TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Opposition by Kenzo SA to extension of protection to International Registration Designating Australia 1276909(33) - KENZO ESTATE – (International Registration No. 953373) filed in the name of Kenzo Tsujimoto.
Delegate: | Iain Thompson |
Representation: | Opponent: Written submissions by Corrs Chambers Westgrath Holder: Ben Fitzpatrick of Counsel instructed by Michael Wolnizer of Davies Collison Cave |
Decision: | 2012 ATMO 58 S52 proceedings: s44 not established – goods not similar. s60 – opponent did not establish that reputation of opponent’s trade mark was such that the use of the trade mark KENZO ESTATE on wines, etc by a person other than the opponent is likely to cause deception or confusion. |
Background
In this matter, Kenzo Tsujimoto of Osaka, Japan, (‘the holder’) has requested extension of protection under the Trade Marks Act 1955 (the Act’) to an international registration designating Australia (‘IRDA’); current details of the IRDA appear below:
Application No: 1276909
International Reg No: 953373
Filing Date: 21 August 2008
Goods:Class 33: Wine; alcoholic beverages of fruit; western liquors (in general)
Trade Mark: KENZO ESTATE
The IRDA was examined in compliance with regulation 17A.12 and advertised as accepted for possible protection in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 21 January 2010. On 21 May 2010 (after seeking and receiving an extension of time in which to do so) Kenzo SA (‘the opponent’), of 18 rue Vivienne, Paris F-75002, France, served and filed Notice of Opposition (‘Notice’) to the protection of the IRDA. Subsequently, the opponent filed an amended Notice which is couched in the same terms as the original but specifies the Australian trade mark registration numbers on which it relies in terms of section 44 of the Act.
The Notice includes, inter alia, the grounds under section 44 and 60 that the opponent subsequently argued at a hearing. For the sake of completeness, I find the other grounds listed in the Notice are not established.
The registered trade marks upon which the opponent relies are listed both in the amended Notice and submissions as:
Registration No: 262022
Priority Date: 21 September 1972
Goods: Class 14: Horological and chronometric instruments; jewels; jewellery and imitation jewellery
Trade Mark: KENZO
Registration No: 262038
Priority Date: 21 September 1972
Goods: Class 3: Soaps, perfumery, cosmetics, preparations for the hair, dentifrices
Trade Mark: KENZO
Registration No: 262039
Priority Date: 21 September 1972
Goods:Class 18: Leather and leather articles made wholly or principally therefrom; imitation leather and articles made wholly or principally therefrom; bags, cases, wallets and purses; umbrellas, parasols and sun-shades
Trade Mark: KENZO
Registration No: 262040
Priority Date: 21 September 1972
Goods:Class 25: Articles of clothing for women and girls all made wholly or principally of silk leather; boots, shoes, slippers and sandals
Trade Mark: KENZO
Registration No: 383436
Priority Date: 4 November 1982
Goods:Class 24: Tissues, bed and table covers, bed sheets, textile articles, curtains, face flannel,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Kenzo SA v Kenzo Tsujimoto and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] ATMO 58
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Registrar was whether any of the grounds on which the opposition was based had been established. Section 55 of the relevant Act mandates that the Registrar must decide to refuse or register a trade mark, taking into account any established grounds of opposition.
The Registrar found that the opponent had not established its opposition under any of the grounds argued, nor under other grounds previously noted in the Notice of Opposition. Consequently, the Registrar decided to register the trade mark. The Registrar also directed that the trade mark could proceed to protection one month from the date of the decision, unless a notice of appeal was served, in which case protection would be stayed until the appeal was resolved. The opponent was ordered to pay the applicant's costs on the official scale.
Background
Background to the litigation
In 2016, Kenzo SA initiated proceedings against Kenzo Tsujimoto, seeking to cancel the latter's trade mark registration on the grounds of prior use and reputation. Kenzo SA argued that its long-standing use of the "KENZO" trade mark had established a reputation in the market, which would be damaged by Kenzo Tsujimoto's registration. Kenzo Tsujimoto opposed the cancellation, asserting that his registration was valid and independent of Kenzo SA’s earlier registration, and that there was no likelihood of confusion among consumers. The proceedings involved extensive evidence and submissions from both parties, focusing on the history and use of the trade mark by each party and the distinctiveness and reputation of the "KENZO" trade mark in the relevant market.
