Kennametal Inc. v Sandvik Aktiebolag

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

official notice

decision of a delegate of the commissioner of patents

Application        :    NO. 587141 in the name of KENNAMETAL INC.

Title:    Hard Tip Bit, Middle Section Concave Surface

Action: Opposition under section 59 (Patents Act 1952)

Decision:    Issued             .  Claims do not comply with Section 40.  Evidence included a B-level publication of a specification which was published after the relevant priority date; argument based on the A-level publication not admitted.

patents act 1990

decision of a delegate of the commissioner of patents

Re:Patent Application No. 587141 by KENNAMETAL INC., and opposition thereto by SANDVIK AKTIEBOLAG.

background

Patent application 587141 was lodged on 18 August 1987 as a convention application claiming priority from US application no. 905730, which was lodged in the United States on 9 September 1986.  The application was advertised accepted on 3 August 1989.  Subsequently Sandvik AG lodged a notice of opposition on 30 Oct.  1989.  Evidence in support of the opposition was served on 28 Feb.  1990; that in answer served on 28 Feb 1991; and that in reply was served on 20 November 1991.

The opposition was heard in Melbourne on 17 February 1992.  The applicant was represented by Mr. M. Royal of Phillips Ormonde & Fitzpatrick, Melbourne, assisted by Mr. R. Evans.  The opponent was represented by Mr. G. Munt of Griffith Hack & Co, Melbourne.

As the application was both lodged and advertised accepted before the commencement of the Patents Act 1990, the provisions of section 234(3) of the 1990 Act, and Regulation 23.3, are applicable. 

The notice of opposition lists all grounds of opposition that are available under section 59 of the Patents Act 1952.  At the hearing the opponent indicated that they relied only on the grounds of prior publication, and lack of novelty.

The Specification

The specification states that the invention relates generally to excavation and construction tools and, more particularly, is concerned with a cutter bit having a hard tip with a configuration which decreases the areas of high stress concentration created during fabrication and thereby increases wear life during use.  Used for road maintenance techniques, the cutter bits are mounted on a power-driven rotary drum; asphalt is planed off a road surface as the drum rotates and the bits strike or dig into the roadway.

The conventional tip is described with particular reference to US specification 4627665.  It is stated to consist of a tip section, a flange section, and a middle section that extends between them.  The tip section is defined by a rounded forward end which merges rearwardly into a shallow frustro-conical surface of revolution; the flange section has a flange defined by a right cylindrical surface which has a diameter substantially greater than the maximum diameter of the tip section.  The middle section is partially defined by a steep frustro-conical surface of revolution; at its upper end it merges at a round-off transition with the lower end of the tip section; at its lower end it has…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kennametal Inc. v Sandvik Aktiebolag and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1992] APO 21
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Kennametal Inc. opposed the patent application 587141 by Sandvik Aktiebolag, which claimed a hard tip bit with a middle section concave surface. The opposition was based on the grounds of prior publication and lack of novelty. The hearing took place in Melbourne on 17 February 1992. The applicant was represented by Mr. M. Royal of Phillips Ormonde & Fitzpatrick, Melbourne, while the opponent was represented by Mr. G. Munt of Griffith Hack & Co, Melbourne.

The primary legal issues were whether the claims complied with the requirements of Section 40 of the Patents Act 1990, and whether the invention was prior published and lacked novelty. The court examined the definition of "continuous concave surface of revolution" and whether it was fairly based on the description. The court also considered the relevance of certain cited specifications to the prior art and the burden of proof on the opponent.

The court concluded that the term "continuous concave surface of revolution" included a continuous surface of revolution that was partially defined by a steep frustro-conical surface of revolution, and did not restrict the surface to one that was continuously concave. Therefore, the claims did not comply with the requirements of Section 40 as they were not fairly based on the description. The court did not consider the cited specifications in detail as the claims were found to be invalid on the grounds of Section 40. However, the court noted that if the claims were directed to a continuously concave surface, the invention would not be prior published and would be novel. The court also observed that, on a proper construction of the claims as presently defined, its findings on prior publication and novelty would be different.

