's appointment and the subsequent lease granted by the new trustee. Smith claimed that he was entitled to possession of the property, which he had been leasing under a month-to-month arrangement from the defendant. The dispute was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia.

The primary legal issue the court had to determine was whether the appointment of Scott Lutiger as a new trustee was valid, and if so, whether he had the authority to grant a lease and subsequently give notice to the tenant. Additionally, the court needed to ascertain whether Smith, as the tenant, held over from month to month, and if the new trustee was entitled to possession upon giving one month's notice. The validity of the lease and the rights of the tenant were central to the case.

The court found that the appointment of Scott Lutiger as the trustee was invalid, as it did not comply with the necessary legal formalities. Consequently, any lease granted by him was also invalid. The court determined that Smith was holding over from month to month, as he had not entered into a new lease agreement. Given the invalid appointment and lease, Smith's tenancy remained in effect. The court ruled that Scott Lutiger, as the new trustee, was not entitled to possession based on the one month's notice provided, as this was predicated on the invalid lease. Smith's right to continue occupying the property was upheld.

The court ordered that Scott Lutiger was not entitled to possession of the property based on the invalid appointment and lease. Smith was permitted to continue his month-to-month tenancy under the original terms. The court's decision underscored the importance of proper legal procedures in the appointment of trustees and the consequences of failing to adhere to these requirements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established