Kennedy v Queensland Police Service

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

[2007] QDC 353

DISTRICT COURT
CIVIL JURISDICTION

JUDGE ROBERTSON

MARK LESLIE KENNEDY Applicant
and
QUEENSLAND POLICE SERVICE Respondent
MAROOCHYDORE
..DATE 13/12/2007
ORDER

13122007 T1-08-10/LG(MARO) M/T MARO-01 (Robertson DCJ)

HIS HONOUR: Mark Leslie Kennedy applies, pursuant to section 1
131(2) of the Transport Operations (Road Use Management) Act
1995 (the TORUM), for removal of a disqualification of licence
imposed by me in this Court on the 27th of September 2005 as
part of a sentence following upon Mr Kennedy's plea of guilty 10
to dangerous driving causing death while adversely affected by
alcohol.
It follows that on the date he filed his application, the 26th 20
of October 2007, this was just over two years after the
imposition of the sentence imposed in 2005. As part of that
sentence and obviously, the most significant part of the
sentence, Mr Kennedy was sentenced to four and a-half years'
imprisonment and was required to serve 15 months before that 30
sentence was suspended That suspended sentence remains in
place.
Section 131(2C) of the TORUM directs the Court in considering 40
the application in the following terms:

"Upon hearing any such application, the Judge of the
Supreme Court or District Court or Justices constituting
the Court may, as is thought proper, having regard to the

character of the person disqualified and the person's 50
conduct subsequent to the order, the nature of the
offence and any other circumstances of the case, either
by order remove the disqualification as from such date as
may be specified in the order or refuse the application."

ORDER

2   60

13122007 T1-08-10/LG(MARO) M/T MARO-01 (Robertson DCJ)

I will deal firstly with the nature of the offence. The brief 1
circumstances of the offence are that after drinking and
partying with some friends on the 9th of February 2003, Mr
Kennedy made the fateful decision to drive a relatively short
distance at Mudjimba to obtain food. The young woman, Jasmin 10
McDonald who was killed, was his new girlfriend at the time.
She was in the front passenger seat, two other friends sat in
the rear seat.
20
Clearly, as a result of Mr Kennedy's intoxication, he failed
to see a light Pantec truck which was parked on the side of
Mudjimba Beach road and his vehicle slammed into the back of
the truck and Miss McDonald was killed and the two friends
were injured but not to the extent of sustaining grievous 30
bodily harm. Mr Kennedy also sustained injuries. He had a
blood alcohol reading expressed as a percentage of alcohol in
his blood of .183; objectively, a very high reading.
40
Mr Kennedy had a relevant traffic history which was clearly a
fact bearing upon the sentence including the period of
disqualification. He was born on the 20th of June 1980. The
first entry was for an offence of unlicensed driving on the
50

22nd of April 1999 for which he was fined. On the 22nd of April 1999, the same day as the first offence, he…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kennedy v Queensland Police Service and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] QDC 353
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Kennedy v Queensland Police Service, the applicant, Mark Leslie Kennedy, sought the removal of a disqualification of his driver's licence imposed by the court on 27 September 2005. This disqualification was part of a sentence following Kennedy's guilty plea to dangerous driving causing death while adversely affected by alcohol. Kennedy applied for the removal of the disqualification pursuant to section 131(2) of the Transport Operations (Road Use Management) Act 1995. The court was required to consider the application under section 131(2C) of the Act, which directs the court to consider the character of the person, their conduct since the order, the nature of the offence, and any other relevant circumstances before deciding whether to remove the disqualification.

The court considered the nature of the offence, which involved Kennedy driving under the influence of alcohol, resulting in the death of his girlfriend and injuries to others. The court also examined Kennedy's traffic history, which included several speeding offences, and his efforts towards rehabilitation since the offence. The court acknowledged Kennedy's remorse, his employment, and his stable family situation but noted that the application was made just over two years into a four-year disqualification period. The court concluded that, while Kennedy had demonstrated rehabilitation, the offence was serious, and the disqualification period had not yet reached its midpoint.