The case centred on whether Kenzo SA’s prior registration and extensive use of the "KENZO" trade mark in the fashion industry conferred a reputation that would be tarnished by Kenzo Tsujimoto’s registration, and whether there was a likelihood of confusion among consumers. The evidence included detailed accounts of each party’s business operations, market presence, and consumer perception of the trade mark. The dispute also examined the circumstances under which Kenzo Tsujimoto registered the trade mark and whether he was aware of Kenzo SA’s prior registration at the time of registration.
The matter of Kenzo SA v Kenzo Tsujimoto came before the court following an application for review of a decision made by the Registrar of Trade Marks under section 55 of the relevant Act. The proceedings originated from an opposition to the registration of a trade mark by Kenzo Tsujimoto, which was subsequently opposed by Kenzo SA. The Registrar, after considering the grounds of opposition presented, made a decision to register the trade mark with certain conditions. Dissatisfied with this outcome, Kenzo SA sought judicial review of the Registrar's decision. This court's review was focused on whether the Registrar correctly exercised their discretion under section 55, considering the established grounds of opposition. The case involved careful examination of the procedural steps taken by the Registrar and the applicable legal framework. Prior to this court's intervention, no appeals or further interlocutory applications were noted, making this a first-instance review of the Registrar's decision. The procedural history is marked by the formal opposition process, the Registrar's subsequent decision, and Kenzo SA's application for judicial review, culminating in this court's examination of the merits of the Registrar's exercise of discretion.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined whether the opponent had established its opposition to the trade mark application under the grounds specified in the Notice of Opposition. The opponent contended that the application should be refused on the basis that the trade mark was likely to cause confusion with an earlier trade mark, and that the trade mark was devoid of any distinctive character. However, the court found that the opponent had not provided sufficient evidence to substantiate these claims. The court applied the legal principles that for an opposition to be valid, it must be substantiated by sufficient evidence and that the burden of proof lies with the opponent to demonstrate that the grounds of opposition have been met. The authorities relied on included the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) and relevant case law which emphasised the importance of the opponent proving their case. The court’s findings meant that the opponent had not established its opposition, leaving the grounds of opposition unsubstantiated.
Following this, the court considered whether the Registrar must refuse to register the trade mark based on the findings of the opposition. Given that the opponent had not established its opposition, the court ruled that the Registrar should not refuse to register the trade mark. The court applied the principle that if the grounds of opposition are not substantiated, the Registrar is not obligated to refuse the application. This principle was supported by statutory provisions under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) and consistent with precedent where unsubstantiated oppositions do not lead to refusal of registration.
The next issue addressed was whether the Registrar must register the trade mark with or without conditions or limitations, having regard to the extent to which any ground of opposition had been established. The court determined that since the opposition was not established, the Registrar should register the trade mark without any conditions or limitations. The court applied the principle that if an opposition is not substantiated, the Registrar is to proceed with the registration as if no opposition had been filed. This principle was consistent with the statutory framework of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), which does not impose conditions or limitations unless the opposition is validly substantiated.
Furthermore, the court deliberated on whether the International Registration Design Application (IRDA) may proceed to protection one month from the date of the decision, or if an appeal has been lodged, whether protection should be stayed until the appeal is decided or discontinued. The court ruled that the IRDA may proceed to protection one month from the date of this decision. However, if the Registrar is served with a notice of appeal before that time, protection shall be stayed until the appeal is decided or discontinued. The court applied the principle that the progression of IRDA should not be unduly delayed, but that the rights of the appellant to challenge the decision must be respected. This approach aligns with the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) and relevant procedural rules that balance the need for timely protection with the right to appeal.
Lastly, the court addressed whether the holder is entitled to its costs, and if so, at what scale they should be awarded against the opponent. The court held that the holder is entitled to its costs and awarded them at the official scale against the opponent. The court applied the principle that where an opposition is unsuccessful and not substantiated, the opponent is typically liable for the costs incurred by the holder. This principle is supported by statutory provisions under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) and consistent with the practice of awarding costs to the prevailing party in trade mark disputes. The court's decision ensures that the unsuccessful opponent bears the financial burden of the proceedings, reflecting the outcome of the opposition process.