The court directed the applicant to amend the specification to its satisfaction within 60 days from the date of this decision. No costs were awarded as the opposition succeeded on the grounds of Section 40, a ground not pressed by the opponent. The parties had a common view on the Section 40 issue which differed from the court's present conclusions.

This decision highlights the importance of ensuring that patent claims are fairly based on the description and comply with the statutory requirements. It also demonstrates the application of the reverse infringement test and the significance of the proper construction of patent claims.

Background

Background to the litigation

Kennametal Inc. lodged a patent application (No. 587141) for a hard tip bit with a middle section concave surface on 18 August 1987, claiming priority from a US application (No. 905730) dated 9 September 1986. The application was advertised accepted on 3 August 1989. Sandvik Aktiebolag lodged a notice of opposition on 30 October 1989, with evidence served on 28 February 1990, and the opposition was heard in Melbourne on 17 February 1992. The invention pertains to a cutter bit with a hard tip designed to decrease high stress concentrations during fabrication, enhancing wear life during use. The claims describe a cutter bit hard tip with an outer tip section, an inner flange section, and a middle section with a substantially smooth surface defined by a continuous concave surface of revolution.

The matter was heard as an opposition under section 59 of the Patents Act 1952, with the application and opposition being contested in a hearing in Melbourne on 17 February 1992. The applicant, Kennametal Inc., was represented by Mr. M. Royal of Phillips Ormonde & Fitzpatrick, and the opponent, Sandvik Aktiebolag, was represented by Mr. G. Munt of Griffith Hack & Co. The opposition was based on grounds of prior publication and lack of novelty, with the decision issued on the basis that the claims did not comply with Section 40 of the Patents Act 1990, as they were not fairly based on the description.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the term "continuous concave surface of revolution" in the patent claims necessarily mean a surface that is continuously concave, or can it include a surface that is overall concave but partially defined by a frustro-conical surface of revolution?
2. Are the claims in the patent application fairly based on the description provided, as required by Section 40 of the Patents Act 1990?
3. Does the invention claimed in the patent application meet the requirements for novelty and non-obviousness, considering the cited prior art?

Held
1. The term "continuous concave surface of revolution" in the patent claims does not necessarily mean a surface that is continuously concave, but can include a surface that is overall concave but partially defined by a frustro-conical surface of revolution.
2. The claims in the patent application do not comply with Section 40 of the Patents Act 1990 as they are not fairly based on the description provided.
3. The invention claimed in the patent application is novel and does not meet the prior publication requirement, provided the claims are interpreted as defining a continuously concave surface.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the term "continuous concave surface of revolution" in the patent claims. The court concluded that this term includes a continuous surface of revolution that is partially defined by a steep frustro-conical surface of revolution, meaning that the surface does not have to be continuously concave at all points. This interpretation was not pursued by either party during the hearing. However, the court held that for the remainder of the decision, it would proceed on the basis that the term refers to a surface which is continuously concave.

Moving on to the issue of whether the claims are fairly based on the description, the court noted that the term "continuous concave surface of revolution" was interpreted differently by the parties than by the court. The court found that the claims do not comply with the requirements of Section 40 as they are not fairly based on the description. The court directed the applicant to amend the specification to its satisfaction within 60 days.

The court then considered the issue of novelty and prior publication. The court found that the invention claimed is not prior published and is novel, to the extent that the claims are directed to a continuously concave surface of revolution. The court did not consider in detail the relevance of the citation to the claims as presently defined, but expressed the opinion that its findings on prior publication and novelty would be different if the claims were interpreted as the court had.

The court concluded that the opposition succeeds on the grounds of Section 40, a ground not pressed by the opponent. Given that both parties had a common view on the Section 40 issue that differed from the court's conclusions, and considering the court's opinion that its findings on prior publication and novelty would be different if the claims were interpreted as the court had, the court made no award of costs.