| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL | [1992]QCA 095 |
| SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND | Appeal No. 70 of 1991 |
| Before the Court of Appeal | |
| The President Mr Justice Davies Mr Justice McPherson |
MONA EILEEN KENDELL
(Plaintiff) Respondent
- and -
THE NORTH QUEENSLAND
NEWSPAPER COMPANY LIMITED
(Defendant) Appellant
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
Delivered the 13th day of May 1992
In this appeal, the appellant seeks to have a judgment
in favour of the respondent for $35,000.00 together with
interest set aside and asks that judgment be entered for
the appellant or alternatively that there be an order for a
new trial. The judgment from which the appeal is brought
was entered in the District Court at Townsville on 2nd
August 1991, consequent upon answers by a jury to a number
of questions in an action for defamation brought against the
appellant by the respondent.
The appellant publishes The Townsville Bulletin which
circulates in Townsville and elsewhere in northern and
western Queensland. In mid-1989, it was engaged in
publishing material in that paper relating to the conduct of
the Townsville General Hospital's Psychiatric Ward, which
subsequently became the subject of a Commission of Inquiry
known colloquially as the "Ward 10B Inquiry". On 18 May
1989, an article concerning events in the psychiatric ward a
little more than two years earlier, on 14 May 1987, was
published. The article was critical of the conduct of a
female employee in the ward, identified as "the matron", The
respondent was not named in the article and was not the
woman whose conduct was described. However, she was the
Nursing Superintendent at the Townsville General Hospital, a
position which she pleaded was "commonly known to the
medical profession, the staff of the Townsville General
Hospital and the public as the matron." There was, however,
no plea that it was "commonly known" that she was the matron
at the material time. The respondent alleged that the
article was defamatory of her and, further, was "understood
to mean to persons with medical or psychiatric training,
that the Plaintiff had behaved in dealing with patients, in
an unprofessional and uncaring manner."
The Amended Defence denied most of the respondent's
pleaded allegations and, in addition, contained the
following paragraph 5:
"5. If the said words are defamatory of the Plaintiff
(which is denied):-(a) the publication thereof was made in good faith and for the public good and/or;
(b) the said publication was made in good faith and
was in the course of and/or for the purposes of
discussion of a subject of public interest, namely
the manner in which the Townsville Psychiatric
Ward was conducted, the public discussion of which
is for the public benefit and insofar as the
alleged defamatory matter consists of comment the
comment is fair."After the conclusion of evidence and before the
commencement of counsel's final addresses, the trial judge
made rulings in relation to the defences raised by that
paragraph. His Honour ruled "that the publication cannot be
said to have been for the public…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Kendell v North Queensland Newspaper Company Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1992] QCA 95
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to decide whether the jury could have been satisfied as to the identification of the plaintiff in the article, whether the damages awarded were disproportionate to the extent of the circulation of the newspaper, and whether a new trial ought to be ordered. The court considered the evidence presented and the arguments of both parties. The court found that the jury could have been satisfied as to the identification of the plaintiff in the article, that the damages awarded were not disproportionate to the extent of the circulation of the newspaper, and that a new trial ought not to be ordered.
The court held that the verdict against the plaintiff should stand. The court found that the plaintiff had not established that the jury could not have been satisfied as to the identification of the plaintiff in the article. The court also found that the damages awarded were not disproportionate to the extent of the circulation of the newspaper, as the newspaper had a limited circulation and the defamation had caused significant harm to the plaintiff's reputation. Finally, the court found that a new trial ought not to be ordered, as there were no grounds for doing so. The court dismissed the plaintiff's application to set aside the verdict.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi