Kevin Delaney v Commercial Building Centre Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

KEVIN DELANEY v COMMERCIAL BUILDING CENTRE PTY LIMITED
t/as COMMERCIAL BUILDING CENTRE and NRMA INSURANCE LIMITED
[2003] ACTSC 17 (28 March 2003)

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Third Party Notice – whether accident “arising out of the use of motor vehicle” – worker in chain passing goods to be loaded onto truck – not arising out of use of motor vehicle.

Motor Traffic Act 1936, s 54(1)(b)

State Government Insurance Commission v Stevens Brothers Proprietary Limited (1984) 154 CLR 552

Fawcett v BHP By-Products Proprietary Limited (1960) 104 CLR 80

The Government Insurance Office of New South Wales v King (1960) 104 CLR 93

Government Insurance Office of New South Wales v RJ Green & Lloyd Pty Limited (1965) 114 CLR 437

Balfour Beatty Power Constructions (Australia) Pty Ltd v Government Insurance Office of New South Wales [1996] 24 MVR 162

CE Heath Underwriting and Insurance Pty Ltd v George Weston Foods (unreported, 6 October 1993, Victorian Court of Appeal)

No SC 661 of 2001

Judge:   Connolly J 
Supreme Court of the ACT
Date:     28 March 2003

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE  )
  )  No SC 661 of  2001
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY  )

BETWEEN:KEVIN DELANEY

Plaintiff

AND:COMMERCIAL BUILDING CENTRE PTY LIMITED

(ACN 083 816 497) t/a COMMERCIAL BUILDING CENTRE

Defendant

AND:NRMA INSURANCE LIMITED

(ACN 000 0167 22)

Third Party

ORDER

Judge:  Connolly J
Date:  28 March 2003
Place:  Canberra

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

  1. The Third Party Notice be dismissed with costs.

  1. This matter falls for decision on a narrow but important point arising from a third party contribution claim brought by the defendant employer against the third party motor vehicle insurer in the course of an employment personal injuries claim.  The plaintiff was injured at work in the course of activities, which involved the loading of a truck and brought action against his employer.  The employer has joined the insurer of the truck.  The substantive action between the injured worker and his employer was settled by consent judgment on 18 February 2003.  The third party proceedings remain in issue.

  1. Counsel for the parties prepared an agreed statement of facts, which substantially shortened these proceedings.  This was an entirely appropriate and sensible approach, and counsel are to be commended for this.  The agreed statement is as follows:

On 30 July 1999, Mr Delaney was one in a team of three people helping to move 20-kilogram bags of plaster from a pallet on the ground, onto a delivery truck for the purpose of subsequent delivery.  “Mick”, the man standing beside the pallet, grasped the first bag from the stack at about waist height and passed it to Mr Delaney, who received it.  Mr Delaney turned around and taking a small step, passed the bag to “Brian” who placed it onto the tray of the 7 tonne truck.  On the second occasion, Mick grasped the next 20-kilogram bag from the pallet, and again at about waist height, passed it to Mr Delaney who received it and turned to pass it…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kevin Delaney v Commercial Building Centre Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] ACTSC 17
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved an employment personal injury claim brought by Kevin Delaney against his employer, Commercial Building Centre Pty Limited. The employer sought to join the insurer of the truck involved in the incident as a third party, seeking contribution under the Motor Traffic Act 1936. The key issue for the court was whether Delaney's injury "arose out of the use of the motor vehicle." The court examined various judicial interpretations of the phrase "arising out of the use of the motor vehicle" and found that while the High Court has directed a broad construction, not all acts in relation to the vehicle constitute such an injury. The court held that the injury must be part of a single process of loading and there must be a direct or proximate relationship between the injury and the use of the vehicle. As Delaney's injury occurred while he was passing the load to another worker, the court determined that the action was too remote from the use of the vehicle and dismissed the Third Party Notice with costs.

The court considered the arguments presented by both parties, with the employer arguing for a broad interpretation of the phrase "arising out of the use of the motor vehicle" and the third party insurer arguing that the injury did not arise out of the use of the motor vehicle. The court found that while a broad interpretation was appropriate, it could not extend to any and all acts related to the vehicle. Instead, the injury must be part of a single process of loading and there must be a direct or proximate relationship between the injury and the use of the vehicle. The court held that in this case, the injury did not meet these criteria and dismissed the Third Party Notice with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 30 July 1999, Mr Kevin Delaney, while at work, was part of a team tasked with moving 20-kilogram bags of plaster from a pallet on the ground onto a delivery truck for subsequent delivery. The process involved Mick, another worker, grasping a bag from the stack at about waist height and passing it to Mr Delaney, who then turned around and passed the bag to Brian, a taller worker. Brian then placed the bag onto the tray of the truck. On the second occasion of this process, as Mr Delaney passed the bag to Brian, he went up on his toes, at which moment he heard a popping sound and immediately experienced a sharp pain in his back that shot down into his right leg, resulting in an injury.

The injury led Mr Delaney to bring an action against his employer, Commercial Building Centre Pty Limited, who in turn sought to join NRMA Insurance Limited, the insurer of the truck, as a third party. The substantive action between Mr Delaney and his employer was settled by consent judgment on 18 February 2003, but the third party proceedings remained unresolved. The matter before the court was a narrow but crucial point regarding whether the injury arose out of the use of the motor vehicle, thus implicating the third party insurer. The court had before it an agreed statement of facts from counsel for the parties, which significantly streamlined the proceedings and was commended for its efficiency. The court considered the phrase "arising out of the use of the motor vehicle" within the context of the Motor Traffic Act 1936, noting that while the injury occurred during the process of loading the truck, the critical issue was whether this process was sufficiently linked to the use of the vehicle itself.

This matter came before the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory as an interlocutory application in the context of an ongoing personal injury claim. The plaintiff, Kevin Delaney, was injured at work and sought damages from his employer, Commercial Building Centre Pty Limited. The employer sought to join NRMA Insurance Limited, the insurer of the motor vehicle involved in the incident, as a third party to the proceedings, arguing that Delaney's injury arose out of the use of the motor vehicle. The case was settled between the plaintiff and the employer, but the third-party proceedings continued. The court was tasked with deciding whether Delaney's injury arose out of the use of the motor vehicle, a determination crucial for the third-party insurer's potential liability. The court heard arguments from counsel for both the defendant employer and the third party, referencing various judicial precedents on the interpretation of "arising out of the use of the motor vehicle." The decision was rendered on the basis of an agreed statement of facts, which facilitated a focused determination on the legal issue at hand. The court concluded that Delaney's injury did not arise out of the use of the motor vehicle, dismissing the third party's notice with costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the injury to the plaintiff arose out of the use of the motor vehicle as defined in section 54(1)(b) of the Motor Traffic Act 1936.
2. Whether the act of passing the bag of plaster to another worker can be considered part of the process of loading the vehicle.
3. If not, whether the injury is too remote from the use of the vehicle to be covered under the third party motor vehicle insurance policy.
4. Whether the employer's liability should be held for the injury as it is not covered by the third party motor vehicle insurance policy.

Held
1. Whether the injury to the plaintiff arose out of the use of the motor vehicle as defined in section 54(1)(b) of the Motor Traffic Act 1936. The court concluded that the plaintiff's injury did not arise out of the use of the motor vehicle.
2. Whether the act of passing the bag of plaster to another worker can be considered part of the process of loading the vehicle. The court concluded that the act of passing the bag to another worker was not part of the process of loading the vehicle.
3. If not, whether the injury is too remote from the use of the vehicle to be covered under the third party motor vehicle insurance policy. The court concluded that the injury was too remote from the use of the vehicle to be covered under the insurance policy.
4. Whether the employer's liability should be held for the injury as it is not covered by the third party motor vehicle insurance policy. The court concluded that the employer's liability should be held for the injury since it was not covered by the insurance policy.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case of Kevin Delaney v Commercial Building Centre Pty Limited concerns the interpretation of the phrase "arising out of the use of a motor vehicle" as stipulated in section 54(1)(b) of the Motor Traffic Act 1936. This case examines whether the plaintiff's injury, which occurred while he was passing a bag of plaster to another worker during the process of loading a truck, falls within the scope of the third party motor vehicle insurance policy. The Court was required to determine if the injury arose out of the use of the vehicle, or if it was too remote to be covered under the policy.

The plaintiff's counsel argued that the injury arose out of the use of the vehicle by presenting a broad construction of the phrase "arising out of." The argument was supported by the High Court's decision in State Government Insurance Commission v Stevens Brothers Proprietary Limited (1984) 154 CLR 552, which emphasized that "arising out of" requires a less proximate relationship of the injury to the relevant use of the vehicle than "caused by." However, the Court noted that while a broad view should be taken of what amounts to the use of a vehicle, there are limits, and not all acts upon or in relation to a vehicle involve the use of that vehicle.

On the other hand, the third party's counsel argued that the injury was not an injury arising out of the use of the motor vehicle, citing Government Insurance Office of New South Wales v RJ Green & Lloyd Pty Limited (1965) 114 CLR 437, where the High Court held that not every act in loading a vehicle for the conveyance of what is loaded upon it is necessarily a use or part of the use of the motor vehicle. The Court also referred to Balfour Beatty Power Constructions (Australia) Pty Ltd v Government Insurance Office of New South Wales [1996] 24 MVR 162, where the New South Wales Court of Appeal held that the lifting which caused the injury was part of the process by which it was lifted onto the trailer and was not remote from the use of the vehicle.

In this case, the Court held that for the loading activity to arise from the use of the motor vehicle, the action of the worker which gives rise to the injury must at least be part of a single process of loading. Since the injured worker was not in the process of placing the bag of plaster onto the truck himself but was instead handing the bag to another worker who was to place the bag on the truck, the link between the action of lifting the bag and the use of the motor vehicle had not been made. The injured worker had no contact with the motor vehicle, and that was the task of the next worker in the line. Therefore, the injury was too remote from the use of the vehicle, and the responsibility should properly lie with the employer.

The Court distinguished the present case from the cases where the loading operation involved one worker in a continuous process, such as the High Court's decision in Government Insurance Office of New South Wales v RJ Green & Lloyd Pty Limited, and the New South Wales Court of Appeal's decision in Balfour Beatty Power Constructions (Australia) Pty Ltd v Government Insurance Office of New South Wales. In those cases, the loading activity was considered part of the use of the motor vehicle, as the worker was directly involved in placing the load on the vehicle designed to bear it during transport.

In conclusion, the Court held that the plaintiff's injury did not arise out of the use of the motor vehicle, and accordingly, the Third Party Notice should be dismissed, with costs, and the full consequence of the judgment should lie against the employer. The ratio decidendi of this case is that for an injury to be covered under a third party motor vehicle insurance policy, the action giving rise to the injury must be part of a single process of loading the vehicle, and the worker must have direct contact with the vehicle during the loading process. If the action is too remote from the use of the vehicle, the responsibility should lie with the employer.