The court ultimately decided that Kennedy had not demonstrated sufficient grounds for the early removal of the disqualification. The court emphasised the importance of the disqualification as part of the overall sentence and noted that the Commissioner's attitude was neutral, unlike in other cases where the Commissioner had been more supportive of the applicant. Therefore, the court refused the application for the removal of the disqualification.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mark Leslie Kennedy was convicted of dangerous driving causing death while adversely affected by alcohol, resulting from an incident on 9 February 2003. Kennedy had been drinking and partying before deciding to drive to obtain food. He collided with a stationary Pantec truck on Mudjimba Beach Road, resulting in the death of his passenger, Jasmin McDonald, and injuring two other friends in his vehicle. Kennedy's blood alcohol level was.183, which is objectively very high. Prior to this incident, Kennedy had a traffic history that included offences of unlicensed driving and speeding. He was sentenced on 27 September 2005 to four and a half years' imprisonment, with 15 months to be served before the sentence was suspended, and was also disqualified from holding a driver's licence for four years.

Kennedy applied to the Court for the removal of his licence disqualification on 26 October 2007, just over two years after the initial sentencing. In his application, Kennedy emphasised his efforts at rehabilitation, including his full-time employment, recent marriage, and the purchase of a townhouse. He also highlighted the difficulties his wife faces in driving him to and from work due to his disqualification. Kennedy's employers attested to his responsible conduct and steady employment. Despite these efforts, Kennedy's application was made just over halfway through the four-year disqualification period. The Court considered the nature of the offence, Kennedy's rehabilitation efforts, and the difficulties his disqualification caused, but ultimately decided not to exercise its discretion in his favour at that stage.

The matter of Kennedy v Queensland Police Service came before the District Court of Queensland for an application to remove a disqualification of licence imposed by the Court on 27 September 2005, following Mark Leslie Kennedy's plea of guilty to dangerous driving causing death while adversely affected by alcohol. The application was made pursuant to section 131(2) of the Transport Operations (Road Use Management) Act 1995. Kennedy filed his application on 26 October 2007, which was just over two years after the imposition of the sentence. Kennedy was sentenced to four and a half years' imprisonment, with 15 months to be served before the sentence was suspended, and the suspended sentence remains in place. The Court considered the application in light of section 131(2C) of the TORUM, which grants the Court discretion to remove the disqualification, taking into account the character of the person, their conduct since the order, the nature of the offence, and any other relevant circumstances. The Court ultimately refused the application, noting that the disqualification was an important part of the sentence, and that Kennedy had not demonstrated sufficient grounds for the Court to exercise its discretion in his favour at that stage of the disqualification period.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court has the discretion to remove the disqualification of the applicant's licence under section 131(2C) of the Transport Operations (Road Use Management) Act 1995.
2. Whether the nature and seriousness of the offence committed by the applicant warrant a refusal of the application for removal of disqualification.
3. Whether the applicant has demonstrated sufficient rehabilitation and good conduct since the imposition of the disqualification to warrant its removal.
4. Whether the difficulties faced by the applicant and his family due to the absence of a driver's licence are sufficient grounds for the removal of the disqualification.
5. Whether the applicant's employment prospects and career advancement are significantly impeded by the continued disqualification, and if so, whether this is a sufficient reason for its removal.
6. Whether the timing of the application, made just over half-way through the disqualification period, impacts the court's discretion in deciding the application.
7. Whether the applicant's circumstances are comparable to those in previous cases where the court has exercised its discretion to remove a disqualification, and if not, whether this justifies a refusal of the application.

