Kennedy v Hill & Ors No. Scgrg-98-156 Judgment No. S440

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

KENNEDY V HILL & ORS

[1999] SASC 440

Full Court:   Mullighan, Lander & Martin JJ

  1. MULLIGHAN J       I agree with the orders proposed by Lander J and with his reasons.

  2. LANDER J:               This is an appeal by a beneficiary of an estate against a decision and orders made in this Court on an application made by the trustee of the estate for directions under the Trustee Act and Administration of Probate Act.

Orders Under Appeal

  1. Apart from the orders for costs, which are not relevant, the orders complained of are:

    “The Court declares and orders:

    1.That the contract made by exchange of letters made by the plaintiff, Robert Michael Kennedy and the defendant Suzanne Margaret Keast entered into on or about 4 September 1997 for the sale and purchase of an interest in land and shares, was terminated on 30 January 1998 by the institution of these proceedings.

    2.That the plaintiff, Robert Michael Kennedy proceed to settlement with contracts made by an exchange of letters between the plaintiff, Robert Michael Kennedy and the defendants, Brenton Scott Hill and Wendy Joylene Blades and entered into respectively on about 11 August 1997 and 13 August 1997 for the sale and purchase of an interest in shares and land.”

  2. By way of explanation the contract referred to in paragraph 1 of the Judge’s orders was both during the trial and on appeal called ‘the Keast Contract’. 

Procedure Adopted

  1. The first respondent is the plaintiff in these proceedings.  He is a practising Chartered Accountant and the sole executor and trustee of the last Will and testament Thelma Joyce Hill, whose Will was executed on 15 February 1995.  Mrs Hill (the deceased) died on 7 June 1997 and probate of her Will was granted to the first respondent on 11 August 1997.

  2. The appellant is a daughter of the deceased.  The second respondent is a son of the deceased and a third respondent, another daughter of the deceased.

  3. The proceedings between the parties are somewhat unusual.  The plaintiff brought an application in which he named the three children of the deceased as defendants seeking orders in the following terms:

    “1..... An order that it is appropriate for the plaintiff to take the following actions in performing his obligations as executor and trustee of the Will of Thelma Joyce Hill executed 15 February 1995 (“the Will”):

    1.1Accept the repudiation by Suzanne Margaret Keast of her contract with the plaintiff to purchase shares in Sidney Harrison Pty Ltd and land occupied and tenanted by or leased to Sidney Harrison Pty Ltd from the estate of Thelma Joyce Hill in accordance with clause 3 of the Will; and

    1.2Settle Brenton Scott Hill and Wendy Joylene Blades contracts with the plaintiff to purchase shares in Sidney Harrison Pty Ltd and land occupied and tenanted by or leased to Sidney Harrison Pty Ltd from the Estate of Thelma Joyce Hill in accordance with clause of 3 of the Will.”

  4. The originating proceedings which were instituted on 30 January 1998 were…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kennedy v Hill & Ors No. Scgrg-98-156 Judgment No. S440 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] SASC 440
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal concerns the estate of Thelma Joyce Hill, who died in 1997. The parties in dispute are the deceased's daughter, Suzanne Margaret Keast (appellant), and her father, Brenton Scott Hill, acting as the executor and trustee of the estate (first respondent). The central issue is whether the first respondent accepted a repudiation of a contract by the appellant regarding the sale of shares and property in accordance with the deceased's will. The appeal was heard by Mullighan, Lander, and Martin JJ, who agreed with Lander J's proposed orders. The first respondent had applied to the Supreme Court for directions to proceed with the sale of shares and property to the second and third respondents, while excluding the appellant. The trial judge ruled in favour of the first respondent, declaring the contract between the first respondent and the appellant terminated and directing the first respondent to proceed with the sale to the second and third respondents. The appeal against this decision focused on whether the appellant had repudiated the contract and whether the first respondent had accepted that repudiation. The Full Court found that while the appellant had indeed repudiated the contract, the first respondent had not accepted this repudiation. The Court held that the first respondent's application for directions was an attempt to seek the Court's approval to accept the repudiation, indicating that no acceptance had actually occurred. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, and the orders made by the trial judge were set aside.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

MULLIGHAN J MARTIN J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MULLIGHAN J, MARTIN J