Kentgreen Dural Pty Ltd v Hornsby Shire Council

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read
Reported Decision: 103 LGERA 219

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales

          CITATION:
Kentgreen Dural Pty Ltd -V- Hornsby Shire Council [1999] NSWLEC 158
          PARTIES
APPLICANT:
Kentgreen Dural Pty Ltd
RESPONDENT
Hornsby Shire Council
          NUMBER:
10084 of 1999
          CORAM:
Bignold J
          KEY ISSUES:
Practice & Procedure :- Discontinuance of class 1 proceedings 3 weeks prior to fixed hearing - costs
          LEGISLATION CITED:
Pt 11 r 5 Rules of Court
          DATES OF HEARING:
07/06/1999
          DATE OF JUDGMENT DELIVERY:

07/08/1999
          LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:


APPLICANT:
Mr T. Robertson, Barrister

SOLICITORS:
Macedone Christie Willis - Solari

RESPONDENT:
Mr M. Wright, Solicitor

SOLICITORS:
Michell Sillar


    JUDGMENT:

TABLE OF CONTENTS



      A. INTRODUCTION 1-5
      B. THE BASIS FOR THE COUNCIL’S CLAIM FOR COSTS 6
      C. RELEVANT PRINCIPLES FOR THE EXERCISE OF THE COURT’S
      DISCRETION 7-25
      D. THE APPLICANT’S CASE THAT NO EXCEPTIONAL
      CIRCUMSTANCES HAVE BEEN ESTABLISHED 26-32
      E. CONCLUSIONS 3 3-35
      F. SHOULD THE COSTS TO BE AWARDED BE ON THE
      INDEMNITY BASIS? 36-37
      G. ORDERS 38-42

IN THE LAND AND Matter No. 10084 of 1999


ENVIRONMENT COURT OF Coram: Bignold J.


NEW SOUTH WALES 8 July 1999

KENTGREEN DURAL PTY LIMITED

Applicant

v.

HORNSBY SHIRE COUNCIL

Respondent

JUDGMENT


Bignold J:

A. INTRODUCTION

1. By its Notice of Motion filed 31 May 1999, the Respondent (the Council) seeks an order that the Applicant pay the Council’s costs of the proceedings on an indemnity basis in consequence of the Applicant’s discontinuance of the proceedings..

2 The Applicant resists the order sought.

3. The proceedings which involved an appeal pursuant to s 96(7) of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 against the Council’s determination refusing the Applicant’s application to modify two existing development consents were commenced in this Court on 16 February 1999 and were terminated on 21 May 1999 when the Applicant filed a Notice of Discontinuance.

4. At the time the proceedings were discontinued, they had been fixed for hearing on 15, 16 and 17 June 1999, having been so fixed, at the Applicant’s instigation by the Registrar at callover held on 10 March 1999.

5. The discontinuance did not have the consent of the Council.

B. THE BASIS FOR THE COUNCIL’S CLAIM FOR COSTS

6. The Council’s claim for costs is principally founded upon the provisions of Part 11 Rule 5(1) of the Rules of Court which provide as follows:

            If a party to any proceedings discontinues them in whole or in part, the Court may, on the application of another party, order the discontinuing party to pay the costs of any party against whom the discontinued claim was brought and who does not consent to the discontinuance.

C. RELEVANT PRINCIPLES FOR THE EXERCISE OF THE COURT’S DISCRETION

7. In support of its costs claim, the Council places considerable reliance upon my decision in Manly Wharf Pty Ltd v. Manly Council (1997) 98 LGERA 245 which, like the present case, involved a discontinuance of class 1 proceedings at a time when they had been fixed for hearing (some two months previously) and the discontinuance occurred…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kentgreen Dural Pty Ltd v Hornsby Shire Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] NSWLEC 158
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Kentgreen Dural Pty Ltd sought to appeal a decision of the Hornsby Shire Council under the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979, but subsequently discontinued the appeal three weeks before the fixed hearing date. The Council applied for costs under Part 11 Rule 5 of the Rules of Court, arguing that the discontinuance constituted "exceptional circumstances" warranting an award of costs on an indemnity basis. The applicant opposed the claim, contending that its decision to discontinue was reasonable and not exceptional, as it was based on professional advice received shortly before the hearing date. The court considered the relevant principles for exercising its discretion in awarding costs, particularly the principle that discontinuance of proceedings ordinarily results in an award of costs unless there are exceptional circumstances. The court also noted that the applicant's discontinuance was not influenced by any action of the council or supervening events, but rather a deliberate decision based on professional advice. However, the court found that the circumstances did not justify a departure from the ordinary cost consequence of discontinuance. While the applicant's case had difficulties, it was not hopeless or ill-advised. Therefore, the court ordered the applicant to pay the council's costs reasonably incurred prior to the discontinuance, but denied the council's claim for indemnity costs.

The final orders were that the applicant pay the council's costs reasonably incurred before the discontinuance, either by agreement or assessment, and that each party pay their own costs of the hearing. The court did not award indemnity costs to the council as it found the applicant's decision to discontinue was reasonable conduct based on professional advice, even though it did not constitute an exceptional circumstance warranting indemnity costs. The key issue was whether the applicant's discontinuance, though reasonable, nevertheless amounted to an exceptional circumstance under the court's practice direction regarding costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established