Held
1. The court concluded that it has the discretion to remove the disqualification of the applicant's licence under section 131(2C) of the Transport Operations (Road Use Management) Act 1995. Result: N/A as this was not the final holding.
2. The court concluded that the nature and seriousness of the offence committed by the applicant did not warrant a refusal of the application for removal of disqualification. Result: N/A as this was not the final holding.
3. The court concluded that the applicant had demonstrated sufficient rehabilitation and good conduct since the imposition of the disqualification to warrant its removal. Result: N/A as this was not the final holding.
4. The court concluded that the difficulties faced by the applicant and his family due to the absence of a driver's licence were not sufficient grounds for the removal of the disqualification. Result: N/A as this was not the final holding.
5. The court concluded that the applicant's employment prospects and career advancement were not significantly impeded by the continued disqualification, and thus, this was not a sufficient reason for its removal. Result: N/A as this was not the final holding.
6. The court concluded that the timing of the application, made just over half-way through the disqualification period, did impact the court's discretion in deciding the application. Result: N/A as this was not the final holding.
7. The court concluded that the applicant's circumstances were not comparable to those in previous cases where the court has exercised its discretion to remove a disqualification. Result: Application dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began its analysis by considering the statutory discretion granted to it under section 131(2C) of the Transport Operations (Road Use Management) Act 1995. The court acknowledged the broad discretion it possesses in deciding whether to remove the disqualification of the applicant's licence, which must be exercised by taking into account the character of the person disqualified, their conduct since the order, the nature of the offence, and any other relevant circumstances. The court's task was to weigh these factors judiciously to determine whether the disqualification should be removed.

The court then evaluated the nature and seriousness of the offence committed by the applicant, which was dangerous driving causing death while adversely affected by alcohol. The court noted the tragic consequences of the applicant's actions, which led to the death of his passenger and injuries to two others. The court also highlighted the applicant's high blood alcohol content at the time of the offence and his prior traffic violations, although it acknowledged that his criminal history was otherwise unblemished. The seriousness of the offence was a significant factor that weighed against the applicant's chances of having his disqualification removed.

In assessing the applicant's rehabilitation and conduct since the imposition of the disqualification, the court found that the applicant had made commendable efforts to rehabilitate himself. He had expressed deep remorse, maintained full-time employment, purchased a home with the help of his family, and was now a responsible member of the community. The court accepted that there was no evidence of any further offending by the applicant. Despite this, the court noted that the application was made just over halfway through the four-year disqualification period, which influenced its decision.

The court also considered the difficulties faced by the applicant and his family due to the absence of a driver's licence. The applicant's wife had to drive him to work and back, which created additional strain on their relationship. However, the court noted that while the lack of a driver's licence impeded the applicant's career advancement, it was not suggested that he would lose his job if the disqualification continued.

Regarding the impact on the applicant's employment prospects and career advancement, the court recognised that a driver's licence was important for his work as a builder. Nevertheless, it was satisfied that the applicant's current employment was not at risk due to the disqualification. The court reasoned that while career advancement might be hindered, this was not sufficient grounds to warrant the removal of the disqualification at that stage.

The timing of the application was another factor considered by the court. The application was made just over halfway through the four-year disqualification period, a point that influenced the court's decision. The court observed that it was early in the disqualification period, and the statutory period of two years had only recently expired. This timing factor, combined with the other considerations, led the court to refuse the application at that juncture.

Lastly, the court compared the applicant's circumstances with those in previous cases where the court had exercised its discretion to remove a disqualification. It noted that the applicant's situation was distinguishable from cases where the disqualification period had nearly expired or where the applicant needed a licence for rehabilitation purposes. In the present case, the court was not persuaded that the circumstances warranted the exercise of its discretion to remove the disqualification.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the court has broad discretion under section 131(2C) of the Transport Operations (Road Use Management) Act 1995 to decide whether to remove a disqualification of a licence, and this discretion must be exercised by considering the nature of the offence, the applicant's rehabilitation and conduct, the difficulties faced by the applicant and their family, the impact on employment prospects, the timing of the application, and whether the circumstances are comparable to previous cases. In this instance, the court refused the application due to the serious nature of the offence, the relatively early stage of the disqualification period, and the absence of exceptional circumstances warranting the removal of the disqualification.