| i | r ' |
| ! | IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA |
| I | AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY GENERAL DIVISION |
| BETWEEN | : | KENT HEATING LIMITED |
Applicant
| I | AND : | PEUREN AGENCIES PTY. LIMITED |
| I | I | First respondent |
| I |
JOHN CLARENCE BRIDGE
| i | Second respondent |
| I |
| i | LIMITD |
| CAN-FAB ENGINEERING PTY. | |
| i |
| I | Third respondent |
| i |
| l | HI-TECH COATING SYSTMES PTY. LIMITED (formerly | |
| ||
| Limited) |
Fourth respondent
MINUTE OF ORDER
| JUDGE MAKING ORDER | : Neaves J. |
,
| DATE OF ORDER | : 3 Aprll 1987 |
| WERE MADE | : Canberra |
| THE COURT ORDERS | THAT: |
| 1. | The | first | and | second | respondents | within | 14 days |
| from the date | of | this order make further answer, |
| verified by affldavit in accordance with Order | 16, |
| rule 7 of | Ehe | Federal | Court | Rules, | to | the |
| interrogatories set out in the notice dated | 27 |
February 1986 served by the applicant on the first and second respondents and numbered 22, 25, 37(a), 40, 58 and 59(f).
L .
| 2. | Otherwise, the motion notice | of which was given on |
| 14 August 1986 be dismissed. |
| 3. | The applicant pay three-quarters of the | costs of |
| the | first and second respondents | of | the motion. |
| N o t e : | Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order | 36 |
| of the Federal Court | Rules. |
.
IN THE FDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| I | ) |
| ! | AUSTRALIAN | CAPITAL | 1'ERRITORY | 1 |
No. G 85 of 1982
DISTRICT REGISTRY
1
| DIVISION | GENERAL | ) |
I
I
I
| EETWEEN: | KENT | HEATING | LIMITED |
Applicant
| AND: | PEUREN | AGENCIES PTY. |
LIMITED
First respondent
| I | JOHN CLARENCE BRIDGE |
Second respondent
CAN-FAB ENGINEERING PTY.
LIMITED
Third respondent
HI-TECH COATING SYSTMES
PTY. LIMITED (formerly
| Durelink Engineering Pty. | Limited) Fourth respondent |
CORAM: Neaves J.
| m: | 3 April 1987 |
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
:'
| Kenc Heating Limited ("the applicant") has | applied to |
the Court by motion on notice that Peuren Agencies Pty. Limited
| ("the first respondent") and | John Clarence Bridge ("the second |
respondent") be ordered to make further answer, verified by
| affidavit in accordance | with 0.16, r.7 | of the Federal Court |
| Rules, to a number of interrogatories set out in | a notice dated |
| 27 February 1986. |
| ! | I |
| , | ' |
| 1 | d . | L . |
The notice to answer lnterrogatories was given in
proceedings in which the applicant seeks relief against the
flrst and second respondents and against Can-F& Engineering
| Pty. Lmited ("the third respondent") | and | Hi-tech | Coating |
| Systems | Pty. | Limited, | formerly | Durelink | Englneering | Pty. |
Limlted ("the fourth respondent"). According to its amended
| application, filed herein on 11 September | 1985, the applicant |
| claims | : |
| i | "(a) | An | injunctlon | restraining | the | First, |
Third and Fourth Respondents by their
| directors, | officers, | s rvants, |
contractors or agents, and the Second
| Respondent, | manufacturing, | from |
distributing, advertising, selling, or
| offering for sale | or otherwise dealing |
with the heaters manufactured by them
| and marketed under the name 'Erik | 2000 ' |
| or any | other | heater | similar | to | or |
| substantially simllar to the Tile | Fire |
or any other heaters manufactured by the
Applicant.
| Delivery up | to the Applicant of all |
| heaters, | dyes, | jigs , components, |
| brochures, | advertising |
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Kent Heating Ltd v Peuren Agencies Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1987] FCA 204
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Justice Neaves examined each of the interrogatories and found many of them to be objectionable on the grounds that they lacked precision, proceeded on unproven assumptions, or were irrelevant to the issues in the case. The interrogatories that were found to be objectionable included those that assumed the Erik 2000 heater was designed, planned, or invented by a specific person, and those that asked for details about the manufacturing and marketing of the Erik 2000 without proper limitations. The interrogatories that were deemed acceptable related to the number of units of the Erik 2000 sold and the total gross revenue of the sales.
The court ordered that the first and second respondents provide further answers, verified by affidavit, to interrogatories numbered 22, 25, 37(a), 40, 58, and 59(f). The motion was to be dismissed otherwise. Kent Heating Limited was ordered to pay three-quarters of the costs of the first and second respondents for the motion.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi